Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
elshamah.heavenforum.com/does-god-exist-origin-of-god-metaphysical-reality-f10/who-is-god-essence-of-god-t79.htm

The phrase "Essence of God" is a theological term used to refer to God's personal characteristics, or to the facets of His personality. Sometimes the term "Attributes of God" is used to refer to God's essence. The "attributes", or the "essence", of God are His primary characteristics, so they cannot be completely communicated to man. They can be described to a degree, but they cannot be fully defined.

Finite man cannot define the infinite. The Bible is the Word of God, and as such it reveals those facts about the Creator that He has seen fit to reveal about Himself.

Man suppose that God thinks like a man. We think God wants revenge, because when we're insulted, we want revenge. When we are cheated, we want immediate justice and retribution. We are indignant and shocked at the behavior of others, so we expect God to be shocked.

But God does not feel insulted. He does not feel cheated - He owns everything. He is not indignant, temperamental, or emotional. He does not throw tantrums (or lightning bolts). He is not surprised or shocked by anything. He is never depressed or moody.

God is not arrogant or egotistical. He knows Himself, is self-assured, and is humble.

God is a rational, logical, stable-minded, patient; and all of His thinking is backed up by His omniscience. And He approaches every issue from the basis of His perfect character, the subject of this study.

God approaches every issue regarding human beings out of His love for all men. His thinking toward man takes all of His attributes into consideration - but Love is always present. It is God's thinking about us, in love, that is His perfect Grace thinking. He is always gracious, always thinks Grace.

Spirituality is one of God's primary attributes. God is immaterial, in a universe that is made up of both material and immaterial. God has revealed something of what He is in the Word, but only He knows Himself fully. We must rely on what is written in the Bible for any understanding of what God is like.

The fact that God is a spiritual being means that He lives. Spirituality implies life. Jer. 10:10 and 1 Th. 1:9 tell us that God is alive and well. The life of God has no beginning and no ending. God is eternal. The Christian shares God's eternal life, but since his eternal life has a beginning at the time he accepted Jesus Christ as Saviour, his eternal life is properly called "everlasting life".

All of the characteristics of the divine essence are present in God at all times, but not all are manifest at the same time, just as while all colors are present in a ray of white light, the individual colors can be seen only under certain conditions of reflection or refraction. Various attributes of God can be seen in certain situations. For example:

* In salvation, God's love and eternal life are apparent.

* In judgment, His righteousness and justice are manifested.

* In God's faithfulness, His immutability and veracity are shown.

* In God's Plan, His omniscience and sovereignty are seen.

* In God's will, sovereignty is paramount.

* In God's revelation, veracity, love, and omniscience are obvious.

The rest of this paper is devoted to a description of the ten characteristics of the Essence of God as seen in the various Bible passages that describe them.

Sorry, but this hardly makes sense, let alone of anything else.
 
Undesired Walrus, you're exactly right. The Big Bang was a very simple event. Lots and lots of energy in a very small space, then the laws of physics (which we're still working on) taking over from there. From that first fraction of a second after it happened, we pretty much have the rest of our existence figured out, no need for a God hypothesis.

So at this point, we have a really freakin' humongous appearance of energy, but otherwise fairly simple to explain. But if you assume there was a God who caused it, you have to not just explain the fairly simple appearance of energy; you have to explain how an extremely complex, intelligent, infinitely powerful sentient being came into existence. If those are the only two choices, there's no contest which is preferable - one is way way way way way simpler than the other.

Besides, it's so much more exciting to say "We don't know" (Which is what humble people must say) rather than "The Christian God who answers prayers, forgives sins, invents heaven and hell, hates homosexuals, dislikes alcohol abuse did it".
 
You say that as if it was a factual occurrence. The exodus of the Jews from Egypt is every bit as mythical as the story about Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden. No serious archaeologists believe it actually happened. There is a huge empty place where we would expect to find tons of evidence of the Exodus, and all the positive evidence we do have conclusively shows that the Jews were indigenous to the area of Judea.

despite what you think, there IS evidence of exodus.

ensignmessage.com/archives/exodusscptcs.html

Rohl’s biggest discovery, though, was in finding the evidence for the Exodus in the Thirteenth Dynasty. His findings are summarized by John Fulton, a supporter of David Rohl:

‘Before Moses, the Bible records that the Israelites were enslaved by their Egyptian hosts (Exodus 1:8-14). In the Brooklyn Museum (p.276, fig. 310) resides a papyrus scroll numbered Brooklyn 35:1446 which was acquired in the late 19th century by Charles Wilbour. This dates to the reign of Sobekhotep III, the predecessor of Neferhotep I and so the pharaoh who reigned one generation before Moses. This papyrus is a decree by the pharaoh for a transfer of slaves. Of the 95 names of slaves mentioned in the letter, 50% are Semitic in origin. What is more, it lists the names of these slaves in the original Semitic language and then adds the Egyptian name each had been assigned, which is something the Bible records the Egyptians as doing, cf. Joseph’s name given to him by pharaoh (Genesis 41:45). Some of the Semitic names are biblical and include:- Menahem, Issachar, Asher, and Shiprah (cf. Exodus 1:15-21).
 
despite what you think, there IS evidence of exodus.

ensignmessage.com/archives/exodusscptcs.html

Rohl’s biggest discovery, though, was in finding the evidence for the Exodus in the Thirteenth Dynasty. His findings are summarized by John Fulton, a supporter of David Rohl:

‘Before Moses, the Bible records that the Israelites were enslaved by their Egyptian hosts (Exodus 1:8-14). In the Brooklyn Museum (p.276, fig. 310) resides a papyrus scroll numbered Brooklyn 35:1446 which was acquired in the late 19th century by Charles Wilbour. This dates to the reign of Sobekhotep III, the predecessor of Neferhotep I and so the pharaoh who reigned one generation before Moses. This papyrus is a decree by the pharaoh for a transfer of slaves. Of the 95 names of slaves mentioned in the letter, 50% are Semitic in origin. What is more, it lists the names of these slaves in the original Semitic language and then adds the Egyptian name each had been assigned, which is something the Bible records the Egyptians as doing, cf. Joseph’s name given to him by pharaoh (Genesis 41:45). Some of the Semitic names are biblical and include:- Menahem, Issachar, Asher, and Shiprah (cf. Exodus 1:15-21).

David Rohls claims are pseudo history and have not found widespread acceptance outside the usual pseudo science circles, that you have to rely on pseudo science speaks volumes, that you have been unable to answer any of my questions says a lot more
:rolleyes:

the bible itself claims that there were 2 million slaves who left during the exodus, science tells us that this is approximately 1/5 of the world population at the time, the bible is therefore wrong as it states an impossibility and if its wrong there...............
 
Last edited:
despite what you think, there IS evidence of exodus.

ensignmessage.com/archives/exodusscptcs.html

Rohl’s biggest discovery, though, was in finding the evidence for the Exodus in the Thirteenth Dynasty. His findings are summarized by John Fulton, a supporter of David Rohl:

‘Before Moses, the Bible records that the Israelites were enslaved by their Egyptian hosts (Exodus 1:8-14). In the Brooklyn Museum (p.276, fig. 310) resides a papyrus scroll numbered Brooklyn 35:1446 which was acquired in the late 19th century by Charles Wilbour. This dates to the reign of Sobekhotep III, the predecessor of Neferhotep I and so the pharaoh who reigned one generation before Moses. This papyrus is a decree by the pharaoh for a transfer of slaves. Of the 95 names of slaves mentioned in the letter, 50% are Semitic in origin. What is more, it lists the names of these slaves in the original Semitic language and then adds the Egyptian name each had been assigned, which is something the Bible records the Egyptians as doing, cf. Joseph’s name given to him by pharaoh (Genesis 41:45). Some of the Semitic names are biblical and include:- Menahem, Issachar, Asher, and Shiprah (cf. Exodus 1:15-21).

I hope you don't try to use that level of scholarship in a history class. You'd have evidence for the crucifixion if you tried.
 
...
Man suppose that God thinks like a man. We think God wants revenge, because when we're insulted, we want revenge. When we are cheated, we want immediate justice and retribution. We are indignant and shocked at the behavior of others, so we expect God to be shocked.
... (endless gibberish)


If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck...

God apparently revealed himself to be easily insulted, vengeful, etc. Who are we to go adding interpretations about how he's not really like that? I think that's a bit of a sin on your part, my good man.
 
Or you could go here for a full list of these kinds of arguments, and there are hundreds of arguments listed here:

http://www.godlessgeeks.com/LINKS/GodProof.htm

Examples:

ARGUMENT FROM BEAUTY, a.k.a. DESIGN/TELEOLOGICAL ARGUMENT (II)
(1) Isn't that baby/sunset/flower/tree beautiful?
(2) Only God could have made them so beautiful.
(3) Therefore, God exists.

MORAL ARGUMENT (I)
(1) Person X, a well-known atheist, was morally inferior to the rest of us.
(2) Therefore, God exists.

MORAL ARGUMENT (II)
(1) In my younger days I was a cursing, drinking, smoking, gambling, child-molesting, thieving, murdering, bed-wetting bastard.
(2) That all changed once I became religious.
(3) Therefore, God exists.

DORE'S ARGUMENT
(1) I forgot to take my meds.
(2) Therefore, I AM CHRIST!!
(3) Therefore, God exists.

ARGUMENT FROM GUITAR MASTERY
(1) Eric Clapton is God.
(2) Therefore, God exists.

ARGUMENT FROM INCOMPREHENSIBILITY
(1) Flabble glurk zoom boink blubba snurgleschnortz ping!
(2) No one has ever refuted (1).
(3) Therefore, God exists.

But my all time favorite argument is:

ARGUMENT FROM ABSURDITY
(1) Maranathra!
(2) Therefore, God exists.
 
despite what you think, there IS evidence of exodus.

ensignmessage.com/archives/exodusscptcs.html

Rohl’s biggest discovery, though, was in finding the evidence for the Exodus in the Thirteenth Dynasty. His findings are summarized by John Fulton, a supporter of David Rohl:

‘Before Moses, the Bible records that the Israelites were enslaved by their Egyptian hosts (Exodus 1:8-14). In the Brooklyn Museum (p.276, fig. 310) resides a papyrus scroll numbered Brooklyn 35:1446 which was acquired in the late 19th century by Charles Wilbour. This dates to the reign of Sobekhotep III, the predecessor of Neferhotep I and so the pharaoh who reigned one generation before Moses. This papyrus is a decree by the pharaoh for a transfer of slaves. Of the 95 names of slaves mentioned in the letter, 50% are Semitic in origin. What is more, it lists the names of these slaves in the original Semitic language and then adds the Egyptian name each had been assigned, which is something the Bible records the Egyptians as doing, cf. Joseph’s name given to him by pharaoh (Genesis 41:45). Some of the Semitic names are biblical and include:- Menahem, Issachar, Asher, and Shiprah (cf. Exodus 1:15-21).

1. You'll notice the difference in scale there. Some less than 50 slaves with semitic names are mentioned. That is a massive difference between that and 2 million leaving Egypt. Among other things because:

2. The 13'th Dynasty (to which Sobekhotep III belongs) is before the Hyskos invasion. Egypt was as much bottled in by the desert as it was protected from the outside from it. That a few slaves would be brought in by caravans or by boat, sure, it's possible. (Egypt had a trade with Mesopotamia since pre-dynastic times.) But nobody had yet the technology to wage a war across the desert. So the notion that they would enslave some 2 million people from across the desert is underpants-on-the-head pencils-up-the-nose stupid. More importantly:

3. There is no evidence of such warfare or even the armies to do it in Egypt at the time. And even more importantly:

4. The armies of Egypt even at the time of the Hyskos invasion were thoroughly obsolete. (And we're a bit before it at this time.) If Egypt were to somehow manage to magically teleport its armies across the desert and wage war to enslave those Hebrews, Egypt would have gotten thoroughly spanked. As they will soon be by the Hyskos.

Egypt's army was that bad, that the Hyskos pretty much rolled over them.

Almost funnily, Egypt's army and equipment at the time they got invaded, weren't even up to what's recorded about the war between Lagash and Umma. Egypt's army was over 1000 years out of date, compared to its eastern "neighbours". Its only saving grace was that there was a desert between it and those neighbours, or they'd have been toast.

The notion that _that_ Egyptian army would actually attack those neighbours and enslave some two millions of them, is on par with 9/11 conspiracies for sheer stonking stupidity.

5. Exodus also mentions being chased by Egyptian chariots. Egypt didn't actually have any, nor horses for that matter, until the Hyskos brought those. That's one reason why the Hyskos just rolled over the obsolete Egyptian infantry.

If Neferhotep I and the Pharaohs after him had had any chariots, or even enough army to pose any threat to a migrating band of 2 millions (even of civillians with sticks), Egypt could have saved itself from the Hyskos. Which, again, it didn't.

The first mention of the Egyptian army actually using horses is in the wars to free itself from the Hyskos, in the 17'th dynasty. So giving them to a 13'th dynasty Pharaoh is just stupid even by the standards of the pseudo-archaeology used to try to prop up the Bible.

Even the earliest skeletons of horses found in Egypt (at this point, probably still belonging to the Hyskos) are from about a century after Sobekhotep III.

6. "Semitic" names doesn't equal "Hebrew." The whole group of languages derived from Akkadian, including Babylonian, Hebrew, Phoenician, etc, were semitic and would have semitic names. There's a vast teritory out there from which such slaves could be bought (but again, in tiny numbers) or brought in by their immigrating masters. (Egypt had a steady immigration, though not yet comparable with the massive immigration wave that would come later.)

From the slightly over 40 slaves mentioned there with semitic names, realistically you'd be lucky if 2-3 were even from the region that would later become the Hebrew kingdoms. If any.

ETA:

7. The only places within reach of the Egyptian army at the time, were by sea. (And again, never mind that the army was obsolete and tiny and there's no evidence of such warfare.) And how even the later attempted invasions of the Sea People, during the 19'th and 20'th dynasties, proved: the tech level just wasn't yet up to snuff to haul and supply a large army by sea.

But there's an even more perverse issue there: even theoretically, they could only haul and supply an army in that eastern part if it was basically on the shore. Everything else was out of their reach the hard way. And the area of the latter Hebrew kingdoms simply wasn't by the sea.
 
Last edited:
Sure. What is not rational about my argument ?

The appearance of the universe has a meta-physical origin anyway, with , or without a efficient cause. If God is not the cause of the universe, what else would you suggest ?


I would suggest you and I use the following sentence when asked this question.

I dont know.
 
1. You'll notice the difference in scale there. Some less than 50 slaves with semitic names are mentioned. That is a massive difference between that and 2 million leaving Egypt. Among other things because:

2. The 13'th Dynasty (to which Sobekhotep III belongs) is before the Hyskos invasion. Egypt was as much bottled in by the desert as it was protected from the outside from it. That a few slaves would be brought in by caravans or by boat, sure, it's possible. (Egypt had a trade with Mesopotamia since pre-dynastic times.) But nobody had yet the technology to wage a war across the desert. So the notion that they would enslave some 2 million people from across the desert is underpants-on-the-head pencils-up-the-nose stupid. More importantly:

3. There is no evidence of such warfare or even the armies to do it in Egypt at the time. And even more importantly:

4. The armies of Egypt even at the time of the Hyskos invasion were thoroughly obsolete. (And we're a bit before it at this time.) If Egypt were to somehow manage to magically teleport its armies across the desert and wage war to enslave those Hebrews, Egypt would have gotten thoroughly spanked. As they will soon be by the Hyskos.

Egypt's army was that bad, that the Hyskos pretty much rolled over them.

Almost funnily, Egypt's army and equipment at the time they got invaded, weren't even up to what's recorded about the war between Lagash and Umma. Egypt's army was over 1000 years out of date, compared to its eastern "neighbours". Its only saving grace was that there was a desert between it and those neighbours, or they'd have been toast.

The notion that _that_ Egyptian army would actually attack those neighbours and enslave some two millions of them, is on par with 9/11 conspiracies for sheer stonking stupidity.

5. Exodus also mentions being chased by Egyptian chariots. Egypt didn't actually have any, nor horses for that matter, until the Hyskos brought those. That's one reason why the Hyskos just rolled over the obsolete Egyptian infantry.

If Neferhotep I and the Pharaohs after him had had any chariots, or even enough army to pose any threat to a migrating band of 2 millions (even of civillians with sticks), Egypt could have saved itself from the Hyskos. Which, again, it didn't.

The first mention of the Egyptian army actually using horses is in the wars to free itself from the Hyskos, in the 17'th dynasty. So giving them to a 13'th dynasty Pharaoh is just stupid even by the standards of the pseudo-archaeology used to try to prop up the Bible.

Even the earliest skeletons of horses found in Egypt (at this point, probably still belonging to the Hyskos) are from about a century after Sobekhotep III.

6. "Semitic" names doesn't equal "Hebrew." The whole group of languages derived from Akkadian, including Babylonian, Hebrew, Phoenician, etc, were semitic and would have semitic names. There's a vast teritory out there from which such slaves could be bought (but again, in tiny numbers) or brought in by their immigrating masters. (Egypt had a steady immigration, though not yet comparable with the massive immigration wave that would come later.)

From the slightly over 40 slaves mentioned there with semitic names, realistically you'd be lucky if 2-3 were even from the region that would later become the Hebrew kingdoms. If any.

ETA:

7. The only places within reach of the Egyptian army at the time, were by sea. (And again, never mind that the army was obsolete and tiny and there's no evidence of such warfare.) And how even the later attempted invasions of the Sea People, during the 19'th and 20'th dynasties, proved: the tech level just wasn't yet up to snuff to haul and supply a large army by sea.

But there's an even more perverse issue there: even theoretically, they could only haul and supply an army in that eastern part if it was basically on the shore. Everything else was out of their reach the hard way. And the area of the latter Hebrew kingdoms simply wasn't by the sea.

Didn't I just tell him to listen to the words of Saint Augustine? QED :jaw-dropp
 
1. You'll notice the difference in scale there. Some less than 50 slaves with semitic names are mentioned. That is a massive difference between that and 2 million leaving Egypt. Among other things because:

2. The 13'th Dynasty (to which Sobekhotep III belongs) is before the Hyskos invasion. Egypt was as much bottled in by the desert as it was protected from the outside from it. That a few slaves would be brought in by caravans or by boat, sure, it's possible. (Egypt had a trade with Mesopotamia since pre-dynastic times.) But nobody had yet the technology to wage a war across the desert. So the notion that they would enslave some 2 million people from across the desert is underpants-on-the-head pencils-up-the-nose stupid. More importantly:

3. There is no evidence of such warfare or even the armies to do it in Egypt at the time. And even more importantly:

4. The armies of Egypt even at the time of the Hyskos invasion were thoroughly obsolete. (And we're a bit before it at this time.) If Egypt were to somehow manage to magically teleport its armies across the desert and wage war to enslave those Hebrews, Egypt would have gotten thoroughly spanked. As they will soon be by the Hyskos.

Egypt's army was that bad, that the Hyskos pretty much rolled over them.

Almost funnily, Egypt's army and equipment at the time they got invaded, weren't even up to what's recorded about the war between Lagash and Umma. Egypt's army was over 1000 years out of date, compared to its eastern "neighbours". Its only saving grace was that there was a desert between it and those neighbours, or they'd have been toast.

The notion that _that_ Egyptian army would actually attack those neighbours and enslave some two millions of them, is on par with 9/11 conspiracies for sheer stonking stupidity.

5. Exodus also mentions being chased by Egyptian chariots. Egypt didn't actually have any, nor horses for that matter, until the Hyskos brought those. That's one reason why the Hyskos just rolled over the obsolete Egyptian infantry.

If Neferhotep I and the Pharaohs after him had had any chariots, or even enough army to pose any threat to a migrating band of 2 millions (even of civillians with sticks), Egypt could have saved itself from the Hyskos. Which, again, it didn't.

The first mention of the Egyptian army actually using horses is in the wars to free itself from the Hyskos, in the 17'th dynasty. So giving them to a 13'th dynasty Pharaoh is just stupid even by the standards of the pseudo-archaeology used to try to prop up the Bible.

Even the earliest skeletons of horses found in Egypt (at this point, probably still belonging to the Hyskos) are from about a century after Sobekhotep III.

6. "Semitic" names doesn't equal "Hebrew." The whole group of languages derived from Akkadian, including Babylonian, Hebrew, Phoenician, etc, were semitic and would have semitic names. There's a vast teritory out there from which such slaves could be bought (but again, in tiny numbers) or brought in by their immigrating masters. (Egypt had a steady immigration, though not yet comparable with the massive immigration wave that would come later.)

From the slightly over 40 slaves mentioned there with semitic names, realistically you'd be lucky if 2-3 were even from the region that would later become the Hebrew kingdoms. If any.

ETA:

7. The only places within reach of the Egyptian army at the time, were by sea. (And again, never mind that the army was obsolete and tiny and there's no evidence of such warfare.) And how even the later attempted invasions of the Sea People, during the 19'th and 20'th dynasties, proved: the tech level just wasn't yet up to snuff to haul and supply a large army by sea.

But there's an even more perverse issue there: even theoretically, they could only haul and supply an army in that eastern part if it was basically on the shore. Everything else was out of their reach the hard way. And the area of the latter Hebrew kingdoms simply wasn't by the sea.


This is the "E" of JREF. Thank you, Hans. I have a feeling the poster you were attempting to educate will not listen, but I hope you take a little bit of satisfaction knowing at least one long-time lurker did.
 
I think that it was actually Methuselah who "died in the flood", and not Adam.

[off topic] Didn't some early Jewish writings, when using Bishop Ussher's dateline technique actually "prove" that Methuselah actually lived on after the flood, and have to get altered to fit the "correct" timeline" - that he really dies during the flood (or perhaps have a heart attack the day before it started - after all he was 969.

- very vague memory of reading this soomewhere -

[/off topic]

Norm
.
The poor schlumpf on AIG failed to use his own chronology to finger out exactly what the consequences of it would be. I just took his numbers and pointed out the problem with Noah's abandoning the number 1 human during the flood.
They were irritated also when I pointed out in the LA Times that there were physical problems with those pre-Fall herbivores suddenly becoming carnivores, with the serious problems in dentition and digestive system carnivoring needs to be successful.
 
Last edited:
Man suppose that God thinks like a man. We think God wants revenge, because when we're insulted, we want revenge. When we are cheated, we want immediate justice and retribution. We are indignant and shocked at the behavior of others, so we expect God to be shocked.

But God does not feel insulted. He does not feel cheated - He owns everything. He is not indignant, temperamental, or emotional. He does not throw tantrums (or lightning bolts). He is not surprised or shocked by anything. He is never depressed or moody.

God is not arrogant or egotistical. He knows Himself, is self-assured, and is humble.

God is a rational, logical, stable-minded, patient; and all of His thinking is backed up by His omniscience. And He approaches every issue from the basis of His perfect character, the subject of this study.

Which Bible have you been reading? The God of the Bible is petty, vain, jealous, sadistic, xenophobic, vengeful and just plain mean.

Before you take this thread any further, I suggest you read this. The guy who started that thread talks a lot about evidence too.
 
Really havign a god as first mover make no sense, as you only shifted the origin one step, now you have to POSIT god is eternal or you are in the conendary to have to explain god creation. And if you posit any stuff, then why not jsut posit there was nothing before the universe sprang into existence.

As for the fine tuning argument, I am sorry but WHICH universe is fine tuned ??? Without technology most of the earth surface is either downright hostile to human life, or only passable. And the earth is what percentage of the surface of the solar system ? 0.000000001% ? Less ? Not even counting the rest of the universe , I don't see fine tuning I see imperfection of our body and an utter waste of space (in an extremly hostile universe).


Those are argumentn for gods existence only if you already posit it exists. If you do not, then the argument lead to no conclusion.

The fine-tuning argument isn't concerned with just human life. For any life at all to develop, physical constants have to have very precise values (unless you want to postulate the existence of non-molecular life, non-stellar life, or some other exotic life form that contradicts everything we know of biology). Apparent fine-tuning is almost universally accepted. Actual fine-tuning is hotly debated.
 
(off topic)


[qupte=Gawdzilla]
Just avoid American beer, it's like making love in a canoe.
(off topic)
That's funny, I had a Belgian friend in grad school who said this fairly often. However, I think this is less true. There are some very good microbrews in the US. I have had a lot of good ones from Maine. Cadillac Mountain Stout is very good but only available in Maine and primarily around Bar Harbor.
(/off topic) [/QUOTE]

Yeah, that joke stopped making sense ten or fifteen years ago.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom