Faith leads to evil.

I didn't say anything remotely like that, either. Where did you come up with that nonsense?

See, I'm a practical sort of person, so I figure that you use your brain, you see what works and what doesn't, and you go from there. And, before some idiot asks "what if murdering and stealing works", the answer is that eventually someone comes along and chops your head off or hangs you for it, and order is restored for at least a little while.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but that's good ol' "What's right is what society deems to be right" right there. I mean lots of times in history people patted you on the back for stealing and killing, so they definitely worked at those points. If the best answer you can come up with for "What works" then your code is completely at the mercy of society's judgments, as you admit in your own example, and thus utterly arbitrary since society is, by and large, totally irrational.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but that's good ol' "What's right is what society deems to be right" right there. I mean lots of times in history people patted you on the back for stealing and killing, so they definitely worked at those points. If the best answer you can come up with for "What works" then your code is completely at the mercy of society's judgments, as you admit in your own example, and thus utterly arbitrary since society is, by and large, totally irrational.
Well... yes and no. Every set of rules for every society that has ever existed, and ever will exist, has been "arbitrary" on some level. The question you should have asked, and what I should have made more clear, is "works towards what end?" The end I would like to see is the minimum amounts of hatred, misery, and violence as is possible while creating as much freedom and prosperity for all as is possible. So, when I say "look at what works and what doesn't", I mean to take what I consider to be the things that have made countries achieve some measure of success(by my ideal standard) and avoid those things which have failed to produce the desired outcome.
 
How is it possible to found morality upon reason? I can see how given a set of moral axioms, one can use reason to derive principles from which to act, but how can one found morality solely on reason?

Mobyseven has explained this in another thread, where he points out that moral systems are always arbitrary and of equal status.

You can found morality upon reason, but like anything else, you're going to hit a point where you say, "I can't reason to a more basic level than this." Using those basic assumptions, it is possible to use reason to construct a moral system - but don't expect everyone to agree with it, as they may have come to an equally reasonable but different moral system (either based upon different values, or having weighted the same values slightly differently).

That does not mean, however, that all moral systems are of equal status. If the values upon which a system is founded are inappropriate, then the entire system is based upon a faulty premise (and thus, even if the resultant moral system is identical to one based upon appropriate values, the argument from the value to the system is invalid).

By appropriate here, I do not mean 'appropriate' in the moral sense. Instead, I mean that the value has some grounding in reality. So, for example, a moral system that has been constructed based on the premise that a particular person or entity is a perfect model of morality is based upon a faulty premise - because in order to evaluate the morality of the person as perfect we need to already have a moral system in place, and would therefore be begging the question.
 
Well... yes and no. Every set of rules for every society that has ever existed, and ever will exist, has been "arbitrary" on some level. The question you should have asked, and what I should have made more clear, is "works towards what end?" The end I would like to see is the minimum amounts of hatred, misery, and violence as is possible while creating as much freedom and prosperity for all as is possible. So, when I say "look at what works and what doesn't", I mean to take what I consider to be the things that have made countries achieve some measure of success(by my ideal standard) and avoid those things which have failed to produce the desired outcome.
Are there ideals greater than individual happiness, and the minimization of hatred, misery, and violence? If freedom is one of the ideals, what happens when it headbutts the happiness ideal? Certainly people appear happier if you take away certain freedoms (taken to the absurd, we could put antidepressants in the drinking water and take away people's freedom to be unhappy - certainly reducing violence, misery, and hatred to new record lows).

I don't find the hedonist morality very compelling, unfortunately. It always seems to work better in theory than in practice, as identifying what makes people unhappy is theoretically a snap, and practically nearly impossible.

And that's before we get to the issue of minimizing violence or hatred. Video games? Comic Books? Single parent homes? All of these have been blamed for violence, at one time or another.
 
Last edited:
What I mean is that atheism refers to something too narrow and specific to be called an ideology. It is simply the disbelief in worshiped beings called gods. There are certainly people who use atheism in order to justify their political, social, moral, scientific, and religious views, but to equate the component with the whole is no different from the fallacy I mentioned above.

I get this part of it, but I fail to see why this leads to the conclusion that it's impossible to base a state on atheism? Why it is impossible to do anything in the name of atheism. That being the case, wouldn't arguing for atheism, or against religious belief, be antithetical?

Or perhaps I'm just hung up on your use of the word "impossible". Again, I'm not trying to be pedantic, but maybe I have been just the same.
 
I must question the concept of faith. My suspicion is that there is (mostly) no such thing.
Sure, people go to church; claim to believe in this or that wooishness...but do they really?

I suspect that (mostly) they don't actually have faith. They just go along with the program, for whatever advantages it has...including not pissing-off your mom.

I guess I'm saying that most faith isn't really faith. It just uses the word faith.
Don't most proclaimed christians actually have more faith in technology than in Jesus?

And don't most people whom proclaim faith in technology actually harbor some doubts about technology's ability to 'save us' from an ugly fate?

I see mostly two types of people.
Those whom are curious and introspective; and those whom are more mentally lazy or ill-equipped for examination of reality.

The second type cop to faith because it gets them off the hook of inquisitiveness.
Yet, they don't actually believe or disbelieve much of anything...and they are willing to switch horses as the need arises.
 
Apparently, the fundamental principle of your diseased ethics is "make up unflattering things about other people." And, since you make your lies so obvious, "not getting caught" isn't an obvious part of your twisted version of morality.

How does that feel, lying through your teeth while preaching about morals?

I never said or implied anything even remotely like "the fundamental principle is 'don't get punished'." You, sir, are a liar, and you owe me an apology.

See, I'm a practical sort of person, so I figure that you use your brain, you see what works and what doesn't, and you go from there. And, before some idiot asks "what if murdering and stealing works", the answer is that eventually someone comes along and chops your head off or hangs you for it, and order is restored for at least a little while.

As I said - I don't believe that Joe Ellison's ethics are really as he portrayed them. But he said the above. He gave as his reason for not murdering and stealing that someone comes along and chops his head off.

I didn't make that up. I've posted it again, entire. As I said, I don't think that represents his genuine ethical stance, but I can't seen any ethical principle in what he stated apart from fit in and avoid punishment.
 
I get this part of it, but I fail to see why this leads to the conclusion that it's impossible to base a state on atheism? Why it is impossible to do anything in the name of atheism. That being the case, wouldn't arguing for atheism, or against religious belief, be antithetical?

Or perhaps I'm just hung up on your use of the word "impossible". Again, I'm not trying to be pedantic, but maybe I have been just the same.

I should explain what I meant when I said that communism was founded on atheism. Clearly much of Marxist theory is to do with economics, or history, or politics, or sociology. But Marxist thought has a very clear philosophical base, which precedes ideology. It rests on a foundation of materialism.

I don't necessarily think that a state founded on atheism, or founded on some political principle based on atheist principles will necessarily end in disaster - but all the examples we have, did.

There are plenty of secular states around, to a greater or lesser extent, but that's a different matter. They are based on a principle that all religious beliefs should be treated equally. Such states tend to do better that those which favour a single religious belief, and those that explicitly oppose all.
 
I think that when people say they are acting as Christians, then it's reasonable to conclude that that is what they are doing, whether it is something with which one agrees or disagrees. Going back to the bible to see if it can be reconciled with what someone else interprets is a pointless process.


So if some nutter started eating people and claimed to be doing it in the name of christianity would you just accept it and not bother to point out that cannabalism has no scriptural basis? Or do you only do so with the opponents of slavery because you want to be able to claim them as motivated by your faith?


The fact is that the British and American opponents of slavery were motivated by their Christian beliefs.


How can they be said to be motivated by their christian beliefs when there was no scriptural basis for their actions?
 
Well... yes and no. Every set of rules for every society that has ever existed, and ever will exist, has been "arbitrary" on some level. The question you should have asked, and what I should have made more clear, is "works towards what end?" The end I would like to see is the minimum amounts of hatred, misery, and violence as is possible while creating as much freedom and prosperity for all as is possible. So, when I say "look at what works and what doesn't", I mean to take what I consider to be the things that have made countries achieve some measure of success(by my ideal standard) and avoid those things which have failed to produce the desired outcome.

And the clarification is noted. This is something like what I assumed was intended.
 
So if some nutter started eating people and claimed to be doing it in the name of christianity would you just accept it and not bother to point out that cannabalism has no scriptural basis? Or do you only do so with the opponents of slavery because you want to be able to claim them as motivated by your faith?

I wouldn't claim such a thing wasn't mandated by scripture - because I can well imagine someone could interpret the sections of the New Testament dealing with transubstantiation and find a justification for cannibalism there.

How can they be said to be motivated by their christian beliefs when there was no scriptural basis for their actions?

Because their Christian beliefs incorporate their moral beliefs. They did not consider their moral judgement as seperate from their Christianity.

The idea that a Christian decides how to feel about a particular issue by poring through the bible is more Atheist Fundamentalism. The Christians who opposed slavery didn't need to go much further than "Love your neighbour as yourself".

It's fair comment when the hypocrisy of Christian slave-owners is pointed out. I won't try to pretend that they weren't somehow real Christians. But the abolitionist movement was dominated by Christians acting according to their Christian principles.
 
You can found morality upon reason, but like anything else, you're going to hit a point where you say, "I can't reason to a more basic level than this." Using those basic assumptions, it is possible to use reason to construct a moral system - but don't expect everyone to agree with it, as they may have come to an equally reasonable but different moral system (either based upon different values, or having weighted the same values slightly differently).

Assuming perfect reason, and the same assumptions, and putting aside issues of language and comprehension, starting with the same fundamental principles it should be possible to derive the same moral code. Naturally this will never happen.

That does not mean, however, that all moral systems are of equal status. If the values upon which a system is founded are inappropriate, then the entire system is based upon a faulty premise (and thus, even if the resultant moral system is identical to one based upon appropriate values, the argument from the value to the system is invalid).

However, the principle on which a moral system is founded is typically not something which can be determined as faulty or sound. If the fundamental principle is "Increase human happiness" then it's not possible to use reason to determine whether that is a correct premise or not.

By appropriate here, I do not mean 'appropriate' in the moral sense. Instead, I mean that the value has some grounding in reality. So, for example, a moral system that has been constructed based on the premise that a particular person or entity is a perfect model of morality is based upon a faulty premise - because in order to evaluate the morality of the person as perfect we need to already have a moral system in place, and would therefore be begging the question.

But a large number of systems have been based on such a view, explicitly or implicitly. Admittedly they tend not to turn out so well.

http://www.iht.com/articles/1994/10/19/ederic.php
 
How is it possible to found morality upon reason? I can see how given a set of moral axioms, one can use reason to derive principles from which to act, but how can one found morality solely on reason?

Suffering is, by definition, unpleasant. It is logical to minimize suffering.
 
I'm still trying to wrap my head around an "atheist ideology". Where does atheism say that the repression of religion is a good thing? Couldn't you imagine an atheist king who believed that the plebs needed religion to survive?
 
Last edited:
As I said - I don't believe that Joe Ellison's ethics are really as he portrayed them. But he said the above. He gave as his reason for not murdering and stealing that someone comes along and chops his head off.

I didn't make that up. I've posted it again, entire. As I said, I don't think that represents his genuine ethical stance, but I can't seen any ethical principle in what he stated apart from fit in and avoid punishment.

You're still lying. What part of your ethics allows to lie without causing your conscience any issues?
 
Certainly, this thread could stand as proof that faith leads to lying... what up with that?
 
Suffering is, by definition, unpleasant. It is logical to minimize suffering.

It's this reason that should be the basis for morality. Morality should be about reasoning out ways to minimize suffering. From this basic axiom comes the "golden rule" and ethics about stealing, lying, cheating etc.

When faith is the basis for morality, you get idiotic moral codes about how to treat slaves, keep women quiet, how to barter your children and how to kill homosexuals.
 
.
Faith all by itself has no substance, but many good people pattern their lives on what they have been taught, and act accordingly.
It gives them a set of rules, with a goal other than just blanking out forever.
Faith being an outgrowth of the ethical and moral rules any coherent group develops isn't always mentioned, the reverse idea that faith makes morals is what is preached.
"Atheists can't be good citizens!"
When enhanced with the carrot of eternal life, thinking about what society would be sans faith just never occurs.
It makes a handy cover-up for the actual reasons for aggression, which as noted are economic or political for the most part.
The spectacular brutalities and abject failures of the Crusades are more popular in the public mind than empire expansion for the sake of empire expansion, ala Alexander, or Attila...
Religion is merely about population pacification. A quiescent populace can be depended on to confirm what should be repugnant activities by the leaders, if the leaders can gloss over their criminal intent with pious reasons.
It helped get the current criminal adventure into Iraq going that Iraq was Islamic, for instance, bringing back memories of the Crusades' high-falutin' motives, while covering up the true intent of getting to all that oil.

I believe that your premise is wrong. Evil does not exist. Evil was created so that Good (the gods) what have something to do battle with and to scare the masses into submission. Sick vs. healthy is how I try to look at the world, not good vs. evil.
ETA: And it is the blind faith in anything from a religion to a godless warlord without the benefit of skepticism that leads to the bad acts, or unhealthy behavior.
 
Last edited:
Faith. In order to defend faith, people will do any number of immoral things.

Yes, but... it is getting to the point that "outspoken Christian on the Internet" is almost a synonym for "bigoted liar." It is weird, since real-life Christians don't follow that pattern nearly as closely. When someone starts a thread here defending theism, however, I'd bet you dollars to donuts that they'll be lying by page 2.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom