The implication of anti-semitism. If all this was, was a difference of opinion, then this would be not different to any other vigorous exchange of opinions and evidence. Israel is not to blame for everything, but if you read most of this thread, the clear implication is that the Palestinians and Arabs are. If you say that Israel is to blame to an extent, then you must logically be an anti-semite. If 'skeptic' was still here, the accusation would also be that you want all Jews killed in another Holocaust.
I can't count the number of times I've been accused of being prejudiced against Arabs, being Islamo-phobic, or for being against peace, so you don't have any special whinging rights there.
Further, I'm routinely told that I smear everyone who says anything critical of Israel with being an anti-Semite, no matter how many times I give examples of criticisms against Israel that are not only not anti-Semitic but that I may share myself,
and how many times I point out where those that may be anti-Semitic have crossed the line.
I've said this before; if you want to elevate the level of debate, then look to yourself and raise the level of
your debate. Not just you personally (though, yes, you personally) but also anyone who believes as you do that the level of debate on the Israel/Palestine issue needs to be improved.
If you think people are not even-handed, then look for ways you can demonstrate even-handedness yourself. If you think only one side of the argument is being understood, then try yourself to not just understand, but to express understanding of the other side of the argument. If you believe the debate is poisoned by personal insults, then try yourself not to personalize the arguments, and take steps to admonish
those that share your position from poisoning the debate with personal attacks.
In short, lead by example, not by whinging.