Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
This portion is too silly to respond to. You're not even trying to make sense here.
Thats handy, beats responding.



No. As I've already said, you could reserve judgement until you have the information.
What information are you referring to?


Just made it...? What evidence do you have that was a recent decision?
recent is subjective The bedouin have been there a lot longer than Military declared zones. Some of them have moved around since they were declared and some were there when they were declared.

If they didn't have any reason for firing off the tear-gas or taking down the Bedouin tents...what does that imply?
Who said they didn't have any reason? In the example that Virus provided they may have had perfectly valid reasons. So can someone tell me what the reasons are. Rock throwing? Its possible but I have not seen any evidence in support of that, have you?

And if that's "cheap trash", as you say, what is telling me I'd be popular in the bigfoot community?
Maybe we can come to a historic agreement?
 
ok, videos can be described as containing anything you like and Wildcat will provide cover for you... He will describe you as being "duped" for not accepting that a video contains things that it clearly doesn't. Instead you substitute a failure to accept a misrepresentation of a video with acceptance of whatever some other group claims in other videos.

simple dishonesty.



I will not stand by and applaud stuff being made up no matter how much you want me to. No matter how much you try to assign beliefs to me about other issues. This is a skeptics forum and one of the things we do here is fact check what people say is in a video. Sorry if that gets in the way of your preferred narrative.
So your theory is that the Israeli soldiers were just bored or something and decided to launch tear gas and flash grenades at schoolchildren just because they're cartoonishly evil?
 
So your theory is that the Israeli soldiers were just bored or something and decided to launch tear gas and flash grenades at schoolchildren just because they're cartoonishly evil?

No amount of straw is going to add stone throwing to the video. I seriously apologize for fact checking claims which is something you appear to dislike.
 
Round and around we go:rolleyes:...
Let me ask you a simple question. Should people on a skeptic forum simply ignore claims made about the content of videos that are blatantly untrue?

I just want to get it firmed up what is getting you guys into this frenzy.


Nice that you quote Mycroft in your sig and rush to his defence.....in a choice of defending misrepresentation or defending Mycrofts right to rationalize misrepresentation I think you may be jumping on the wrong bandwagon.
 
No amount of straw is going to add stone throwing to the video. I seriously apologize for fact checking claims which is something you appear to dislike.
So why do you think the ISM didn't show what preceded the tear gas and flashbangs?
 
So why do you think the ISM didn't show what preceded the tear gas and flashbangs?
seriously wildcat....Ask the ISM... They are a partisan fact source like yourself.

No....lets all make something up and post a video saying that it shows what we think happened. Doesn't matter if the video contains it. We are all skeptics and are willing to overlook that sort of thing.

I'll do you a deal. Post a video of rock throwing every day here for a week they are not hard to find, but no amount of smoke mirrors tantrums and distractions are going to prevent me from pointing out any that you claim show rock throwing and in fact don't. Its just plain sloppy and I am amazed that you tie yourself in knots trying to rationalize misrepresentation on a skeptic forum.
 
seriously wildcat....Ask the ISM... They are a partisan fact source like yourself.
I don't need to ask them. I can figure it out all by myself, and I don't think they'd produce it anyway.
 
Last edited:
If the content supported ISM they would have shown it.

This isn't rocket science.
Virus posted a video claiming it showed rock throwing, likely he just assumed it did. I pointed out it didn't.

Virus got over it.

You need to get over it too.
 
I have no problem with ISM being partisan; they're supposed to be. I have a problem with them being completely FOS.

I don't see what this has got to do with the ISM anyway. The last couple of pages of BS has been due to tantrums over descriptions of videos and their content.

I prefer accuracy but some are not so sure.
 
Virus posted a video claiming it showed rock throwing, likely he just assumed it did. I pointed out it didn't.

Virus got over it.

You need to get over it too.
There is such a thing as an educated guess. If I hear hooves, I'll assume there's a horse coming. If I hear engines over my head and look up to see contrails, it's not a shot in the dark to assume a plane has just flown by. If you see a bottle in a store containing a black liquid, and it has a Coca-Cola label on it, chances are it contains coke.

Likewise, if you see footage of IDF soldiers using tear gas, there is a very, very, very high chance they do so in response to a provocation, rather than just "tear gassing children on their way to school". You can be pedantic and scream "OMG u can't know that for 100% certain!!!!" for several pages to your heart's content, but it changes absolutely nothing. Get over it, indeed:rolleyes:.

No....lets all make something up and post a video saying that it shows what we think happened.
Yes, like "Joos fire tear gas on kids going 2 school!!!"...
 
Last edited:
There is such a thing as an educated guess. If I hear hooves, I'll assume there's a horse coming. If I hear engines over my head and look up to see contrails, it's not a shot in the dark to assume a plane has just flown by. If you see a bottle in a store containing a black liquid, and it has a Coca-Cola label on it, chances are it contains coke.

Absolutely agree, There is such thing as an educated guess and I have no problems with someone expressing their educated guess. Just describe it as such. No one has said "joos fire teargas on kids going to school" so why use that as your quote?

Likewise, if you see footage of IDF soldiers using tear gas, there is a very, very, very high chance they do so in response to a provocation, rather than just "tear gassing children on their way to school". You can be pedantic and scream "OMG u can't know that for 100% certain!!!!" for several pages to your heart's content, but it changes absolutely nothing. Get over it, indeed:rolleyes:.
You want me to get over describing a video as containing something when it didn't. There is not a very very very high chance the video contains rock throwing. Its 100% not there. Its not the same thing and its either sloppy to do it or dishonest to do it depending on the circumstances.
Yes, like "Joos fire tear gas on kids going 2 school!!!"...
So if ISM does it does that mitigate doing it yourself? Partisan groups do this...and deserve to have it pointed out.
 
Didn't even say rock throwing was in the video. Was just describing how the scam behind these videos works. I don't know why you want to start a big argument over nothing.
 
Didn't even say rock throwing was in the video. Was just describing how the scam behind these videos works. I don't know why you want to start a big argument over nothing.

"Classic Pallywood. Kids throw rocks at soldiers. Soldiers disperse with with teargas. Activists stand around capturing it on tape and insert their own BS headline that you're supposed to believe at face value, without question."

May I suggest..

Classic Pallywood, Activists publish video of IDF firing teargas I believe there must have been provocation that justified the use of teargas that they left out of the video.
 
Thats handy, beats responding.

:oldroll:

What information are you referring to?

The missing information, of course. You know, where because you don't know why something is done you assume there is no good reason for it.

recent is subjective The bedouin have been there a lot longer than Military declared zones. Some of them have moved around since they were declared and some were there when they were declared.

So for all you know the Bedouin have been kicked off this spot by the Israelis, the Jordanians, the British, the Ottomans and the Romans before them, but because all that is "recent" on a geologic time scale, you're not responsible for maintaining any semblance of accuracy you're demanding from Virus?

Who said they didn't have any reason?

The ISM. Also Childlike Empress. They're the ones who characterized the event as "firing tear-gas on students on their way to school."

In the example that Virus provided they may have had perfectly valid reasons.

So suddenly Virus has given an "example" and not a description of the video. Troll much?

Maybe we can come to a historic agreement?

It's been tried before and resulted in failure, but I'm always optimistic. What do you propose?
 
"Classic Pallywood. Kids throw rocks at soldiers. Soldiers disperse with with teargas. Activists stand around capturing it on tape and insert their own BS headline that you're supposed to believe at face value, without question."

May I suggest..

Classic Pallywood, Activists publish video of IDF firing teargas I believe there must have been provocation that justified the use of teargas that they left out of the video.

When I first read it, I understood it to mean Virus describing how he believes the video came to be, and not a description of the contents of the video. Subsequent statements from Virus have backed up that initial interpretation.

You, on the other hand, insist your interpretation is the only possible interpretation, and have made a two-page argument over a very minor point.

What's your purpose? Is pointless argument fun for you? Don't you think it would be more productive to move on to more substantive issues?
 
When I first read it, I understood it to mean Virus describing how he believes the video came to be, and not a description of the contents of the video. Subsequent statements from Virus have backed up that initial interpretation.

You, on the other hand, insist your interpretation is the only possible interpretation, and have made a two-page argument over a very minor point.
That seems to sum it up pretty nicely, yes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom