Frozenwolf150
Formerly SilentKnight
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2007
- Messages
- 4,134
Why? I'm not trying to lay any kind of semantic trap or be pedantic here. Why is it impossible to found a state in the name of atheism? Why is it impossible to do anything in the name of atheism?
What I mean is that atheism refers to something too narrow and specific to be called an ideology. It is simply the disbelief in worshiped beings called gods. There are certainly people who use atheism in order to justify their political, social, moral, scientific, and religious views, but to equate the component with the whole is no different from the fallacy I mentioned above. There have certainly been Communist regimes who instituted a state of atheism, but they primarily brought in atheism as an afterthought in order to suppress other religions from competing with Communism. Atheism alone is a singular conclusion. It's not the atheism but what people (sometimes fallaciously) attach to it that motivates them, for better or for worse.
As I pointed out once before, communist North Korea is technically an atheistic state (though they allow for Christianity to be practiced because Kim Il Sung came from a Christian family). However this does not mean by any stretch of the imagination that it was founded on atheism. People do not end up with a nation like North Korea by becoming too rational. Communism is their religion, devotion to the regime is their dogma, and Kim Jong Il is worshiped as God. Any rational dissenting atheists, like myself, who lived in North Korea would have been chopped into pieces long ago and fed to their other political prisoners.