Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
The fine-tuning argument isn't concerned with just human life. For any life at all to develop, physical constants have to have very precise values (unless you want to postulate the existence of non-molecular life, non-stellar life, or some other exotic life form that contradicts everything we know of biology). Apparent fine-tuning is almost universally accepted. Actual fine-tuning is hotly debated.

What's so important about life?
 
I'd like to add though that there is a hypothesis that there might be a seed of truth in the Exodus, though massively distorted. Namely that the Hebrews are the Hyskos.

The name Hyskos for a start isn't what those guys called themselves, but merely a contraction of the Egyptian phrase "foreign lords." We don't know what they actually were called or called themselves. For the Egyptians they were simply "the foreign lords."

They also seem to have been semitic, and all their recorded names are semitic. (ETA: No big surprise, since the only place they could have come from is that huge chunk of land and population that was semitic next to Egypt.)

The Hyskos, while probably nowhere nearly as monotheistic or even monolatrous as the later Hebrews, seem to have worshipped mainly one god: Seth. Ok, really one of their own gods, which they assimilated with Seth. (Apparently just because their God was a war god, and Seth as one of the bodyguards of Ra on the solar barge was the closest the Egyptians had to a soldier god at all.)

Their actual kingdom only spanned the delta and a bit more, the rest was under the rule of an Egyptian Pharaoh, though he seems to have been a vassal and paid tribute to the Foreign Lords up north.

By the 17'th dynasty, the southern Egyptians were obviously not very fond of it all, and there is some symbolism to be found in the newfound love of the nobles for hunting hippos. Seth as worshipped by the Hyskos had a hippo head and the hippo as his sacred animal. (The Egyptian versions mostly had desert animals or mixtures thereof, as Seth was a desert god. The hippo isn't exactly what you'd associate with the desert.)

The war broke out when the Hyskos Pharaoh tried to forbid his vassals in the south to hunt hippos. Which tells me the symbolism wasn't lost on the Hyskos. Upper Egypt promptly declared war over that. This also tells me how fed up the Egyptians were with their Foreign Lords, if that ridiculous a Casus Beli was all they needed.

The thing about that war is that the Hyskos were't even conquered and didn't stay there, they were pushed out into Canaan. After the fall of Avaris, the remaining Hyskos army (and presumably their relatives and whatnot) packed up and fled into southern Canaan. Pursued by the army of Pharaoh Ahmose, which even laid siege to, captured and razed a Canaanite city the Hyskos had captured and fortified themselves in. The Egyptians were _that_ fed up with them, and were taking no chances.

It makes a compelling hypothesis that that fleeing Hyskos population were, or would later become the Hebrews. And they did have to fight for their place in Canaan. Or at least the ruling class of the Hebrews. The large mass of the population there seems to have been there all along.

Of course, that story would need some massive distortion to become the Exodus. For a start the Hyskos were not fleeing slaves, but the fleeing ex-masters of Egypt.

Also, not all the Hyskos seem to have been invaders. The Semitic invaders found plenty of willing subjects and allies in the semitic populations who had immigrated into Egypt before, some indeed to work on Egypt's construction projects, which would sorta almost fit the Exodus. Though those would not be slaves either, but really paid labourers. Since many of those had been absorbed into the Hyskos ruling class and identified with them, it's likely that a lot would have to flee with them.

The "we were slaves" slant would have developed much later, maybe even as late as when they had the Babylonians on their doorstep and were about to become slaves. Sorta "oh well, we've been there before and managed just fine."
 
Last edited:
You know, now we only have to find Aquinas's tomb, wrap him in copper wire, and put a big-ass magnet around his tomb. *WHAM* Instant free electricity ;)

More seriously, it's ironic that the fundies who try to use Aquinas's arguments actually seem to understand Aquinas the least, and I suspect some haven't even read more than a few quotes from him.

Those rationales aren't some kind of Redundant Array of Independent Drivel. They're not X independent proofs of god, but a small part of the bigger whole of Aquinas's work on the topic. That's what allows Aquinas to make the leap from such generic stuff as "something must have always existed" to specifically the Christian God. They're not even his main proofs of God, but each deal with just one aspect of a God which Aquinas had already proven (or so he believed.)

E.g., even if you bridge from "something which always existed" to divinity, why the Christian _one_ God, and not, say, to the 8 Gods of the Ogdoad?

Aquinas could do that because he had already devoted a freaking chapter on that one point, based on the philosophical principle that the one must come before the multitude. There must be _one_ human before there are two humans. There must be _one_ God before there are two Gods. And if we extrapolate that principle: there must be one quark before there are two or three quarks in the universe, and there must be one kind of particle (either quark or gluon) before there are two kinds of particles (quarks _and_ gluons.)

That extrapolation, btw, is the counter-example: a single quark can't actually exist, nor quarks without gluons, nor gluons without quarks. Hence that principle applied by Aquinas is false, and so is any conclusion based on it.

But at any rate, that's why Aquinas could do the leap to one God.

E.g., if something existed, why specifically a God and not, say, an amorphous bit of energy?

Aquinas could bridge that gap better, because he also goes through a whole list of what other attributes get ascribed to his God. E.g., the unmoved mover part.

Ironically, that's also false and based on a falsehood. The pre-Galilei physics they had postulated that anything only moves if it's pushed, and stops when you stop pushing it. What they had instead of Newton's a = F / m was basically v = F / m. No force applied, no velocity. Hence they needed someone who moves the planets around.

Again, nowadays we know that to be false, so Aquinas's whole "unmoved mover" argument falls flat on its face.

But, again, that bit is one of the many which allow Aquinas to (brokenly) support such a leap between notions.

But, of course, that all goes right over the head of the average fundie who quotes a bit of Aquinas as definitive proof of God. He'll pick such a bit and think it's a full independent proof.

Should someone tell them he was a Catholic? Protestant fundies tend to hate Catholics so it's really funny to see them trot out his arguments.
 
Finite man cannot define the infinite.
<snip>
All of the characteristics of the divine essence are present in God at all times, but not all are manifest at the same time, just as while all colors are present in a ray of white light, the individual colors can be seen only under certain conditions of reflection or refraction. Various attributes of God can be seen in certain situations. For example:

* In salvation, God's love and eternal life are apparent.

* In judgment, His righteousness and justice are manifested.

* In God's faithfulness, His immutability and veracity are shown.

* In God's Plan, His omniscience and sovereignty are seen.

* In God's will, sovereignty is paramount.

* In God's revelation, veracity, love, and omniscience are obvious.

Don't you notice a slight contradiction between that first line and the rest?
 
<snip the gobbledegook>

The rest of this paper is devoted to a description of the ten characteristics of the Essence of God as seen in the various Bible passages that describe them.
This, plus several subsequent posts, suggests to me this is one of those students that has to engage with skeptics as part of a course requirement.
 
This, plus several subsequent posts, suggests to me this is one of those students that has to engage with skeptics as part of a course requirement.

Shame those courses don't seem to differentiate between "engage with" and "post drivel at."
 
This, plus several subsequent posts, suggests to me this is one of those students that has to engage with skeptics as part of a course requirement.

I think you're onto it.

Dr. Dr. Dempski's College of Bible Inanity.
 
In many cultures it is customary to answer that God created the universe out of nothing. But this is mere temporizing. If we wish courageously to pursue the question, we must, of course ask next where God comes from? If we answer that God always existed, why not save a step and declare that the universe always existed? And if we decide the existence of God to be an unanswerable question, why not save a step and conclude that the existence of the Universe is unanswerable?- Sagan

Worth repeating--
 
1. You'll notice the difference in scale there. Some less than 50 slaves with semitic names are mentioned. That is a massive difference between that and 2 million leaving Egypt. Among other things because:

Etc

Brilliant! Thanks for the education, Hans. This is the wonderful thing about living - you never stop learning.
 
1. God makes sense of the origin of the universe.

That's not a reason. "Making sense" is not a way to explain things. Your hypothesis must describe how things work and make testable predictions.

2. God makes sense of the fine-tuning of the universe for intelligent life.

What fine-tuning ? Most of the universe is bleak and hostile. So far only one planet we know of has life. How is that fine-tuned ?

3. God makes sense of objective moral values in the world.

Such as ?

4. God makes sense of the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.

...a set of events we don't know happened.

5. God can be immediately known and experienced.

Really ? I'm yet to experience him. Care to explain ?

1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its
existence.
2. The universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the universe has a cause of its
existence. that cause was God.

3 doesn't follow from 1 and 2.
 
I believe there was no cause of God.

Why this exception and not another ?

How do we know this? We know that from nothing, nothing comes. So, if there were ever a time when there was absolutely nothing in existence, then nothing would have ever come into existence. But things do exist. Therefore, since there could never have been absolutely nothing, something had to have always been in existence.

So far, so good.

That ever-existing thing is what we call God.

This is where your reasoning breaks down. Why do you conclude that the most basic thing in existence must be the most complex being imaginable is beyond me. Also you have no evidence, and your conclusion doesn't follow.

Since it did not always exist, but came into existence (had a singular beginning), then some other reality must have caused or created it.1

Or maybe it's just part of an endless cycle and nothing created reality, either. It saves a step, as was said upthread.

Everything we observe in nature has a beginning.

Not quite. Everything is transformed from something else. My thought is that the universe is a "bubble" of quantum stuff that is just ephemerous.

God however is in a different category, and must be so.

"Must" ? Why ? Because you want to maintain your faith ?
 
you can believe whatever you want. The quest is if your beliefs are rational , compelling, and the best explanation for our existence.

We have science for that.

What is not rational about my argument ?

Pretty much everything. You know nothing about logic and reason, and instead attempt to dress up your faith as arguments. Unfortunately for you, it doesn't work that way. If you're interested in correcting yourself I and others will be more than happy to explain this to you in more detail.
 
We have science for that.

So please explain how science explains the origin and cause of the universe.


Pretty much everything. You know nothing about logic and reason, and instead attempt to dress up your faith as arguments. Unfortunately for you, it doesn't work that way. If you're interested in correcting yourself I and others will be more than happy to explain this to you in more detail.

Excellent. then please start to explain to me things more in detail Starting with answering my above question. ;)
 
Why this exception and not another ?

why do you think God is a exception ?

This is where your reasoning breaks down. Why do you conclude that the most basic thing in existence must be the most complex being imaginable is beyond me.

why do you think God is complex ? and how does this correlate with the improbatiliy of God's existence ?

Also you have no evidence, and your conclusion doesn't follow.

the facts shown in my opening thread ARE evidence. If not, please explain, why.


Or maybe it's just part of an endless cycle and nothing created reality, either. It saves a step, as was said upthread.

So everything coming from nothing. Makes that sense to you ?


Not quite. Everything is transformed from something else. My thought is that the universe is a "bubble" of quantum stuff that is just ephemerous.

and where is the evidence ? and what caused that bubble of quantum stuff ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom