Faith leads to evil.

Why? I'm not trying to lay any kind of semantic trap or be pedantic here. Why is it impossible to found a state in the name of atheism? Why is it impossible to do anything in the name of atheism?

What I mean is that atheism refers to something too narrow and specific to be called an ideology. It is simply the disbelief in worshiped beings called gods. There are certainly people who use atheism in order to justify their political, social, moral, scientific, and religious views, but to equate the component with the whole is no different from the fallacy I mentioned above. There have certainly been Communist regimes who instituted a state of atheism, but they primarily brought in atheism as an afterthought in order to suppress other religions from competing with Communism. Atheism alone is a singular conclusion. It's not the atheism but what people (sometimes fallaciously) attach to it that motivates them, for better or for worse.

As I pointed out once before, communist North Korea is technically an atheistic state (though they allow for Christianity to be practiced because Kim Il Sung came from a Christian family). However this does not mean by any stretch of the imagination that it was founded on atheism. People do not end up with a nation like North Korea by becoming too rational. Communism is their religion, devotion to the regime is their dogma, and Kim Jong Il is worshiped as God. Any rational dissenting atheists, like myself, who lived in North Korea would have been chopped into pieces long ago and fed to their other political prisoners.
 
Faith is an attack on reason, which is the very foundation of morality, ethics and humanity.
 
Faith is an attack on reason, which is the very foundation of morality, ethics and humanity.

How is it possible to found morality upon reason? I can see how given a set of moral axioms, one can use reason to derive principles from which to act, but how can one found morality solely on reason?

Mobyseven has explained this in another thread, where he points out that moral systems are always arbitrary and of equal status.
 
You can't found a state on "atheism" any more than you can found a state on a-astrology-ism. You don't form a state by what you don't believe in-- but by the ideals that unite the group. There are always things that the majority won't "believe in". You can't found a state on the lack of belief in psychics can you?

You can have a secular state... or a state bound upon the will of the people being governed... this was supposedly how the United States was set up. But that is not an "atheist" state. People seem to think of atheism as something it's not. It isn't an "anything" ... it's a lack of belief in gods. You could found a state based on humanism or rationalism... but not on what people don't believe in.

Why is that so hard for people to grasp? Why do they need to see atheism as something it isn't when they can so readily relate it to exactly what it is by thinking of how the things they don't believe in affect them.

Atheists unite because they don't like being marginalized because they refuse to pretend that the Emperor is wearing clothes and people see all sorts of nastiness associated with this --while ignoring all the harms that come from promoting faith as a virtue and "obedience to faith" as salvation worthy... and questioning of faith as damning or treasonous.

Faith elevates delusions and self importance and "belief" above reason and humanity and truth. It might have positive results in some cases... but in other cases it leads to horrors. And there is no reasoning with folks sure that they have tapped in to some "higher law". And no matter what good it brings... it doesn't make it true and it sure doesn't justify the hideous misrepresentation of those who don't-- indeed can't-- believe this nonsense and won't pretend that it's good to do so.
 
Last edited:
The following quotation from the Nobel prize winning physicist Steven Weinberg has become well known too: “With or without [religion] you’d have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, it takes religion.

Or a situational instinct of self preservation or preservation of loved ones over the welfare of others.
 
What do you offer as an alternative? What CAN you offer?
Is it necessary to offer an alternative foundation? Reason would certainly be a good place to start, but I find the entire concept is usually too abstract - I have yet to see very many people follow their proclaimed moral code. And even less actually follow it because of said code (most just fear getting caught).
 
Last edited:
What do you offer as an alternative? What CAN you offer?

The alternative is to say that certain things are wrong. Such a system relies on a belief which cannot be grounded in science/pure reason.

Alternatively you can say that we are going to say that certain things are wrong, and work on that basis, while accepting that it's entirely arbitrary, but necessary to do certain things we want.

Either will work. Constructing a moral system on pure reason is simply impossible, as far as I can see.
 
What I mean is that atheism refers to something too narrow and specific to be called an ideology. It is simply the disbelief in worshiped beings called gods. There are certainly people who use atheism in order to justify their political, social, moral, scientific, and religious views, but to equate the component with the whole is no different from the fallacy I mentioned above. There have certainly been Communist regimes who instituted a state of atheism, but they primarily brought in atheism as an afterthought in order to suppress other religions from competing with Communism.

The motivation may well have been the preservation of the regime, but atheism was part of Marxism from the get-go.

Atheism alone is a singular conclusion. It's not the atheism but what people (sometimes fallaciously) attach to it that motivates them, for better or for worse.

As I pointed out once before, communist North Korea is technically an atheistic state (though they allow for Christianity to be practiced because Kim Il Sung came from a Christian family). However this does not mean by any stretch of the imagination that it was founded on atheism. People do not end up with a nation like North Korea by becoming too rational.

That's begging the question there. The assumption is that people become atheists by being rational, that North Korea isn't rational, and therefore North Korea wasn't founded on atheism seems to assume what you wanted to prove.

Communism is their religion, devotion to the regime is their dogma, and Kim Jong Il is worshiped as God. Any rational dissenting atheists, like myself, who lived in North Korea would have been chopped into pieces long ago and fed to their other political prisoners.

It's also sometimes known for religious regimes to persecute followers of religion. North Korea isn't atheistic because No True Atheist would behave like that. All that's required to join the atheist club is to not believe in God. Nobody said you had to be rational as well. One can be an atheist and have entirely irrational reasons for one's beliefs.
 
The following quotation from the Nobel prize winning physicist Steven Weinberg has become well known too: “With or without [religion] you’d have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, it takes religion.

So when the atheists in China during the Cultural Revolution did evil things, were they good people corrupted by an evil regime, or just evil people?

The idea that only religion can be a corrupting force is hardly worth taking seriously. Weinburg is smart enough to know that.
 
The alternative is to say that certain things are wrong. Such a system relies on a belief which cannot be grounded in science/pure reason.

Alternatively you can say that we are going to say that certain things are wrong, and work on that basis, while accepting that it's entirely arbitrary, but necessary to do certain things we want.

Either will work. Constructing a moral system on pure reason is simply impossible, as far as I can see.
So you offer no alternative, you just pretend that you do because it allows you to attack reason in favor of imaginary things?

When you say something is "wrong", are you just tossing a dart at a list of things and randomly selecting, or do you use your brain? If you use your brain to DECIDE what is wrong, then reason would automatically play a part, and you have no point.
 
Is it necessary to offer an alternative foundation? Reason would certainly be a good place to start, but I find the entire concept is usually too abstract - I have yet to see very many people follow their proclaimed moral code. And even less actually follow it because of said code (most just fear getting caught).

See, I'm a practical sort of person, so I figure that you use your brain, you see what works and what doesn't, and you go from there. And, before some idiot asks "what if murdering and stealing works", the answer is that eventually someone comes along and chops your head off or hangs you for it, and order is restored for at least a little while.
 
So you offer no alternative, you just pretend that you do because it allows you to attack reason in favor of imaginary things?

I just gave the alternatives. And they are genuine alternatives.

When you say something is "wrong", are you just tossing a dart at a list of things and randomly selecting, or do you use your brain?

I start with a set of principles and apply reason to them. If I don't have a set of principles, then I can't get anywhere, no matter how much brainpower I apply.

If you use your brain to DECIDE what is wrong, then reason would automatically play a part, and you have no point.


Of course reason plays a part. That's very different from saying that moral systems are founded on reason. They clearly are not.
 
See, I'm a practical sort of person, so I figure that you use your brain, you see what works and what doesn't, and you go from there. And, before some idiot asks "what if murdering and stealing works", the answer is that eventually someone comes along and chops your head off or hangs you for it, and order is restored for at least a little while.

Somemight regard "avoid punishment" as a moral framework. I wouldn't (and that includes the avoidance of divine punishment as well).

However, even such a framework starts out with a basis on which to build. In JoeEllison ethics, the fundamental principle is "don't get punished". Then the reason part kicks in.

(Incidentally, I don't believe that Joe Ellison would actually do anything especially bad if he thought he'd get away with it. But I may be wrong).
 
Somemight regard "avoid punishment" as a moral framework. I wouldn't (and that includes the avoidance of divine punishment as well).

However, even such a framework starts out with a basis on which to build. In JoeEllison ethics, the fundamental principle is "don't get punished". Then the reason part kicks in.

(Incidentally, I don't believe that Joe Ellison would actually do anything especially bad if he thought he'd get away with it. But I may be wrong).

Apparently, the fundamental principle of your diseased ethics is "make up unflattering things about other people." And, since you make your lies so obvious, "not getting caught" isn't an obvious part of your twisted version of morality.

How does that feel, lying through your teeth while preaching about morals?

I never said or implied anything even remotely like "the fundamental principle is 'don't get punished'." You, sir, are a liar, and you owe me an apology.
 
People in Communist Russia had faith in the Party. People in the PRNK have faith in the Great Leader.

It's faith (that is - the unquestioning deference to and willingness to be supine to a higher, inerrant and imposed authority) that's inherently the problem here, not what the faith is in, necessarily. Communism, authoritarian fascism or personality cults are just as faith-based as the monotheisms are, and trying to highlight them as examples of faith-free or even atheist states is naive.

In essence, states like Nazi Germany, Communist Russia, Turkmenistan, North Korea etc. use the tools of faith to their own ends. When people believe in something without question (that is, they have faith), then evil ensues.
 
People in Communist Russia had faith in the Party. People in the PRNK have faith in the Great Leader.

It's faith (that is - the unquestioning deference to and willingness to be supine to a higher, inerrant and imposed authority) that's inherently the problem here, not what the faith is in, necessarily. Communism, authoritarian fascism or personality cults are just as faith-based as the monotheisms are, and trying to highlight them as examples of faith-free or even atheist states is naive.

In essence, states like Nazi Germany, Communist Russia, Turkmenistan, North Korea etc. use the tools of faith to their own ends. When people believe in something without question (that is, they have faith), then evil ensues.
Exactly. The problem is that when people abandon reason for faith, they open themselves up to allow evil people to manipulate and exploit them. Once you've decided that your preacher or your political leader is right for no reason other than because he shares your faith or political leanings, you have surrendered your ability to think, and you've made yourself into a mindless follower. That, in itself, is an immense evil.
 
See, I'm a practical sort of person, so I figure that you use your brain, you see what works and what doesn't, and you go from there. And, before some idiot asks "what if murdering and stealing works", the answer is that eventually someone comes along and chops your head off or hangs you for it, and order is restored for at least a little while.
So your moral code is "prevailing local customs?"

I mean seriously, by that logic, homosexuality is immoral in the cultures where they'll execute you for it. And not immoral in the cultures where it's not a crime. I mean obviously it doesn't work in those cultures (if by work, you mean "keep you alive").

I think this fails to meet any definition of morality that is in any way conventional. At best it could be called the "When in Rome" morality.
 
So your moral code is "prevailing local customs?"

I mean seriously, by that logic, homosexuality is immoral in the cultures where they'll execute you for it. And not immoral in the cultures where it's not a crime. I mean obviously it doesn't work in those cultures (if by work, you mean "keep you alive").

I think this fails to meet any definition of morality that is in any way conventional. At best it could be called the "When in Rome" morality.

I didn't say anything remotely like that, either. Where did you come up with that nonsense?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom