Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
I notice Zsa Zsa Gibhor ;) has not answered my points. I wonder why.

for the same reason that he has ignored mine, and for the same reason that none of the "faithful" posted in this thread
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=152198&highlight=mesopotamian
because they daren't read the facts and are too indoctrinated to understand that there are any.

seems to me anyway that those christians who attempt to prove evidence for God are demonstrating that they have no faith in his existence without it, according to their own rules this means that they're gonna buuuuuuuurn
:degrin:
 
Last edited:
.
The ass-kicking you describe could just be basis of the victimization/divine intervention myth.
Nice.

Well, given almost a thousand years, all sorts of distortions can happen.

E.g., a simple "hah, at least we gave them a final battle where probably every family in Egypt had lost a relative" could become some elaborate divine intervention act. And it wouldn't be far from the truth. Even two consecutive Upper Egypt pharaohs had died in battle with the Hyskos in that war. And at least one queen (Ahhotep I) was buried with military equipment and decorations in that war too. Apparently she actually took command on the front when her husband was felled.

E.g., giving ample thanks to God when the great Egyptian army gave up after they razed Sharuhen, could become distorted in some great act of divine intervention that destroyed the Pharaoh's army. (Note that it took much less time to get a lifted siege of Jerusalem turned into "an angel slaughtered them all", when in fact the king had paid a hefty tribute and had given his daughters hostage to keep his head attached to his shoulders.) In reality, likely Egypt was exhausted by the long war to free itself, and the following 3 years long campaign across the desert probably was all that Ahmose could afford.

E.g., _if_ the evicted Hyskos would take over Canaan, it's not hard to imagine that a lot of people would try to align and identify themeselves with the ruling class and its history. Hundreds of years later, millions of people would imagine themselves to have come from Egypt too, although probably a _much_ smaller number could trace their ancestry to anyone who had ever been in Egypt.

But, of course, all that's historical fiction, so don't take that as fact or anything. We don't actually _know_ what became of the Hyskos. From the Egyptian point of view, they just disappeared from history after the end of that campaign. Maybe simply the last of the Hyskos were killed at Sharuhen. Or maybe they just disappeared because they were no longer "lords" of anything. Or whatever. We don't know.

But I like to think it makes an interesting "what if" fiction scenario. Would make a nice Hollywood or computer game script. Sorta, "Knights Of The Old Kingdom: The Seth Lords" ;)
 
Last edited:
I followed one of the papers there some years back, which when all was untangled, "proved" that Adam drowned in the Flood!
Maffematically done, it were!
Drat that Noah, leaving his kin behind!


If you just compare Genesis 5:5 to Genesis 7:6, that seems to work out, but if you take the time to add up the years between, it doesn't.
Genesis said:
005:005 All the days that Adam lived were nine hundred thirty years,
then he died.

005:003 Adam lived one hundred thirty years, and became the father of a
son in his own likeness, after his image, and named him Seth.
005:004 The days of Adam after he became the father of Seth were eight
hundred years, and he became the father of sons and daughters.
005:005 All the days that Adam lived were nine hundred thirty years,
then he died.
005:006 Seth lived one hundred five years, and became the father of Enosh.
005:007 Seth lived after he became the father of Enosh eight hundred
seven years, and became the father of sons and daughters.
005:008 All the days of Seth were nine hundred twelve years,
then he died.
005:009 Enosh lived ninety years, and became the father of Kenan.
005:010 Enosh lived after he became the father of Kenan, eight hundred
fifteen years, and became the father of sons and daughters.
005:011 All the days of Enosh were nine hundred five years, then he died.
005:012 Kenan lived seventy years, and became the father of Mahalalel.
005:013 Kenan lived after he became the father of Mahalalel eight hundred
forty years, and became the father of sons and daughters
005:014 and all the days of Kenan were nine hundred ten years,
then he died.
005:015 Mahalalel lived sixty-five years, and became the father of Jared.
005:016 Mahalalel lived after he became the father of Jared eight hundred
thirty years, and became the father of sons and daughters.
005:017 All the days of Mahalalel were eight hundred ninety-five years,
then he died.
005:018 Jared lived one hundred sixty-two years, and became
the father of Enoch.
005:019 Jared lived after he became the father of Enoch eight hundred years,
and became the father of sons and daughters.
005:020 All the days of Jared were nine hundred sixty-two years,
then he died.
005:021 Enoch lived sixty-five years, and became the father of Methuselah.
005:022 Enoch walked with God after he became the father of Methuselah
three hundred years, and became the father of sons and daughters.
005:023 All the days of Enoch were three hundred sixty-five years.
005:024 Enoch walked with God, and he was not, for God took him.
005:025 Methuselah lived one hundred eighty-seven years, and became
the father of Lamech.
005:026 Methuselah lived after he became the father of Lamech seven hundred
eighty-two years, and became the father of sons and daughters.
005:027 All the days of Methuselah were nine hundred sixty-nine years,
then he died.
005:028 Lamech lived one hundred eighty-two years, and became the father
of a son,
005:029 and he named him Noah, saying, "This same will comfort us
in our work and in the toil of our hands, because of the ground
which Yahweh has cursed."
Genesis said:
007:006 Noah was six hundred years old when the flood of waters came
on the earth.

On the other hand, it does say that Methuselah (Noah's grandfather) lived to the age of 969 years old, and if you add up the dates, the flood came when Methuselah was 969 years old.
 
Science appropriately answers: We don't know yet, but we're looking into it.

This is the only appropriate answer!




EDIT: Where do you think our current understanding of the universe would be if science had taken the biblical account as truth from the beginning?

We'd still be huddling in caves in fear of the lightning because the 'holy man' screams that it is because god is angry at us.

'I don't know, but we're going to try and find out!' is the best answer in existence.
 
If you just compare Genesis 5:5 to Genesis 7:6, that seems to work out, but if you take the time to add up the years between, it doesn't.


005:003 Adam lived one hundred thirty years, and became the father of a
son in his own likeness, after his image, and named him Seth.
005:004 The days of Adam after he became the father of Seth were eight
hundred years, and he became the father of sons and daughters.
005:005 All the days that Adam lived were nine hundred thirty years,
then he died.
005:006 Seth lived one hundred five years, and became the father of Enosh.
005:007 Seth lived after he became the father of Enosh eight hundred
seven years, and became the father of sons and daughters.
005:008 All the days of Seth were nine hundred twelve years,
then he died.
005:009 Enosh lived ninety years, and became the father of Kenan.
005:010 Enosh lived after he became the father of Kenan, eight hundred
fifteen years, and became the father of sons and daughters.
005:011 All the days of Enosh were nine hundred five years, then he died.
005:012 Kenan lived seventy years, and became the father of Mahalalel.
005:013 Kenan lived after he became the father of Mahalalel eight hundred
forty years, and became the father of sons and daughters
005:014 and all the days of Kenan were nine hundred ten years,
then he died.
005:015 Mahalalel lived sixty-five years, and became the father of Jared.
005:016 Mahalalel lived after he became the father of Jared eight hundred
thirty years, and became the father of sons and daughters.
005:017 All the days of Mahalalel were eight hundred ninety-five years,
then he died.
005:018 Jared lived one hundred sixty-two years, and became
the father of Enoch.
005:019 Jared lived after he became the father of Enoch eight hundred years,
and became the father of sons and daughters.
005:020 All the days of Jared were nine hundred sixty-two years,
then he died.
005:021 Enoch lived sixty-five years, and became the father of Methuselah.
005:022 Enoch walked with God after he became the father of Methuselah
three hundred years, and became the father of sons and daughters.
005:023 All the days of Enoch were three hundred sixty-five years.
005:024 Enoch walked with God, and he was not, for God took him.
005:025 Methuselah lived one hundred eighty-seven years, and became
the father of Lamech.
005:026 Methuselah lived after he became the father of Lamech seven hundred
eighty-two years, and became the father of sons and daughters.
005:027 All the days of Methuselah were nine hundred sixty-nine years,
then he died.
005:028 Lamech lived one hundred eighty-two years, and became the father
of a son,
005:029 and he named him Noah, saying, "This same will comfort us
in our work and in the toil of our hands, because of the ground
which Yahweh has cursed."


On the other hand, it does say that Methuselah (Noah's grandfather) lived to the age of 969 years old, and if you add up the dates, the flood came when Methuselah was 969 years old.

is there any doubt here that the ages of the Patriarchs are based on the kings of kish ?
 
.
This might help as well:


[qimg]http://img192.imageshack.us/img192/8672/circularlogic.jpg[/qimg]


How about these... ?

0003.png


265734b27d7815cfd7.gif

​

is there any doubt here that the ages of the Patriarchs are based on the kings of kish ?

I'd never herd of the Kings of Kish before, but after a quick web-search, it certainly seems plausible that they could have been a strong influence on the text.
 
Last edited:
If you just compare Genesis 5:5 to Genesis 7:6, that seems to work out, but if you take the time to add up the years between, it doesn't.
...
On the other hand, it does say that Methuselah (Noah's grandfather) lived to the age of 969 years old, and if you add up the dates, the flood came when Methuselah was 969 years old.
.
As I recall, the guy was doing some odd math to prove that all of it in the book was inerrant, and just using his numbers, got Noah almost as old if not older than Adam.
When they delve into logic and science, they always fail to detect the logical problems and impossibilities of their faith-based reasoning.
 
1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its existence.
2. The universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the universe has a cause of its existence. that cause was God.


1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its existence.
2. The universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the universe has a cause of its existence. That cause was a time-traveller from the future called Zortron who created a worm-hole type time-tunnel called a Time Wheel that transported him to the beginning of time. His other major invention was an Existence Discombobulator that removed his katra from the natural world, allowing him to exist in reality without time. He used special ocular implants to shoot creation-lasers from his eyes to create the universe. He then travelled forward in time to tell himself that all these things must come to pass, thereby creating a causal loop from which the entire universe makes sense and infinite regression is finally solved. The past comes from the future and the future from the past simultaneously.


Please provide evidence that this story is less likely than your God-figure.
 
Last edited:
1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its existence.
2. The universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the universe has a cause of its existence. That cause was a time-traveller from the future called Zortron who created a worm-hole type time-tunnel called a Time Wheel that transported him to the beginning of time. His other major invention was an Existence Discombobulator that removed his katra from the natural world, allowing him to exist in reality without time. He used special ocular implants to shoot creation-lasers from his eyes to create the universe. He then travelled forward in time to tell himself that all these things must come to pass, thereby creating a causal loop from which the entire universe makes sense and infinite regression is finally solved. The past comes from the future and the future from the past simultaneously.


Please provide evidence that this story is less likely than your God-figure.

Sad thing is, it's actually more likely than the god-figure. It avoids the whole need for special pleading or infinite regression.
 
Sad thing is, it's actually more likely than the god-figure. It avoids the whole need for special pleading or infinite regression.


And if it were written in a millennia-old holy book, it would be defended just as vigorously as the Judeo-Christian religions.
 
How about these... ?

[qimg]http://www.atheistguidebook.org/theologan/comics/0003.png[/qimg]

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/265734b27d7815cfd7.gif[/qimg]
​
.
HAHA! I like those too. I especially liked the second one - the one with Alice.
 
Why must every thread in the JREF Forum turn into a science discussion?

This is the Religion and Philosophy section. If God "makes sense" according to one's philosophy, it hardly makes sense to cite scientific evidence as an argument against that.


Though, I for one, would like to know what some of these "objective moral values" are.

And, how can "God can be immediately known and experienced"? Some of the lines I will grant to a believer. But, this claim seems to diminish faith as some sort of delusion.
 
Why must every thread in the JREF Forum turn into a science discussion?

This is the Religion and Philosophy section. If God "makes sense" according to one's philosophy, it hardly makes sense to cite scientific evidence as an argument against that.

If we could keep the flag-wavers out of the Science forum we probably wouldn't be over here very much at all.
 
Why must every thread in the JREF Forum turn into a science discussion?

This is the Religion and Philosophy section. If God "makes sense" according to one's philosophy, it hardly makes sense to cite scientific evidence as an argument against that.

If you go into a church and pass out a survey asking if they feel their god exists, think their god exists, or know their god exists, you know very well what the majority answer will be. So while religion is a philosophy topic, it is separate, not just because it is more easily categorized that way, but because of the way it is treated by its adherents. Because of that, science comes up to show the religious that their religion is merely a philosophy and not factually true, as they would like to (also) believe.

And of course, it comes up because they often bring it up, as has happened here, by those whose faith is not so well developed that they're willing to believe despite the overwhelming lack of evidence in its favor.

So it makes perfect sense to cite scientific as an argument against that.
 
Why must every thread in the JREF Forum turn into a science discussion?

This is the Religion and Philosophy section. If God "makes sense" according to one's philosophy, it hardly makes sense to cite scientific evidence as an argument against that.


Though, I for one, would like to know what some of these "objective moral values" are.

And, how can "God can be immediately known and experienced"? Some of the lines I will grant to a believer. But, this claim seems to diminish faith as some sort of delusion.

Umm, so, in a talk about the origins of the universe, and when asked what other explanation than God makes sense of it... you can't see why science entered the thread? :p
 
Because, again, you are applying laws which only apply within the universe to the universe itself. Outside the universe, the laws which say that something can't come from nothing do not necessarily apply.

Of course they do. From absolutely no thing, any thing, ever, will arise, inside, or outside of our universe makes no difference whatsoever.


No, it isn't. Because if everything has to have a cause, then there cannot be an eternal being, because an eternal being does not have a cause. If there is an eternal being, then not everything has to have a cause, and you are committing the special pleading fallacy.

Everything that had a beginning, must have a cause, i.e. our universe.
Since God had no beginning, he needs no cause.


All of this, besides being bare assertion, is still the special pleading fallacy. If your god did not need a creator, then not everything needs a creator, and you are committing the special pleading fallacy to insert him for no reason. If everything needs a cause, then he needs a cause.
Your argument contradicts itself.

No special pleading here. Whatever was the cause of the universe, it was meta-physical. You can choose between a efficient cause ( God ) or a inefficient one ( nothing ). what makes more sense to you ?
 
Of course they do. From absolutely no thing, any thing, ever, will arise, inside, or outside of our universe makes no difference whatsoever.

But it does. We can't show that the laws that apply inside our universe apply outside. To declare that they do is the bare assertion fallacy, and it is upon this fallacy that your argument rests.

Everything that had a beginning, must have a cause, i.e. our universe.
Since God had no beginning, he needs no cause.

Let me try to explain this again.

If everything needs a cause, then everything needs a cause. Including your god. If everything needs a cause, then there can be no eternal beings, since an eternal being would not need a cause. Therefore, if everything needs a cause, there would be an infinite regression of causes.
If your god does exist, then, he does not have a cause. If he does not have a cause, then not everything needs a cause, and you have committed the special pleading fallacy by saying that your god created the universe rather than the universe just coming into being.
The only solution which avoids fallacies entirely is:

- Not everything needs a cause.
- The universe has no cause.

This is fallacy-free because, outside the universe, there is no need for cause-effect relations. You saying that there is does not make it true.

No special pleading here. Whatever was the cause of the universe, it was meta-physical. You can choose between a efficient cause ( God ) or a inefficient one ( nothing ). what makes more sense to you ?

Nothing. Your insertion of god is both an unnecessary complication and the special pleading fallacy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom