Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
prove it.

Philosophical precision aside, we know that events in the brain give rise to experience. No brain activity, no experience.

Death has a way of melting your brain.

There's no you, anymore.

Change brain function, and you change personality.

Destroy brain function, destroy personality.
 
Philosophical precision aside, we know that events in the brain give rise to experience. No brain activity, no experience.

Death has a way of melting your brain.

There's no you, anymore.

Change brain function, and you change personality.

Destroy brain function, destroy personality.

there are no strong reasons to believe in monism.

Scientific Evidence Grows that Mind and Brain Are Separate!

http://www.ukapologetics.net/07/mindandbody.htm

Cardiologist Dr Michael Sabom has described a near-death experience that occurred while its experiencer - a woman who was having an unusual surgical procedure for the safe excision and repair of a large basilar artery aneurysm - met all of the accepted criteria for brain death. Neither is this is an isolated instance for there are now a growing number of people who have testified that they experienced consciousness - indeed, frequently consciousness on a very high and vivid plane, while they were - for a short period - technically "brain-dead." The University of Southampton, England, has also conducted some research which is quite compelling,

"...University of Southampton researchers have just published a paper detailing their pioneering study into near death experiences (or near-death experiences) that suggests consciousness and the mind may continue to exist after the brain has ceased to function and the body is clinically dead.

Independent EEG studies have confirmed that the brain's electrical activity, and hence brain function, ceases at that time. But seven out of 63 (11 per cent) of the Southampton patients who survived their cardiac arrest recalled emotions and visions during unconsciousness." (more information here: http://www.mikepettigrew.com/afterlife/html/u_k__study.html).

Interestingly, the old challenge from sceptical scientists that after-death experiences were simply the result of near-death hallucinations caused by medication or oxygen-starvation are now just about completely refuted. The quoted report of the University of Southampton research briefly also raises this same point:

"...There are currently three explanations for these accounts. The first is physiological; that the hallucinations patients experience is due to disturbed brain chemistry caused by drug treatment, a lack of oxygen or changes in carbon dioxide levels.

In the Southampton study none of the four patients who had near-death experiences had low levels of oxygen or received any unusual combination of drugs during their resuscitation."

It might also be added that 'technically after death' consciousness experiences right across many countries and cultures show a remarkable similarity - this tends to rule out the idea that particular western medical practises tend to cause the dying to hallucinate.
 
Just to derail this long thread, I think I came up with my first solid argument (evidence) for God's existence, in the "sacred feminine" thread.

We all agree that no natural power would make a normal, basic-needs fulfilled person in a wealthy (say G8) country envy a dirt poor, starving African baby. However, this story made me, and many other men without a doubt, wished they were a particular starving African baby who feasted on Salma Hayek's milk. Thus Salma Hayek's glorious breasts have supernatural powers, hence they are evidence (possibly proof) of God. Obviously these bosoms are worthy of worship, and to deny that fact is pure heresy.
 
Just to derail this long thread, I think I came up with my first solid argument (evidence) for God's existence, in the "sacred feminine" thread.

We all agree that no natural power would make a normal, basic-needs fulfilled person in a wealthy (say G8) country envy a dirt poor, starving African baby. However, this story made me, and many other men without a doubt, wished they were a particular starving African baby who feasted on Salma Hayek's milk. Thus Salma Hayek's glorious breasts have supernatural powers, hence they are evidence (possibly proof) of God. Obviously these bosoms are worthy of worship, and to deny that fact is pure heresy.

Well, duh. Took you that long to figure this out?

Honestly. :rolleyes:
 
If you can show me solid evidence of 'near death' experiences giving the experiencer some real, specific knowledge--confirmable--that they couldn't have had any other way, that would be impressive. But there isn't any such evidence.

All we have are self-reports of hallucinatory experiences, without any confirmation.

People can experience things under anesthesia, because brain activity hasn't stopped.

Besides, near-death doesn't equal death.

Their brains hadn't dissolved, yet.

Others here will find other problems with your link, I'm sure.
 
please critizise the arguments, not me. If you think i have no grasp of my arguments, you loose time, debating with me. Then you should search someone, that you have the feeling, is at your level of understanding.
I, and many others, have criticized your arguments in depth. You have simply ignored those criticisms. Speculation as to why you do this is well within the parameters of the discussion. If you truly do not want to learn something new then simply state as much and I will stop attempting to explain the concept to you.

what shall that mean, now ? nothing is nothing.its the absence of any thing. period.
Right. And there was nothing into which the universe could have "popped into existence". We are, for some reason, constrained to experience time as a flow in one direction only. We cannot significantly alter our rate of progress and we cannot change direction, not with any knowledge we currently posses anyway. But time is a dimension just as the three spatial dimensions that we experience in our daily lives. We have "length" in time just as we do in space. Imagine a universe with two spatial dimensions and a third temporal dimension. (You've mentioned Flatland, do you know what it is meant to explain? We reduce a dimension in order to understand dimensions that we can't conceptualize.) If we imagine a universe that is a sphere with an axis like a globe then we can imagine space as the two dimensions perpendicular to the axis and time as the dimension parallel to the axis. This universe (a very simplified model, granted) is self contained. It exists without creation.

again, ad hominem atack. please stop it. next time i will stop answering you.
That isn't even remotely an ad hominem attack. I suggest that you look up the definition of that phrase.

what has that now to do with your previous sentence.
It has everything to do with my previous sentence.
If you agree, there was nothing prior the big bang, start think about what was the universe'cause.
Although I may have to modify my position as stated in said previous sentence based on your above response.
 
the Universe was not. And then it came to be. Since there was no physical need , the universe to come into existence, there had to be a decision, to bring the universe into existence, thus e personal being.

Going along with your argument, what *caused* the decision to create the universe? Decisions are caused by physical processes in physical brains.
 
Sure. The universe is caused, since it had a beginning.
the cause had to be uncaused, otherwise there woule be eternal regress of causes, which is not plausible. And goes against Occams Razor.


Even if there were an uncaused cause, where is the evidence that that uncaused cause must be the Christian god as described in the Bible? Why is your god any more likely to exist than the countless number of gods that have been followed throughout history? Why one god and not thousands? Why God and not a time-traveller or a dragon or an unconscious, infinite cycle of universes or Chuck Norris?
 
That's an interpretation of the data using an agreed upon model, not certain knowledge. The Copenhagen Interpretation is a set assumptions that allows us to use quantum physics and that also happen to not contradict any evidence. Had the interpretation instead assumed that there is in fact an underlying cause, it wouldn't have made any difference for it's utility. That isn't to say there isn't one -- everything else has a cause (or a reason). But the bottom line is, not detecting a cause isn't the same thing as knowing that there isn't one.

It sounds like you're saying that there may be hidden characteristics just below the surface of our understanding of QM, and these non-random, causal (but hidden) variables are responsible. But the idea of hidden variables has been pretty decisively shown to be false. Things really are, fundamentally, random and without cause.

Suggesting that atomic decay "isn't caused" is like suggesting that tops should spin forever. It's not as if atomic nuclei decay into more energetic forms, right? It takes energy to maintain those forms and when it isn't sufficient, those forms decay.
No. Atomic decay is fundamentally a random process.
 
The extreme fine-tuning of the universe

http://elshamah.heavenforum.com/ast...e-extreme-fine-tuning-of-the-universe-t31.htm

(1) If our universe is random, then it is very unlikely that it permits life.
(2)Our universe permits life.
(3)Therefore,the existence of our universe is very likely due to something other than chance.

1. The fine-tuning of the universe is due either to physical necessity, chance, or design.
2. It is not due to physical necessity or chance.
3. Therefore, it is due to design.

Fred Hoyle
(British astrophysicist)

“A common sense interpretation of the facts suggests that a superintellect has monkeyed with physics, as well as with chemistry and biology, and that there are no blind forces worth speaking about in nature. The numbers one calculates from the facts seem to me so overwhelming as to put this conclusion almost beyond question.”

The fine-tuning of our earth and solar system

http://elshamah.heavenforum.com/ast...tuning-of-our-earth-and-solar-system-t180.htm

the axial tilt of the Earth
the rotational period of the Earth
the Earth's crust thickness
Earth's gravity and interaction with the moon
CO2 and ozone levels in the atmosphere
oxygen/nitrogen ratio in the atmosphere
the mass and size of the Earth
and about a 70 more special factors

If any one of these conditions were slightly higher or lower, life on Earth would cease to exist. For example, the Earth is at a very specific distance from the sun. Malcolm Bowden says, "If it were 5% closer, then the water would boil up from the oceans and if it were just 1% farther away, then the oceans would freeze, and that gives you just some idea of the knife edge we are on." Dr. Duane Gish says, "If the Earth's diameter were 7,200 miles, instead of 8,000, then almost the whole Earth, due to a lessening of the atmospheric mantle, would be reduced to snow and ice waste."


Highlighting mine.

I hope the members here will forgive me fro invoking a metaphor coined by someone else, instead of using my own words, but Douglas Adams said it far better than I ever could:

"It's rather like a puddle waking up one morning - I know they don't normally do this, but allow me, I'm a science fiction writer - A puddle wakes up one morning and thinks: 'This is a very interesting world I find myself in. It fits me very neatly. In fact it fits me so neatly... I mean really precise isn't it... It must have been made to have me in it.'"​

- Douglas Adams, The Salmon of Doubt​



Regarding the highlighted portion:

5% closer, 1% farther

Earth Aphelion: 152 million km
Earth Perihelion: 146 million km
(source)

To err on the side of caution, let's take the percentages off the aphelion.

1% of 152 million = 1.52 million km
5% of 152 million = 7.6 million km

The difference between the Earth's aphelion and perihelion?

6 million km.

Here's a link to a list of studies on the "habitable zone" around our sun. The first 4 (the only ones listing an inner boundary) are somewhat broader than what Bowden specifies. Btw, Bowden is a YEC, and a geocentrist. In other words: an imbecile. He's not exactly the most reputable source you could have used. For that matter, neither is Gish.

For reference: 1 Astronomical Unit (1 AU) = 149,598,000 km. (from Google)

The one's with an inner boundary of 0.95 AU (your "5%") put the inner boundary (5% of 1 AU = 7,479,900 km) put us perilously close during what the northern hemisphere calls winter.




[T]here is no right or wrong interpretation of the scientific data, as long as there is [sic] no conclusive proofs. One day, when you die, you will know, if my God exists or not. Unfortunately, if am right, you wrong, you will encounter [sic] yourself in hell, since this is was [sic] happens to unbelievers.



You do realize this depends on your particular version of your particular religion being the right one, don't you?
Frankly, iff* there is a hell, I'll see you there. Because Sikhism is correct.


*"iff" means "if and only if"



orry, but the fine-tune argument of the universe has absolutely nothing to do with Darwinism.



What the hell is "Darwinism"?
Educate yourself, before spouting nonsense that makes you look like an idiot.






BTW: [url=]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=5417823#post5417823]Still awaiting a reply.
What knowledge does your feel-good "god" bandaid provide us? Why should we slap this impenetrable label over something just because we currently don't know the answer?
If I'd slapped "god" over everything I didn't know, instead of trying to learn, I would be a pathetic ignorant troglodyte. I certainly wouldn't have learned the physics necessary to get my B.Sc. in Mechanical Engineering.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom