Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

You'll note that many of these persons have been selling the Truth concerning 9/11/01 the lie for many years. This forum exists to convince you that scientific evidence is required to back up technical claims up is down, and left is right. You will be chastised, derided, mystified in malfeasance, and negated, but when your arguments are shown to be severely lacking. will be ignored. Stories will be crafted You will be instructd on the relevance of to justify free fall, aerodynamics from engineers and pilots physics at 22,000ft will be applied to 700ft, scientists will be discredited because they're crackpots 'qualified, but the truth.... Unless you find it between the lines, you won't find it here.

You need to check your spelling.
 
Exactly. They are using the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy.

I didn't ask why they are doing it I asked why you are giving it any concern. What (if any) aspect of the flight of UA 77 don't you understand? Hitting the sidewall after a descending turn (easiest way to descend with control) would be far easier than trying to "dive-bomb" it.

I could never follow any logic that decides that Hanjour hit the specific part of the Pentagon that was planned to be hit.
They deliberately picked very large buildings to attack with high speed piloted aircraft. Real logic would deduce that one reason for this was the better chance of hitting at any location on a bigger target, is much better than the chance of hitting a much smaller target at all.

Some have opined that flight 93's target was the Whitehouse, but I doubt that very much. The next most logical target to attack, IMHO, would have been the Capitol Building, followed, perhaps, by CIA hdqtrs and the NSA. Much bigger than the WH and no covering forested areas around them.
 
Last edited:
Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>
Edited for rule 12.


Can't you just go ahead so we can move on from whether or not a 757 sized hole in the ground can be caused by a 757?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I didn't ask why they are doing it I asked why you are giving it any concern.

As I said, I think you may be inferring more importance than I intended. It was purely a fixed example, no more or less significant than anything else.

It is not my way to simply dismiss claims without thinking about them though.
 
Some have opined that flight 93's target was the Whitehouse, but I doubt that very much. The next most logical target to attack, IMHO, would have been the Capitol Building, followed, perhaps, by CIA hdqtrs and the NSA. Much bigger than the WH and no covering forested areas around them.

They weren't using your logic.

If you want to make a big statement, hit the White House. Do you remember the audience reaction when they blew it up in the movie Independence Day?
 
They weren't using your logic.

If you want to make a big statement, hit the White House. Do you remember the audience reaction when they blew it up in the movie Independence Day?
I would have been very surprised if they hit the WH. Finding it from the air is hard enough but there really is no good clear run to it. The only side that's really wide open, you have the (not so) small problem with the Washington Monument.
 
They weren't using your logic.

If you want to make a big statement, hit the White House. Do you remember the audience reaction when they blew it up in the movie Independence Day?

They weren't using your logic either. I believe the general understanding is that the three targets chosen were the Twin Towers as a symbol of America's economic strength, the Pentagon as a symbol of its military strength, and the Capitol as a symbol of its political strength, with the aim of demonstrating that none of these strengths could prevail against the moral strength of Islam.

Dave
 
Oh you can, I just missed out the bit about consequences :)

Do you suppose you'll address the size of the hole that perfectly matches the size of the plane that made it at any point? (Flight 93 if you're unaware)

Do you still think it wasn't made by Flight 93?
 
Do you suppose you'll address the size of the hole that perfectly matches the size of the plane that made it at any point? (Flight 93 if you're unaware)

Do you still think it wasn't made by Flight 93?

I don't know yet, I'm looking at other things.

Tell you what, if you can provide before and after photos of the impact site, from a similar angle, that will help when it comes time to look at it more closely.

Or do you want me to just reel off random **** without thinking about it, just so you can jump on any mistakes I might make?

Either you are here to pick a fight, or you are here to discuss and share understanding and knowledge. Let me know what you decide.
 
I don't know yet, I'm looking at other things.

Tell you what, if you can provide before and after photos of the impact site, from a similar angle, that will help when it comes time to look at it more closely.

An overhead photo of an obscure field in a remote part of the country is unlikely to be available.
 
I don't know yet, I'm looking at other things.

Tell you what, if you can provide before and after photos of the impact site, from a similar angle, that will help when it comes time to look at it more closely.

Or do you want me to just reel off random **** without thinking about it, just so you can jump on any mistakes I might make?

Either you are here to pick a fight, or you are here to discuss and share understanding and knowledge. Let me know what you decide.
14 years and I don't know...

It looks right for a crash site; you will have to go to aircraft accident investigation school, at USC to get educated. Asking for others to do your work is BS. You lack the knowledge to know. In fact on google earth you can measure the crater, it matches the wing span.

Radar data is the evidence it is 93; don't do science based evidence yet?

Hard facts, the FDR was in the crater, it was 93, and the flight path in the FDR matches the location... even the wind speed and direction are in the FDR for the impact moment.
DNA for each Flight 93 hero is in the ground and area. DNA for each murderer is in the area, even your BS alive ones. DNA for each crew member in the crash site.

Reality based evidence is in, it makes your looks like stuff, BS.

http://www.ntsb.gov/about/Documents/Rec_Radar_Data_Study_all_aircraft.pdf
The evil USA government's inside job is so secret, our government gives out the raw Radar data too, besides the summary; so you skeptics can plot it, and confirm 93 flew into the ground and was not one of your drone fantasy BS plot based on zero evidence.

https://sites.google.com/site/wtc7lies/flight93page1
https://sites.google.com/site/wtc7lies/flight93page2
https://sites.google.com/site/wtc7lies/flight93page3
research done long ago,,, photos of thousands of aircraft parts after a 1200 pounds of TNT in kinetic energy impact... A "normal" crash is done as slow as the pilot can fly,, thus the kinetic energy you are use to seeing is about 180 pounds of TNT, not 1200 pounds of TNT...

Are you the 911 truth believer who wants the USA to have a civil war? lol, alive terrorists, no clue who flew planes, no clue which planes... Radar ignored, and you picked BS like lost liberties you can't list, and other BS you fail to cover, but you post show up to post off topic BS, three or four times a day.
 
Hani, or his fellow murderer flew the worse turn in history. Poor bank angle, poor airspeed control, and poor decent rate. Hani was aiming to hit the Pentagon, not a special section. He had a target that was 900 feet wide, not 40 feet wide like the runway where he had his last Cessna flight. 900 feet wide and you say pilots on Jesse the Body's show could not hit a 900 foot wide runway? Are you saying pilots are bragging about not being able to do what a bad pilot did do? So sad to see pilots who can't hit a 900 foot target, yet they claim to be pilots who land on 40 to 200 feet wide runways. How do they land?

LOL, the biggest error is trying to hit where Hani hit, he hit at random, it was not a game of "horse", it was random. Thus to replicate Hani's poor flying, hitting the Pentagon Anywhere is the same as hitting it where Hani hit it; He was not aiming at the specific section, he was trying to hit the Pentagon.
It seems to me that if Ventura wanted to find out how likely it was for a minimally-trained pilot to hit a huge target like Washington, DC, he should have gathered some flight students and given them the simulator goal, not of exactly reproducing Hani's track, but to hit something, somewhere, sometime before running out of fuel. The Pentagon? The Capitol? The White House? Any of those would have been acceptable.

I'll bet the analysis of this kind of test would provide a much different answer.
 
I don't know yet, I'm looking at other things.

Tell you what, if you can provide before and after photos of the impact site, from a similar angle, that will help when it comes time to look at it more closely.
.
It's possible to get a reasonable estimate of the crater size from this one photo: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/46/UA93_crash_site_noborder.jpg

ShanksvilleCraterSize.jpg
 
.
It's possible to get a reasonable estimate of the crater size from this one photo: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/46/UA93_crash_site_noborder.jpg

[qimg]http://opendb.com/images/ShanksvilleCraterSize.jpg[/qimg]
Using math is cheating. 911 truth believers are not allowed to use math, and physics is banned.

911 truth is in rerun, with 911 truth followers who can't do simple research... their google is stuck on 911 lies.


It seems to me that if Ventura wanted to find out how likely it was for a minimally-trained pilot to hit a huge target like Washington, DC, he should have gathered some flight students and given them the simulator goal, not of exactly reproducing Hani's track, but to hit something, somewhere, sometime before running out of fuel. The Pentagon? The Capitol? The White House? Any of those would have been acceptable.

I'll bet the analysis of this kind of test would provide a much different answer.

The simulator was harder to fly than the plane... it was this way to keep you busy as you did emergency procedures. Plus, the darn sim would crash for over speed, and other things that in real life would not happen. Simulators suck.

I flew as an instructor, and flew orientation flights with kids... sadly, kids with no training... some could fly better than I. Could they land at 2000 to 2400 RVR in fog... maybe not... but flying is not hard unless you believe it is... but flying can be hard under certain conditions... on 911 the weather was with the terrorists... could not have been a better day.
 
Last edited:
I don't know yet, I'm looking at other things.

Tell you what, if you can provide before and after photos of the impact site, from a similar angle, that will help when it comes time to look at it more closely.

Or do you want me to just reel off random **** without thinking about it, just so you can jump on any mistakes I might make?

Either you are here to pick a fight, or you are here to discuss and share understanding and knowledge. Let me know what you decide.

Riigghhtt....
:dl:

You're not interested in gaining any knowledge. Don't pretend you are.
 
Last edited:
They weren't using your logic.

If you want to make a big statement, hit the White House. Do you remember the audience reaction when they blew it up in the movie Independence Day?

Oh I believe they used my logic.

Yes biggest statement to be made would be hitting the WH.
BUT
It's not particularly visible from the air, surrounded on at least two sides by tall trees. It's also not particularly a big structure. Not in comparison to the known targets that were hit.

Logic applied in selecting targets would have take place in the weeks\months prior. Perhaps they had secondary targets but it's also probable that the plan B, as it were, would be to hit a residential area or, if all was going badly, to simply work to ensure destruction of the plane and death of all on board.

The Capitol Building would be, IMHO, the single most visible target in all of D.C., Virginia, and Delaware. Nothing occludes the view of it, it's huge, it stands next to an enormous reflecting pool and a tall stone tower with blinking aviation warning lights.

It's an easier target to find and hit than the Pentagon. IMHO, that's why it was as left for last.
 
Last edited:
Seems as good a thread as any:

What evidence is there for a south of Citgo gas station approach to the Pentagon? So far I have tallied the damage to the building, the downed light poles, and the damaged generator outside. Is there any other evidence I'm missing?

Why is there not a conclusive radar track, elevation?


Sent from our shared looking glass platform
 
I don't know yet, I'm looking at other things.
And making progress. :thumbsup:

Either you are here to pick a fight, or you are here to discuss and share understanding and knowledge. Let me know what you decide.
Recall the comment I made a couple of weeks back:
Some members will still treat you aggressively. Some of us - me included - will respond to focussed specific requests for help
Some members are into explaining/helping....some are into picking fault. Some manage to mix the two. Filter out the aggression only posts and ignore them. With the "half and half" posts extract the reasonable bits and work on them.

My advice is still "ignore the aggression - focus on the issues".
 
Seems as good a thread as any:

What evidence is there for a south of Citgo gas station approach to the Pentagon? So far I have tallied the damage to the building, the downed light poles, and the damaged generator outside. Is there any other evidence I'm missing?
Evidence for what? The "end point" is known - the plane ended up in the Pentagon. So what is your objective in considering evidence of the route that was taken?

Why is there not a conclusive radar track, elevation?
Begging the question??? Why do you need/want it?
 
What evidence is there for a south of Citgo gas station approach to the Pentagon? So far I have tallied the damage to the building, the downed light poles, and the damaged generator outside. Is there any other evidence I'm missing?
Tons of aircraft debris laid out on the flight path and impact path, on the final course in the FDR, found in the Pentagon along with DNA from all but the small boy. This is called evidence, and proof it was 77. Thus all 911 truth claims are lies.

Why is there not a conclusive radar track, elevation?
There are four or five conclusive Radar tracks. Looks like another bogus 911 truth question. Did you miss the Radar data?

http://www.ntsb.gov/about/Documents/Rec_Radar_Data_Study_all_aircraft.pdf

Why are you worried about elevation, the FDR last Radar Altimeter reading was 4 feet.

http://nsarchive.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB196/doc02.pdf

The NTSB figured out 911, why can't 911 truth?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom