Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
it depends on further evidence. The cosmological argument does not give a hint WHICH God might be the cause of all created.

No, it doesn't even give the slightest hint about the nature of your precious "cause." Or about the nature of the "causing" that presumably happens.

All it does is give you the illusion that you knew something, the illusion that you were somehow 'smarter' as per the conclusion of the cosmological 'arguments,' the illusion that you now made sense of stuff.

Pffffffffffffffffft ... Gimme a cosmological arguement, let all the premises be true, and let the conclusion follow. Now ... Now what?
 
When I opened my eyes I was about seven, there has been no time that I have closed them again, except to sleep.

Gee daddy, why is the sky blue?

Daddy: because god made it that way.

Gee daddy, how do birds fly?

Daddy: because god made it so they could.

Gee daddy, why does the sun go down?

Daddy: because god made the day and night and wanted it that way.

Gee daddy, I like talking to you, I learn so much.

Daddy: because god wanted it that way.


Paul

:) :) :)
 
Last edited:
there is no right or wrong interpretation of the scientific data, as long as there is no conclusive proofs. One day, when you die, you will know, if my God exists or not. Unfortunately, if i am right, you wrong, you will encounter yourself in hell, since this is was happens to unbelievers.

And if you chose the wrong religion and end up in some other believer's hell?
 
Well, you are free to close your eyes, and not think about the evidence, and what it tells you. I would call that behavior willfull ignorance. If that satisfies you, shall it be.... ;)

What does the evidence tell you? How about you just attempted to describe that to me (and other people) so I (and other people) can partake of these fantastic conclusion, so I (and other people) can partake of the wonderful sense it all now makes? (Instead of all ... this *points to the thread*)
 
it depends on further evidence. The cosmological argument does not give a hint WHICH God might be the cause of all created.

*IF* you accept the Comsological Argument as valid (which we don't, but just pretend), then it doesn't even give any hint that this creating thing would be any version of anyone's god. It could be a non-sentient gigantic mushroom, for all the argument tells us.

Yet you not only accept the argument's validity, you think that it must be proving the existence of a god, and not just any god, but the big-G God of Christianity. That's quite an impressive leap of logic there.

Do you understand why those leaps are not justified?



there is no right or wrong interpretation of the scientific data, as long as there is no conclusive proofs. One day, when you die, you will know, if my God exists or not. Unfortunately, if i am right, you wrong, you will encounter yourself in hell, since this is was happens to unbelievers.

Maybe I choose to believe in a God who rewards our using the cool brains that he gave us, and will torture you forever for believing anything you're told without critical examination. My version of God is at least as likely as your version, actually it seems way way way more likely. So - before it's too late! - reject this path of credulousness, you're endangering your eternal soul!
 
A number of adages come to mind. My favorite is one my father in law has on a plaque in his office. It says: "When you're up to your ass in alligators, it is difficult to remember that your original objective was to drain the swamp."

Your intention here is to illuminate us with your theories,

what theories ? i do not present any theories. Just my faith, and the reasons that back up my faith.

but in practice you've opened up a war on something like twelve fronts at once.

A war ? Why a war ? I think that comment shows only, that you have already made up your mind, and do not want to change, despite the evidence in contrary.

Oh sure, there's been some piling on, but this has been significantly exacerbated by the fact that so much of what you say is wrong

prove it.


and your method of dealing with that isn't productive is the least.

its not productive for you, since it does not fit into your preconceived beliefs.
for me, its VERY productive, since it backs up my faith.

You need to address each point one at a time to everyone's satisfaction before rushing to your conclusion.

we have concentrated on the kalaam argument. And i still do not think anyone of you guys have a better explanation for the existence of our universe, than God ( whatever God that was , is secondary at the moment ).

You need to acknowledge valid criticism.

Only if i consider it valid. So far, i don't think it is convincing.

" I don't know " is no answer at all ( despite i think, a deductive rational conclusion is possible based on the already collected scientific data ) , and : " the universe can pop up uncaused, through virtual particles " , does not convince me, based on the presented objections.

You need to stop quoting vast passages of cobbled together quotes from other people and presenting them as "evidence".

why ?

You need to acknowledge obvious inconsistencies, as when you take statements from people like Hawking out of context and make them do things Hawking would never approve of. (Given Hawkings own tendencies, this is especially bad.) Mostly though, you need to stop repeating things that have been effectively been put in doubt as if they haven't and then wondering why everyone is so excited about it.

all we are arguing about, is the evidence that leads to the conclusion, the universe had to have a absolute beginning. If you do not like that i mention Hawking, i can mention Vilenkin, Paul Davies, and many other scientists, which share the same conclusion. Its based on very solid scientific evidence.

I am not free to think anything -- I'm bound by logic and honesty.

I think you are biased as all others here. Thats what you transmit.

Do I screw those up? Sure, but never on purpose. Knowledge is not a choice.

the questions we are talking about however, can never be answered with conclusive proves, thus, no " knowledge " will be obtained. We discuss philosophycal issues, which do permit different conclusions, of which however, some are reasonable, others less.

You sitting here and telling us that no one has bother to try to explain to the flaws in your thinking is a complete and utter copout.

i don't think i have said that. Actually, a lot of people have not been able to bring up a better explanation than God to the questions made.

There are presently 14 pages of people telling you the flaws in your thinking.

so what ? the opinion of the majority wins ? do you think, i expected all to hand clapping to my arguments ? i did not.

In the face of a steep learning curve, you've evidently decided to put your head down and focus on what you'd prefer to be the case, rather than do the hard thing and acknowledge your own ignorance. No doubt you think this is persecution.

BS.

The religious are like pigeons playing chess -- they swoop down, knock over all the pieces, **** on the board, and then fly home and declare victory.

i know that. Its insulting.
 
It does not follow that the universe was caused from the fact that it had a beginning.
It does not follow that if there was a cause, that it would be uncaused. It does not even follow that if there was a cause, and you wish to avoid infinite regress, that that cause must have been uncaused.

That the universe requires yet another entity to create it does not follow from "do not multiply entities unnecessarily".

These laws you're coming up with are not supported by anything save your own preconception that they must be true, which in turn is based on the very thing you're trying to prove. You're begging the question.

i am not trying to prove anything....
 
we have concentrated on the kalaam argument. And i still do not think anyone of you guys have a better explanation for the existence of our universe, than God ( whatever God that was , is secondary at the moment ).

You don't have an explanation. You have the illusion of an explanation (AKA "God").

If you disagree, you can always explain stuff. Or at least attempt to, for a change.
 
what theories ? i do not present any theories. Just my faith, and the reasons that back up my faith.
Faith does not equal Truth.

Faith is used for the unknown, and should be dropped like a hot potato when knowledge is learned.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
I well understand it. But i am not willing to prove anything. Capiche.

Then WTF are you doing here?


but in practice you've opened up a war on something like twelve fronts at once.
A war ? Why a war ? I think that comment shows only, that you have already made up your mind, and do not want to change, despite the evidence in contrary.

English isn't your first language, is it?
 
this one, for example :

http://www.big-bang-theory.com/

First of all, we are reasonably certain that the universe had a beginning.
Second, galaxies appear to be moving away from us at speeds proportional to their distance. This is called "Hubble's Law," named after Edwin Hubble (1889-1953) who discovered this phenomenon in 1929. This observation supports the expansion of the universe and suggests that the universe was once compacted.
Third, if the universe was initially very, very hot as the Big Bang suggests, we should be able to find some remnant of this heat. In 1965, Radioastronomers Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson discovered a 2.725 degree Kelvin (-454.765 degree Fahrenheit, -270.425 degree Celsius) Cosmic Microwave Background radiation (CMB) which pervades the observable universe. This is thought to be the remnant which scientists were looking for. Penzias and Wilson shared in the 1978 Nobel Prize for Physics for their discovery.
Finally, the abundance of the "light elements" Hydrogen and Helium found in the observable universe are thought to support the Big Bang model of origins.

The extreme fine-tuning of the universe

http://elshamah.heavenforum.com/ast...e-extreme-fine-tuning-of-the-universe-t31.htm

1) If our universe is random, then it is very unlikely that it permits life.
(2)Our universe permits life.
(3)Therefore,the existence of our universe is very likely due to something other than chance.

1. The fine-tuning of the universe is due either to physical necessity, chance, or design.
2. It is not due to physical necessity or chance.
3. Therefore, it is due to design.

Fred Hoyle
(British astrophysicist)

“A common sense interpretation of the facts suggests that a superintellect has monkeyed with physics, as well as with chemistry and biology, and that there are no blind forces worth speaking about in nature. The numbers one calculates from the facts seem to me so overwhelming as to put this conclusion almost beyond question.”

The fine-tuning of our earth and solar system

http://elshamah.heavenforum.com/ast...tuning-of-our-earth-and-solar-system-t180.htm

the axial tilt of the Earth
the rotational period of the Earth
the Earth's crust thickness
Earth's gravity and interaction with the moon
CO2 and ozone levels in the atmosphere
oxygen/nitrogen ratio in the atmosphere
the mass and size of the Earth
and about a 70 more special factors

If any one of these conditions were slightly higher or lower, life on Earth would cease to exist. For example, the Earth is at a very specific distance from the sun. Malcolm Bowden says, "If it were 5% closer, then the water would boil up from the oceans and if it were just 1% farther away, then the oceans would freeze, and that gives you just some idea of the knife edge we are on." Dr. Duane Gish says, "If the Earth's diameter were 7,200 miles, instead of 8,000, then almost the whole Earth, due to a lessening of the atmospheric mantle, would be reduced to snow and ice waste."

All of which proves that evolution fits us to our niche.
 
If you take it granted, that uncaused things can appear and pop up into existence from absolutely nothing, then you might be right.

I am beginning to suspect that you are being deliberately obtuse. I do not take as granted any such thing. That is not what is being described at all. You have a completely fallacious and overly simplistic concept of space/time. There is no time before the Big Bang. The universe did not "pop up into existence from absolutely nothing" because there simply is no outside to the universe (for the pedants with a firmer grasp of cosmology than GIBHOR, I'm not complicating the argument with ideas about bubble universes or a multiverse at this point). Outside the universe there is no time, no space, technically there isn't even any "nothing". I do not yet believe that this concept is beyond your capacity for comprehension, but I do get the impression that you are choosing not to understand it rather than let it threaten your desired beliefs.
 
there is no right or wrong interpretation of the scientific data, as long as there is no conclusive proofs. One day, when you die, you will know, if my God exists or not. Unfortunately, if i am right, you wrong, you will encounter yourself in hell, since this is was happens to unbelievers.

I will not encounter anything. Death is the end of experiences, thoughts.

The afterlife isn't a possibility without some sort of system where somehow people are copied and subjected to some sort of judging ordeal--which would be absurdly cruel if it were a real possibility. Fortunately, it isn't.

This life is all we have, all we know.

It might be satisfying to punish people who don't believe as you do, so I see the attractiveness of the doctrine.

Also, group solidarity couldn't exist without uniform beliefs, so I see the utility.
 
Sure. The universe is caused, since it had a beginning.
It does not follow that the universe was caused from the fact that it had a beginning.
the cause had to be uncaused, otherwise there woule be eternal regress of causes, which is not plausible.
It does not follow that if there was a cause, that it would be uncaused. It does not even follow that if there was a cause, and you wish to avoid infinite regress, that that cause must have been uncaused.
And goes against Occams Razor.
That the universe requires yet another entity to create it does not follow from "do not multiply entities unnecessarily".

These laws you're coming up with are not supported by anything save your own preconception that they must be true, which in turn is based on the very thing you're trying to prove. You're begging the question.
i am not trying to prove anything....
What does the fact that you're not trying to prove anything have to do with the following claims?:
  • That the universe having a beginning means it has a cause
  • That the universe having a cause means that the cause must be uncaused
  • That if the universe has a cause and that cause is not uncaused, then this means there is infinite regress (e.g., God could not have created two branes that collided to form the universe?)
  • That all of the above is supported by Occam's razor ("entia non sunt multiplicanda praeter necessitatem")
...and that fact that none of the above follows?
 
there is no right or wrong interpretation of the scientific data, as long as there is no conclusive proofs. One day, when you die, you will know, if my God exists or not. Unfortunately, if i am right, you wrong, you will encounter yourself in hell, since this is was happens to unbelievers.

The problem with Pascal's Wager is that it also applies to you. If you are worshiping the wrong god then you too may be subject to its capricious wrath. You yourself may find yourself in someone else's hell. That's what makes it a fallacious argument.
 
GIBHOR, why did you not begin this thread by stating that you simply have a strong belief in your personal god and no lack of evidence would sway you otherwise? Would have saved a lot of bother.
 
*IF* you accept the Comsological Argument as valid (which we don't, but just pretend), then it doesn't even give any hint that this creating thing would be any version of anyone's god. It could be a non-sentient gigantic mushroom, for all the argument tells us.

the Universe was not. And then it came to be. Since there was no physical need , the universe to come into existence, there had to be a decision, to bring the universe into existence, thus e personal being.

There are, however, good reasons to believe that the cause of the universe was a personal cause with attributes that closely resemble a monotheistic conception of God.

http://www.debate.org/debates/The-Kalam-Cosmological-Argument-for-the-Existence-of-God-is-Sound/1/

Firstly, it must be noted that since there is nothing prior to the cause of the universe, it cannot be explained scientifically, as this would imply the existence of antecedent determining conditions. Hence, because there are no prior determining conditions, the cause of the universe must be personal and uncaused. Moreover, the cause must transcend space both matter and time to create both matter and time. It must also be changeless, since there was no time prior to the creation of the universe. Interestingly enough, this also lends credibility to the notion that the cause was personal, for how else could a timeless cause give rise to a temporal effect? It seems that the only way this could be possible is if the cause was a free agent who has the ability to effect a change; for if the cause of the universe was impersonal, then it would not have created. Finally, in order to create the universe ex nihilo, this cause must be enormously powerful, if not omnipotent. One is warranted in concluding that therefore, God exists.

Yet you not only accept the argument's validity, you think that it must be proving the existence of a god, and not just any god, but the big-G God of Christianity. That's quite an impressive leap of logic there.

Do you understand why those leaps are not justified?

as said, the cosmological argument does not evidence which specific God. But it had to be a transcendent, bodyless, timeless spirit. This description correlates perfectly with the way, the bible describes God :

http://www.everystudent.com/journeys/who2.html

Before the mountains were born or you brought forth the earth and the world, from everlasting to everlasting you are God. (Psalms 90:2)

No one has ever seen God, but God the One and Only, who is at the Father's side, has made him known. (John 1:18)

Where can I go from your Spirit? Where can I flee from your presence? If I go up to the heavens, you are there; if I make my bed in the depths, you are there. (Psalms 139:7)

"I am God, and there is none like me. I make known the end from the beginning, from ancient times, what is still to come. I say: My purpose will stand, and I will do all that I please." (Isaiah 46:10)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom