The first premise is relatively uncontroversial, and is rooted in the metaphysical principle that out of nothing, nothing comes.
Calling the principle uncontroversial and metaphysical is merely begging the question.
The denial of the first premise, although strictly logically possible, is metaphysically unactualizable.
And by what means does the metaphysical unactualizability lead to your knowing about this rule? You didn't
observe anything about it, and you didn't logically
infer it.
By definition, nothing has no potentialities. Thus, it is impossible for something to arise out of nothing, for how can its existence be actualized if the potential is not there?
You're repeating your reification of zero. But I can be repetitive too. So let's go over the joke proof again:
1. A dime is better than nothing
2. Nothing is better than heaven
3. Therefore, a dime is better than heaven
And again, I'll distinguish between "nothingness" and "no thing (including nothingness)" to show you how to understand the flaw:
1. A dime is better than nothing nothingness
2. Nothing No thing (including nothingness) is better than heaven
3. Therefore, a dime is better than heaven
In this form you can clearly see the error. 3 doesn't follow in this syllogism, because "nothingness" is not the same as "no thing (including nothingness)".
Now let's apply this to the universe, again. We'll start with there being a beginning of time.
1. No thing, including nothingness, existed before T=0
Now let's apply your metaphysical rule:
2. Nothingness has no potentialities (to begin to exist)
3. Therefore, the universe was created.
It's the same error. As you see, in 1, there was never a metaphysical "nothingness". So 2 doesn't really apply to anything 1 established. A dime isn't better than heaven after all.
[3] The truth of the causal premise is additionally supported by our everyday experience.
No it's not, because our everyday experience deals with transformations, which deal with creativity, not formation ex nihilo. I've discussed this before too, but I can repeat myself just as good as you can ignore it and repeat your error.
Your artists paint using things that are already there. Your musician uses energy that's already there. Your party planner goes and collects party favors and games that are already there. In none of these cases do we have causation of being. We simply do not observe causation of being in our everyday lives. Furthermore, those are only one of many classes of things we observe that are transformations. We also see snow, formed by meterological events; diamonds, formed by geological processes, and potassium, formed by cosmic processes.
You're making up a law that extrapolates beyond the things it properly applies to. You cannot infer from energy flowing from one form to another that energy must have a cause. Quite the opposite--the law of conservation of energy suggests that energy is always conserved.
If the causal premise were false, then it is quite odd as to why we don't observe things coming into existence uncaused and out of nothing in our everyday experience.
It's not so odd when you consider virtual particles doing this very thing. But even so, you cannot infer something from a lack of information. Even the virtual particles don't convey enough information to say if the question of causation of big bang even makes sense to ask. Wait for the information to come in before making up your answers.
Presumably, nobody lives their life worrying about the possibility of an elephant suddenly appearing out of nothing in their living room.
This is an appeal to authority.
But, sure. I don't worry about elephants suddenly appearing out of nothing in my living room. But I don't commit a reification of zero error either. Nor do I worry about elephants suddenly being divinely created in my living room. To suggest that this means more than what it does is sophistry.
"Why is it only universes that can come into being from nothing?
There is your reification of zero again (well, properly, it's your appeal to authority fallacy, and Craig's reification of zero, but I digress). You're confusing the word "nothing" used in two completely different ways--you're making a dime better than heaven. "No thing (including nothingness)" is not "nothingness".
I explained this to you before. I don't mind repeating it though. But please actually try to comprehend this before rebutting. At the very least, address it. Otherwise, you're not really demonstrating your case--rather, you're demonstrating that you're ignoring everything wrong with your argument.
the existence of an actual infinite ... is impossible because inverse operations of mathematics involving actual infinites entail contradictory answers.
Wrong. You either get an answer, or it's undefined, or it's indeterminate. It's never contradictory.
Were it contradictory, mathematics would be inconsistent. And if one thing in a mathematical system is inconsistent, everything is (see principle of explosion
WP). Fortunately for mathematicians, you're the one that's wrong.
Besides, none of this is relevant, since "always was" doesn't mean "for an infinite amount of time", but rather, "for every point in time". And the best evidence is that time began.
For example, what is infinity minus infinity?
The difference of two infinite quantities is indeterminate.
Well, you get contradictory answers.
No you don't. You get an indeterminate.
If the universe had existed for eternity,
...which is eternity used in a different sense (and note I used the words "always was" rather than eternity anyway)...
then its past duration would have been actually infinite.
Sure. That implication would actually be true.
How about an infinite series of causes?
What about it? Your claim was that if the universe was caused, its cause must be uncaused. I only need one counterexample to show the claim false. I chose one that should be very easy for even you to swallow--God creates two branes (ref M-theory
WP), and the branes cause the universe. In this example, the cause of the universe--branes--would be caused. That's a direct violation of your claim, which was that the cause of the universe must be uncaused.
And nothing precludes this possibility, logically speaking, or evidentially speaking.
Even if this were true, it would not explain why there exists anything at all.
Sure. But that doesn't actually imply anything further, for a number of reasons.
First and foremost, you were the one that claimed that if the universe was caused, its cause must be uncaused. What I was doing was refuting that this rule was true. If you recognize that it's false, you should discard it. If you forsee a different rule that is true, put it forth. That an alternative doesn't explain anything has absolutely nothing to do with the fact that your claim turned out to be wrong--you can't use a wrong rule just because you don't see an explanation in an alternative. Wrong is wrong is wrong.
Second, if God created everything, then that doesn't explain why there exists anything at all either. In this case, all you have is the illusory answer "because God did it". But you still don't know
why God did it, how God did it, or why there is a
God at all to begin with. In fact, it's a much bigger problem for God to simply be there in the first place than it is for the universe to simply be there in the first place--after all, if you can't imagine what a finite universe would be doing here, why then wouldn't an
infinitely complex God be an
infinitely greater problem? (And furthermore, you just got through arguing that an actual infinite was impossible--even if that were true, wouldn't God be an actual infinite?)
You still have an infinite chain of contingent facts
...and here you go rebutting something that was never put onto the table. And why would you do that?
The only reason I could imagine is that you're basically "telemarketing" your way through a script I'm not following, rather than being rational. The next step in your flowchart is to refute the infinite chain? Or is this because you want to brag that you know the term "contingently infinite", perhaps? You're certainly not rebutting anything I said here.
It must be beyond the universe because anything that is physical or material has a prior cause and cannot be necessary.
You have absolutely nothing to support that formulation ex nihilo is like that. The law of conservation of energy is our only observed law concerning the creation of potentially
ontological physical entities, and
that law has the total amount being preserved throughout time. Which is precisely
not what you need to demonstrate.
Therefore, this being transcends space and time which leaves us with two categories – either it’s an abstract object (like numbers) or it is a mind.
This is a black and white fallacy anyway.
It does not
logically follow that such a cause must either be an abstract object or a mind, because it could be a physical object or principle that
in itself transcends time.
It does not
evidentially follow that such a cause must either be an abstract object or a mind, because no observation rules out that it could be a physical object or principle that transcends time.
But regardless, you are trying to win by default by refuting an assertion not made. This is not rational.
However, all abstract objects do not have a casual relationship, otherwise, it’s not abstract! Therefore, the only explanation is an immaterial mind which has been commonly referred to as God.
This is a pattern of yours. You present a black and white fallacy, putting what you can't imagine to be true on one side, and declaring what is essentially God on the other side, and you declare those two things to be the
only two possibilities. Then you attempt to argue against the thing you can't imagine, and conclude that therefore it must be God.
This fails because you don't actually ever seriously consider whether or not the things you present really
are the only possibilities, nor do you ever seriously consider the alternative you present. And you don't do this because, emotionally, all you want is to win by default.
But the very reason you have to try to argue your case like this is very suspiciuos. Can't you support your God case, by
supporting it? Why is it that the only means you have of supporting it is to present what you believe to be absurd alternatives and attack those? This pattern is more reminiscent of someone trying to rationalize--trying to fool themselves--than it is someone trying to discover what's true.