Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I keep checking this thread but it has massively degenerated (not that it was ever great) into people like CE, JG and KS who frankly should be embarrassed by their level of debate.

This is the problem I have with this debate, I'm sure Israel does its share of bad and questionable **** like any other nation made up of human beings, but those on the anti-Israel side tend to be so ridiculous in their argumentation and wilful in their ignorance of the history and context (and I consider my knowledge shallow at best) that it just makes me disgusted with their side and more pro-Israeli. Maybe some of the less extreme pro-Israeli's in this thread could, for my benefit sum up the things they thing are most 'wrong' done by Israel and what changes to its current policy Israel should make

also while scouring the internet following this debate I hadn't come across this quote before but I love it:

http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/m/martinluth101536.html

Why do you think that such a big and complex subject is confined to one moderated thread?

You know what? I have just purged the first fringe-lefty friend from my Facebook.

Bye bye Dave. You're a nice guy of lukewarm intelligence who believes a lot of nonsense CT's, but between this and the anti-vaxx crap, I've had enough.

The offending post was 'photo-collage' of a fighter jet bombing some ME-town (from a Michael Bay movie) and 'Gazan' bombing victims that were actually Syrians crawling out of a bombed building in 2012.

It had the text 'Israeli cowardice' superimposed over the photos.

The source of the pictures were revealed on a blog I follow.
 
Maybe some of the less extreme pro-Israeli's in this thread could, for my benefit sum up the things they thing are most 'wrong' done by Israel and what changes to its current policy Israel should make


Building settlements on and near some of the land capture during war is a bad idea. First of all, taking the land has the strategic purpose of forcing the enemy out further and making it more difficult for them to hit built up areas. Building there completely negates this purpose! So even if taking the land had valid reason, building on it negates that reason as well as produces the PR nightmare of 'land stealing'. The contested lands should have remained undeveloped. This police is driven by the extreme right, super religious sects in Israel. This brings me to another criticism. Those anti-Arab asshats have too much say. Many Israelis agree on that one. Yes, it's a free democracy and like the US and Israel, that means extreme elements will have their voice too. It would be nice to see more voices countering people who talk about killing all the Palestinians. Yes, they are frustrated and angry at all their own pain, but so are the Palestinians. It's not alright when anyone says that sort of thing. That's not so much a policy issue as a social one, but they interconnect as social issues can drive policy issues.
 
Why do you think that such a big and complex subject is confined to one moderated thread?

You know what? I have just purged the first fringe-lefty friend from my Facebook.

Bye bye Dave. You're a nice guy of lukewarm intelligence who believes a lot of nonsense CT's, but between this and the anti-vaxx crap, I've had enough.

The offending post was 'photo-collage' of a fighter jet bombing some ME-town (from a Michael Bay movie) and 'Gazan' bombing victims that were actually Syrians crawling out of a bombed building in 2012.

It had the text 'Israeli cowardice' superimposed over the photos.

The source of the pictures were revealed on a blog I follow.

wow yeah. personally I'd first call them out on it and tell them how disgusting it was, and if they failed to acknowledge and retract then they'd be removed. Hardly anyone on my fb (which I keep to about 50-60 people usually) is taking my bait, apart from two comments on seperate posts by the most likely suspect, but I just deleted them immediately since they brought nothing to the discussion, and hey, its my wall :P
 
Building settlements on and near some of the land capture during war is a bad idea. First of all, taking the land has the strategic purpose of forcing the enemy out further and making it more difficult for them to hit built up areas. Building there completely negates this purpose! So even if taking the land had valid reason, building on it negates that reason as well as produces the PR nightmare of 'land stealing'. The contested lands should have remained undeveloped. This police is driven by the extreme right, super religious sects in Israel. This brings me to another criticism. Those anti-Arab asshats have too much say. Many Israelis agree on that one. Yes, it's a free democracy and like the US and Israel, that means extreme elements will have their voice too. It would be nice to see more voices countering people who talk about killing all the Palestinians. Yes, they are frustrated and angry at all their own pain, but so are the Palestinians. It's not alright when anyone says that sort of thing. That's not so much a policy issue as a social one, but they interconnect as social issues can drive policy issues.

thanks for that. one thing I would say though is the extremists on the israeli side, while I agree they are asshats, they at least provide a nice contrast to be pointed out that in Israel and in the west we allow their views to be aired, whereas in palestinian or other islamist states the airing of non-religious extremist/anti-govt policies etc views is likely to get you persecuted (and in a pretty harsh way)
 
can it be considered anti-semitic to be anti-judaism? in the same way as I and I'm sure many many others on here are anti-all religions? I think currently in today's world Islam is the most dangerous form but that's mainly just happenstance rather than anything inherent in Islam that is different to other religions.

I've never been completely clear on how 'secular' Israel is, but I suspect they are still 'too' religious for the liking of many on here. However palestine and most/all other islamic states are clearly way WAY worse
 
That's not to say all or most anti-Zionists are antisemites, but they may be doing the antisemites quite a favour.

Right. It's kind of like the thing with the abolitionists in the mid-19th century US. Plenty of them were actual 'anti-racists' like so, but a lot of them were just anti-slavery. In this context, with Israel, there are those who are mostly motivated by anti-semitism and then those who are mostly anti-'Manifest Destiny'-stuff of Israel. [from which we also get this oddity of a concept: "self-hating jew"]
 
Last edited:
thanks for that. one thing I would say though is the extremists on the israeli side, while I agree they are asshats, they at least provide a nice contrast to be pointed out that in Israel and in the west we allow their views to be aired, whereas in palestinian or other islamist states the airing of non-religious extremist/anti-govt policies etc views is likely to get you persecuted (and in a pretty harsh way)


That's true, but it doesn't mean the words of the extremists are any less condemnable. There are also issues with sexism in Israel that are not mitigated in any way by the much greater issues with sexism (and mistreatment of women) on the Palestinian side.

To be clear I know that's not the argument you were making, but someone was bound to take it that way.
 
Anyone who claims that anti-Zionist (using this term broadly for criticism of Israel) sentiments have nothing to do with antisemitism are in denial or deluded. It's quite clear that they are connected, if you investigate the development of attitudes (for anyone fluent in Swedish, this is an interesting article about the situation in Germany: http://skma.se/blogg/2014/06/antise...kland-problem-stridsfragor-och-laroprocesser/ about Peter Ullrich's research). Antisemitic rhetoric is prevalent in anti-Zionist arguments, conspiracy theories abound, and I suspect antisemitism is at least part of the reason for why the conflict is such a hot topic.

That's not to say all or most anti-Zionists are antisemites, but they may be doing the antisemites quite a favour.


If you look into the origin of the term "antisemitism" you'll find that it was created - as "Antisemitismus" - in stinky backrooms of Austrian pubs not unlikely next to the Austrian pubs in whose stinky backrooms Zionism was created at the same time in the late 19th century. They are indeed very much connected and Theodor Herzl is famous for saying that the Antisemites are the Zionists best friends.

That's because the term is inherently racist and was made up by racists to distinguish their "modern" jew-hatred from the traditional "they killed Jesus" jew-hatred. Every time it's used it is implied that the accused is a racist, and it is implied that there is something like a jewish race that the accused hates, which of course there isn't. While the accusers are often racists themselves and think they are the chosen people (by "God", just like the Nazis thought they were by Evolution (->Aryan race)).

When we add that Semites are of course also not a race, but speakers of a family of languages which includes almost all Palestinians but next to no early Zionists, we should throw that term into the dustbin of history with a healthy laugh.
 
Last edited:
Some days I really hate my "side" of the political spectrum.

*sigh*


I know what you mean. Some of the things my liberal friends say about Israel or the Israeli/Palestinian conflict are horrendously stupid. One posted a cartoon asking 'Which is worse, A. Using human shields or B. Hitting them', the cartoon implying that they are equally bad (or that hitting them is worse as my friend seemed to think). A friend of hers commented on how the Jews of all people should know better than to commit genocide, then actually said that my saying that it is not genocide (because of the definition of the word) was no different than his claim that it is based on, well, nothing. That is that they are the same weight, despite his making a positive claim with no backing.

It's just so frustrating that people who rightfully call out those claiming all Arabs are barbarians are so eager to paint Jews (especially rich Jews) as imperialists and thieves.
 
In other words:

People who criticize Israel are Jew Haters.

No, some people who criticize Israel are Jew haters. Just like some people who criticize black nationalism are racists. Your posts on how the "Zionists" are all arrogant cowards is instructive in this regard.
 
Looks like some of the most rabid anti-Semites are now advocating throwing the term "antisemitism" into the dustbin of history (with a hearty laugh, no less.)

How convenient.
 
If you look into the origin of the term "antisemitism" you'll find that it was created - as "Antisemitismus" - in stinky backrooms of Austrian pubs not unlikely next to the Austrian pubs in whose stinky backrooms Zionism was created at the same time in the late 19th century. They are indeed very much connected and Theodor Herzl is famous for saying that the Antisemites are the Zionists best friends.

That's because the term is inherently racist and was made up by racists to distinguish their "modern" jew-hatred from the traditional "they killed Jesus" jew-hatred. Every time it's used it is implied that the accused is a racist, and it is implied that there is something like a jewish race that the accused hates, which of course there isn't. While the accusers are often racists themselves and think they are the chosen people (by "God", just like the Nazis thought they were by Evolution (->Aryan race)).

When we add that Semites are of course also not a race, but speakers of a family of languages which includes almost all Palestinians but next to no early Zionists, we should throw that term into the dustbin of history with a healthy laugh.

Ho boy.

I'm sorry to say this, but quibbling over the term "antisemitism" and its semantics is in my experience a pretty strong indicator that you're at the very least talking to someone who believes in antisemitic factoids, myths and conspiracy theories.
 
Ah, we have arrived at the "people calling me antisemite are the real racists" stage of denial. So predictable.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom