Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
And so, another thread on this topic quickly degenerates into misrepresenting a persons position, and make snide insinuations about those lies. I suppose arguing the point is not possible, so this is the only fall back position available.

How is this different from any other heated forum exchange?
 
How is this different from any other heated forum exchange?

The implication of anti-semitism. If all this was, was a difference of opinion, then this would be not different to any other vigorous exchange of opinions and evidence. Israel is not to blame for everything, but if you read most of this thread, the clear implication is that the Palestinians and Arabs are. If you say that Israel is to blame to an extent, then you must logically be an anti-semite. If 'skeptic' was still here, the accusation would also be that you want all Jews killed in another Holocaust.
 
The implication of anti-semitism. If all this was, was a difference of opinion, then this would be not different to any other vigorous exchange of opinions and evidence. Israel is not to blame for everything, but if you read most of this thread, the clear implication is that the Palestinians and Arabs are. If you say that Israel is to blame to an extent, then you must logically be an anti-semite. If 'skeptic' was still here, the accusation would also be that you want all Jews killed in another Holocaust.

I can't count the number of times I've been accused of being prejudiced against Arabs, being Islamo-phobic, or for being against peace, so you don't have any special whinging rights there.

Further, I'm routinely told that I smear everyone who says anything critical of Israel with being an anti-Semite, no matter how many times I give examples of criticisms against Israel that are not only not anti-Semitic but that I may share myself, and how many times I point out where those that may be anti-Semitic have crossed the line.

I've said this before; if you want to elevate the level of debate, then look to yourself and raise the level of your debate. Not just you personally (though, yes, you personally) but also anyone who believes as you do that the level of debate on the Israel/Palestine issue needs to be improved.

If you think people are not even-handed, then look for ways you can demonstrate even-handedness yourself. If you think only one side of the argument is being understood, then try yourself to not just understand, but to express understanding of the other side of the argument. If you believe the debate is poisoned by personal insults, then try yourself not to personalize the arguments, and take steps to admonish those that share your position from poisoning the debate with personal attacks.

In short, lead by example, not by whinging.
 
This is 2013 not 1926. The British Mandate has been over for 65 years. Israel accepted the borders of UN resolution 181 and those borders recognized by the UN when they accepted them as a member state.
Israel accepted, the Arabs rejected. Doesn't make a non-binding UN resolution law and neither do these proposed borders actual borders. Then there are the wars of aggression against Israel since then.

But you are right. This isn't 1926. Its 2013. Neither is it 1947 nor 1967 nor 1973 either.
 
Israel accepted, the Arabs rejected. Doesn't make a non-binding UN resolution law and neither do these proposed borders actual borders. Then there are the wars of aggression against Israel since then.

But you are right. This isn't 1926. Its 2013. Neither is it 1947 nor 1967 nor 1973 either.

And it's not the Ottoman Empire, yet the laws from that time are used to take lawfully owned land from it's owners.
 
The implication of anti-semitism. If all this was, was a difference of opinion, then this would be not different to any other vigorous exchange of opinions and evidence. Israel is not to blame for everything, but if you read most of this thread, the clear implication is that the Palestinians and Arabs are. If you say that Israel is to blame to an extent, then you must logically be an anti-semite. If 'skeptic' was still here, the accusation would also be that you want all Jews killed in another Holocaust.

I haven't seen you being accused, in this recent exchange, of racism. As far as the rest of this thread goes, I've seen Israel compared to a cancer and a toxic virus, so the implication is sometimes warranted.
 
Last edited:
And it's not the Ottoman Empire, yet the laws from that time are used to take lawfully owned land from it's owners.

That's an interesting sentence there. It simultaneously evokes the law for one group, while condemning another group for being lawful. One would almost think it's not about law at all.
 
Last edited:
I haven't seen you being accused, in this recent exchange, of racism. As far as the rest of this thread goes, I've seen Israel compared to a cancer and a toxic virus, so the implication is sometimes warranted.

You won't see it stated, it has to be implied, otherwise it's a personal attack, and you get banned like Skeptic was. It's not hard to find examples if you look in this thread or others.
 
You won't see it stated, it has to be implied, otherwise it's a personal attack, and you get banned like Skeptic was. It's not hard to find examples if you look in this thread or others.

And I've seen barely veiled anti-Semitic references in the I/P discussions.

But you implied the current exchange had degenerated into unwarranted accusations of racism against you. Where?
 
You won't see it stated, it has to be implied, otherwise it's a personal attack, and you get banned like Skeptic was. It's not hard to find examples if you look in this thread or others.

Speaking of personal attacks, I've been repeatedly called a "Nakba Denier" by one user, in an obvious (and rather disgusting) attempt to equate me to a Holocaust denier. Another person described me as "...pretty much the Matt Giwer of your side", Matt Giwer being a person notorious on the internet for being an anti-Semite and a holocaust denier.

Personal attacks? Yeah.

Again, if you want to raise the level of debate on this topic, you must start by raising the level of your own debate. One who thinks personal attacks are wrong, shouldn't make them. If one thinks people shouldn't be demonized as groups or individuals, then they shouldn't demonize them. They should uphold the standards they want themselves before whinging that they're not upheld by others.
 
Personal attacks? Yeah.
It's not only personal attacks, though, it's also disgusting comparisons of Israelis to Nazis and other unjustified rhetoric such as "terrorism", "ethnic cleansing", "Apartheid state", "master race", etc.

There's plenty of vitrol on both sides. Deal with it. And as Mycroft says above, if you dislike it, "be the change you want to see in the world".
 
No discussion on the resumption of Israeli-Palestinian talks?

Maybe that's because many people do not have much hope for success.


Can desire for US approval top Israeli-Palestinian divide? (+video)

Some say that Israel and the Palestinians are only joining the talks because they don't want to be labeled as obstacles to peace by the US.


"They have zero chances of reaching an end of conflict, end of claims agreement," says Yossi Alpher, a leading Israeli analyst who is former director of the Jaffee Center for Strategic Studies. ''The positions are too far apart on narrative issues like the future of holy places and the right of return'' of Palestinians who fled or were expelled at Israel's establishment in 1948....



Ghassan Khatib, a former minister in the Palestinian Authority, says that the negotiations will in practice continue for some time, albeit without a peace deal.

"Endless negotiation is good for the Americans. They can point to success in bringing the sides to the table and keeping them there. Netanyahu can avoid US pressure and shows he's engaged in the peace process. Abbas can continue to be fed with money, prisoner releases and other things and maintain the survival of the PA.''

But Mr. Khatib does not believe the US will put enough pressure on Israel to force the substantial concessions necessary to enable the emergence of a viable Palestinian state.
 
I thought about saying something about it, but I don't see anything different here to suggest any more hope than any of the previous rounds. Once again, Israel has been cajoled into giving a concession just to bring the Palestinians to the table, this time by releasing imprisoned terrorists, breaking with their tradition of not releasing militants with "blood on their hands". What will come of it? If the past is any indicator, most likely months of stalling and foot-dragging leading to a final break-down sometime before the next Presidential elections in the US.
 
A peace plan that might work.

...because it takes a different approach. Trying to bribe Palestinian leadership into negotiating in good faith and trying to squeeze additional concessions from the Israelis to provide those bribes has failed for 40 years now, it's clearly time to try something different.



http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/04/world/meast/rawabi-palestinian-project/index.html?iid=article_sidebar

To be clear, I don' think this project will succeed. It won't succeed because Palestinian government isn't set up to facilitate business and promote a strong economy, it's set up to facilitate "struggle" and promote "resistance".

The worst thing Israel ever did to the Palestinian people was to recognize the PLO as their representatives. They didn't want to do that, and only did so after many years of international pressure, but the result is that Palestinians have a government that is systematically incapable of compromise. To participate one must first demonstrate their anti-Israel credentials. Voices of peace and compromise are labeled as "collaborators" and ostracized if not outright killed.

What's really needed is a new Palestinian government. One that sidelines the radicals and promotes the advancement of people capable of building an economy and compromising with the Israelis.
 
Yes, it takes a different approach.

There won't be any Palestinian state anytime soon. The reality is a one state solution, and the one state, equals Israel.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom