Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
The selective recognition of law almost always favours the settlers, or even tolerates settlers who for years flout Israel's own laws.



http://www.amnesty.org/en/news/west-bank-wall-and-settlements-affront-palestinian-rights-2013-03-21



http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/2011/08/2011823152713716742.html

Its very confusing as to why anyone would cite British law and the regulations of the British Mandate to justify illegal settlements in Palestine. Will they also apply the British Mandate's immigration restrictions upon Jews to Palestine?
 
This is 2013 not 1926. The British Mandate has been over for 65 years. Israel accepted the borders of UN resolution 181 and those borders recognized by the UN when they accepted them as a member state.
They were never recognized by the Arab states or the Palestinians, who instantly launched a war of genocide against Israel.

As it turns out, there's consequences for losing wars of genocide.
 
I look forward to Israel applying the Jewish immigration restrictions of the British Mandate. That would be interesting.
 
I look forward to Israel applying the Jewish immigration restrictions of the British Mandate. That would be interesting.
Why would they do that?

I'd look forward to the Palestinians work towards peace instead of the destruction of Israel and genocide of the Jews.

A Palestinian state "from the river to the sea" isn't going to happen. Nor are millions of descendants of the people who fled in the belief they could return after the Arab armies completed their genocide ever going to be allowed to live in Israel.
 
Why would they do that?

That was the question. How does the selective use of law against Palestinians work? Some aspects of Ottoman law, in regard to land, land borders set defined at one time but not another. Enforced against Palestinians but not settlers. Palestinians stripped of their livelihood. That, is, the means they use to live.
 
Found a new article about the peace talks between Olmert and Abbas. Quite interesting:
Revealing never before heard details of talks with Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, Olmert was referring to the proposal for a peace agreement that he presented to Abbas in the afternoon hours of a Tuesday, September 16, 2008 meeting in the Prime Minister’s residence in Jerusalem.
“At the end of the meeting” Olmert recalled this week, “we called Saeb Erekat [chief negotiator for PLO] and Shalom [Shalom Turjeman, Olmert's diplomatic adviser]. We asked them to meet the following day, Wednesday, together with map experts, in order to arrive at a final formula for the border between Palestine and Israel.”
But that Wednesday, Erekat called Turjeman and said they could not meet to finalize the peace deal because they “had forgotten that Abbas had to go to Amman!” Erekat said they would meet the following week. “I’ve been waiting ever since,” Olmert said with a smile.

The author, Avi Issacharoff, used to write for Haaretz. IMO, he was of their better journalists. It seems they let him go (maybe due to budget cuts) while keeping less talented writers.
 
Found a new article about the peace talks between Olmert and Abbas. Quite interesting:


The author, Avi Issacharoff, used to write for Haaretz. IMO, he was of their better journalists. It seems they let him go (maybe due to budget cuts) while keeping less talented writers.

Olmert was interesting, perhaps something could have come of his proposal. He was caught up in what proved to be unfounded allegations of fraud and corruption, and the deal died. Perhaps Abbas could have returned, but there was nothing to return to.
 
Olmert was interesting, perhaps something could have come of his proposal. He was caught up in what proved to be unfounded allegations of fraud and corruption, and the deal died. Perhaps Abbas could have returned, but there was nothing to return to.

I think that the author of this paper is intending to write a followup explaining the reasons that Abbas other Palestinian negotiators gave for the rejection of the offer. If he does and I find the paper I post a link in this thread.

I must say that I am familiar with the claim that Olmert's weakness is the reason and that I do not buy the logic behind it. If the offer is good enough, and especially if it is better that what his replacement can realistically offer, you either take it or make a counter offer. If an agreement on principles was made and Olmert is too weak politically to get approval you can still demand that future negotiations will be based on that offer, and will have the world's backing for that. By not responding the PA ensured that the Olmert's plan went away with him. Also, I found the excuses that the PA made at the time embarrassing. If they thought at the time that Olmert's political status made future negotiations problematic they should have said so. They did not, and therefore I think they may had other motives. (For example, thinking that they can get more under an Obama administration.)
 
This is 2013 not 1926. The British Mandate has been over for 65 years.

Hey Parky!

If you want to ignore the roll the past has played on creating the present, that's your choice, but it doesn't lead to a greater understanding of the issues. Further, if you only want to selectively ignore the past, then that's biased.

Israel accepted the borders of UN resolution 181 and those borders recognized by the UN when they accepted them as a member state.

And yet those borders are not the borders of Israel now. Why not? If not, then what relevance?

Maybe your next incarnation can answer.
 
Olmert was interesting, perhaps something could have come of his proposal. He was caught up in what proved to be unfounded allegations of fraud and corruption, and the deal died. Perhaps Abbas could have returned, but there was nothing to return to.

Interesting how Abbas doesn't need to even make an excuse for his failings, someone will always be willing to make one for him.
 
I think that the author of this paper is intending to write a followup explaining the reasons that Abbas other Palestinian negotiators gave for the rejection of the offer. If he does and I find the paper I post a link in this thread.

I must say that I am familiar with the claim that Olmert's weakness is the reason and that I do not buy the logic behind it. If the offer is good enough, and especially if it is better that what his replacement can realistically offer, you either take it or make a counter offer. If an agreement on principles was made and Olmert is too weak politically to get approval you can still demand that future negotiations will be based on that offer, and will have the world's backing for that. By not responding the PA ensured that the Olmert's plan went away with him. Also, I found the excuses that the PA made at the time embarrassing. If they thought at the time that Olmert's political status made future negotiations problematic they should have said so. They did not, and therefore I think they may had other motives. (For example, thinking that they can get more under an Obama administration.)
It appears to me both sides are angling for the most the they can get in a settlement of the dispute, is this not unusual? The difference is one is bargaining from a position of greater strength than the other.
 
It appears to me both sides are angling for the most the they can get in a settlement of the dispute, is this not unusual? The difference is one is bargaining from a position of greater strength than the other.

If the Palestinians were angling for the most they can get, why not a counter-offer?

The evidence points to a lack of willingness by Fatah to engage in talks at all, which is very different from trying to get the most out of them.
 
That was the question. How does the selective use of law against Palestinians work? Some aspects of Ottoman law, in regard to land, land borders set defined at one time but not another. Enforced against Palestinians but not settlers. Palestinians stripped of their livelihood. That, is, the means they use to live.
Maybe the Palestinians should work towards peace instead of endless war to destroy Israel and/or kill all the Jews, eh?
 
I'm all in favour of peace, but the report indicates Israel is not acting in good faith. What it is documented as doing would tend to incite a violent response.

Right. Out of all the actors in this mess it is Israel who is acting in bad faith...

How on earth can any unbiased witness come to that conclusion?
 
And so, another thread on this topic quickly degenerates into misrepresenting a persons position, and make snide insinuations about those lies. I suppose arguing the point is not possible, so this is the only fall back position available.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom