Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
With the way Israel is stealing land from the Palestinians, they are helping to create a situation in the future where they may have to take drastic measures - yet not have the world-wide Moral Capital to do so: Israel could become an international pariah. So...why not do the right thing now and build up that Moral Capital for the day they may need it to deal with the Palestinians.

Seriously, if Israel returned to Reasonable Borders (like what Clinton proposed) and then had to do something drastic because the Pals attacked them, then they would have the Moral Capital to pull it off. But right now? No....because lots of nations would not respect them.

Seriously folks, you may think the Palestinian Situation is under control, but the clock is ticking down for Israel. The more land they steal, the more emboldened they will become. And this will go on until one day they will become just like the people they despise.

Israel has played the "Pity Card" with this country more than a few times, but the day is coming when it won't work. Every year there are fewer and fewer Fundy Xtians (Israeli Allies) in America and more Liberal Xtians and Agnostics. There will be a day when this country views any religious state like Israel as some kind of Retrograde accident. When this day happens Israel will pretty-much be on its own.

Really...ya' think Israel can go it alone?
 
With the way Israel is stealing land from the Palestinians, they are helping to create a situation in the future where they may have to take drastic measures - yet not have the world-wide Moral Capital to do so: Israel could become an international pariah. So...why not do the right thing now and build up that Moral Capital for the day they may need it to deal with the Palestinians.

Seriously, if Israel returned to Reasonable Borders (like what Clinton proposed) and then had to do something drastic because the Pals attacked them, then they would have the Moral Capital to pull it off. But right now? No....because lots of nations would not respect them.

Seriously folks, you may think the Palestinian Situation is under control, but the clock is ticking down for Israel. The more land they steal, the more emboldened they will become. And this will go on until one day they will become just like the people they despise.

Israel has played the "Pity Card" with this country more than a few times, but the day is coming when it won't work. Every year there are fewer and fewer Fundy Xtians (Israeli Allies) in America and more Liberal Xtians and Agnostics. There will be a day when this country views any religious state like Israel as some kind of Retrograde accident. When this day happens Israel will pretty-much be on its own.

Really...ya' think Israel can go it alone?

Tried it. Didn't work.

What does work is a good, firm hand. They respect that. Terrorist attacks are down to almost nil. Hamas suppress rocket attacks on Israel's behalf. Some Palestinians are being allowed into Israel as day workers. That's as good as it gets.

That's why Israel doesn't listen to the peace movement and the political left anymore. All of their advice turned out to be wishful thinking and worthless.
 
Maybe they are trying to get the land back that Israel stole from them.

Israel builds those Walls to keep the Palestinians off the land they just stole - and to keep the Palestinians confined to their Ghettos.
I give up. You're like a broken record, endlessly repeating the same claims and refusing to back them up in any way whatsoever, and then express frustration because we don't want to discuss the answers you refuse to give us:rolleyes:. Then, 10 posts later, you post the same "Meanwhile in Palestine" spam post, effectively trying to hit the reset button on the whole conversation.

Have fun, all.
 
Last edited:
Odd, isn't it, that peace-loving peaceful Palestinians prefer a genocidal terrorist group as their government.

I'm sure the usual suspects will come alomng shortly and explain how it's all Israel's fault that anti-semitism runs rampant in the PA.

Well you lot did have Bush Jr. Went to war because God told him too. Blair wasnt much better.

We call them holy wullies round here
 
Well you lot did have Bush Jr. Went to war because God told him too. Blair wasnt much better.

We call them holy wullies round here
Yeah, that's why we went to war., Bush went before Congress and told them God said "go to war".


Ridiculous.
 
So Israelis should all commit suicide and then there'd be peace?

It's been suggested before:


-----------------------------------------------------------------
In 1938, just after Kristallnacht, when the Nazis systematically destroyed Germany’s and Austria’s synagogues, Gandhi wrote these shameful words where he urged Europe’s Jews to joyfully accept the Nazi onslaught:

“If I were a Jew and were born in Germany … I would claim Germany as my home even as the tallest gentile German may, and challenge him to shoot me or cast me in the dungeon. … And suffering voluntarily undergone will bring them an inner strength and joy. … The calculated violence of Hitler may even result in a general massacre of the Jews by way of his first answer to the declaration of such hostilities. But if the Jewish mind could be prepared for voluntary suffering, even the massacre I have imagined could be turned into a day of thanksgiving and joy that Jehovah had wrought deliverance of the race even at the hands of the tyrant.”

...

Fisher asked him [1947]: “You mean that the Jews should have committed collective suicide?” Gandhi responded: “Yes, that would have been heroism.”

http://blogs.timesofisrael.com/gandhi-on-jews-part-2-nazis-and-cowardice/
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
It's been suggested before:


-----------------------------------------------------------------
In 1938, just after Kristallnacht, when the Nazis systematically destroyed Germany’s and Austria’s synagogues, Gandhi wrote these shameful words where he urged Europe’s Jews to joyfully accept the Nazi onslaught:

“If I were a Jew and were born in Germany … I would claim Germany as my home even as the tallest gentile German may, and challenge him to shoot me or cast me in the dungeon. … And suffering voluntarily undergone will bring them an inner strength and joy. … The calculated violence of Hitler may even result in a general massacre of the Jews by way of his first answer to the declaration of such hostilities. But if the Jewish mind could be prepared for voluntary suffering, even the massacre I have imagined could be turned into a day of thanksgiving and joy that Jehovah had wrought deliverance of the race even at the hands of the tyrant.”

...

Fisher asked him [1947]: “You mean that the Jews should have committed collective suicide?” Gandhi responded: “Yes, that would have been heroism.”

http://blogs.timesofisrael.com/gandhi-on-jews-part-2-nazis-and-cowardice/
------------------------------------------------------------------------------


And in 1937, Hitler was receiving the British Foreign Secretary, Edward Frederick Lindley Wood, Lord Halifax. Halifax had been Viceroy of India (1926-1931), and the question of unrest there somehow came up.

Hitler's proposed solution was brief and blunt: "Shoot Gandhi."

Halifax said that would just not be done.

Hitler replied: "Shoot Gandhi, and if that dues not suffice to reduce them to submission, shoot a dozen leading members of the Congress, and if that doesn't suffice shoot 200 and so on as you make it clear that you mean business."

On the other end of the spectrum, Annamese educator Nguyen Sinh Cung opined that if Gandhi had tried satyagraha against the French, he would speedily have been reunited with his ancestors.

:blackcat:
 
You gave no evidence that the Jewish leadership intended to violated the UN partition plan had it been signed by all sides.

Well I mentioned Abba Eban, and think that's somewhat speaks to the zeitgeist of that era. Also we have the openings of some archives and Ben-Gurions (and others) dairies that have shed some light. It is not often theses things are not commited to paper and lot is euphemisms and beating around the bush. I think it works quite similar to how Morris describes the 'tranfer' (euphemism for ethnic cleansing):

Benny Morris said:
From April 1948, Ben-Gurion is projecting a message of transfer. There is no explicit order of his in writing, there is no orderly comprehensive policy, but there is an atmosphere of [population] transfer. The transfer idea is in the air. The entire leadership understands that this is the idea. The officer corps understands what is required of them. Under Ben-Gurion, a consensus of transfer is created.

They wanted as much as possible. Of course the Zionists accepted the plan, who wouldn't in their shues. If you officially have nothing, of course you say yes to something. But it seems clear to me, that they wanted as much as they could get.

Instead you gave evidence that once hostilities started by the Arab side,

Define "started". There where hostilies from both sides, a tit for tat. But from an objective viewpoint the conflict started 1897 in Basel when the first Zionist Congress decided,"...to establish a home for the Jewish people in Palestine…", without asking the indigenous population, one might ad.

...the Jews thought it will be hard to the to defend whatever area they managed to get. This is still true today, just look at the map of Israel.
Here, you are inserting a new factor in the discussion, military logic. Well, all kinds of violations can be made by refering to "defense capabilities", "security" and the like. If you start down that path you might very well end up with Guantanamo och tapping Angela Merkels phone, "for security reasons", if you catch my drift. The concept of ein brira is deeply embedded in the military mindset, and in the israeli psyche as a whole.

Secondly, you seem to think that the Palestinians were right not to compromise.(And lets be honest, at the time their beef was not about the amount of land allocated to a Jewish state. They objected to the existence of a Jewish state in any part of the land.)
I'm not sure what you mean here. Of course they had every right to dispute it. Why should the indigenous Palestinian population feel that they had a moral obligation to sacrifice their land to compensate for the crimes commited against jews by the Europeans? They perhaps wondered why a more appropriate response would not have been to remove the population of Bavaria and turned it into a jewish state.

Are you implying they were also right to start a war?
I'm not sure what you mean by "right to start a war" here. Did they have a right to resist an immigration that meant that they would get dispossesed from their land?

If so, what are you exactly complaining about? Which side won? What do you think should be done today?
I'm not complaining. The Jews won. There won't be a Palestine.

What should be done? That is really an answer that demands a book. :)

I think that in 20 years, there will be a one-state solution. Israel isn't capable of leaving the WB. The Israeli governement want The Land. That's why they are building on it. Sure, they want peace too, but they want land more than peace.

Given this perpective, it's resonable for a new generation of Palestinians, to demand equal rights in the country that they de facto live in, Israel.

Sure there are hatred and bigotry on all sides, but that’s a natural residual of the fact that the conflict is still there. And if you talk to Palestinians today, especially younger people, they are as fed up with the corruption of Fatah and Hamas as they are with the occupation.

Not far from now, I predict, the turning point will come, and Palestinians on the West Bank, will give up their claim for statehood, and demand equal rights within a Greater Israel, from the river to the sea. When that day comes, zionist of the standard brand will have real problems.

This probably requires more discussion but I fear I am too busy to really engage in long discussion here. I wish I had more free time, but this is not going to happen soon.
Yeah, same here. Happy New Year.
 
With the way Israel is stealing land from the Palestinians, they are helping to create a situation in the future where they may have to take drastic measures - yet not have the world-wide Moral Capital to do so: Israel could become an international pariah. So...why not do the right thing now and build up that Moral Capital for the day they may need it to deal with the Palestinians.

What, exactly, is "Moral Capital" and how much of it do the Palestinians have?
 
They wanted as much as possible. Of course the Zionists accepted the plan, who wouldn't in their shues. If you officially have nothing, of course you say yes to something. But it seems clear to me, that they wanted as much as they could get.

Shues?

That's not the first time you've misspelled a common word, I'm guessing English is not your first language? If so, what is your first language?
 
Given this perpective, it's resonable for a new generation of Palestinians, to demand equal rights in the country that they de facto live in, Israel.
You mean the new generation of Palestinians raised on bigotry and hatred on a scale that makes the Hitler Youth pale in comparison?







Yeah, the young generation, there's reason to hope!
 
Point notwithstanding, that will get you a reprimand for "getting information from YouTube propaganda".
 
You mean the new generation of Palestinians raised on bigotry and hatred on a scale that makes the Hitler Youth pale in comparison?







Yeah, the young generation, there's reason to hope!

Decades of this stuff has raised a generation that think a Third Intifada is a brilliant idea. They have no memory of the disaster of the last one.

Once again the Palestinians bring huge fail upon themselves.
 
With the way Israel is stealing land from the Palestinians, they are helping to create a situation in the future where they may have to take drastic measures - yet not have the world-wide Moral Capital to do so: Israel could become an international pariah. So...why not do the right thing now and build up that Moral Capital for the day they may need it to deal with the Palestinians.

Seriously, if Israel returned to Reasonable Borders (like what Clinton proposed) and then had to do something drastic because the Pals attacked them, then they would have the Moral Capital to pull it off. But right now? No....because lots of nations would not respect them.

Seriously folks, you may think the Palestinian Situation is under control, but the clock is ticking down for Israel. The more land they steal, the more emboldened they will become. And this will go on until one day they will become just like the people they despise.

Israel has played the "Pity Card" with this country more than a few times, but the day is coming when it won't work. Every year there are fewer and fewer Fundy Xtians (Israeli Allies) in America and more Liberal Xtians and Agnostics. There will be a day when this country views any religious state like Israel as some kind of Retrograde accident. When this day happens Israel will pretty-much be on its own.

Really...ya' think Israel can go it alone?

That would be a lovely argument if Israel had actually stolen any land. But they didn't. So this is only an issue for people such as yourself who perpetuate this myth in order to justify your bias and can't be bothered to actually study the history in that region.

Again, the reason why you have such a hard time understanding Israel's position, is because you completely misunderstand what is actually going on in this land dispute.
 
Meanwhile in reality, a very significant portion of Israel's population still supports a withdrawal. This article comes from the NRK, the Norwegian state broadcaster, which is hardly known for being an Israel-friendly source.

As we've been saying for pages, there is a very real possibility of a peaceful, dignified and fair solution to this conflict, should the Palestinians be willing to take it after having had their butts kicked for 70 years. They aren't, however. That's the real problem here, not that Israel "terrorices the Palestinians", "continuously steals land", or any other myths perpetuated by the usual suspects. The Palestinians don't want their slice back, they want the whole cake.
 
That would be a lovely argument if Israel had actually stolen any land*. But they didn't. So this is only an issue for people such as yourself who perpetuate this myth in order to justify your bias and can't be bothered to actually study the history in that region.

Again, the reason why you have such a hard time understanding Israel's position, is because you completely misunderstand what is actually going on in this land dispute.

*With the exception of some (most?) West Bank settlements which I think actually do fall under that label.

They removed all settlements in Sinai and Gaza, I believe. So it's not an unimaginable step for them to remove them from the West Bank. But from their perspective I'm not sure there's a reason to do so.

Allowing illegal civilian settlements is wrong, but their negotiating partner is a democratically elected genocidal terrorist group. And where do you go with that?
 
Last edited:
Allowing illegal civilian settlements is wrong, but their negotiating partner is a democratically elected genocidal terrorist group. And where do you go with that?
Maybe they can compromise, like any Jew born in January, March, May, July, September, and November reports immediately to Hamas for execution, and the rest will be allowed to live in Muslim-ruled Palestine as dhimmi.

Bu no, those Jews won't even meet them halfway, those sons of apes and pigs!
 
They wanted as much as possible. Of course the Zionists accepted the plan, who wouldn't in their shues. If you officially have nothing, of course you say yes to something. But it seems clear to me, that they wanted as much as they could get.

I think that in 20 years, there will be a one-state solution. Israel isn't capable of leaving the WB. The Israeli governement want The Land. That's why they are building on it. Sure, they want peace too, but they want land more than peace.

Really?

During the 1967 War, Israel gained land from Egypt, Jordan, and
Syria. Israel maintained that Jerusalem would remain a unified city,
with all religions having access to their holy sites. But Israel stated it
was open to returning other territories in exchange for peace and
recognition of its right to exist. Arab nations met in Khartoum, Sudan
in 1967, and declared their unwillingness to make peace, recognize,
or even negotiate with Israel. Egypt began small-scale attacks
against Israeli positions which continued until Anwar Sadat came to
power in 1970. During this same period, the PLO attacked Israeli
military personnel and civilians from bases in Jordan, Lebanon, Syria
and Egypt. It also carried out airplane hijackings and terrorist attacks
outside of Israel.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom