Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
As to his latest post wanting to send the Israeli Army to be sent to the Ukraine to be taught a lesson,I think the Isrealis would go through the Ukrainian Seperatists like a hot knife through butter.
With far fewer civilian losses, too. The IDF has fought far stronger enemies than HAMAS terrorists before.
 
As to his latest post wanting to send the Israeli Army to be sent to the Ukraine to be taught a lesson,I think the Isrealis would go through the Ukrainian Seperatists like a hot knife through butter.

Agreed. They are one of the best if not the best fighting force in existence today. There is no Air Force in the world that is better and that includes the US. They are very selective and perfect outstanding tactics. Their historic kill ratio in air-to-air engagements has no equal. Of course, they are fighting against some of the worst Air Forces, but still they are very, very good...
 
Agreed. They are one of the best if not the best fighting force in existence today. There is no Air Force in the world that is better and that includes the US. They are very selective and perfect outstanding tactics. Their historic kill ratio in air-to-air engagements has no equal. Of course, they are fighting against some of the worst Air Forces, but still they are very, very good...

I'd say Israeli combined forces are still in the very good to excellent range, although not anywhere near the caliber achieved during the first 30 years- during which they were one of the finest modern military units ever assembled. Which is to be expected after achieving phenomenal success and pretty much total domination of all clear threats; it's natural to expect motivation at all levels to degrade sharply. Clearly, a new set of high standards are needed, particularly focused on asymmetrical, gorilla style combat situations and more aggressive development of young command.
 
Does "gorilla style" refer to the current HAMAS "run up to the armoured fighting vehicle and throw rocks" doctrine :p ?
 
I have a genuine question (and please, no snarky one-liners).

I'm somewhat pro-Israel and consider Hamas to be more or less entirely responsible for the current conflict (a rare position in Sweden) and discuss the issue relatively frequently. One point which I am inclined agree somewhat with is that Israel is very heavy-handed in their bombing and military action, compared to the threat posed. My reply, however, is usually "Well, what should they do? Sit around and accept being constantly bombed until Hamas figures out some way to do serious damage?"

A suggestion that crops out from time to time is that Israel should take less heavy-handed military action (e.g. bombing) and treat the issue in a more police operational manner, attempting to arrest those responsible rather than employing artillery with great collatteral damage.

I don't quite understand the details of how that is supposed to work, but I assume it is not an entirely uncommon suggestion. Given a charitable interpretation of the suggestion, is anyone familiar with the pros and cons involved in less heavy-handed operations? Have they been tried and failed in the past?
 
A suggestion that crops out from time to time is that Israel should take less heavy-handed military action (e.g. bombing) and treat the issue in a more police operational manner, attempting to arrest those responsible rather than employing artillery with great collatteral damage.

I don't quite understand the details of how that is supposed to work, but I assume it is not an entirely uncommon suggestion. Given a charitable interpretation of the suggestion, is anyone familiar with the pros and cons involved in less heavy-handed operations? Have they been tried and failed in the past?

What precisely are you suggesting ? That Israel would send in a police squad into Gaza with the aim of arresting people shooting rockets, or discover tunnels into Israel. They would be either killed or captured.

Your question shows complete lack of understanding of the situation on the ground. These are not actions of some individuals, but of an military like organization that acquired arms in vast quantities, located his missiles in civilian neighbourhoods, and then made sure his fighters in the same neighbourhood have excellent defensive positions (i.e. bunkers and tunnels) from which to surprise and snipe any Israeli forces. Doing what you were suggesting is simply suicide.
 
What precisely are you suggesting ? That Israel would send in a police squad into Gaza with the aim of arresting people shooting rockets, or discover tunnels into Israel. They would be either killed or captured.

Your question shows complete lack of understanding of the situation on the ground. These are not actions of some individuals, but of an military like organization that acquired arms in vast quantities, located his missiles in civilian neighbourhoods, and then made sure his fighters in the same neighbourhood have excellent defensive positions (i.e. bunkers and tunnels) from which to surprise and snipe any Israeli forces. Doing what you were suggesting is simply suicide.

Those would tend to be my thoughts, as well. Thank you.
 
Agreed. They are one of the best if not the best fighting force in existence today. There is no Air Force in the world that is better and that includes the US. They are very selective and perfect outstanding tactics. Their historic kill ratio in air-to-air engagements has no equal. Of course, they are fighting against some of the worst Air Forces, but still they are very, very good...

I really couldn't comment.
Most of their adversaries suck, so it is hard to tell.

In 1982 they (this is from memory) fought the biggest air-to-air battle since WWII against Syria. Israel shot down 90% of the Syrian planes in about six hours.

The two most successful strategies deployed against Israel are:
-Keeping Palestinians from settling in Arab countries
-Firing rockets into Israel necessitating a military response and then whining about civilian casualties.
 
O what a lovely genocide!

I saw this Jewish dude double-park today.
It was genocide.


Don't you ever tire of misapplying that term?

I wonder what would happen do our judicial system if we just let go of strict definitions of crimes.
Make dirty joke to attractive co-worker: rape!
 
I'd say Israeli combined forces are still in the very good to excellent range, although not anywhere near the caliber achieved during the first 30 years- during which they were one of the finest modern military units ever assembled. Which is to be expected after achieving phenomenal success and pretty much total domination of all clear threats; it's natural to expect motivation at all levels to degrade sharply. Clearly, a new set of high standards are needed, particularly focused on asymmetrical, gorilla style combat situations and more aggressive development of young command.

:D
 
I saw this Jewish dude double-park today.
It was genocide.


Don't you ever tire of misapplying that term?

I wonder what would happen do our judicial system if we just let go of strict definitions of crimes.
Make dirty joke to attractive co-worker: rape!

wikipedia said:
GenocideWP is the systematic destruction of all or part of a racial, ethnic, religious or national group via the (a) Killing members of the group; (b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; (c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group; or (e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.


At least a) to c) are fulfilled. Genocide is the correct term, just like "concentration camp" for Gaza and increasingly the West Bank, and "Apartheid state" or "colonial settler state" for Israel. That it hurts your precious feelings or doesn't seem "rational" to you in your downplaying of the crimes isn't a reason to not call a spade a spade.
 
I have a genuine question (and please, no snarky one-liners).

I'm somewhat pro-Israel and consider Hamas to be more or less entirely responsible for the current conflict (a rare position in Sweden) and discuss the issue relatively frequently. One point which I am inclined agree somewhat with is that Israel is very heavy-handed in their bombing and military action, compared to the threat posed. My reply, however, is usually "Well, what should they do? Sit around and accept being constantly bombed until Hamas figures out some way to do serious damage?"

A suggestion that crops out from time to time is that Israel should take less heavy-handed military action (e.g. bombing) and treat the issue in a more police operational manner, attempting to arrest those responsible rather than employing artillery with great collatteral damage.

I don't quite understand the details of how that is supposed to work, but I assume it is not an entirely uncommon suggestion. Given a charitable interpretation of the suggestion, is anyone familiar with the pros and cons involved in less heavy-handed operations? Have they been tried and failed in the past?

According to the European left Israel has these options:
-Live under constant rocket fire, sleep in the basement forever, have your kids follow classes on the Internet, work from your basement, you're probably in IT anyway.
-Next elections: DO NOT vote for politicians that promise to act on the constant rocket barrage. That would be fascist.
-If you have to react with military means, please try to bomb enemy positions without killing anyone.
-Ground invasion? Please try not to hurt anyone during urban close-combat operations.
-Lift the blockade! It's not like they are stockpiling rockets or anything and you are literally STARVING the Palestinians in Gaza. I've seen heartbreaking pictures of Gazan supermarkets shelves full of off-brand M&M's that even Auschwitz didn't have to put up with.
-Negotiate important political concessions like lifting the blockade as part of the cease-fire. It's like that time you were in a nasty divorce and your wife got drunk and pulled a kitchen knife on you. THAT is the best moment divide your estate. And don't give me any of that 'put the knife down honey, we'll call mediator on monday'-crap. You fascist.

EDIT:
Sorry, you asked for non-snarky response and I precision-bombarded you with snark.
But your question had been answered already, so I hope it's OK.

Israel screwed up a lot leading up to this. But they are now put in a position where they have no choice but to go in and destroy rocket capabilities.
Suggestions of doing this with police actions could maybe be done if Sweden volunteers some police officers to go in and confiscate rocket installations under some kind of UN mandate. I'm sure Israel will try to get them back.

This rose-tinted glasses attitude is growing among the left, I feel.
It usually manifests in wanting to deal with radicalising Islamic youth by 'listening to their needs', switching off nuke plants 'because we can use windmills instead', and opposing GM-foods so we can feed hungry people with empty promises and unicorn-farts.

-
 
Last edited:
At least a) to c) are fulfilled. Genocide is the correct term, just like "concentration camp" for Gaza and increasingly the West Bank, and "Apartheid state" or "colonial settler state" for Israel. That it hurts your precious feelings or doesn't seem "rational" to you in your downplaying of the crimes isn't a reason to not call a spade a spade.

If it were "Genocide", Israel would be marching Palestinians across minefields, rounding them up into barns and burning them alive, launching bubonic plague into Gaza and giving food laced with anthrax, forcing sons to rape mothers and fathers to rape daughters, Impaling thousands of Palestinians on the road to Jerusalem and leaving a pyramid of skulls where Gaza once stood.
 
At least a) to c) are fulfilled. Genocide is the correct term, just like "concentration camp" for Gaza and increasingly the West Bank, and "Apartheid state" or "colonial settler state" for Israel. That it hurts your precious feelings or doesn't seem "rational" to you in your downplaying of the crimes isn't a reason to not call a spade a spade.

If you are going to include killing 500+ people in military operations under the genocide-label, what the hell are we going to call Rwanda? Ultra-genocide?

Do you have any idea how many 'genocides' we'd have if we start applying that label every time people are marginalised, persecuted or get caught-up in combat operations?

Syria would have several genocides going on, Morocco has been committing genocide in the Sahara, The Turks have been committing genocide against the Kurds etc.
 
If you are going to include killing 500+ people in military operations under the genocide-label, what the hell are we going to call Rwanda? Ultra-genocide?

Do you have any idea how many 'genocides' we'd have if we start applying that label every time people are marginalised, persecuted or get caught-up in combat operations?

Syria would have several genocides going on, Morocco has been committing genocide in the Sahara, The Turks have been committing genocide against the Kurds etc.


You cannot understand the current events without the context. Pretending that history started yesterday (or in this case with the killing of the three teenagers) is not a way to seriously digest the situation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom