Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why can't Israel push religion to the back-burner like other advance nations and integrate their population ? The church of England and church of Sweden are official state religions, but largely ignorable.

I would guess that it's because Israel was founded specifically in order to provide a safe homeland for Jews and so Judaism is more than just a state religion.
 
This does look like a very cheap shot at Kerry (he deserves better criticism).

I disagree with his position, but it's no more stupid than other US policy.

Why can't Israel push religion to the back-burner like other advance nations and integrate their population ? The church of England and church of Sweden are official state religions, but largely ignorable.

Jefferson saw first hand now non-Anglicans were excluded from power in Virginia and invented the areligious state to cure this problem. Why are we now trying to help enforce a religious state or else separation on others ? It defies our principles as a nation. Would the US send arms if half the Vatican population decided to turn pagan ? What exactly is the US national interest here ?

I agree with this. I'm Jewish and I've made this exact point to my family members, but they considered it heresy. What makes America great is that we have no official language, ethnicity, or religion. Anyone can live and thrive here, no matter where they come from or what their background is. It makes our culture vibrant and dynamic.

The idea that we'd support a society that seeks to exclude anyone not of the official religion or background goes against what we're founded on.
 
And by the way, can you name the only nation in the Middle East that allows Muslims to vote?

Oh, really honest non-argument there. Rhetorical device specifically designed to mislead.

ETA: Unless it's just a case of abject ignorance, also possible I guess.
 
Last edited:
Turkey is certainly a fairly stable and fairly liberal democracy, but not ME either.

The eastern part of Istanbul has a strong Eastern European vibe but it gives way pretty quickly to the Middle East.

How are you getting your definition?
 
http://freebeacon.com/national-secu...xtremely-harmful-apartheid-remarks-on-israel/

Krauthammer weighs in:

"it’s beyond nonsense,” he said. ”It’s pernicious and extremely harmful. What the Secretary of State of the United States has succeeded in doing in what he thought was a private comment is to echo and therefore to legitimize the worst of the libelous (claims) against the Jewish state. If there is one minority in the Middle East that enjoys the rule of law and protection and democracy, it is Arabs in Israel … This is beyond something requiring an apology. I think this is a resigning-type statement. This is an injury to an ally that will echo, because it will be repeated. People will say, ‘I’m not saying this, it is the Secretary of State of the United States.’ It’s untrue, it’s pernicious and it’s truly something that demands at the very least an immediate apology.”
 
http://freebeacon.com/national-secu...xtremely-harmful-apartheid-remarks-on-israel/

Krauthammer weighs in:

"it’s beyond nonsense,” he said. ”It’s pernicious and extremely harmful. What the Secretary of State of the United States has succeeded in doing in what he thought was a private comment is to echo and therefore to legitimize the worst of the libelous (claims) against the Jewish state. If there is one minority in the Middle East that enjoys the rule of law and protection and democracy, it is Arabs in Israel … This is beyond something requiring an apology. I think this is a resigning-type statement. This is an injury to an ally that will echo, because it will be repeated. People will say, ‘I’m not saying this, it is the Secretary of State of the United States.’ It’s untrue, it’s pernicious and it’s truly something that demands at the very least an immediate apology.”

He also doesn't respond to what Kerry actually said.
 
http://freebeacon.com/national-secu...xtremely-harmful-apartheid-remarks-on-israel/

Krauthammer weighs in:

"it’s beyond nonsense,” he said. ”It’s pernicious and extremely harmful. What the Secretary of State of the United States has succeeded in doing in what he thought was a private comment is to echo and therefore to legitimize the worst of the libelous (claims) against the Jewish state. If there is one minority in the Middle East that enjoys the rule of law and protection and democracy, it is Arabs in Israel … This is beyond something requiring an apology. I think this is a resigning-type statement. This is an injury to an ally that will echo, because it will be repeated. People will say, ‘I’m not saying this, it is the Secretary of State of the United States.’ It’s untrue, it’s pernicious and it’s truly something that demands at the very least an immediate apology.”
Can always count on Charles. Love Krauthammer. He's a genius.
Who else but John Kerry could be counted upon to always make Hillary look good?
 
Last edited:
John Kerry - Israel Apartheid state?

I was checking my notes ... hmmm ... didn't Kerry just rip this off from Jimmy Carter?
No original thought needed.
 
John Kerry - Israel Apartheid state?

I was checking my notes ... hmmm ... didn't Kerry just rip this off from Jimmy Carter?
No original thought needed.

No. You could first use some further though, check what each person has said, then think about what is similar or what is different.
 
Last edited:
As usual, a thread with zero substance from the OP.

I ask again.

“A two-state solution will be clearly underscored as the only real alternative. Because a unitary state winds up either being an apartheid state with second-class citizens—or it ends up being a state that destroys the capacity of Israel to be a Jewish state,”

What is wrong with that statement?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom