Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

Where's the plane? I'd say that has vanished, it doesn't even warrant a "pretty much". Looks like it was a lot smaller than a Boeing, and it's impossible to tell much about the surface conditions from that one photo. (I know I could google the exact crash, but I'm giving first impressions here).

The fact it's smaller (it was a regional jet) doesn't matter. The plane is exactly where you are not seeing it. Shattered into small pieces due to a high energy impact. Like on 9/11, the recorders were found and all the parts are there.

Have you looked at the pictures in the link I gave you? Are you still thinking a plane didn't crash there?
 
Last edited:
The fact it's smaller (it was a regional jet) doesn't matter. The plane is exactly where you are not seeing it. Shattered into small pieces due to a high energy impact. Like on 9/11, the recorders were found and all the parts are there.

Have you looked at the pictures in the link I gave you? Are you still thinking a plane didn't crash there?

I had a look at some, and some of the rest of the website. It doesn't seem like a very reliable source, more like some teenager in his bedroom with a tinfoil hat.
 
I had a look at some, and some of the rest of the website. It doesn't seem like a very reliable source, more like some teenager in his bedroom with a tinfoil hat.

lol, you can't do evidence... and worse, according to you, a teenager in his bedroom with a tinfoil hat debunked your failed BS claims... now that is extra credit debunking... I think you made another logical error... lol

https://sites.google.com/site/wtc7lies/flight93page1

The FDR was found in the crater, as was an engine from Flight 93, thus your failed 911 truth claim are debunked by what you call "a teenager in his bedroom". What does that make your failed claims... lol

Were you banned by Balsamo? lol, a 911 truth believer banned by 911 truth nuts... that takes extra special BS


...
It's a big plane, it's a small hole, yet there was debris anything up to 8 miles away depending on which reports you read...

The small hole is the exact size of Flight 93, in the exact attitude it crashed at; thus you failed to do more than make up BS about 93.

8 miles, is that by road or air? You don't have a clue because you cherry picked this from 911 truth dolts. The debris "8 miles" away was light weight stuff like paper, and stuff which floats on the air, the exact direction the air was flowing on 911. Thus you are repeating idiotic claims from 911 truth, and not able to say what it means.

Why did Balsamo ban you.
 
Last edited:
I don't know what you are referring to. Who gave me a slamdown? Is Beachnut this Balsamo? He's the biggest one giving out the vitriol.
Do not try to pretend you are unfamiliar with Balsamo of pfffft fame. It wont wash.



Christ, I have repeatedly stated, I am not an aeroplane guy, that's why I came on here initially asking questions about aeroplane stuff. God you guys have short memories or you are just twisting everything around again.
Our memories are fine. You got your answers and ignored them.

It's a big plane, it's a small hole,
The "hole" is larger that the diameter of the fuselage.

yet there was debris anything up to 8 miles away depending on which reports you read.
Explosions do that. Couple of hundred thousand pounds of aircraft nose-diving into the ground does that. This isn't rocket magic.
I am not experienced in plane crashes, other than 9/11 and Lockerbie I haven't looked into them much. I do know some of the claims made out there are junk, because some people seem to think that because a lot of plane crash footage shows crash landings, where the plane slides on its belly, that they all should. I don't think that way.
You clearly do.
Same as I don't think the planes would have just bounced off the twin towers. I've said before, I'm not a no-planer.
Just a different flavour of troofer.

That is very true, but apparently just asking questions about them is extremely suspicious.
Suspicious? No. Obvious game? Yes.

Where's the plane? I'd say that has vanished, it doesn't even warrant a "pretty much".
Buried in the dirt due to that thing called momentum.

Looks like it was a lot smaller than a Boeing, and it's impossible to tell much about the surface conditions from that one photo. (I know I could google the exact crash, but I'm giving first impressions here).
Except that it wasn't. "looks to me" is not evidence of anything. And you go on to claim that you know nothing about it yet have first impressions which are somehow meaningful. Give us a break.
 
Do not try to pretend you are unfamiliar with Balsamo of pfffft fame. It wont wash.
I'm not pretending anything. I don't know him, I'm not a member of p4t, they don't allow registration with gmail addresses, as I found out shortly before joining this site, which does. Again you lot come up with your radical assumptions trying desperately to prove that I'm something other than what I am. I once sent an email to Chandler, and got a disappointing response, I don't know Jones (the infowars one or the other one) anymore than I know Tom Cruise. I definately don't know Judy Wood, and I've had no dealings with Gage. I did get Michael Schumachers autograph once, but I think my ex-wife got it in the divorce. I'm me, doing stuff on my own, with no prior agenda.

Except that it wasn't. "looks to me" is not evidence of anything. And you go on to claim that you know nothing about it yet have first impressions which are somehow meaningful. Give us a break.

I wasn't presenting evidence, or implying that my comments were meaningful. I was commenting about a photo I had never seen before, stop looking for meaning that isn't there, I do NOT have any hidden agenda, either individually or as part of some group of truthers, I am in complete isolation from them. I'm an aspergic bloke living in a cottage in Scotland, who suddenly finds himself with a lot of free time since I had to stop working to look after my disabled wife (Wife #2, in case you are looking for inconsistencies). I'm not affiliated to anyone else, working with anyone else, I only know a few names of people from watching videos and reading reports, I don't know the actual people. I don't exactly live in a place where massive truth conventions pass through every week where I can meet and greet and go to book signings.
 
I wasn't presenting evidence, or implying that my comments were meaningful. I was commenting about a photo I had never seen before, ....

Why not google for information before passing comment about the 'inappropriate' size of the hole? It's all out there, in written and image form, and very easily found.
 
I'm not pretending anything. I don't know him, I'm not a member of p4t, they don't allow registration with gmail addresses, as I found out shortly before joining this site, which does. Again you lot come up with your radical assumptions trying desperately to prove that I'm something other than what I am. I once sent an email to Chandler, and got a disappointing response, I don't know Jones (the infowars one or the other one) anymore than I know Tom Cruise. I definately don't know Judy Wood, and I've had no dealings with Gage. I did get Michael Schumachers autograph once, but I think my ex-wife got it in the divorce. I'm me, doing stuff on my own, with no prior agenda.

I wasn't presenting evidence, or implying that my comments were meaningful. I was commenting about a photo I had never seen before, stop looking for meaning that isn't there, I do NOT have any hidden agenda, either individually or as part of some group of truthers, I am in complete isolation from them. I'm an aspergic bloke living in a cottage in Scotland, who suddenly finds himself with a lot of free time since I had to stop working to look after my disabled wife (Wife #2, in case you are looking for inconsistencies). I'm not affiliated to anyone else, working with anyone else, I only know a few names of people from watching videos and reading reports, I don't know the actual people. I don't exactly live in a place where massive truth conventions pass through every week where I can meet and greet and go to book signings.


Mr Clark,
Understanding something implies that you begin from a place of NOT UNDERSTANDING.

We go through life thinking we understand what we see live and on TV and so forth. We LEARNED about how the world works from experience and from being taught, formally or informally.

Many or perhaps most things about the world are little understood by most people or they have a simplistic or cartoon or shorthand understanding of it... how a kidney works, a plane stays aloft or a sailboat works... or a bomb, or fire or gravity and so on.

Physics is the grand daddy of all things to explain the world... especially mechanical "things". Chemistry is right up there to explain lots including how living things work. This can and often is too esoteric and only "experts" are facile with this level of understanding. Can you read a cat scan? No! A radioloigist is required.

On the face 9/11 seems easy to understand. Some of it. Some of it seems or feels counter intuitive. Would a high speed jumbo knock a building over? If not would it bounce off? Why not? What sort of destruction would the plane do? Well that depends on understanding physics... the speed of the plane, it's mass... where the mass was distributed... the nature of the structure of the building and so on. A plane hitting a high rise is not something anyone has experience with. We've seen smaller planes hit buildings. Can we extrapolate from that? If so how? If not why not?

The collapses of the 3 buildings were very complex and actually chaotic events. This sort of chaos is almost impossible to model because of the random nature of the events, interactions, collisions, various materials and so forth. What you get are some attempts at simplification. Or you get people drilling down and investigation one "node" a connection, a beam, a column and so on... This sort of isolation to understand the larger chaotic event is interesting, can be helpful or may not be in understand the much large complex event.

For those buildings to collapse tens of thousands... perhaps hundreds of thousands of structural failures where taking place and spread out through time with some level of interaction between the failure events.

But one needs to have some basic understanding and good powers of observation to inform you understanding.

Laws of physics cannot and were not violated. People have explained that the collapse of the twin towers was a floor slab collapse first... Mass from above an intact floor fell overwhelmed it's capacity. Sure you realize that an office floor is designed to support X pounds and no more. When X+1 falls on it it fails. Failure means it loses its integrity and cracks shatters, and probably falls down. There was way more weight coming down on an intact floor than it was able to resist.. So the collapse was unstoppable and proceeded very rapidly to the ground. The resistance of the slabs was very small compared to the impinging force. So the collapse was not much slower than and object falling through air. But it was slower for sure.

The steel columns had not to do with the collapse... didn't resist it and didn't assist it. Some argue that the strength of the connections from the floor slabs to the axial members (columns) were a weak link or weaker than the floor slabs and failed BEFORE the slabs shattered from thousands of collisions with other slabs and parts of slabs etc. The connection system DID fail... they sheared... the bend over like spaghetti and the were ripped off. The trusses which connected to the axial system also experienced failures at the connections which DID not fail.. they sheared.


The columns were left without required bracing to stand up and remain stable. Columns stability is determined by slenderness ratio and that is also dependent on the material of the column. Long and short is that the high rise columns are unstable without bracing. The bracing was ripped off by / in the floor collapse and so the unstable columns collapsed or toppled as a RESULT of the floor collapse.

The Twin tower collapses are right there and understandable with some basic physics and good observation. The blasts of debris from the building just below the collapse front is also basic physics... the air inside was displaced by the falling floor mass. This air took with it contents of / on the floors... suspended clg tiles, furniture, office contents. The blast of air burst reach as much as 200+ mph. Do the math... it's simple... very simple.

There are no proofs and the evidence is the visual record... the structural information about the buildings... the science of materials, fire and so forth.

Witnesses are incapable of using language to accurately... in a scientific, object manner what they observe... assuming they had what it takes to PROPERLY understand their observations. We all can see the clouds and the stars and movement in "the heavens"... how man can scientifically describe what they are seeing?

How do you scientifically describe very loud noises? Is there even a scientific .. objective way to describe very loud sounds? People resort to analogies... it sounded like... and that is usually a sound they heard in a movie or on TV.

LOOKS LIKE is NOT -IS-

The failure to understand 9/11 is a failure of mostly technical understanding and critical thinking. But most adult will find a way to characterize and explain everything they experience... even resorting to analogies and movies, TV etc. Truthers are driven by poor technical understanding and failure to think critically and to recognize their limitations. But they are more than willing to take a little bit of knowledge and twist it to an explanation which makes sense to them and their limited technical knowledge. How many people have hear of Euler buckling or if they have know what it is? Or modulus of elasticity?

And of course it's a fool's errand to try to explain complex, sophisticated phenomena to an uneducated person and one with a "political agenda" such as ... not trusting a word from an authority figure. You don't have to trust them to understand... but you do have to technically INFORM yourself to understand.

++++

Do you think it's hard to fly a plane into the twin towers? I could see them from 50 miles away! Aiming at something when sailing or flying is not terribly difficult especially with little cross winds or currents. You just keep the target on the nose until you hit it by making minor corrections and try not to over steer. I see this oversteering in novices when they try to steer a boat. But it's not hard to get the hang of it. And hitting the largest most prominent targets is not difficult at all... targets much larger than the braod side of a barn!

You clearly need to brush up on your engineering to inform your understanding. And you clearly need to stop listening to people who are technically inept regardless of how they will claim expert status.

LEARN TO THINK

Asking questions and having doubts is fine. Inform yourself with technical knowledge.. basic... not PhD level.
 
Thank you JSanderO, that was a wonderful, human response and I appreciate it more than you can know (or I can express, one of the two).

I'm a prickly bastard at times, and I have difficulties with human interactions. One of which is being accused of things I didn't do, which just makes me see red. The levels of pedantry and obfuscation on this forum are very high at times, and it's easy to forget that you are not all speaking with one voice (or level of knowledge/expertise). Despite all that, I do have a brain in my head, which occasionally points in the right direction.

There is a very good chance that the way I process information is slightly off-centre compared to you guys, and certainly my vocabulary and speech methods will differ too. I know that what some of you will call nit-picking is just me aiming for a level of exactness in what I hear, which unfairly I do not display myself to others.

Anyway, I appreciate the few on here who are taking the time to deal with me fairly, and though I may not always grasp what you say first time, I will continue to seek my own way through things, as I'm the only one who can work with my world view for any length of time :)
 
Do you think it's hard to fly a plane into the twin towers? I could see them from 50 miles away! Aiming at something when sailing or flying is not terribly difficult

That's one of the things that niggled at me. There were a number of pilots who said "I couldn't do that", or "I tried in a simulator and failed" as if it was like doing a fastest lap at Le Mans, when actually I see it more as holding on to a runaway horse (simplified analogy, but it serves as a mental image). You might be able to get on the same horse and gallop in the same direction, but it will be very hard to make it go in the hoofprints of the previous journey.

And you clearly need to stop listening to people who are technically inept regardless of how they will claim expert status.

THIS. Guilty as charged m'lud. My filters do not operate at optimum levels.
 
There is a very good chance that the way I process information is slightly off-centre compared to you guys, and certainly my vocabulary and speech methods will differ too. I know that what some of you will call nit-picking is just me aiming for a level of exactness in what I hear, which unfairly I do not display myself to others.

Can you come to grips with the fact that there is a lot about 9/11 that we can never know for sure, e.g. a "level of exactness" about what caused WTC7 to collapse? Do you understand that we're all just trying to make our best guess?
 
Found your problem.
Jesse Ventura is a crackpot. A common misconception is that wrestling is fake, therefore injuries sustained doing it are fake, too.

Wrestling is pre-determined. However, the injuries can be all too real. There can be no doubt as to the affect of Traumatic Brain Injury today. We see it everywhere. When Jesse was wrestling, it was just "getting dinged up". Well, now the years have passed and we see what TBI can really do. It can make you think that 9/11 was a government plot.

As to setting up the experiments - there's no need. Literally. Would you need to set up an experiment that shows getting stabbed by a knife can cause bleeding? No, you wouldn't. Something like that is just understood.

The events of 9/11 are equally easily explained. 19 homicidal/suicidal morons flew planes into buildings with only a 75% success rate. We know any and all maneuvers performed by the pilots were possible, because they happened. Not one of you people has, in 14 YEARS come up with an alternative narrative that better explains the entire day's events. Not one. You pick and choose what minutiae to cling to, and that's that. Pathetic.

While you are clearly correct on pathetic, you left out the very important and correct co-difficulties: incompetence, lacking important knowledge, and obvious single-mindedness to the point of mental dysfunction!!!!
 
Can you come to grips with the fact that there is a lot about 9/11 that we can never know for sure, e.g. a "level of exactness" about what caused WTC7 to collapse? Do you understand that we're all just trying to make our best guess?

I'm trying to :)
 
Thank you JSanderO, that was a wonderful, human response and I appreciate it more than you can know (or I can express, one of the two).

I'm a prickly bastard at times, and I have difficulties with human interactions. One of which is being accused of things I didn't do, which just makes me see red. The levels of pedantry and obfuscation on this forum are very high at times, and it's easy to forget that you are not all speaking with one voice (or level of knowledge/expertise). Despite all that, I do have a brain in my head, which occasionally points in the right direction.

There is a very good chance that the way I process information is slightly off-centre compared to you guys, and certainly my vocabulary and speech methods will differ too. I know that what some of you will call nit-picking is just me aiming for a level of exactness in what I hear, which unfairly I do not display myself to others.

Anyway, I appreciate the few on here who are taking the time to deal with me fairly, and though I may not always grasp what you say first time, I will continue to seek my own way through things, as I'm the only one who can work with my world view for any length of time :)

We can't possibly know what we don't know. The odious Donald Rumsfeld gave us this gem:

"There are known knowns. These are things we know that we know. There are known unknowns. That is to say, there are things that we know we don't know. But there are also unknown unknowns. There are things we don't know we don't know."

Yet despite not knowing much about how things work... we drive cars, take planes, elevators undergo surgery and use computers etc. We have enough knowledge to deal with the world on a basic level.

But average folks are pretty clueless about the physical world.

This DOES not prevent us from coming up with what makes sense to US... we sort of need to have a handle on reality... but we can only do it on the level of technical knowledge that we have.

The truth movement doesn't WANT to do anything but confirm their bias about what they WANT to believe happened... or conversely confirm their belief about what could not have happened.

It's totally OK to not know... to ask questions. It how we learn... by getting our questions answered in a way we can understand... furthering our knowledge... and disabusing us or our naive ideas.

++++

Sorry for all the typos. mis spells and syntax errors... I didn't bother to proof... just hit the submit button.
 
Last edited:
That's one of the things that niggled at me. There were a number of pilots who said "I couldn't do that", or "I tried in a simulator and failed" as if it was like doing a fastest lap at Le Mans, when actually I see it more as holding on to a runaway horse (simplified analogy, but it serves as a mental image). You might be able to get on the same horse and gallop in the same direction, but it will be very hard to make it go in the hoofprints of the previous journey.



THIS. Guilty as charged m'lud. My filters do not operate at optimum levels.

There were 2 different aviation steering challenges.

1 - hitting the twin towers on a more or less straight in approach. Any pilot who claims he can't do it is lying. How else do they land a plane on a 100' runway?

2. hitting the Pentagon beginning at a rather high altitude and hitting a target with a HUGE foot print but only 5 or 6 stories high. I would assume that if the pilot were flying visual he would need to be high enough to spot the target since unline the twins it did not tower over the city scape. One can't assume that he had flown about the city and had experience with the landmarks either. So he came in quite high finding the easy land marks including the airport which was near the pentagon. But he could safely "dive" the plane and steer it... probably and so he made a very wide turn losing altitude... keeping the target at his starboard wing.... When he was low enough he went straight for the target and had to fly quite low. But at that point it was almost impossible to miss.... and the likely screw up would be coming too low and crashing before reaching the low target. But final was like landing! and the runway was 3,000 feet wide or whatever the pentagon was. This maneuver may have been more difficult than hitting the twin towers... but it was by no means impossible considering how much leeway the size of the target presented. It likely didn't matter what part he hit, what floor he hit, what ring he hit... just hit the damn thing. He did!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom