Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I consider donating crown (local currency) to a charity of my choice (in my case, organizations against sexual abuse) every time someone posts a Godwin in a thread about Israel and Palestine. It wouldn't reduce the number of Godwins, but I would eradicate sexual abuse.
 
That group has been fighting for its own life for thousands of years- on and off.

Still here. Now includes an army.

Sure
And as I have told you, they had some setbacks, around 70 years ago.

Now, they will still be here in 100 years, maybe not with a country in the middle east but as a minority in the US, UK or some Arab nation, why not?
 
That group has been fighting for its own life for thousands of years- on and off.

Still here. Now includes an army.
Yup. People have been trying to eradicate them for much longer than the 70 or so years Israel has existed. They are still here, only now there are here in force, with a modern army, a missile shield, powerful allies and a nuclear arsenal.

Sure, Kumar. 10 more years.
 
Why? Why have they fought so many people over time?

Why do so many people hate them?

I think somebody had just shown he has "issues" with the Jews.

And since this poster seems to be pretty far out on the Left end of the political spectrum, it is just more proof that ,sadly, Anti Semitism is no longer confined to the political right.
 
I think somebody had just shown he has "issues" with the Jews.

And since this poster seems to be pretty far out on the Left end of the political spectrum, it is just more proof that ,sadly, Anti Semitism is no longer confined to the political right.

So...are you saying that a lot of people don't hate the Jews? That Jews are welcomed throughout the Muslim World? That many throughout Europe were not cheering when Hitler sent the Jews to Concentration Camps? That the Spanish Inquisition was a Jewish Love Fest? That the Russian Empire did not forge "The Protocols of the Elders of Zion" as a campaign of lies? That even the Bible (New Testament) does not make smears against Jews? And on, and on....

The examples are numerous.
 
Last edited:
So...are you saying that a lot of people don't hate the Jews? That Jews are welcomed throughout the Muslim World? That many throughout Europe were not cheering when Hitler sent the Jews to Concentration Camps? That the Spanish Inquisition was a Jewish Love Fest? That the Russian Empire did not forge "The Protocols of the Elders of Zion" as a campaign of lies? That even the Bible (New Testament) does not make smears against Jews? And on, and on....

The examples are numerous.

And it all must be the Jews' fault, right? There just must be something that they control that makes everyone hate them, right?
 
And it all must be the Jews' fault, right? There just must be something that they control that makes everyone hate them, right?

I don't know. I am asking. I just can't think of another people who have been so reviled for so long by so many. Could it be....just bad luck?

There is nothing wrong with asking, is there?
 
Last edited:
I don't know. I am asking. I just can't think of another people who have been so reviled for so long by so many.

There is nothing wrong with asking, is there?

Quite simply the world's two biggest religions have issues with the Jews for various reasons.
 
Minorities without their own country tend to serve as scapegoats and punching bags for the majority. It's like this with Jews, Gypsies, you name it. Then certain people use this hostility as an excuse for even more hostilty ("there must be a reason why so many hate them"). Are you disputing this, Jules? If so, why? Remember, JAQing off is frowned upon here.
 
Last edited:
I don't know. I am asking. I just can't think of another people who have been so reviled for so long by so many.

There is nothing wrong with asking, is there?

There is when the answer is easy to find, and necessary to understand the issue in this thread.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_antisemitism

Jews have been persecuted since before Jebus. The reason for the persecution has shifted between the persecutors and the fashion of the day. Started off as ethnic persecution in the interest of cultural hegemony. With Christianity, that morphed into religious persecution - after all, the killed the J-man. This persecution continued under Muslim domination in the Middle-East, and under Christian in Europe. In the 20th century, the type of persecution morphed again into racial persecution, with the new ideas about race.

In short, hatred is irrational, and your hatred of Jews is as irrational as any other.
 
Quite simply the world's two biggest religions have issues with the Jews for various reasons.

The Romans and the Egyptians - who were Pagan - really disliked Israel.

And...Mahatma Ghandi was neither a Christian or a Muslim, yet he didn't care for Israel much at all and even wrote about it. As a result, I don't think Israelis particularly like Ghandi, either.
 
Netanyahu government knew teens were dead as it whipped up racist frenzy

Max Blumenthal said:
From the moment three Israeli teens were reported missing last month, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and the country’s military-intelligence apparatus suppressed the flow of information to the general public. Through a toxic blend of propaganda, subterfuge and incitement, they inflamed a precarious situation, manipulating Israelis into supporting their agenda until they made an utterly avoidable nightmare inevitable.

Israeli police, intelligence officials and Netanyahu knew within hours of the kidnapping and murder of the three teens that they had been killed. And they knew who the prime suspects were less than a day after the kidnapping was reported.

Rather than reveal these details to the public, Israel’s Shin Bet intelligence agency imposed a gag order on the national media, barring news outlets from reporting that the teens had almost certainly been killed, and forbidding them from revealing the identities of their suspected killers. The Shin Bet even lied to the parents of the kidnapped teens, deceiving them into believing their sons were alive. [...]

Weeks after the incident, it is now clear that the Israeli government, intelligence services and army engaged in a cover-up to provide themselves with the political space they required for a military campaign that had little to do with rescuing any kidnapped teens.

The disinformation campaign they waged sent a heavily indoctrinated, comprehensively militarized population into a tribalistic frenzy, provoking a wave of high-level incitement, the shocking revenge killing of an innocent Palestinian teen and rioting across East Jerusalem.

Where the chaos will end and how far it will spread is unknown. But its origins are increasingly clear. [...]
 
Sure
And as I have told you, they had some setbacks, around 70 years ago.

Now, they will still be here in 100 years, maybe not with a country in the middle east but as a minority in the US, UK or some Arab nation, why not?

They've had "setbacks" for practically their entire history as an identifiable ethnic group, thanks to enlightened little fellers such as yourself and a scattered, minority existence. Never again...at least not without one hell of a fight.

That's why not.
 
I double checked your first comment and it dated back to 2012.
Apparently.

I am talking about the recent news of a dead teen here.
And yes, two bads do not make one good. :)

Funny, it's dated Saturday July 5, 2014. Now it's up to 857 likes.
 
Why? Why have they fought so many people over time?

Why do so many people hate them?

Because they're Satan's minions.

Or maybe the same reason people have always hated females, homosexuals, gypsies, redheads, Kurds, and others the majority perceives as "weak". And as soon as those "weaklings" begin to fight back...



Excellent question

For simple minded bigots.
 
The Romans and the Egyptians - who were Pagan - really disliked Israel.

The Romans also disliked the Gauls and the Carthaginians, mainly because they were a pain in Romes side, just like the Jews (See: Zealots).

And...Mahatma Ghandi was neither a Christian or a Muslim, yet he didn't care for Israel much at all and even wrote about it. As a result, I don't think Israelis particularly like Ghandi, either.

Yes, Ghandi was not a fan of Zionism. What's your point?

Hitler was atheistic or at least not much religious

Hitler wasn't a strict Atheist, nor was he a strict Christian. He was his own brand of Crazy. But the SS was predominantly Roman Catholic/Protestant, and atheism was banned IIRC.

But, are you trying to say there wasn't a culture of antisemitism in Germany at the time of the nazis, and even before?
 
Gaddafi seemed invincible just a few months before his death.
In politics, such dramatic changes happen unexpectedly.

Who thought he was invincible?

Definition of "success" may be debatable, but I would not qualify what happened in Germany between 1943 and 1945 as a success for the Jewish people :sdl: :sdl: :sdl: :sdl: :sdl:

Wow.

We live in interesting times..
And thing change quite quickly.

Who would have said in 1932 that 10 years later the most rich people in Germany would have to fight for their own life?

Rich people?

I consider donating crown (local currency) to a charity of my choice (in my case, organizations against sexual abuse) every time someone posts a Godwin in a thread about Israel and Palestine. It wouldn't reduce the number of Godwins, but I would eradicate sexual abuse.

Anyone who has that kind of money... :)

Both sides have got to stop and to look at what they have allowed themselves to denigrate into in their reactions to the atrocities in this region. It's time to stop making it about sides and make it about the common human integrity of peace and respecting life.

I agree, but how do you accomplish that?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom