Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
what knowledge do you have in regard of the cause of the universe ?
The same as you, only you jump to a so-called god, when I see that it isn't needed. and this so-called god needs a jump start too, prove that it doesn't, you can't, it brings nothing to the table.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
because i HAVE philosophycal and scientific evidence of Gods existence.

Perhaps it might be a good idea to show it then rather than simply postulating bollocks and ignoring perfectly reasonable responses.

We're all crying out for it. If you have the evidence, it's fairly likely that you can claim a Noble Prize. Go for it.

Oh, but please try to avoid just regurgitating the nonsense of other people. That tends not to impress. Encountering it on here is rather like encountering a pool of vomit on the street - someone clearly cannot cope with something (alcohol, sensible questions) and is therefore reduced to a purgative regurgitation. The sensible thing to do is to step aside and ignore it.

If you have nothing of your own to say, then better to say nothing.
 
What does the fact that you're not trying to prove anything have to do with the following claims?:
  • That the universe having a beginning means it has a cause
  • That the universe having a cause means that the cause must be uncaused
  • That if the universe has a cause and that cause is not uncaused, then this means there is infinite regress (e.g., God could not have created two branes that collided to form the universe?)
  • That all of the above is supported by Occam's razor ("entia non sunt multiplicanda praeter necessitatem")
...and that fact that none of the above follows?

why do you think none of the above follows ?
For A:
It does not logically follow, because if the universe came about uncaused, then it could have a beginning without having a cause. It also does not follow because if the universe simply always was, but time had a beginning, then the universe would have been since the beginning of time, and therefore would not have a cause.

It does not follow evidentially because we have no data suggesting that these other logical possibilities are not in fact the case.

For B, and for C:
It does not logically follow, because if the universe had a cause, the thing that caused the universe could very well have a cause as well. The parenthetical in (C) gives an example, where God created the universe indirectly, by creating two branes, and having them smash together. Then even your uncaused God would have created the branes, which then would have caused the universe. This has God causing branes, and branes causing the universe. And in this scenario, the branes would be the cause of the universe. And, the branes would not be uncaused.

It does not follow evidentially because you have no data on how the universe was caused.

For D:
Occam's razor is "entia non sunt multiplicanda praeter necessitatem"--Do not multiply entities beyond necessity. This is about not adding things to your theory when you don't have to. But you're making the claim that Occam's razor supports your addition of an entity. Even if you had to add the entity, that's not what Occam's razor says (it does not say to add entities when necessary, it says, instead, to not add entities when it's not necessary). So by the largest possible stretch in your direction, Occam's razor still does not support it.

None of your claims logically follow, and none of them evidentially follow.

So what is left?
 
Last edited:
I, and many others, have criticized your arguments in depth. You have simply ignored those criticisms.

No, i do simply consider them as not compelling, as bad explanations.

Speculation as to why you do this is well within the parameters of the discussion. If you truly do not want to learn something new then simply state as much and I will stop attempting to explain the concept to you.

what concept ? i have not seen yet any reasonable concept.

Right. And there was nothing into which the universe could have "popped into existence". We are, for some reason, constrained to experience time as a flow in one direction only. We cannot significantly alter our rate of progress and we cannot change direction, not with any knowledge we currently posses anyway. But time is a dimension just as the three spatial dimensions that we experience in our daily lives. We have "length" in time just as we do in space. Imagine a universe with two spatial dimensions and a third temporal dimension. (You've mentioned Flatland, do you know what it is meant to explain? We reduce a dimension in order to understand dimensions that we can't conceptualize.) If we imagine a universe that is a sphere with an axis like a globe then we can imagine space as the two dimensions perpendicular to the axis and time as the dimension parallel to the axis. This universe (a very simplified model, granted) is self contained. It exists without creation.

there is no reason to belief so. At least not in my understanding. The universe cannot be cause and effect at the same time. And Hawking's attempt to avoid a singularity fails, as already shown.
 
Going along with your argument, what *caused* the decision to create the universe? Decisions are caused by physical processes in physical brains.

not necessarly. If God is spirit, he is personal, and can make decisions. I am not monist.
 
Even if there were an uncaused cause, where is the evidence that that uncaused cause must be the Christian god as described in the Bible? Why is your god any more likely to exist than the countless number of gods that have been followed throughout history? Why one god and not thousands? Why God and not a time-traveller or a dragon or an unconscious, infinite cycle of universes or Chuck Norris?

Why is christianity the only true religion ?

The Mathematical Odds of Jesus Fulfilling Prophecy

http://elshamah.heavenforum.com/bib...e-christianity-the-only-true-religion-t96.htm

"The following probabilities are taken from Peter Stoner in Science Speaks (Moody Press, 1963) to show that coincidence is ruled out by the science of probability. Stoner says that by using the modern science of probability in reference to eight prophecies, ‘we find that the chance that any man might have lived down to the present time and fulfilled all eight prophecies is 1 in 1017." That would be 1 in 100,000,000,000,000,000. In order to help us comprehend this staggering probability, Stoner illustrates it by supposing that "we take 1017 silver dollars and lay them on the face of Texas. They will cover all of the state two feet deep. Now mark one of these silver dollars and stir the whole mass thoroughly, all over the state. Blindfold a man and tell him that he can travel as far as he wishes, but he must pick up one silver dollar and say that this is the right one. What chance would he have of getting the right one? Just the same chance that the prophets would have had of writing these eight prophecies and having them all come true in any one man."

Stoner considers 48 prophecies and says, "We find the chance that any one man fulfilled all 48 prophecies to be 1 in 10157, or 1 in 10,00,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000, 000,000,000,000,000, 000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000, 000, 000,000,000,000,000,000,000, 000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 000,000,000." 1

The resurrection

Christ's resurrection from the dead is the basis for our faith (1 Cor. 15:14). To somehow disprove the resurrection would destroy the entire foundation of Christianity. On the other hand, proving it as an actual historical event establishes the Christian faith throughout all ages.

There are several legitimate evidences for Christ's resurrection: the empty tomb; multitudes of eyewitnesses; the outpouring of the Holy Spirit on the day of Pentecost; miracles performed by the apostles; the silence of critics. Without going into detail about each of these, it is sufficient to say that these provide ample evidence for Christ's resurrection as an historical event. And His resurrection proves that He is the only way to God because He is the only man to win the victory over death.

The most reasonable world view

It just makes sense that for a religion to be true then it must answer the crux of life's spiritual questions such as the creation, death, sin, righteousness, and love. But not only should it address the spiritual but also the issues of daily life like family, marriage, divorce, money, work, politics and ministry. No other religion touches on so many areas of life than the Bible.

I know a lady who is diligently seeking the one true religion among many. Along with my wife witnessing to her about Christ, she is also being pursued by a Muslim who gave her a Koran. One day she read in it that it is acceptable for a man to beat his wife. This really turned her off to that religion and rightly so. We need to recognize that the Bible portrays men and women in their proper roles and gives dignity to both.

Conclusion

Some people try to test God by stating that if He is real then why does He not just show Himself or else give us overwhelming evidence of His existence and His will. Actually, God is not obligated to give us anything at all. It is His own prerogative to do as He pleases. But He did choose to show Himself to us in the Person of His Son Jesus Christ. He said, "He who has seen Me has seen the Father" (John 14:9). And in order that we would have strong faith, He gave us not only sufficient evidence but also overwhelming evidence of Him. All the evidence we need is right there in Scripture and mankind is left without excuse.
 
Matthew 25:41 "Depart from me, ye accursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the Devil and his angels."

Is this just? Yes or no answer, please.

yes, i think it is just.

How could a GOD of love possibly send people to Hell?

http://www.freedomministries.org.uk/masters/hell.htm

Consider some of the reasons why God cannot let everyone go to Heaven. He cannot open Heaven to everyone, firstly, because He is holy. God is sublime in majesty and holiness - He is perfect. We, on the other hand, are full of pride, greed selfishness and callousness. We are full of back-biting, whispering, gossiping, cheating and lying; not to mention sensual deeds and thoughts.

But God is a holy God. There is not the slightest imperfection in His character and conduct. Through all eternity God will never change, never deteriorate or disappoint.

While as a God of love He is pained by the eternal banishment we bring upon ourselves, yet He hates sin and will never tolerate or co-exist with it. We cannot, at the end of this life be admitted into His eternal presence, unless we have first searched for His forgiveness and been converted.

Consider also this second reason why God cannot admit unforgiven, unconverted people to Heaven. If God did admit us to Heaven in our sinful condition (which He cannot do), we would not be able to endure it, not even for a few seconds.

With our polluted minds and hearts, we would be utterly destroyed by the holiness of God. It would be a situation similar to a dazzling light which is impeded by some obstruction, so that a shadow is cast. Take the obstruction away, and at once the shadow is destroyed. It cannot endure the light.

Then, consider this third reason why God cannot let unforgiven sinners into Heaven. If God did allow us in as sinners (which He will not), and if His presence by some chance did not destroy us (which it would(, then Heaven would not be Heaven any longer.

Would almighty God, the sovereign landlord of the universe, the Kind of kings and Lord of lords, the Holy One, allow Heaven to become like earth? Would He really let hordes of rebellious enemies, selfish, self-seeking, proud, wilful, sensual, gossiping, stealing, lying, cheating, fighting worldlings into Heaven?
 
prove it.

:id:

The Condemnation of the Unrighteous

1:18 For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of people39 who suppress the truth by their40 unrighteousness,41 1:19 because what can be known about God is plain to them,42 because God has made it plain to them. 1:20 For since the creation of the world his invisible attributes – his eternal power and divine nature – have been clearly seen, because they are understood through what has been made. So people43 are without excuse. 1:21 For although they knew God, they did not glorify him as God or give him thanks, but they became futile in their thoughts and their senseless hearts44 were darkened. 1:22 Although they claimed45 to be wise, they became fools.

this is true today , more than ever before.

Revelation 21.8 :

To the one who is thirsty I will give water13 free of charge14 from the spring of the water of life. 21:7 The one who conquers15 will inherit these things, and I will be his God and he will be my son. 21:8 But to the cowards, unbelievers, detestable persons, murderers, the sexually immoral, and those who practice magic spells,16 idol worshipers,17 and all those who lie, their place18 will be in the lake that burns with fire and sulfur.19 That20 is the second death.”

Oh, look...he quotes the Bible to prove the Bible is true. How...circular. Also repetitive.
 
No, i do simply consider them as not compelling, as bad explanations.

And yet they are perfectly valid rebuttals.

there is no reason to belief so. At least not in my understanding. The universe cannot be cause and effect at the same time.

So why can it not simply be effect without cause?

Why is christianity the only true religion ?

The Mathematical Odds of Jesus Fulfilling Prophecy

http://elshamah.heavenforum.com/bib...e-christianity-the-only-true-religion-t96.htm

"The following probabilities are taken from Peter Stoner in Science Speaks (Moody Press, 1963) to show that coincidence is ruled out by the science of probability. Stoner says that by using the modern science of probability in reference to eight prophecies, ‘we find that the chance that any man might have lived down to the present time and fulfilled all eight prophecies is 1 in 1017." That would be 1 in 100,000,000,000,000,000. In order to help us comprehend this staggering probability, Stoner illustrates it by supposing that "we take 1017 silver dollars and lay them on the face of Texas. They will cover all of the state two feet deep. Now mark one of these silver dollars and stir the whole mass thoroughly, all over the state. Blindfold a man and tell him that he can travel as far as he wishes, but he must pick up one silver dollar and say that this is the right one. What chance would he have of getting the right one? Just the same chance that the prophets would have had of writing these eight prophecies and having them all come true in any one man."

Stoner considers 48 prophecies and says, "We find the chance that any one man fulfilled all 48 prophecies to be 1 in 10157, or 1 in 10,00,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000, 000,000,000,000,000, 000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000, 000, 000,000,000,000,000,000,000, 000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 000,000,000." 1

The resurrection

Christ's resurrection from the dead is the basis for our faith (1 Cor. 15:14). To somehow disprove the resurrection would destroy the entire foundation of Christianity. On the other hand, proving it as an actual historical event establishes the Christian faith throughout all ages.

There are several legitimate evidences for Christ's resurrection: the empty tomb; multitudes of eyewitnesses; the outpouring of the Holy Spirit on the day of Pentecost; miracles performed by the apostles; the silence of critics. Without going into detail about each of these, it is sufficient to say that these provide ample evidence for Christ's resurrection as an historical event. And His resurrection proves that He is the only way to God because He is the only man to win the victory over death.

The most reasonable world view

It just makes sense that for a religion to be true then it must answer the crux of life's spiritual questions such as the creation, death, sin, righteousness, and love. But not only should it address the spiritual but also the issues of daily life like family, marriage, divorce, money, work, politics and ministry. No other religion touches on so many areas of life than the Bible.

I know a lady who is diligently seeking the one true religion among many. Along with my wife witnessing to her about Christ, she is also being pursued by a Muslim who gave her a Koran. One day she read in it that it is acceptable for a man to beat his wife. This really turned her off to that religion and rightly so. We need to recognize that the Bible portrays men and women in their proper roles and gives dignity to both.

Conclusion

Some people try to test God by stating that if He is real then why does He not just show Himself or else give us overwhelming evidence of His existence and His will. Actually, God is not obligated to give us anything at all. It is His own prerogative to do as He pleases. But He did choose to show Himself to us in the Person of His Son Jesus Christ. He said, "He who has seen Me has seen the Father" (John 14:9). And in order that we would have strong faith, He gave us not only sufficient evidence but also overwhelming evidence of Him. All the evidence we need is right there in Scripture and mankind is left without excuse.

ALL of the examples of prophecy you just used are in the Bible. This is the equivalent of a work of fantasy in which we witness the making of a prophecy in the first chapter, then its fulfilling in the climax. It is not convincing in the slightest.
As for the "no other religion touches on so many areas of life" bit, bull.

yes, i think it is just.

How could a GOD of love possibly send people to Hell?

http://www.freedomministries.org.uk/masters/hell.htm

Consider some of the reasons why God cannot let everyone go to Heaven. He cannot open Heaven to everyone, firstly, because He is holy. God is sublime in majesty and holiness - He is perfect. We, on the other hand, are full of pride, greed selfishness and callousness. We are full of back-biting, whispering, gossiping, cheating and lying; not to mention sensual deeds and thoughts.

But God is a holy God. There is not the slightest imperfection in His character and conduct. Through all eternity God will never change, never deteriorate or disappoint.

Non sequiter: God being holy while we are not does not mean that he cannot accept us.

While as a God of love He is pained by the eternal banishment we bring upon ourselves, yet He hates sin and will never tolerate or co-exist with it. We cannot, at the end of this life be admitted into His eternal presence, unless we have first searched for His forgiveness and been converted.

Or he could simply abolish sin. 'Cause, y'know, he's omnipotent. And omnibenevolent. Why does he not simply wash everyone free of sin upon death, if he truly loves them all without bounds?

Consider also this second reason why God cannot admit unforgiven, unconverted people to Heaven. If God did admit us to Heaven in our sinful condition (which He cannot do), we would not be able to endure it, not even for a few seconds.

With our polluted minds and hearts, we would be utterly destroyed by the holiness of God. It would be a situation similar to a dazzling light which is impeded by some obstruction, so that a shadow is cast. Take the obstruction away, and at once the shadow is destroyed. It cannot endure the light.

Bare assertion.

Then, consider this third reason why God cannot let unforgiven sinners into Heaven. If God did allow us in as sinners (which He will not), and if His presence by some chance did not destroy us (which it would(, then Heaven would not be Heaven any longer.

Would almighty God, the sovereign landlord of the universe, the Kind of kings and Lord of lords, the Holy One, allow Heaven to become like earth? Would He really let hordes of rebellious enemies, selfish, self-seeking, proud, wilful, sensual, gossiping, stealing, lying, cheating, fighting worldlings into Heaven?

And yet, if these people did not have these faults, would they really be human? If there is no sin in Heaven, is there freedom? Or is everyone in Heaven a mindless drone?

why ? where does my logic fail ?

Everywhere.
 
I certainly wouldn't have learned the physics necessary to get my B.Sc. in Mechanical Engineering.

if you learned physics, you should know this....

http://www.scribd.com/doc/3925361/Strobel-Lee-The-Case-for-a-Creator

page 183

• The Evidence of Physics
One of the most striking discoveries of modern science has been that the laws and constants of physics unexpectedly conspire in an extraordinary way to make the universe habitable for life. For instance, said physicist-philosopher Robin Collins, gravity is finetuned to one part in a hundred million billion billion billion billion billion.
The cosmological constant, which represents the energy density of space, is as precise as throwing a dart from space and hitting a bulls-eye just a trillionth of a trillionth of an inch in diameter on Earth. One expert said there are more than thirty physical or cosmological parameters that require precise calibration in order to produce a universe that can sustain life.
Collins demonstrated that chance cannot reasonably account for this "anthropic principle" and that the most-discussed alternativethat there are multiple universes-lacks any evidential support and ultimately collapses upon the realization that these other worlds would owe their existence to a highly designed process.
This evidence was so powerful that it was instrumental in Patrick Glynn abandoning his atheism. "Today the concrete data point strongly in the direction of the God hypothesis," he said. "It is the simplest and most obvious solution to the anthropic puzzle."

• The Evidence of Astronomy

Similar to the fine-tuning of physics, Earth's position in the universe and its intricately choreographed geological and chemical processes work together with exquisite efficiency to create a safe place for humans to live.
For example, astronomer Guillermo Gonzalez and science philosopher Jay Wesley Richards said it would take a star with the highly unusual properties of our sun-the right mass, the right light, the right age, the right distance, the right orbit, the right galaxy, the right location-to nurture living organisms on a circling planet. Numerous factors make our solar system and our location in the universe just right for a habitable environment.
What's more, the exceptional conditions that make life possible also happen to make our planet strangely well-suited for viewing and analyzing the universe and our environment. All of this suggests our planet may be rare, if not unique, and that the Creator wanted us to be able to explore the cosmos.
"If the universe had not been made with the most exacting precision we could never have come into existence," said Harvard-educated astrophysicist John A. O'Keefe of NASA. "It is my view that these circumstances indicate the universe was created for man to live in."
 
if you learned physics, you should know this....

http://www.scribd.com/doc/3925361/Strobel-Lee-The-Case-for-a-Creator

page 183

• The Evidence of Physics
One of the most striking discoveries of modern science has been that the laws and constants of physics unexpectedly conspire in an extraordinary way to make the universe habitable for life.

Well, I guess that's why there's so much of it, isn't it?

For instance, said physicist-philosopher Robin Collins, gravity is finetuned to one part in a hundred million billion billion billion billion billion.

Fine-tuned to what, exactly?

The cosmological constant, which represents the energy density of space, is as precise as throwing a dart from space and hitting a bulls-eye just a trillionth of a trillionth of an inch in diameter on Earth.

And altering it does what? How do you measure how fine-tuned it is?

One expert said there are more than thirty physical or cosmological parameters that require precise calibration in order to produce a universe that can sustain life.

And his evidence for this is?

Collins demonstrated that chance cannot reasonably account for this "anthropic principle" and that the most-discussed alternativethat there are multiple universes-lacks any evidential support and ultimately collapses upon the realization that these other worlds would owe their existence to a highly designed process.

No, they wouldn't. And yes, chance could very well account for them. Texas sharpshooter fallacy again.

• The Evidence of Astronomy

Similar to the fine-tuning of physics, Earth's position in the universe and its intricately choreographed geological and chemical processes work together with exquisite efficiency to create a safe place for humans to live.

Well, given the size of the universe, and the number of galaxies/stars/planets in it, at least one of them is practically guaranteed to fall within the necessary parameters for life to form.

For example, astronomer Guillermo Gonzalez and science philosopher Jay Wesley Richards said it would take a star with the highly unusual properties of our sun-the right mass, the right light, the right age, the right distance,

All of which are really only important if you take into account the distance of the planet in question. The mass of the star alters the orbits of the planets, which would alter their distance from it, but it does not mean that it would be impossible to have a planet orbiting the right distance away.

the right orbit,

Orbit around what?

the right galaxy,

:confused:

the right location

Distance again.

-to nurture living organisms on a circling planet. Numerous factors make our solar system and our location in the universe just right for a habitable environment.

Again, given the size of the universe, it had to happen somewhere.

What's more, the exceptional conditions that make life possible also happen to make our planet strangely well-suited for viewing and analyzing the universe and our environment.

No.

All of this suggests our planet may be rare, if not unique, and that the Creator wanted us to be able to explore the cosmos.
"If the universe had not been made with the most exacting precision we could never have come into existence," said Harvard-educated astrophysicist John A. O'Keefe of NASA. "It is my view that these circumstances indicate the universe was created for man to live in."

And he is wrong.
 
For A:
It does not logically follow, because if the universe came about uncaused, then it could have a beginning without having a cause.

http://www.debate.org/debates/The-Kalam-Cosmological-Argument-for-the-Existence-of-God-is-Sound/1/

The first premise is relatively uncontroversial, and is rooted in the metaphysical principle that out of nothing, nothing comes. The denial of the first premise, although strictly logically possible, is metaphysically unactualizable. By definition, nothing has no potentialities. Thus, it is impossible for something to arise out of nothing, for how can its existence be actualized if the potential is not there? [3] The truth of the causal premise is additionally supported by our everyday experience. If the causal premise were false, then it is quite odd as to why we don't observe things coming into existence uncaused and out of nothing in our everyday experience. Presumably, nobody lives their life worrying about the possibility of an elephant suddenly appearing out of nothing in their living room. Writes Craig:

"Why is it only universes that can come into being from nothing? What makes nothingness so discriminatory? There cannot be anything about nothingness that favors universes, for nothingness does not have any properties. Nothingness is the absence of anything whatsoever. As such, nothingness can have no properties, since there literally is not anything to have any properties. Nor can anything constrain nothingness, for there is not anything to be constrained." [4]


It also does not follow because if the universe simply always was, but time had a beginning, then the universe would have been since the beginning of time, and therefore would not have a cause.

http://www.debate.org/debates/The-Kalam-Cosmological-Argument-for-the-Existence-of-God-is-Sound/1/

the existence of an actual infinite (See my OP for a definition of what an actual infinite is) is impossible because inverse operations of mathematics involving actual infinites entail contradictory answers. For example, what is infinity minus infinity? Well, you get contradictory answers. Therefore, the existence of an actual infinite is metaphysically impossible. If the universe had existed for eternity, then its past duration would have been actually infinite. Since actual infinities are impossible, the past duration of the universe must have been finite. According to the second law of thermodynamics, had the universe been existing for eternity, it would have attained maximum entropy buildup. However, since the universe has not attained maximum entropy buildup, it cannot have been eternal.


For B, and for C:
It does not logically follow, because if the universe had a cause, the thing that caused the universe could very well have a cause as well.

http://www.philapologia.org/blog/

How about an infinite series of causes? Even if this were true, it would not explain why there exists anything at all. You still have an infinite chain of contingent facts and therefore the “contingent infinite” itself needs an explanation! It follows that there must be a sufficient explanation that lies outside this casual chain of contingent facts. A necessary being seems to be the best explanation (from 2).We now have something that is “necessary” but what is it exactly?

It must be beyond the universe because anything that is physical or material has a prior cause and cannot be necessary. Therefore, this being transcends space and time which leaves us with two categories – either it’s an abstract object (like numbers) or it is a mind. However, all abstract objects do not have a casual relationship, otherwise, it’s not abstract! Therefore, the only explanation is an immaterial mind which has been commonly referred to as God.
 
Actually, where has anyone seen Gibhor's logic? All I have seen are spammed cut-and-paste jobs from other sources, nothing seems to be original with him/her.


Agreed. I don't recall seeing him/her express an original thought yet.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom