Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am assuming you expect intelligent rational arguments here. Dont you want to join in?

Sure. What is not rational about my argument ?

The appearance of the universe has a meta-physical origin anyway, with , or without a efficient cause. If God is not the cause of the universe, what else would you suggest ?
 
Even if the total energy is not zero, matter could still be created spontaneously - but only for a very short time. According to Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, we cannot determine energy and time precisely. Therefore, it is possible for a group of particles with non-zero total energy appear spontaneously and then disappear within a short time. The more the total energy is created, the shorter the lifetime. This process is known as the quantum fluctuation, which has been well confirmed by experiments.


No.

In 1973, Edward Tryon suggested that our universe might originate from the quantum fluctuation. This requires extremely accurate cancellation between matter energy and gravitational energy. If the matter energy is just slightly (within 1 part in 1050) greater than the gravitational energy, the uncertainty principle would dictate the matter to disappear in a time period that is too short to have any physical meaning. For such gigantic fluctuation to occur spontaneously is almost impossible.


Close, but no.
 
you can believe whatever you want. The quest is if your beliefs are rational , compelling, and the best explanation for our existence.

Well, there it is. Far be it from anyone here to mention that your "beliefs" require an inordinate amount of suspension of disbelief in order to fit them into the tight little package of your brand of rationality.
 
1. God makes sense of the origin of the universe.

God of the gaps. The idea that we are all AI in a very advanced version of "The Sims" would also make sense of the origin of the universe. This manner of argument is stupid and ridiculous beyond speculating for the fun of it.

2. God makes sense of the fine-tuning of the universe for intelligent life.

The fact that the universe appears to be fine tuned for life is tautological in nature. We could not exist to observe a universe which did not lead to our existence as observers. To insert god as this "fine tuner" is also simply special pleading. Why not aliens, or again, a simulation? Not that any of this matters, the entire basis of the "the universe is fine-tuned" argument is personal ignorance of the fact that we can observe no other type of universe. No god, aliens or simulation needed.

3. God makes sense of objective moral values in the world.

Objective moral values? What? Do you mean subjective moral values that happen to cross cultural lines? Such as: "killing is bad?" This is an argument from personal incredulity if you cannot see how these systems of morality have evolved naturally. This is fail.

4. God makes sense of the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.

Begging the question.

5. God can be immediately known and experienced.

So can lobster people from the planet clak-tor for a person sufficiently willing to believe in them.

1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its
existence.
2. The universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the universe has a cause of its
existence. that cause was God.

God of the gaps, personal incredulity, AND special pleading. Congrats.
 
But, of course, that all goes right over the head of the average fundie who quotes a bit of Aquinas as definitive proof of God. He'll pick such a bit and think it's a full independent proof.

It seems you did not observe, but i avoid to write about definitive proofs. They do not exist. But there is plenty of evidence, which i have posted in my initial post. If you have a better explanation for our existence, please post it here.
 
In 1973, Edward Tryon suggested that our universe might originate from the quantum fluctuation. This requires extremely accurate cancellation between matter energy and gravitational energy. If the matter energy is just slightly (within 1 part in 1050) greater than the gravitational energy, the uncertainty principle would dictate the matter to disappear in a time period that is too short to have any physical meaning. For such gigantic fluctuation to occur spontaneously is almost impossible.
Well, the universe is here, what does a so-called god explain, and if this so-called god always was, what was it doing all the time before 13.7 billion years. Gods answer nothing, they only make more questions.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Last edited:
Check out this video:
A Universe From Nothing' by Lawrence Krauss[/URL]


Krauss arguments are flawed....

elshamah.heavenforum.com/astronomy-cosmology-and-god-f15/quantum-fluctuations-t65.htm

Vacuum Fluctuation Models did not outlive the decade of the 1980s. Not only were there theoretical problems with the production mechanisms of matter, but these models faced a deep internal incoherence.{31} According to such models, it is impossible to specify precisely when and where a fluctuation will occur in the primordial vacuum which will then grow into a universe. Within any finite interval of time there is a positive probability of such a fluctuation occurring at any point in space. Thus, given infinite past time, universes will eventually be spawned at every point in the primordial vacuum, and, as they expand, they will begin to collide and coalesce with one another. Thus, given infinite past time, we should by now be observing an infinitely old universe, not a relatively young one. About the only way to avert the problem would be to postulate an expansion of the primordial vacuum itself; but then we are right back to the absolute origin implied by the Standard Model. According to Isham this problem proved to be "fairly lethal" to Vacuum Fluctuation Models; hence, these models were "jettisoned twenty years ago" and "nothing much" has been done with them since.{32}
 
Vacuum Fluctuation Models did not outlive the decade of the 1980s. Not only were there theoretical problems with the production mechanisms of matter, but these models faced a deep internal incoherence.{31} According to such models, it is impossible to specify precisely when and where a fluctuation will occur in the primordial vacuum which will then grow into a universe. Within any finite interval of time there is a positive probability of such a fluctuation occurring at any point in space. Thus, given infinite past time, universes will eventually be spawned at every point in the primordial vacuum, and, as they expand, they will begin to collide and coalesce with one another. Thus, given infinite past time, we should by now be observing an infinitely old universe, not a relatively young one. About the only way to avert the problem would be to postulate an expansion of the primordial vacuum itself; but then we are right back to the absolute origin implied by the Standard Model. According to Isham this problem proved to be "fairly lethal" to Vacuum Fluctuation Models; hence, these models were "jettisoned twenty years ago" and "nothing much" has been done with them since.{32}


No.

Heck, no.
 
I'm presuming that you know nothing about the history of your religion, but can you answer these questions, if God has been here since he created the earth, why is it no one knew his name til Abraham, why is it that all his special creation stories (earth man etc) were copied from the creation stories of other Gods who were worshipped for far longer by pagans before anyone knew your Gods name and why is it that your God has no supporting evidence for his existence whereas the Gods whos stories were plagiarised for your God did (at least according to their followers) ?

seems to me that until you answer these questions, you don't know much about your God so are in no position to ask questions when you havent answered any for yourself

in your own time
;)

How do you know genesis was copied from other Gods ?
 
1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its existence.
2. The universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the universe has a cause of its existence. that cause was God.


Why was that cause God? If there was a cause to the universe, it could be anything at all - why settle on inserting God here?

God does not solve infinite regression, no matter how much you pray that he does.


1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its existence.
2. The universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the universe has a cause of its existence. That cause was:
- God
- An eternal singularity
- Particles that popped into existence from nothing
- Pixie dust
- A time-traveller from the future who travelled back in time to create the universe
- Universe-spewing dragons
- Chuck Norris
- A warp-core breach​


I believe there was no cause of God.


I thought this thread was meant to discuss evidence, and not belief. What evidence do you have that there was no cause of God?


I believe there was no cause of:
- God
- An eternal singularity
- Particles that popped into existence from nothing
- Pixie dust
- A time-traveller from the future who travelled back in time to create the universe
- Universe-spewing dragons
- Chuck Norris
- A warp-core breach​
 
parody said:
five good reasons to think that Bastet exists:

1. Bastet makes sense of the origin of the universe.

2. Bastet makes sense of the fine-tuning of the universe for Feline life.

3. Bastet makes sense of subjective moral values in the world.

4. God makes sense of the life, death, and resurrection of Osiris.

5. Bastet can be immediately known and experienced. Just caress a cat.

Really havign a god as first mover make no sense, as you only shifted the origin one step, now you have to POSIT god is eternal or you are in the conendary to have to explain god creation. And if you posit any stuff, then why not jsut posit there was nothing before the universe sprang into existence.

As for the fine tuning argument, I am sorry but WHICH universe is fine tuned ??? Without technology most of the earth surface is either downright hostile to human life, or only passable. And the earth is what percentage of the surface of the solar system ? 0.000000001% ? Less ? Not even counting the rest of the universe , I don't see fine tuning I see imperfection of our body and an utter waste of space (in an extremly hostile universe).


Those are argumentn for gods existence only if you already posit it exists. If you do not, then the argument lead to no conclusion.
 
Last edited:
you can believe whatever you want. The quest is if your beliefs are rational , compelling, and the best explanation for our existence.

Right. So, of course, a God which created the world in six days complete with fossils, a God who is everywhere... except you can run from him by just going to Tarshish (see Jonah, and that God actually tries to stop him instead of making the point "I'm here too, you know"), a God who needs to sacrifice to himself to forgive you of a sin someone else did, a God who feels threatened that humans might build a tower all the way to heavens and thinks they might actually succeed in _that_ if they're united (wtf?), a God who knows everything... except such things as which guy in Sodom isn't guilty, a God who knows everything... but needs a marking on the door to remind him who not to kill when taking those guys out of Egypt, a God who's allmighty... but needs Noah to build a boat the size of Australia and collect animals from everywhere for him instead of just setting two of each aside himself, a God who's just... but gives a world-wide famine from Tenochtitlan to Edo (places who couldn't buy from Joseph anyway) for no reason than to make one guy obscenely rich, a God who knows everything... but needs to play a cruel candid-camera type prank on Abraham just to see if he'd actually sacrifice his adult son, etc... yeah, that's obviously _got_ to be the most rational explanation ;)

Heh.
 
Last edited:
It seems you did not observe, but i avoid to write about definitive proofs. They do not exist. But there is plenty of evidence, which i have posted in my initial post. If you have a better explanation for our existence, please post it here.

Except you don't seem to actually present anything that would even qualify as evidence. All you have argued about is that _something_ must have existed for ever. There is nothing in there that would warrant the jump from "something" to "God".

And the initial post? Are you genuinely delusional, or just don't know what "evidence" means? Re-read that initial post of yours, and please tell me where the evidence is. I don't see any. I see a couple of postulates and a trivial piece of broken logic at the end. Actual evidence: zero.

Sorry, just postulating that you gave evidence doesn't magically make it so.

As for a better explanation, how about the one without a God? You still have to do the same predictions as the real science with or without God, because otherwise you have a less complete hypothesis. And adding God doesn't actually add any actual prediction or formula or anything. Effectively God is just the kind of unneeded extra entity there that Occam warned against.
 
Finite man cannot define the infinite. The Bible is the Word of God, and as such it reveals those facts about the Creator that He has seen fit to reveal about Himself.

Proof of this so-called god please.

Man suppose that God thinks like a man. We think God wants revenge, because when we're insulted, we want revenge. When we are cheated, we want immediate justice and retribution. We are indignant and shocked at the behavior of others, so we expect God to be shocked.

Again Proof of this so-called god please.

But God does not feel insulted. He does not feel cheated - He owns everything. He is not indignant, temperamental, or emotional. He does not throw tantrums (or lightning bolts). He is not surprised or shocked by anything. He is never depressed or moody.

Again the Prood, and funny how you know so much about it.

God is not arrogant or egotistical. He knows Himself, is self-assured, and is humble.

It is, really, don't read your bible much do you.

God is a rational, logical, stable-minded, patient; and all of His thinking is backed up by His omniscience. And He approaches every issue from the basis of His perfect character, the subject of this study.

Stable, so why the Old and New Testaments.

God approaches every issue regarding human beings out of His love for all men. His thinking toward man takes all of His attributes into consideration - but Love is always present. It is God's thinking about us, in love, that is His perfect Grace thinking. He is always gracious, always thinks Grace.

So, what is this hell thing all about then.

Spirituality is one of God's primary attributes. God is immaterial, in a universe that is made up of both material and immaterial. God has revealed something of what He is in the Word, but only He knows Himself fully. We must rely on what is written in the Bible for any understanding of what God is like.

Revealed, a book, written by men and no women, that reveals a lot to me.

The fact that God is a spiritual being means that He lives. Spirituality implies life. Jer. 10:10 and 1 Th. 1:9 tell us that God is alive and well. The life of God has no beginning and no ending. God is eternal. The Christian shares God's eternal life, but since his eternal life has a beginning at the time he accepted Jesus Christ as Saviour, his eternal life is properly called "everlasting life".

Proof again, that black book doesn't cut it here.

All of the characteristics of the divine essence are present in God at all times, but not all are manifest at the same time, just as while all colors are present in a ray of white light, the individual colors can be seen only under certain conditions of reflection or refraction. Various attributes of God can be seen in certain situations. For example:

* In salvation, God's love and eternal life are apparent.

No they are not.

* In judgment, His righteousness and justice are manifested.

So, killing all men, women and children is OK with you.

* In God's faithfulness, His immutability and veracity are shown.

Dumped the Jews.

* In God's Plan, His omniscience and sovereignty are seen.

In that killing of everyone but one family with that so-called flood.

* In God's will, sovereignty is paramount.

It is all about him in the end.


* In God's revelation, veracity, love, and omniscience are obvious.

As long as you play by his rules, heaven help if you do one thing wrong.

The rest of this paper is devoted to a description of the ten characteristics of the Essence of God as seen in the various Bible passages that describe them.

Anything about not liking slaves and all.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
How do you know genesis was copied from other Gods ?

do you recognise this ?
When a seventh day arrived
I sent forth a dove and released it.
The dove went off, but came back to me;
no perch was visible so it circled back to me
I sent forth a raven and released it.
The raven went off, and saw the waters slither back.
It eats, it scratches, it bobs, but does not circle back to me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom