Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
The reality is the Palestinian position is based on deep-rooted anti-Semitism with genocidal intent and they have made no concessions whatsoever after all these years.

Don't you think its time the rest of the world stopped appeasing anti-Semites and championing them?

(waits for someone to try to re-define "anti-Semitism")

It's funny how Europe bans Nazi parties and holocaust denial but throws money at the PA and Palestinian "NGO" groups. They don't even care that the money gets ripped off and scammed.
 
Last edited:
The reality is the Palestinian position is based on deep-rooted anti-Semitism with genocidal intent and they have made no concessions whatsoever after all these years.

Don't you think its time the rest of the world stopped appeasing anti-Semites and championing them?

(waits for someone to try to re-define "anti-Semitism")

What a load of crap. So the Palestinian position is based on deep seated Anti-Semitism, and has nothing to do with dispossession and occupation but is purely anti-Semitism? I suppose the frequent use of torture by the occupation authorities or the practice of collective reprisals have nothing to do with it. Perhaps you should read a little of the material produced by B'Tselem http://www.btselem.org/; to say nothing of Amnesty International.

Palestinian opposition to the early Zionist settlement had everything to do with fear of dispossession. And since some of the early Zionists made idiotic comments about Palestine being a "land without people" and other such nonsense indicating that some of them wished that the Palestinians would just go away. And by the mid 1930's some Zionists were openly talking about "transferring" the population. Other extremists Zionists were talking about taking over all of Palestine. Sadly there were those pesky Palestinians in the way. And during the first Arab Israeli war several hundred thousand Palestinians fled and or were deliberately driven from their homes by the victorious Israeli. During and after the war various myths were concocted which are still repeated about this disaster but the fact is coercion played an essential part in causing the flight. And to this day there are Israeli political groups that want to complete the conquest of Palestine and the expulsion of the pesky natives. Oh and there were several rather gruesome massacres perpetuated by terrorists of the Israeli Irgun and Lehi during this conflict.

So the Palestinians were indeed dispossessed. That they wanted to go home is hardly a surprise. That the Israelis did not want them back was hardly a surprise either. That the Palestinians did not like Israeli rule of the occupied West Bank is again hardly a surprise. That they would engage in civil disobedience and terrorist violence under the circumstances is again not a surprise. As for not negotiating with terrorists the Palestinians have the example of Zionist terrorism against the British after the Second World War in Palestine. Which of course indicates terrorism never works.(Snark) And of course Israel has had two bona-fide former terrorist Prime Ministers Begin and Shamir. Shamir is especially note worthy having been part of the plot to murder (successfully) a UN envoy - Count Bernadotte.

Oh and the Palestinians have made concessions. There is of course the Oslo accords which among the Palestinians were treated has very much a victory for Israel.

Of course if we wish to discuss Palestinian stupidities one could talk all night. The Palestinian leadership has been largely disastrous for 3 generations. Frankly a two state solution was the only viable one from the early 1930's on and the Palestinian leaderships refusal to accept that incredibly foolish.

To get back to the point Palestinian opposition to Israel is not rooted in anti-Semitism but in the fear of dispossession and colonization and that fear has not been groundless by a long shot.

I strongly suggest you talk to a few Palestinians and you might want to read these two books by Benny Morris, 1948, and The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem 1947-1948.
 
So the Palestinian position is based on deep seated Anti-Semitism,
Yes.

and has nothing to do with dispossession and occupation but is purely anti-Semitism?
Nope.

The Arabs could not bear the thought of a Jewish country, and immediately attacked Israel in a failed attempt at genocide, that's the facts. The Arabs who stayed are full citizens of Israel with all the rights that entails. Jews in Arab countries, OTOH... :eek:
 
There is of course the Oslo accords which among the Palestinians were treated has very much a victory for Israel.
.

Which just shows how little appetite there is on the Palestinian side for meaningful peace (as opposed to surrender) negotiations.
 
Oh and there were several rather gruesome massacres perpetuated by terrorists of the Israeli Irgun and Lehi during this conflict.

It sounds like you're channeling Pappé here, rather than Morris, while also forgetting Arab and Palestinian massacres against Jewish civilians. Some would call this a sort of bias.
 
It sounds like you're channeling Pappé here, rather than Morris, while also forgetting Arab and Palestinian massacres against Jewish civilians. Some would call this a sort of bias.
Indeed, WWII and its aftermath was a turbulent time marked by shifting borders, new countries being created, and massive movements of populations. Everyone except the Palestinians have managed to move on with their lives. We now have the absurdity of 4th generation Palestinian "refugees" whose grandparents haven't ever set foot inside the country they claim to be refugees from.
 
yes the arabs who have stayed are full citizens of the state of Israel however that does not appear to prevent them getting discriminated against by some elements of the authorities.

This is from the US State Department:

http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/204575.pdf

And the articles of this academic are worth a look

http://www.geog.bgu.ac.il/members/yiftachel/index.html

Yes, there is a deep strain of anti-Arab racism in Israel...just like the deep strain of anti-Jewish racism in the territories (and virtually the entire ME). That happens during 65+ years of continuous hot and cold war.
 
Indeed, WWII and its aftermath was a turbulent time marked by shifting borders, new countries being created, and massive movements of populations. Everyone except the Palestinians have managed to move on with their lives. We now have the absurdity of 4th generation Palestinian "refugees" whose grandparents haven't ever set foot inside the country they claim to be refugees from.

Give it a few more generations, and the Palestinians will face the same problem the Jews faced when they initially came to the Levant - "Oh, Jerusalem was your holy city? Too bad, it's been lived in by other people for quite a while now - deal with it."

Or maybe they won't have to deal with it. I don't know.
 
What a load of crap. So the Palestinian position is based on deep seated Anti-Semitism, and has nothing to do with dispossession and occupation but is purely anti-Semitism?

Palestinians consider all of Israel "occupied territory" to "liberated", divvied up as spoils and cleansed of Jews. They're idiots and they're going to hold out until their idiot fantasy comes true.
 
Last edited:
Indeed, WWII and its aftermath was a turbulent time marked by shifting borders, new countries being created, and massive movements of populations. Everyone except the Palestinians have managed to move on with their lives. We now have the absurdity of 4th generation Palestinian "refugees" whose grandparents haven't ever set foot inside the country they claim to be refugees from.

Hmmm, almost as if we should try holding Palestinians to the same standards that we hold the rest of the world to. it's almost as if the world excusing their dysfunctionality means that they are never forced to grow up and so the bloodshed and hatred continues down through the generations.
 
Anti-semite zionist professor denounces IDF for not raping Palestinians.

That's not a typo.

in one case, a professor asked me if I knew how many Palestinians have been raped by IDF forces. I answered that as far as I knew, none. She triumphantly responded that I was right, because, she said, “You IDF soldiers don’t rape Palestinians because Israelis are so racist and disgusted by them that you won’t touch them.”
 
Originally Posted by Pacal
and has nothing to do with dispossession and occupation but is purely anti-Semitism?

Yes.
Originally Posted by Pacal
and has nothing to do with dispossession and occupation but is purely anti-Semitism?
Nope.

The Arabs could not bear the thought of a Jewish country, and immediately attacked Israel in a failed attempt at genocide, that's the facts. The Arabs who stayed are full citizens of Israel with all the rights that entails. Jews in Arab countries, OTOH... :eek:

You regurgitate propaganda most effectively. The bottom line is before 1948 some Zionists were already thinking of "transfer", and The Palestinians were worried about being dispossessed and removed. And some Zionist extremists wanted all of Palestine including parts of Transjordan. Of course there was those pesky people who were already there.

I am amused that you think only anti Semitism could possibly motivate opposition in people who in the space of two generations see hundreds of thousands of settlers descend upon the land they had occupied for hundreds of years, with the intent of many of them to create a state. And as mentioned above some of them talk of removing the pesky prior inhabitants. Opposition is perfectly natural given the situation.

I note the hilarious line of the Arab states who attacked Israel in 1948 to commit genocide. That is a fantasy. There is no evidence of any plans to exterminate the Jews of
Palestine in 1948. In fact Abdullah the King of Transjordan simply wanted to absorb Arab Palestine. He got sucked into the war As for Egypt, Syria and Iraq, they sent only a portion of the forces available to them and not surprisingly failed. In fact King Abdullah expected any attempt to destroy the new Israeli state to fail. Despite myth making the odds against Israel were not large at all.

As for the line about Israeli Arabs being full citizens. That may now be formally true, but everyday reality is another matter. I suggest you talk to some actual Israeli Arabs like I have. Oh and I suggest you look at the activities of the Jewish Agency, a very powerful body, concerning the "equal treatment" of Israeli Arabs.

Thanks again for the PC bromides.
 
Which just shows how little appetite there is on the Palestinian side for meaningful peace (as opposed to surrender) negotiations.

Read the Oslo accords. They are obviously a victory for Israel. As for surrender negotiations that is what the Israeli have been demanding of the Palestinians for quite sometime.
 
Originally Posted by Pacal View Post
Oh and there were several rather gruesome massacres perpetuated by terrorists of the Israeli Irgun and Lehi during this conflict.

It sounds like you're channeling Pappé here, rather than Morris, while also forgetting Arab and Palestinian massacres against Jewish civilians. Some would call this a sort of bias.

I was replying to a post that claimed that the Palestinians were largely motivated by anti-Semitism. I am well aware that there were massacres by Arab forces of Israeli civilians and others during the war. I was also replying to the absurd notion that Israeli forces were somehow pure and noble and commited no atrocities. Mostly I was replying to idiot notion that Palestinian animosity has no "rational" basis. I should point out that there were more massacres of Arabs by Israeli during the first war than of Israeli by Arabs. Largely because very few Israeli settlements were conquered by Arab forces. Oh and I got the massacre stuff from Morris not from Pappe, who is too emotionally commited for my liking.

Terrorist atrocities by the Irgun and Lehi are well documented. King David Hotel bombing anyone? May I suggest Terror Out of Zion, by Bowyer Bell. Oh and the author is very much pro these groups and their use of terror.
 
Originally Posted by Pacal View Post
What a load of crap. So the Palestinian position is based on deep seated Anti-Semitism, and has nothing to do with dispossession and occupation but is purely anti-Semitism?
Palestinians consider all of Israel "occupied territory" to "liberated", divvied up as spoils and cleansed of Jews. They're idiots and they're going to hold out until their idiot fantasy comes true.

What a fantasy world some people live in. That is not true of all Palestinians and has not been true for a long time. But it is a standard PC canard. I shall only mention here the "idiot" fantasy of some Israeli to "remove" all the Palestinians from Palestine, including deporting all the Arab Israeli.

I also note that Hamas which is fanatically and foolishly extremist was helped in its early days by Israeli intelligence has a counter weight to the PLO. They did these well knowing what a bunch of fanatical extremists Hamas was, and sadly still is.

Seriously guys talk to some Palestinians.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom