Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

Since JFK, modern conspiracism has really centered on hoax theories, and the main "research" strategy has been to look for "anomalies" which supposedly expose the hoax using the faulty logic of anomaly => hoax => conspiracy. Your questions about the INS (and others, e.g. the Shanksville crater) appear to be such a hunt for anomalies as confirmation of some vague conspiracy theory. And then, instead of requiring PfT to substantiate their claims about the INS, you are asking someone else to disprove them. And then, you can't even work these "anomalies" into an actual coherent and plausible conspiracy theory. I think what many here are expecting next is the standard result of such "reasoning": "I don't know what happened, but I know the 'official story' isn't true."

Sorry, but this is a pattern that we've seen too many times to count. If you're being treated unfairly, blame it on the "truthers" who preceded you.

That's understandable to an extent, it doesn't make it any less unpleasant to be on the receiving end.

I don't know what happened completely, I know some of it, and I'm trying to piece together the rest of it in a way that it is square in my mind, because this is my journey through it. Things that may be insignificant to others, may be an itch in my mind that needs scratching.

It was such a dramatic, brutal event, simple yet extremely complex, and as I said earlier, it wont go away simply because what it led to is still happening. Unexpected things happened, and the actions of the people in charge is very suspicious.

I believe it was NIST who said that building 7 was a first, unprecedented, yet no one is culpable.

And I still do not have a handle on Shanksville.

I'm not sure there could be one over arching grand conspiracy to cover everything that happened. It is just too complicated and open to cock ups. Some of the information may not be available for another 30+ years, some of it might never become available. Was the collapse of the towers an unexpected bonus to the perpetrators?

The level of CYA, the "set up to fail", the coincindences...

It's like you couldn't plan it, but there's no way it could happen, yet it did, and then the politics happened.

Mowrer, the guy that wrote the fire report, said "high rises must be able to withstand uncontrolled fires, or the risk to emergency services would be too great". Not an exact quote, but the spirit of what he said. I don't know what building codes have changed since 9/11 (I haven't started looking in to that yet), but if the answer is none, then there are some serious issues.
 
...
P4t claim, that because the data is more than 3000ft off, the data cannot be accepted at face value, however this is very misleading to people with no knowledge of the systems used (which includes me).

Firstly, (unless I'm mistaken), it is unlikely that the coordinates used are going to exactly match the precise placement of the inertial platform, therefore a margin of error is allowed.

Secondly, the 3200ft error they claim as solid proof of something, is within the 0.6 nautical miles error margin of the equipment.

Thirdly, there is human error, if the co-ordinates are slightly out, or are entered incorrectly, then this could explain any divergence. Even rounding errors could affect this.

The last nails in the coffin would be the sensitivity of the equipment, could hitting a pothole, or braking sharply or an impact with a tractor falsely update the IRS?

No, you don't move, you stand for 10 minutes. You let it align. Or if the system has a quick align, you use those procedures.

Who said there was a .6 NM error no go BS? Can you find such a thing in Boeing or the IRS manuals?

Being 3000 feet off is not due to data, the system thinks it is where it says it is; if you plot the numbers, it shows you off the runway, but you are on the runway, you use your eyes to taxi not the inertial navigation system.
Unless you have the specification from who made the system, how do you know the allowable initial errors?
What data, the IRS wakes up and says it is someplace, but it is in error, but I don't care, I am using the IRS because it is better than VOR,,, you can look up the hierarchy of accuracy online to see the navigation aid accuracy. Albeit the IRS drifts over hours, but the airways will be shaped for the systems everyone has, or everyone is mandated to have.
Thus the airway rules and size/width are match to what humans and instruments can do.
Balsamo and pilots for truth are using BS to support the BS they produce.

Balsamo can't tell you the initial accuracy of an INS/IRS. But you can google inertial navigation systems and see there is no way for a gyro to wake up and know the exact place it is, it is independent of all but how it senses the world model it has. Read more about INS... my friend, we were on a crew, has been flying as a navigator as long as I have flown, since the 70s... his best alignment was .1 NM...

If you are fooled by Balsamo, go ask him the question. Tell him it is BS if he can't state and support the initial accuracy.

The INS does not wake up at the position you entered; it takes the position to run algorithms as if it was there, and then it comes up with a position it thinks it is at. If you enter a position outside the limits of the system (have to know the specification for how far off the input initial position is allowed, is 1000 feet, or 1 mile, or 1 degree? look it up), the system will not be accurate and most likely "tells" you it is screwed up with lights or messages. And you try again.
My navigator entered in a position 10 degrees off when entering lat and long, and when he was using the system he noticed it was not usable, so he dumped and he did celestial navigation from Diego, to Okinawa... no big deal he was trained, we can fly the world using celestial, and in the tropic winds are some times light and variable, perfect to keep your DR accurate, and easy to check and decide on your shots of the sun, etc....

The fact is the navigation system on 77 was working, as it tracked and changed in flight. Thus it is BS.
The fact is 77 taxied from the correct spot on record, as seen and testified to by the tower ground control.
Fact is 77 was tracked by multiple and sometimes simultaneous Radar, and no swap was made, it was 77 which hit the Pentagon, and put DNA from everyone on board, and the FDR from 77, including the exact 24 hours of previous flights.
Thus to speculate it was not 77, is insanity due to ignorance and BS.

Thus your aircraft swap BS is proved wrong with evidence. So you can't have like 10 people in on the BS, you have to have thousands to make the BS planes you think did 911. Your speculation is fantasy.

Your NIST lies is BS too.
Like alive terrorists, your knowledge on 911 is shallow. Try doing more research on each BS claim you have, and try again.

BTW, if GPS was on the plane, the position of the Nav system might of been off by a few feet... But the system used DME/DME and VOR/DME and VOR/VOR for updates (i think)... Balsamo has no clue how this works either...

To tell the truth... many pilots have no clue how the system works, they use it, they are not building it. Balsamo never flew a 767/757, he most likely has no practical knowledge of the systems he makes up BS about. And when he gets info from pilots who did fly, it usually debunks some of the pilot for truth paranoid CTers pet ideas...

Ironically Balsamo makes up all this BS, implies swapped planes, and yet, swears Radar is real, and Radar is the way to go... and forgets swaps would be seen on Radar...

As for INS, read the literature available from real sources, and you decide. However, the navigation for 77 having offset is in the FDR for 77s flight on 911 and before 911. Thus this issue is BS, it has no evidence to support the claims made by pilots for truth. If you have questions, then Balsamo has to answer, he made up the lies, he can't support them, or prove much more than 911 took place on 911.
 
Mowrer, the guy that wrote the fire report, said "high rises must be able to withstand uncontrolled fires, or the risk to emergency services would be too great". Not an exact quote, but the spirit of what he said. I don't know what building codes have changed since 9/11 (I haven't started looking in to that yet), but if the answer is none, then there are some serious issues.

And WTC7 did, allowing full evacuation and the building's survival for several hours. And it's evacuation that's the key issue. The new WTC7 is better in that respect in a number of ways.

But the Towers were badly damaged, and no plausible building code will solve that. It's close to impossible to design buildings to withstand such impacts *plus* fire.
 
Last edited:
I believe it was NIST who said that building 7 was a first, unprecedented, yet no one is culpable.

I can't be bothered to refresh my memory on who hijacked the specific flight that struck the tower that eventually struck building 7 - but those are the ones who are culpable.

And I still do not have a handle on Shanksville.

Started with Edison. He invented phones which morphed into cell phones / airphones which were used to communicate what was happening to the passengers. They were given a choice - die sitting down or die fighting. They chose to die fighting. I'm confident that airplane was headed for the Capitol building.
Was the collapse of the towers an unexpected bonus to the perpetrators?

I would say that was their intent. If it didn't happen, fine. But that was their intent in my opinion. I base that on the fact it was their stated goal to do just that in 1993, exactly 26 years ago today. 12:17PM to be exact.


Mowrer, the guy that wrote the fire report, said "high rises must be able to withstand uncontrolled fires, or the risk to emergency services would be too great". Not an exact quote, but the spirit of what he said. I don't know what building codes have changed since 9/11 (I haven't started looking in to that yet), but if the answer is none, then there are some serious issues.

High rises must be designed to withstand uncontrolled fires for a period of time. Get the people out, get the firefighters in and give them a chance. None of that applied on 9/11 in building 7. It was already evacuated, and the firefighters who weren't buried by the twin towers were looking for the firefighters who who were. Building 7 was slightly above "fender bender on the Washington Bridge" on the list of priorities that day.

Building codes the world over were changed due to the events of 9/11.
 
The last nails in the coffin would be the sensitivity of the equipment, could hitting a pothole, or braking sharply or an impact with a tractor falsely update the IRS?

Think of it this way: The INS has an accuracy of 0.6NM. Its report of position corresponds to a matter of feet. How much do you suppose that moving the aircraft an inch in any direction is going to affect the INS's reported position?
Note also that if a runway has potholes that are throwing multimillion dollar aircraft around and jarring them enough to affect Nav gear, then that airport needs a great deal of repair.
If the amount of such bumping about is within limits of acceptability for large airports, then its also within the design ability of an INS to remain within its own limit of accuracy. (they don't design these things in a knowledge vacuum)
 
Building codes the world over were changed due to the events of 9/11.

And, I'm pretty sure some things changed even without code changes, e.g. WTC7 recommendations included some "don't do this" warnings for structural framing. I worked as a structural draftsman in the early 70s and I can't really recall any discussions with engineers or architects that showed any particular concern about fireproofing except that it was compliant with the controlling building codes, but I suspect that it's looked at more closely now.
 
Think of it this way: The INS has an accuracy of 0.6NM. Its report of position corresponds to a matter of feet. How much do you suppose that moving the aircraft an inch in any direction is going to affect the INS's reported position?
Note also that if a runway has potholes that are throwing multimillion dollar aircraft around and jarring them enough to affect Nav gear, then that airport needs a great deal of repair.
If the amount of such bumping about is within limits of acceptability for large airports, then its also within the design ability of an INS to remain within its own limit of accuracy. (they don't design these things in a knowledge vacuum)

Further to this:
To be more precise, the above applies when the INS has been aligned at the gate while the a/c doesn't move. Taxing after that will not affect the INS any more than regular flight.(which can be a lot bumpier than a taxiway or runway.)

There are parameters that can be adjusted in flight as well though along with specific flight characteristics to be met while adjusting the INS, such as non-accelerating flight.

<<tip o' the hat to the person who gave me more info>>
 
Last edited:
You'll note the pilot says "Dixie26" when requesting permission to taxi from ground control. The founder of P4T initially implied the recording was fake because no true pilot would ever use the term "Dixie" during communication with ATC instead of the phonetically correct "Delta". He also claimed that flight 77 would never receive taxi instructions from ground control instead of ramp control. Here's the audio of ramp control giving push back clearance
The Dixie bit is/was particularly idiotic, since even the FAA's own Aeronautical Information Manual (paragraph 4-2-7, Phonetic Alphabet) spells out:
ATC facilities may also request pilots to use phonetic letter equivalents when aircraft with similar sounding identifications are receiving communications on the same frequency.
Given that Delta Airlines was a fairly large airline even back then, it's hardly surprising that a lot locations they flew to chose to substitute Dixie for Delta.
 
Given that Delta Airlines was a fairly large airline even back then, it's hardly surprising that a lot locations they flew to chose to substitute Dixie for Delta.

OMG, are you implying that the use of "Delta" as the phonetic for the letter "D" in some aircraft communications could cause confusion, given that the name of a major airline was that very same word, "Delta"?!

Apparently the huge aviation brain trust at Pfffft, cannot envision the persons who make up the supermen they see themselves, and all competent pilots and ATC controllers as, possibly making the mistake and therefore using "Dixie" for the phonetic, is highly suspicious.
 
Delta, using Dixie... grd (ground control) using dixie in dixie...

best part at the end... starting at 1:15

http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=a08_1406358353#Ac8StXhcriIwscFG.16
Delta pilot makes mistake, verbally attacks grd controller

What you should say, "correcting, my mistake"... now he needs to see the shrink...
The best comment is from the "unknown" pilot... "settle down Captain Happy..."
 
Last edited:
OMG, are you implying that the use of "Delta" as the phonetic for the letter "D" in some aircraft communications could cause confusion, given that the name of a major airline was that very same word, "Delta"?!

Apparently the huge aviation brain trust at Pfffft, cannot envision the persons who make up the supermen they see themselves, and all competent pilots and ATC controllers as, possibly making the mistake and therefore using "Dixie" for the phonetic, is highly suspicious.

I seem to recall him also dismissing the recording as fake because he believed Dixie sounded like cop talk and the poster who obtained the recording from the FAA and posted it on this board had been a law enforcement officer at some point in his life.

It was entertaining watching someone who holds himself in such high esteem having their pet theory debunked with 20 seconds of ATC recordings. He has to be a better pilot than conspiracy theorist or he would've augured in decades ago.
 
Delta, using Dixie... grd (ground control) using dixie in dixie...

best part at the end... starting at 1:15

http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=a08_1406358353#Ac8StXhcriIwscFG.16
Delta pilot makes mistake, verbally attacks grd controller

What you should say, "correcting, my mistake"... now he needs to see the shrink...
The best comment is from the "unknown" pilot... "settle down Captain Happy..."
So the pilot took the wrong taxiway, the controller calmly corrects him and the pilot's comment is that there's no other aircraft there anyway, and then slams the controller for having "attitude"? I worked with ATC, and some of them are divas but in this case the bigger diva seems to be the pilot.:D
 
Delta, using Dixie... grd (ground control) using dixie in dixie...

best part at the end... starting at 1:15

http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=a08_1406358353#Ac8StXhcriIwscFG.16
Delta pilot makes mistake, verbally attacks grd controller

What you should say, "correcting, my mistake"... now he needs to see the shrink...
The best comment is from the "unknown" pilot... "settle down Captain Happy..."

I quite like this one, it lasts till about 1:30.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYN00cPV8Pg

The British guy sounded a bit concerned.
 
That's understandable to an extent, it doesn't make it any less unpleasant to be on the receiving end.
Sure but the ball is in your court to stop the truther style ambiguous or vague generalisations and implied global claims. Be focussed, specific and explicit. Some members will still treat you aggressively. Some of us - me included - will respond to focussed specific requests for help - and will ignore when you resort to truther style generalisations.

I don't know what happened completely, I know some of it, and I'm trying to piece together the rest of it in a way that it is square in my mind, because this is my journey through it.
Many of us have taken that journey. A few from a starting point favourable to conspiracy - most of us merely from a position of understanding that "it" happened and wanting to understand details. My own area of interest - understanding the WTC Twin Towers collapses - fits my background as civil/structural engineer and military engineer. That is what led to my involvement in forum discussion - a friend in the town where I was City Engineer asked me what I thought of the CD of the Twin Towers. I laughed at that silly idea - then realised he was serious and had to back off until I worked out why the twins collapsed so I could give him a fully professional explanation of the mechanism and the reasons for "No CD". (He was son of one of the Councillors on the Council I worked for so there was an issue of my local credibility to manage. :)) (And it should be mechanisms - there are two key ones - and easier explained as three because they overlap seamlessly.)
Things that may be insignificant to others, may be an itch in my mind that needs scratching.
Then identify each itch - one at a time - or 3 or 4 in a group. No more than can be rationally sorted within the practical limits of a couple of posts. If you keep vaguely referring to undefined itches things will not progress. Nor will any specific topic area progress whilst ever you persist in ignoring those who are expert on that topic.

It was such a dramatic, brutal event, simple yet extremely complex, and as I said earlier, it wont go away simply because what it led to is still happening.
There you go again. "what led to it" What do you mean by "it" and what do you say led to "it"? If you mean the whole of 9/11 as "it" then what led to it is a big complex issue of international and national politics. BUT each bit of "it" is easy to address. Here is one of the big technical issues - a part of "it". There was no CD at WTC. If you are honest about it then I and others can explain the engineering at any level of detail you need. And - just one example of how each of your "itches" can be resolved one at a time - we can kill two itches with one explanation. Once you understand why Twin Towers collapsed and why CD was neither needed NOR practised - THEN all the MIHOP concerns about CD at WTC are automatically resolved. If there was no CD it could not have been "Made To Happen - either accidentally OR on purpose".

Likewise once you are satisfied that the plane did crash into the Pentagon THEN all the counter claims can be discarded. So start with the big ones - and knock them off one by one.

Some genuine truthers back in 2006-7-8 were prepared and honest enough to take that path. There are few of those "genuine truthers" still coming to forums. Hence much of the antagonism you have faced.

Unexpected things happened, and the actions of the people in charge is very suspicious.
More generalisations. What actions by what people are suspicious for what reasons?
I believe it was NIST who said that building 7 was a first, unprecedented, yet no one is culpable.
NIST probably did say that. All three are probably true BUT so what? What are you trying to say? It reeks of innuendo and - by now - you should be avoiding innuendo.
And I still do not have a handle on Shanksville.
What is your concern about Shanksville? What aspect? A plane flew into the ground - what detail do you want? Why?

I'm not sure there could be one over arching grand conspiracy to cover everything that happened. It is just too complicated and open to cock ups.
My version and most members here go stronger than that - it is not possible that there could be "one overarching" and I don't back off from the (global) "not possible" despite it being a red rag invitation to get the argument arse about. So identify what you are not sure of if you want to take the issue further.

Some of the information may not be available for another 30+ years, some of it might never become available.
Another misleading generalisation. "Some of the information..." - information for what? Until you identify the issue of concern you - we - I cannot scope the needed info.
Was the collapse of the towers an unexpected bonus to the perpetrators?
Almost certainly yes.

The level of CYA, the "set up to fail", the coincidences...
The arguments about "MIHOP" and "LIHOP" from both sides are IMNSHO seriously flawed in structure. "One big plan" is almost certainly impossible. BUT there must have been lots of bits of MI/LIHOP and - the overlooked one - LIHOOI. I've never seen the realities seriously discussed.

It's like you couldn't plan it, but there's no way it could happen, yet it did, and then the politics happened.
True. False obviously. True and True - respectively.

Mowrer, the guy that wrote the fire report, said "high rises must be able to withstand uncontrolled fires, or the risk to emergency services would be too great". Not an exact quote, but the spirit of what he said.
Correct but don't miss the key element. The fires referred to are uncontrolled fires arising from predicted design scenarios. And deliberate attack by aircraft impact was not in the scenario designed for.

I don't know what building codes have changed since 9/11 (I haven't started looking in to that yet),
The primary failings at WTC Twin Towers were in escape paths. Allowance for fires in the design of buildings has two objectives:
1) Priority One provide means of escape and time to use the escape paths to get the occupants out;
2) Priority Two - minimise resulting building damage. (And that one is almost certainly interpreted as "risk manage to optimise (not minimise) likely levels of damage"

BUT both of those against the assessed risk of a likely scenario and aircraft deliberate impact as per 9/11 was NOT in the design scenario.

but if the answer is none,..
Other members will be more familiar with details -the NIST reports emphasised "get the occupants out" - countries other than US may have reacted faster than US in changing codes. BUT codes are not the only driver of safety.
then there are some serious issues.
"could be" - Should investors in high rise buildings allow for deliberate use of aircraft impact as a weapon? Give that some thought before you parrot off "YES!" It is more complicated than that.

So there are a couple of dozen points in that lot.

Some of them should be issues you are concerned about - possibly do not understand. So just pick out one, two, three if you want to discuss or question specific and focussed issues.
 
Last edited:
There you go again. "what led to it" What do you mean by "it" and what do you say led to "it"? If you mean the whole of 9/11 as "it" then what led to it is a big complex issue of international and national politics. BUT each bit of "it" is easy to address.

I just want to clear something up quickly, I'm not ignoring the rest of your post, and hopefully I'm not nitpicking.

I said
what it led to is still happening
, and not "what led to it". Therefore I can't really reply to that section because of the misunderstanding.
 
... I'm not ignoring the rest of your post, ...
on the topic of other questions...
Do you still think they used NANOTHERMATE? Who are they.


And...
... Which aircraft ... is something else entirely. ...
Is this based on a belief the planes were modified 767/757 drones; not needing 11 and 175.

... who flew them is something else entirely. ...
No terrorists. Have you signed up and posted these questions and ideas at pilots for truth, what did Balsamo say.
 
Last edited:
I just want to clear something up quickly, I'm not ignoring the rest of your post, and hopefully I'm not nitpicking.

I said , and not "what led to it".
My error of sequence ... if I'm careless enough to leave nits for you to pick :o
Therefore I can't really reply to that section because of the misunderstanding.
The query about "it" is still valid - it is the same "it" whether your sequence of 'what "it" led to' OR my sequence of 'what led to "it"'

And - whatever sequence or context "it" is used in - reasoned discussion requires that we know what "it" is if we are to avoid "talking at cross purposes". So I would still ask that you be clear as to what you mean by "it".
 
My error of sequence ... if I'm careless enough to leave nits for you to pick :o

More important is you gave him an out............. Your well reasoned post can now be dismissed....

I look down at the first line of my sig................. ;)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom