Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
1. You'll notice the difference in scale there. Some less than 50 slaves with semitic names are mentioned. That is a massive difference between that and 2 million leaving Egypt. Among other things because:

So you need a tablet with 2 million semitic names, to accept evidence they lived in egypt ? No kidding.....
 
Actual fine-tuning is hotly debated.

Once again, we could not exist to observe a universe which did not lead to our existence as observers. This fact leads to absolutely no revelations, and does not imply that the universe was made for us, or anything else. To suggest that it does is known as the fallacy of affirming the consequent.
 
So you need a tablet with 2 million semitic names, to accept evidence they lived in egypt ? No kidding.....

Scrolls. The ones using tablets were the Mesopotamians.

Well, anyway, I would want _some_ evidence that there actually were that many. If not a list of names, than something else. I'm quite open there. But I'll still want evidence, not BS.

Especially because, as you might have noticed, the rest of the story fits what we know about 13'th dynasty Egypt like a square peg fits a triangular hole. Which is to say, not at all.

So basically if you want to override the ample evidence contradicting your fairy tale, I'd like to see at least equal evidence for your version. And just a couple of semitic sounding names on just one scroll, just isn't it, you know what I mean?
 
So please explain how science explains the origin and cause of the universe.
So please explain how a so-called explains the origin and cause of the universe anymore then saying a Pink Elephant did it.

Show me how the bible can show one how to do brain surgery, show how a brain works, make a computer, make the internet, and build cars planes rockets. Show me where in the bible it even comes close to showing how the universe has changed over the last 13.7 billion years. How the universe started out with just hydrogen and helium, and over billions of years large stars with many times the mass as the sun have gone supernova and added the heavy elements to the universe. Show me where in the bible that it has changed to show the new discoveries that have been found. Show me where in the bible it shows that just boiling the water would save so many people from diseases. Show me where in the bible where it said any about what diseases really are.

Show me where in the bible that all people are equal, that slavery is evil. That one does not go into any city, town and/or village to kill everyone there to take their land and rape their young women. Please show me.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Once again, we could not exist to observe a universe which did not lead to our existence as observers. This fact leads to absolutely no revelations, and does not imply that the universe was made for us, or anything else. To suggest that it does is known as the fallacy of affirming the consequent.

Repeating yourself doesn't make it any more relevant. Existence is a necessary condition for concluding any event is (im)probable.
 
So please explain how science explains the origin and cause of the universe.
Let's say that science can't and never will be able to explain the origin and cause of the universe. Even if that's true, it's not a proof of god's existence. The inability of science to explain the origin of the universe doesn't logically lead to the conclusion that god did it.
 
Last edited:
Let's say that science can't and never will be able to explain the origin and cause of the universe. Even if thats true, it doesn't automatically prove that god did it.

I find it amazing optimistic to think that humans will ever understand the origin of the Universe. To claim that some bronze-age, nomadic goat-herders got it right in one is beyond silly to me.
 
So please explain how science explains the origin and cause of the universe.


Science appropriately answers: We don't know yet, but we're looking into it.

This is the only appropriate answer!




EDIT: Where do you think our current understanding of the universe would be if science had taken the biblical account as truth from the beginning?
 
Last edited:
Yeah, that joke stopped making sense ten or fifteen years ago.

I first heard that joke about 25 years ago, and it was told specifically about Coors beer - they wanted a new slogan for their marketing campaign, held a contest, the winner submitted the above, the campaign was launched nationally and they brought the winner to Golden, CO to celebrate. Only then did they ask where he got his inspiration for the slogan "Coors beer is like making love in a canoe." Then the punch line.

Anyway, if the joke is told about Coors beer, it's just as valid today as it was in 1984.
 
One of my Belgian friends recently complained that the best brewmeister in the world had left Belgium for the United States. I quickly pointed out that, by that statement, he had admitted that the US had the best brewmeister in the world. He came back, "No, now his cousin is the best brewmeister in the world."
 
the facts shown in my opening thread ARE evidence. If not, please explain, why.
There are no facts in your OP, only assertions. This was explained to you by a number of people on the first page of this thread, but I am willing to retrace some ground for you. Let's look at the Kalam argument once more:

1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its
existence.
2. The universe began to exist.


These are not facts, they are assertions. We do not know that the universe began to exist. Despite popular notions the Big Bang is not currently thought to represent a temporal point dividing an eternity of nothingness from the existence of the universe. As most current models do not postulate that the universe came to be generated from nothing there is no need to explain why such a thing might be possible or how it could have happened.

3. Therefore, the universe has a cause of its
existence. that cause was God.


The huge problem with this conclusion is that sentence that you tacked on at the end. The first conclusion is flawed as it stands because of the fact that it is drawn from premises that are not established as fact. The part about God being that cause is not at all logically justified. Even if we were to grant the premises as stated and conclude that the universe was generated from nothing, or something else, there is nothing to support the conclusion that YHWH, or any other god, must have been the impetus of that generation.
 
Last edited:
Repeating yourself doesn't make it any more relevant. Existence is a necessary condition for concluding any event is (im)probable.

I was hoping that perhaps the reasoning would settle in this time. The probability of us observing a universe which appears to be fine-tuned for our existence is 1. It is not improbable at all. To pretend that it is improbable and then attempt to drawn reasoning from this erroneous conclusion by affirming the consequent is a double breach of logic, both formal and informal.
 
So please explain how science explains the origin and cause of the universe.

By making theories to explain observations and testing them. Unlike theists, who only invent an explanation and stick with it.

Science doesn't have all the answers and maybe it never will. But ignorance is no reason to speculate wildly, and since we've perfected the tools of science we've discovered more than we ever did when we trusted our intuition and gut feelings.

Oh, and theists from other religions "feel" their gods/spirits just as much as you do. How do you reconcile that ?
 
why do you think God is a exception ?

By your own admission. You use "god" to explain the universe because "everything" has a cause, and then remove god from the set of "everything" that has a cause. Why ?

why do you think God is complex ?

An omnipotent being is, by definition, infinitely complex, and is the most complex thing imaginable.

and how does this correlate with the improbatiliy of God's existence ?

The odds are that the "core" of existence is its simplest thing.

the facts shown in my opening thread ARE evidence. If not, please explain, why.

Because saying that something "gives meaning" is not an argument. Basically, you're saying that god gives meaning FOR YOU. But that meaning is neither explained nor does it solve any of our questions because then we must ask what is God, something that is unanswerable because god is, by definition, beyond the reach of our understanding. In other words God is a construct that justifies intellectual laziness by removing the need to understand anything.

So everything coming from nothing. Makes that sense to you ?

Not intuitively, no. But it's not necessarily wrong because of that. And I also never said that something came from nothing. I said "Or maybe it's just part of an endless cycle and nothing created reality, either." How you interpret that as saying that everything comes from nothing amazes me. What I said is that, perhaps, the entire idea of creation is meaningless.

and where is the evidence ? and what caused that bubble of quantum stuff ?

I did say it was an opinion. But let's see...

We can agree that since the universe exists, and since it expands, there was probably a "time" at which it either didn't exist or wasn't the way we see it now. Now, you can claim an infinitely complex intelligent being created it, but that would be a very complex answer that raises more questions than it answers. But, aside from "nothing", the simplest thing that could exist would be a dimensionless (that is, space-less and timeless) and energy-less chaos in which all states are possible and in flux. And since chaos necessarily leads to patterns, however temporary, the universe could be just such a pattern.

This is speculation, but so far the science I've seen seems to lead in a similar direction.
 
Oh, and theists from other religions "feel" their gods/spirits just as much as you do. How do you reconcile that ?

I wrote a short essay on atheism a while back that devoted an entire paragraph to this.

Gate2501 said:
Another popular form of evidence to which theists frequently appeal is subjective experience. I often hear accounts of the faithful "feeling the pressence" of their god. The fact that people who worship a variety of often mutually exclusive deities have all had such experiences automatically disqualifies this as a credible form of evidence, the same can be said for anecdotal evidence. In the absence of any scientific evidence to back up these experiences and anecdotes, we are left with nothing but confirmation bias. This kind of bias also becomes apparent when you consider theists who reject these forms of evidence(anecdotal and subjective experience), when they are not favorable to their own pet god, or gods. This is how the "Flying Spaghetti Monster" business got started. It is an existential claim equivalent in its extraordinary nature to that of most god-beings, yet it is a recent construct, a deliberate parody that we know does not truly exist. This allows us to examine the absurd consequences of applying very weak standards of evidence to an exceptional claim; anyone not suffering from confirmation bias will be forced to concede the existence of all beings, objects, and events of an equally extraordinary nature which could be verified under those same standards.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom