Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here is what a couple of human beings have to say.... which belies what the bloodthirsty cheerers for Armageddon keep repeating out of a trite script.

Without disputing that such people exist, you seem to be trying to insinuate that there are those here who support Israel and desire Armageddon. Are you? If so, feel free to back it up.

Of course I will be waiting for the usual rebuttal..... "stupid anti-Semites who know nothing and want to kill Jews"... just you wait and see.... I'll bet on it.... just like well trained and obedient good boys, they cannot deviate from their pavlovian conditioning.

First of all, "the usual rebuttal?" Heh. Why should anyone take you seriously when you fundamentally misrepresent the points that tend and have tended to be made here? As keeps on happening in situations like this, the truth is that the situation is dramatically more complex than you seem to want to portray it.

Both videos tell you why it is being done.... truth at last , truth at last, .... "but what do these anti-Semites know.... they just want to destroy Israel".

Just like your "truth" that the Sinai Peninsula was part of Palestine? There's a lot that Israel has done which is quite worthy of condemnation. With that said, far more frequently than not, it seems that the people who vocally attack Israel seize upon issues in a remarkably shortsighted way and horribly misrepresent the issues at hand. Operation Brother's Keeper, for example, is quite worthy of condemnation, in general, even if some of the horrible things that happened may have been directly justifiable. Israel's Likud Party regularly makes condemnation-worthy statements and decisions when it comes to the Palestinians, much like the US' Republican Party has frequently made quite condemnation-worthy statements and decisions, especially in recent years. Returning fire on a government which is engaging in military action against Israel, however, is not condemnation-worthy. Given that Hamas has been systematically violating the laws of war, among numerous other condemnation-worthy actions that are frequently terroristic in nature, that puts them in a position where they should be openly and widely criticized, and indeed, the focus of the overwhelming majority of the criticism, and gets Israel off the hook for a lot, though fairly certainly not everything.



Sorry, even after listening to the arguments, I'm still not remotely impressed by the attempts at spin and the conveniently ignored facts that are extremely relevant to the validity of the arguments made. With that said, for the mention of an ADL argument, the ADL argument presented had a couple huge, gaping factual holes and was blatantly spin and yet the counter made to it was still just nothing more than a poor attempt at tu quoque. Well, if you're actually making a point about how poor the arguments actually are for the claims that you're arguing for, consider it made, for the nth time in this thread alone.
 
Last edited:
Here is what a couple of human beings have to say.... which belies what the bloodthirsty cheerers for Armageddon keep repeating out of a trite script.

Of course I will be waiting for the usual rebuttal..... "stupid anti-Semites who know nothing and want to kill Jews"... just you wait and see.... I'll bet on it.... just like well trained and obedient good boys, they cannot deviate from their pavlovian conditioning.

Both videos tell you why it is being done.... truth at last , truth at last, .... "but what do these anti-Semites know.... they just want to destroy Israel".

You're losing it, Leumas. Your posts no longer have anything to do with what other posters here have said. You're basically just in rage mode now.
 
How Israel has been 'mowing the lawn' in Gaza to unmake Palestinian society

The Israeli government appears to have gone beyond its previous policy of keeping Gaza on the brink of collapse and adopted a policy aimed at unmaking Palestinian society in Gaza.

But as Greg Shupak points out in a fine piece for Jacobin magazine, Israel’s assault on Gaza cannot simply be explained by the Israel strategy of ‘counterinsurgency’ through terror and collective punishment. Shupak argues that its targeting of Palestinian infrastructure, agriculture, cultural and religious institutions is ultimately intended to make it impossible for Palestinian society in Gaza to sustain itself, and that such violence is intrinsic to the Zionist project and peculiar to settler-colonial societies.

Shupak’s suggestion that Gaza belongs to a tradition that includes the ‘clearing of the plains through the deliberate starvation of Aboriginal peoples’ in American and Canada is not something that you are likely to hear on Sky News or the BBC, but it is by no means outlandish.

In the aftermath of the American Civil War, Union heroes General William Tecumseh Sherman and General Philip Sheridan were placed in charge of the US Army’s campaigns against the Plains Indians. Sherman was famous for his scorched earth campaigns against Southern civilians during his army’s rampaging march through Georgia and the Carolinas, while Sheridan had overseen similarly destructive campaigns in response to Confederate ‘bushwhacker’ attacks in the Shenandoah Valley in Virginia.

The essential premise of these campaigns was that civilians as well as soldiers were legitimate objects of war, and the Dahiya doctrine would not have shocked ‘ Little Phil’ Sheridan. In 1870 Sheridan attended the Franco-Prussian War as an observer. Asked by Bismarck what Prussia should do in response to French guerrilla attacks on his forces, he reportedly replied:

‘The proper strategy consists in inflicting as telling blows as possible on the enemy’s army, and then in causing the inhabitants so much suffering that they must long for peace, and force the government to demand it. The people must be left with nothing but their eyes to weep with over the war.’

http://stopwar.org.uk/news/how-israel-has-been-mowing-the-lawn-in-gaza
 
How can you argue for the removal of millions of people, most of whom were born there, and not instantly understand that to be racist? What is it about Jews that creates this amazing blind spot in people?

Your question will be answered by reading the article. The author is arguing for the removal of Zionist colonisers and their descendants, not Jews.

The author is a retired sociologist from the University of Amsterdam and a Jewish-Dutch World War II survivor.

http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article39367.htm
 
Last edited:
This discussion/debate is turning a bit sour and, well... a turn beyond reason. I usually prefer to pee by myself.
 
Last edited:
none of them appear to know anything about the Rules of Warfare (an actual, written down and signed and all that official crap)

I too am shamefully ignorant of the existence of this document and most irritatingly, Google refused to help me out. You aren't just referring to the Geneva Conventions, right?
 
Incidentally, since there have been so many attempts to claim that "Israel is a horrible monster that should be destroyed," with rather questionable arguments, I think that it may be worth remembering that Hamas slaughters Palestinians freely. Frankly, whatever valid legal claims the Palestinians may or may not have, morally speaking, there's no equivalence between Hamas and Israel, and the "unity government" of the Palestinians is dramatically less credible and worth dealing with if it's willing to include Hamas.

Oh, and separately, here is a bit of a map to keep the damage in perspective a bit. It's really not pretty, but it doesn't look like it remotely qualifies as supporting evidence for a number of the accusations leveled at Israel by people like CE.
 
Last edited:
I see that number of people here are at least being honest in their "Death To Israel" beliefs.......
 
How well do you think that solution would work if applied to Russians in Crimea?

And how about all those Polish Colonizers in what used to be East Prussia, Silisia,and Pomoronia. They have really got to go.

The idea of removing 5 million Jews From Israel is so incredibly crazy that anybody adovacating it goes right on "batcrap crazy and should be ignored" list.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom