Faith leads to evil.

It's impossible to do anything "in the name of" atheism, or even to found a state "in the name of" atheism. Your argument makes as much sense as if you were to blame Hitler's mustache for the Holocaust.

Why? I'm not trying to lay any kind of semantic trap or be pedantic here. Why is it impossible to found a state in the name of atheism? Why is it impossible to do anything in the name of atheism?
 
Damn near everything leads to something sometime. (with regard to human behavior)

Most of these arguments use analogy, anecdote, isolated examples or hyperbole and don’t hold much water. History is just way to big to make all inclusive statements with out knowing there is a strong likelihood of just as much evidence being available to the other side.
 
Communist ideology is based very specifically on a philosophy of materialistic humanism. It's a specific Marxist version of humanism, but that's what it is.

And if you think so called "communist" societies have resembled anything like the communist ideology they claim to have been founded upon, you need to read some history books.

I'm not aware of other societies which are explicitly secular in the same way as in the communist bloc. I'd be interested to hear of the examples. However, my contention was never that atheism results in inevitable disaster.

Many modern European countries? I could be wrong about that, but I thought they were pretty secular and doing pretty well when it comes to human rights.
 
:
1. There are some people who would argue that religion and other ideological positions are largely developed and propagated by those with at least some power. For example, I Ratatant said, about 4 posts ago "Religion is merely about population pacification."
True, but why do they have the power and what is the power they have over others? Is it based on material possessions? Food? The promise of a better life?
.
When life became less stressful so that some could leave off hunting and gathering all the live long day, and had the leisure time to sit around and chew the fat, and get the hunters and gatherers to do a bit more of that, so these swifties didn't have to, it wouldn't take too much introspection to develop a way to guilt the workers into supporting the thinkers.
Then comes the fancy vestments and public works projects that keep the new clergy in control.
The invention of an afterlife as the ultimate carrot, which never has to be delivered is pure (evil) genius! :)
 
They were christians, but was it their christianity that motivated them? I am unaware of any part of the Bible that condemns slavery.

I think that when people say they are acting as Christians, then it's reasonable to conclude that that is what they are doing, whether it is something with which one agrees or disagrees. Going back to the bible to see if it can be reconciled with what someone else interprets is a pointless process.

The fact is that the British and American opponents of slavery were motivated by their Christian beliefs.
 
And if you think so called "communist" societies have resembled anything like the communist ideology they claim to have been founded upon, you need to read some history books.

That's just one example of the failure of the ideology.

However, in the repression of religion, they were faithful to the atheistic aspects of the theory at least.

Many modern European countries? I could be wrong about that, but I thought they were pretty secular and doing pretty well when it comes to human rights.

Most European countries have less seperation of Church and State than the USA. I suppose France could be considered secular, in a sense, but that is entirely different from a society that promotes atheism.

Having a society that treats beliefs as a personal matter on which it shouldn't have an opinion is exactly the attitude I was suggesting when I started this thread.
 
Communist ideology is based very specifically on a philosophy of materialistic humanism. It's a specific Marxist version of humanism, but that's what it is.

I suppose that it's possible to claim that a different version of humanism would work differently. Well, that cuts both ways.

I'm not aware of other societies which are explicitly secular in the same way as in the communist bloc. I'd be interested to hear of the examples. However, my contention was never that atheism results in inevitable disaster.

I think where the problem arises is that people see the problems religion has caused and say "I know, let's get rid of religion and that will solve the problem". Then they get rid of supernatural beliefs and what do you know, the problem is not solved. So what went wrong?

What went wrong is that the core problem was not supernatural beliefs as such, it was mindless faith in a cult-like belief structure. If you take the Jesus picture off the wall and replace it with a picture of Stalin, and replace the church meetings with Communist Party meetings, and replace the church dogma with Stalinist dogma, you get all the same problems you had with religion.

It's not the fact that the beliefs were supernatural that caused the problems, it's that the mechanisms for controlling people en masse developed by religion work very well, and work equally well for secular cults.
 
Around 1900, it was quite feasible to believe that if society could be established along the lines of materialistic humanism, then all that could be avoided. Well, we found out. A society based on an explicitly atheist ideology managed to do worse things in a shorter time than any of the horrors inspired by religion.
Repeating that stupidity over and over again doesn't make it any less stupid. Nice try, though... oh, wait, no it wasn't. :rolleyes:
 
You're committing a fallacy of composition regardless. Atheism is a minor component of communism, and of other belief systems such as materialistic humanism, Eastern philosophies such as Buddhism, and cults such as Raelism. You cannot equate atheism with the ideologies it is a part of.

Marxism is founded on the philosophical basis of dialectical materialism. (Marx himself used the term historical materialism, but it's the same fundamental concept). It is firmly based on a materialist view of the universe, which is de facto atheistic.

From this springs Marxism, which is an all-inclusive political movement. It has economic, sociological and historical elements, but it's philosophical basis is firmly atheistic.

It's impossible to do anything "in the name of" atheism, or even to found a state "in the name of" atheism. Your argument makes as much sense as if you were to blame Hitler's mustache for the Holocaust.


Perhaps you could address that to the Tibetan nuns beaten to death for their beliefs?

Atheism was not a minor sideline for communist regimes. It was promoted heavily, and religious belief was suppressed.
 
Repeating that stupidity over and over again doesn't make it any less stupid. Nice try, though... oh, wait, no it wasn't. :rolleyes:

Refusing to admit the obvious doesn't make it less obvious. In order to refute something, it's not sufficient to claim that it's been previously refuted.

The idea that communist regimes weren't really communist, or really atheists, is classic No True Scotsman. They certainly thought they were.
 
Refusing to admit the obvious doesn't make it less obvious. In order to refute something, it's not sufficient to claim that it's been previously refuted.

The idea that communist regimes weren't really communist, or really atheists, is classic No True Scotsman. They certainly thought they were.

Right... Even though your silly claim has been refuted successfully tens of thousands of times, since this is a new thread, we must pretend that it has never been refuted before. I guess we should also ignore where it was refuted in this thread are well?I forgot that you've based your entire worldview on a game of pretend, and ignoring facts and reality. My mistake.:jaw-dropp
 
Refusing to admit the obvious doesn't make it less obvious. In order to refute something, it's not sufficient to claim that it's been previously refuted.

The idea that communist regimes weren't really communist, or really atheists, is classic No True Scotsman. They certainly thought they were.

Did you read my last post?

The communist regimes of Stalin and Mao were definitely materialist and atheist, but the reason they caused so much harm was their religion-like mechanisms of control. You can have harmless supernatural beliefs and harmful secular cults like those in the Stalinist USSR or modern North Korea.

The problem is mass indoctrination with stupidity, whether or not the stupidity is tangled up with supernatural beliefs does not appear to make any difference.
 
I don't feel that faith - in a religion, in your country, in authority, whatever - in and of itself is evil. The trouble is how easily it can be exploited by the unscrupulous.

GreyICE said it best:


GreyICE said:
Any unquestioned belief system is dangerous. Why? It makes you easily led.
Except Lucretius Carus, (ca. 99 BC- ca. 55 BC) said it a little earlier: "Tantum religio potuit suadere malorum.

So potent was religion in persuading to evil deeds."
Source: De Rerum Natura

Or even:
"Those who believe absurdities will commit atrocities." - Voltaire
 
Regimes are about the ideas that unite them... not about the things people don't believe in.

You can't have a regime of "non astrologists" forcing "non astrology" on people. It's a meaningless term. Regimes and faith are about belief in ideals or notions without or despite evidence and obeying them because it's "noble" to do so. Dissent is seen as apostasy or treason.

When faith and obedience are the highest "goals", then what someone "believes in" affects their actions...it's their only way to prove their "faith". If someone thinks that faith and obedience affect their ETERNITY, then they are even more compelled to never question the authority handing down the "message" and more compelled to prove their faith

When someone tries to make you feel arrogant for asking questions or questioning authority, it's a strong sign of an authority that needs questioning. The most virulent regimes and religions are lead by men promoting this kind of meme. Why?-- because it works really really well at getting people to work as a team to squelch dissent and forward the goals of the "leaders".
 
Last edited:
Did you read my last post?

The communist regimes of Stalin and Mao were definitely materialist and atheist, but the reason they caused so much harm was their religion-like mechanisms of control. You can have harmless supernatural beliefs and harmful secular cults like those in the Stalinist USSR or modern North Korea.

The problem is mass indoctrination with stupidity, whether or not the stupidity is tangled up with supernatural beliefs does not appear to make any difference.

Or as Bertrand Russell put it:
"The Communist, like the Christian, believes that his doctrine is essential to salvation, and it is this belief which makes salvation possible for him. It is the similarities between Christianity and Communism that make them incompatible with each other.

The most dangerous features of Communism are reminiscent of the medieval Church. They consist of fanatical acceptance of doctrines embodied in a sacred book, unwillingness to examine these doctrines critically, and savage persecution of those who reject them."
--Bertrand Russell, "Can Religion Cure Our Troubles?" (1954)
 
And if a faith is really a strong meme, it will get you to see everything as a sign that the faith is good or right or true while your mind automatically negates and vilifies all info. and people who challenge the faith.

Heck, Mother Theresa's later revealed lack of faith was "proof" that god was testing her. All facts lead to the same conclusion in the mind of the brainwashed... they make the facts fit the truth they've come to believe or they ignore them. Faith-like regimes are self perpetuating brainwashing memes. They exhibit confirmation bias to the extreme degree-- propped up on all sides by believers in the same thing. It is seen as good for the group to expose those who don't have the strongest of allegiance to the group. If you don't see the Emperor's Magical robes, you better damn well pretend you do. And if you do-- it's a sign that you are "special" and "chosen".
 
Last edited:
Except Lucretius Carus, (ca. 99 BC- ca. 55 BC) said it a little earlier: "Tantum religio potuit suadere malorum.

So potent was religion in persuading to evil deeds."
Source: De Rerum Natura

Or even:
"Those who believe absurdities will commit atrocities." - Voltaire

Ooh, now I have a thematically appropriate quote to stick in my sig. Thanks, Gord.
 
The following quotation from the Nobel prize winning physicist Steven Weinberg has become well known too: “With or without [religion] you’d have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, it takes religion.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom