Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
That seems to sum it up pretty nicely, yes.

One thing I have learned, never get in the way of people and their faith.

If you just have to believe that there was rock throwing prior to the video footage and you just have to believe that when a videos introduction is...."Classic Pallywood. Kids throw rocks at soldiers. Soldiers disperse with with teargas......" means there is actually no rock throwing then there is not a lot I can do but say.......go for it, whatever you need to do.
 
One thing I have learned, never get in the way of people and their faith.

If you just have to believe that there was rock throwing prior to the video footage and you just have to believ--- [and so on]
F for reading comprehension.
 
One thing I have learned, never get in the way of people and their faith.

If you just have to believe that there was rock throwing prior to the video footage and you just have to believe that when a videos introduction is...."Classic Pallywood. Kids throw rocks at soldiers. Soldiers disperse with with teargas......" means there is actually no rock throwing then there is not a lot I can do but say.......go for it, whatever you need to do.


Actually a look at that channel (unknown to me) speaks a lot about those "accusations". A week earlier, a similar scene was uploaded, described "This is a video showing clashes between Israeli soldiers and young demonstrators, soldiers fired tear gas canisters and sound grenades while the youth threw stones."


Bolding mine. So the hasbaraWP parrots' "argument" that this organization routinely omits parts of what happened in the events they document seems flimsy at best. Actually it seems to show the full nature of what those funny-hat-wearing-heros are up to.

I wonder (no I don't) what they make of this until-seven-minutes-ago latest video uploaded to that channel:


Maybe "women shouldn't smoke in the backyard"?

No idea who that "international activist" in that seven minutes old video is - his haircut looks dangerous, though... ;):rolleyes:

 
Last edited:
Since we don't know what precipitated any of these videos or any of the context you haven't proven anything.
 
Since we don't know what precipitated any of these videos or any of the context you haven't proven anything.

Now I'm confused, you were confident of what proceeded the clip you posted. you told us about its context...it was typical of rocks then teargas...even if the rocks where not in evidence.

But these clips.....you don't know?
 
You've been confused the entire time, you just don't realize it.
Ad-Hom ignored
What do you think this video shows? What do you think the purpose of the ISM posting it was?

Watch the video, you should be able to see what it shows.


Ask ISM what their purpose is. I just see them as one of the many partisan commentators on this issue, like yourself.
 
It's entirely possible to be partisan and not be completely FOS. ISM has ZERO credibility.
I don't believe partisan commentators are seeking credibility, they feed a target audience with what they want to hear.

Like the posting of cherries from You tube in this thread...
 
No amount of straw is going to add stone throwing to the video.
If that video doesn't show stone throwing, stone throwing must not have happened, since video cams show you everything field of view be damned.

"Classic Pallywood. Kids throw rocks at soldiers. Soldiers disperse with with teargas. Activists stand around capturing it on tape and insert their own BS headline that you're supposed to believe at face value, without question."
This pattern of behavior on about three sides is a thirty year pattern that I am familiar with from having been subjected to so much *********** news from that piece of real estate over that period of time. Thus, using Occam's Razor, which is frequently appealed to on this site, one may infer that this pattern once again went down as predictably as usual.
Like the posting of cherries from You tube in this thread...
It appears to be a form of shorthand communication on the internet anymore, which I don't care for. What I care for hasn't stopped it from proliferating on this once excellent web site. :(
 
If that video doesn't show stone throwing, stone throwing must not have happened, since video cams show you everything field of view be damned.
No. If the video shows anything.....anything at all....it will always be an opinion what happened before the video. Some people here are disappointed about that.


This pattern of behavior on about three sides is a thirty year pattern that I am familiar with from having been subjected to so much *********** news from that piece of real estate over that period of time. Thus, using Occam's Razor, which is frequently appealed to on this site, one may infer that this pattern once again went down as predictably as usual.
It appears to be a form of shorthand communication on the internet anymore, which I don't care for. What I care for hasn't stopped it from proliferating on this once excellent web site. :(
If you are suggesting that displaying a video of IDF personnel firing teargas means I should accept they have had rocks thrown at them I'm sorry but I still can't. If you want to express it as an opinion based on probability then go ahead.....just describe it as such (like you do).
 
I don't believe partisan commentators are seeking credibility, they feed a target audience with what they want to hear.

Depends entirely on the quality of the partisan commentator. I'm a member of the very partisan Humane Society, and that organization takes its credibility quite seriously. The imbecilic partisans over at We are Change, however, don't.
 
Depends entirely on the quality of the partisan commentator. I'm a member of the very partisan Humane Society, and that organization takes its credibility quite seriously. The imbecilic partisans over at We are Change, however, don't.
I take your point but being Partisan on the sort of topics the humane society is involved in is not going to get you into the same sort of conflict that being partisan on middle east politics will.
 
Good article on how the present peace process has it backwards:

------

Rather than arm and train the terrorists (Fatah) it should force their disarmament.

Rather than finance them to the tune of $7.4 billion thereby enabling them to continue the “resistance”, they should be left to fend for themselves.

Rather than force Israel to freeze settlement activity thereby removing time as an issue it should allow Israel to build to its heart’s content thereby forcing the Palestinians to compromise quickly rather than to allow an erosion of their position in a final settlement.

Rather than force Israel to make goodwill gestures which merely encourages intransigence, it should force the Palestinians to make goodwill gestures. Whatever resistance Israelis have to the “peace process”, it will be reduced with such real gestures.

This is so obvious that one must conclude that the peace process is designed to continue the conflict rather than end it.

...
http://www.theaugeanstables.com/
 
Good article on how the present peace process has it backwards:

------

Rather than arm and train the terrorists (Fatah) it should force their disarmament.

Rather than finance them to the tune of $7.4 billion thereby enabling them to continue the “resistance”, they should be left to fend for themselves.

Rather than force Israel to freeze settlement activity thereby removing time as an issue it should allow Israel to build to its heart’s content thereby forcing the Palestinians to compromise quickly rather than to allow an erosion of their position in a final settlement.

Rather than force Israel to make goodwill gestures which merely encourages intransigence, it should force the Palestinians to make goodwill gestures. Whatever resistance Israelis have to the “peace process”, it will be reduced with such real gestures.

This is so obvious that one must conclude that the peace process is designed to continue the conflict rather than end it.

...
http://www.theaugeanstables.com/
Personally I would think a "good" article would contain some detail, or at least some scope? It contains terms like "to its heart’s content" How far is that?

"left to fend for themselves" What does this mean in practice. Independent foreign agencies are excluded.....how...who does it?

"force the Palestinians to make goodwill gestures." Is that like forcing someone to volunteer? This person is serious??

Honestly, this "article" appears to be simply a reposting of a blog entry by a person with extremist views.

Luckily I doubt if more than a handful of core faithful could be signed up to support this effort as even a slightly serious proposal.
 
A Modest Proposal to the Anti-Defamation League

Alison Weir said:
Dear Abe Foxman,

Thank you! Our organization, If Americans Knew, is enormously honored by our inclusion in your recent Top Ten list of "anti-Israel groups" – in reality, organizations working most strenuously and effectively to oppose Israel's brutal human rights abuses and violent ethnic cleansing project.

As you note, hundreds of such groups "operate in the U.S. today," and, I might add, a great many of them produce profoundly valuable work. This makes us particularly honored to have been included among the ten most effective.

Your organization apparently finds those working on behalf of justice and equality for all abhorrent when this includes Palestinians. Happily, many disagree with you. In fact, a large and growing number of people (of all ethnicities, religions, races, and political persuasions) believe that universal principles of morality do not contain exceptions. [...]


Right on. :thumbsup:
 
Were you guys just talking about rank partisan hacks and BS artists? Alison Weir is a good example of that.
 
Personally I would think a "good" article would contain some detail, or at least some scope? It contains terms like "to its heart’s content" How far is that?

"left to fend for themselves" What does this mean in practice. Independent foreign agencies are excluded.....how...who does it?

"force the Palestinians to make goodwill gestures." Is that like forcing someone to volunteer? This person is serious??

Honestly, this "article" appears to be simply a reposting of a blog entry by a person with extremist views.

Luckily I doubt if more than a handful of core faithful could be signed up to support this effort as even a slightly serious proposal.

Nonsense. It's not a detailed peace plan. It's just pointing out how the current approach is wrong headed.
 
Nonsense. It's not a detailed peace plan. It's just pointing out how the current approach is wrong headed.
Ok.... I've got a foolproof plan. Both sides just get together and live happily ever after!.


Thats easy ...

do you have any comments on the weaknesses I pointed out? The "article" is just a simplistic musing by someone with little or no comprehension on reality.
 
Ok.... I've got a foolproof plan. Both sides just get together and live happily ever after!.


Thats easy ...

do you have any comments on the weaknesses I pointed out? The "article" is just a simplistic musing by someone with little or no comprehension on reality.
The reality is the Palestinian position is based on deep-rooted anti-Semitism with genocidal intent and they have made no concessions whatsoever after all these years.

Don't you think its time the rest of the world stopped appeasing anti-Semites and championing them?

(waits for someone to try to re-define "anti-Semitism")
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom