Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
repetitive is the asking of proves. i don't have any. and i am not here to present any...

Then why is this thread called "Evidence of God's existence"? Why did you present the Kalam cosmological argument, which is an attempted logical PROOF of your god's existence?
 
Scientific Evidence Grows that Mind and Brain Are Separate!
The mind and brain are one in the same. No where is real science is it anything else, stop quoting religious sites.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
...Is the biochip the mark of the beast to be used by the antichrist?
...the true mark of the beast will be easily introduced to the world by the antichrist.
...one world government headed by the antichrist.

What is this 'antichrist' to which you refer? Anyone with even a passing knowledge of the bible would know that there is no such character. The only time the bible uses the term 'anitchrist' it refers to groups of people who are literally anti-christ, as in against christ. There is no big bad boogie man 'antichrist' in the bible.
 
five good reasons to think that God exists:

1. God makes sense of the origin of the universe.

2. God makes sense of the fine-tuning of the universe for intelligent life.

3. God makes sense of objective moral values in the world.

4. God makes sense of the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.

5. God can be immediately known and experienced.

Maibe we start with nr.1

The Kalam Cosmological Argument
Umm, I don't think this is the right way to start. God wouldn't reveal something so important as the way He started the universe to an atheist. That's why the Big Bang theory was first proposed by Belgian Roman Catholic priest Georges Lemaitre back in 1920s.
 
yes, i think it is just.

How could a GOD of love possibly send people to Hell?

<righteous justification snipped

Uh yes, infinite punishment for finite crime. If you truly believe that for no other reason than not loving or believing in god that I deserve infinite punishment, please confirm this....if your morality is actually this corrupt, than I'm better off not participating.

While you're thinking about that, your post and a reponse to that post has pointed out the "problem of evil". The existance of satan, hell, human suffering, evil, disease, earthquakes etc necessarily means that your god character is either not omnibenevolent or not omnipotent. I would greatly appreciate it if you indicated which you believe he is not.
 
It sounds like you're saying that there may be hidden characteristics just below the surface of our understanding of QM, and these non-random, causal (but hidden) variables are responsible. But the idea of hidden variables has been pretty decisively shown to be false. Things really are, fundamentally, random and without cause.


No. Atomic decay is fundamentally a random process.

I don't think we're going to end up agreeing on this. :)

Philosophically (admittedly a bad lead-in for an opinion on science), I have a very strong aversion to the idea that anything can ever be truly random. Rather, I think that any sufficiently noisy system would be indistinguishable from it.

I'm not prepared (and by "prepared", I mean educated well enough in the relevant physics topics) to really defend my opinion here. And I'll do you and my personal integrity the courtesy of not cut-n-pasting random (!) quotes from people who happen to agree with me in the hopes that you'll buy some of it. I've never taken a physics class in my life (and that includes high school), let alone graduate-level quantum physics classes required to truly appreciate a good journal article on the topic. I mean, I'm generally science literate, have read a great deal about physics, and have taken advanced classes like cell biology, chem, and organic chem and done well. But as Feynman said "Anyone who says that they understand Quantum Mechanics does not understand Quantum Mechanics." It's funny because it's true. ;)

That said, I do have a few reasons for thinking this. First and foremost, I think it's by far the more simple "explanation". That might seem odd, since it invokes a "hidden system", but consider that in every single aspect of reality we've ever encountered in the history of humanity encountering things has had an underlying cause. Positing a genuinely random (and therefore uncaused) phenomenon therefore represents an extreme departure from the ordinary. As such, I feel that extraordinary evidence is warranted before determining for certain that there isn't one -- evidence better than "we haven't found it", at least.

Second, on the topic of "hidden systems", quite a lot of systems are in fact missing, aren't they? We don't have any well-developed explanations for gravity. Or time. Or universal expansion -- except that it's happening. Or "dark energy" repulsion -- except that repulsion seems to be happening. The only thing rivaling humanity's unparalleled advances in physics knowledge is humanity's current ignorance of same. Even theories we do have are fraught with problems of their own, are incompatible with other ones, or are just plain unfalsifiable.

Third, so much of these supposedly random events are driven by predictable circumstances. We have no problem with the idea of "virtual" particle pairs because they solve problems for us and help us understand fields. We call the occurrences random, and perhaps they appear that way, but can we discount the fact that their production is predictable, as with Hawking radiation? Any anything about atomic decay be considered genuinely "random" when its progress can be predicted and it only happens in one direction? All of this seems to me a little like shaking a bottle of Mountain Dew up and marveling about the "random and spontaneous" appearance of bubbles. What kind of "random process" obeys rules?

This isn't an argument from ignorance (though no doubt in it) or a "hidden systems of the gaps"-style argument I'm trying to make. Not intentionally. My point is, we know there are factors that are missing -- things we don't understand. We know that our models don't necessarily describe reality, but are only a reflection of what we can or have observed. Necessarily, quantum physics is driven mostly by statistics. But statistics is a mathematical tool, not an observation. According to quantum physics, there is a chance that the Mountain Dew bottle from above, fizzing away, could vanish and reappear in the next room. Riiiiight. I think there is an inherent delusion at work when we accept that something like that could happen just because a given set of equations that fits a model that may or not be correct says it can.

It's as if everything we understand are cats. And we bring the cats in at night. And even though we know there are other other animals out there beyond the house that we haven't been able to catch and catalog, and because we know where the cats are, we insist that the garbage is spontaneously and randomly rearranging itself all over our driveways all by itself without cause.

Well, I think a better explanation might be those raccoons or bears in the nearby woods. That, to me, is the state of quantum physics in a nutshell. It's one thing to pull a god out of the woodwork because we're ignorant of some aspect of reality. But it's quite another to insist that something as long-standing and ubiquitous as causation is turned on its ear on the strength of the same when we know for a fact that there are still major observations we cannot account for with present knowledge.

But like I said, I'm not really prepared to defend that. ;)
 
The first premise is relatively uncontroversial, and is rooted in the metaphysical principle that out of nothing, nothing comes.
Calling the principle uncontroversial and metaphysical is merely begging the question.
The denial of the first premise, although strictly logically possible, is metaphysically unactualizable.
And by what means does the metaphysical unactualizability lead to your knowing about this rule? You didn't observe anything about it, and you didn't logically infer it.
By definition, nothing has no potentialities. Thus, it is impossible for something to arise out of nothing, for how can its existence be actualized if the potential is not there?
You're repeating your reification of zero. But I can be repetitive too. So let's go over the joke proof again:
1. A dime is better than nothing
2. Nothing is better than heaven
3. Therefore, a dime is better than heaven​
And again, I'll distinguish between "nothingness" and "no thing (including nothingness)" to show you how to understand the flaw:
1. A dime is better than nothing nothingness
2. Nothing No thing (including nothingness) is better than heaven
3. Therefore, a dime is better than heaven​
In this form you can clearly see the error. 3 doesn't follow in this syllogism, because "nothingness" is not the same as "no thing (including nothingness)".

Now let's apply this to the universe, again. We'll start with there being a beginning of time.
1. No thing, including nothingness, existed before T=0​
Now let's apply your metaphysical rule:
2. Nothingness has no potentialities (to begin to exist)
3. Therefore, the universe was created.​
It's the same error. As you see, in 1, there was never a metaphysical "nothingness". So 2 doesn't really apply to anything 1 established. A dime isn't better than heaven after all.
[3] The truth of the causal premise is additionally supported by our everyday experience.
No it's not, because our everyday experience deals with transformations, which deal with creativity, not formation ex nihilo. I've discussed this before too, but I can repeat myself just as good as you can ignore it and repeat your error.

Your artists paint using things that are already there. Your musician uses energy that's already there. Your party planner goes and collects party favors and games that are already there. In none of these cases do we have causation of being. We simply do not observe causation of being in our everyday lives. Furthermore, those are only one of many classes of things we observe that are transformations. We also see snow, formed by meterological events; diamonds, formed by geological processes, and potassium, formed by cosmic processes.

You're making up a law that extrapolates beyond the things it properly applies to. You cannot infer from energy flowing from one form to another that energy must have a cause. Quite the opposite--the law of conservation of energy suggests that energy is always conserved.
If the causal premise were false, then it is quite odd as to why we don't observe things coming into existence uncaused and out of nothing in our everyday experience.
It's not so odd when you consider virtual particles doing this very thing. But even so, you cannot infer something from a lack of information. Even the virtual particles don't convey enough information to say if the question of causation of big bang even makes sense to ask. Wait for the information to come in before making up your answers.
Presumably, nobody lives their life worrying about the possibility of an elephant suddenly appearing out of nothing in their living room.
This is an appeal to authority.

But, sure. I don't worry about elephants suddenly appearing out of nothing in my living room. But I don't commit a reification of zero error either. Nor do I worry about elephants suddenly being divinely created in my living room. To suggest that this means more than what it does is sophistry.
"Why is it only universes that can come into being from nothing?
There is your reification of zero again (well, properly, it's your appeal to authority fallacy, and Craig's reification of zero, but I digress). You're confusing the word "nothing" used in two completely different ways--you're making a dime better than heaven. "No thing (including nothingness)" is not "nothingness".

I explained this to you before. I don't mind repeating it though. But please actually try to comprehend this before rebutting. At the very least, address it. Otherwise, you're not really demonstrating your case--rather, you're demonstrating that you're ignoring everything wrong with your argument.
the existence of an actual infinite ... is impossible because inverse operations of mathematics involving actual infinites entail contradictory answers.
Wrong. You either get an answer, or it's undefined, or it's indeterminate. It's never contradictory.

Were it contradictory, mathematics would be inconsistent. And if one thing in a mathematical system is inconsistent, everything is (see principle of explosionWP). Fortunately for mathematicians, you're the one that's wrong.

Besides, none of this is relevant, since "always was" doesn't mean "for an infinite amount of time", but rather, "for every point in time". And the best evidence is that time began.
For example, what is infinity minus infinity?
The difference of two infinite quantities is indeterminate.
Well, you get contradictory answers.
No you don't. You get an indeterminate.
If the universe had existed for eternity,
...which is eternity used in a different sense (and note I used the words "always was" rather than eternity anyway)...
then its past duration would have been actually infinite.
Sure. That implication would actually be true.
How about an infinite series of causes?
What about it? Your claim was that if the universe was caused, its cause must be uncaused. I only need one counterexample to show the claim false. I chose one that should be very easy for even you to swallow--God creates two branes (ref M-theoryWP), and the branes cause the universe. In this example, the cause of the universe--branes--would be caused. That's a direct violation of your claim, which was that the cause of the universe must be uncaused.

And nothing precludes this possibility, logically speaking, or evidentially speaking.
Even if this were true, it would not explain why there exists anything at all.
Sure. But that doesn't actually imply anything further, for a number of reasons.

First and foremost, you were the one that claimed that if the universe was caused, its cause must be uncaused. What I was doing was refuting that this rule was true. If you recognize that it's false, you should discard it. If you forsee a different rule that is true, put it forth. That an alternative doesn't explain anything has absolutely nothing to do with the fact that your claim turned out to be wrong--you can't use a wrong rule just because you don't see an explanation in an alternative. Wrong is wrong is wrong.

Second, if God created everything, then that doesn't explain why there exists anything at all either. In this case, all you have is the illusory answer "because God did it". But you still don't know why God did it, how God did it, or why there is a God at all to begin with. In fact, it's a much bigger problem for God to simply be there in the first place than it is for the universe to simply be there in the first place--after all, if you can't imagine what a finite universe would be doing here, why then wouldn't an infinitely complex God be an infinitely greater problem? (And furthermore, you just got through arguing that an actual infinite was impossible--even if that were true, wouldn't God be an actual infinite?)
You still have an infinite chain of contingent facts
...and here you go rebutting something that was never put onto the table. And why would you do that?

The only reason I could imagine is that you're basically "telemarketing" your way through a script I'm not following, rather than being rational. The next step in your flowchart is to refute the infinite chain? Or is this because you want to brag that you know the term "contingently infinite", perhaps? You're certainly not rebutting anything I said here.
It must be beyond the universe because anything that is physical or material has a prior cause and cannot be necessary.
You have absolutely nothing to support that formulation ex nihilo is like that. The law of conservation of energy is our only observed law concerning the creation of potentially ontological physical entities, and that law has the total amount being preserved throughout time. Which is precisely not what you need to demonstrate.
Therefore, this being transcends space and time which leaves us with two categories – either it’s an abstract object (like numbers) or it is a mind.
This is a black and white fallacy anyway.

It does not logically follow that such a cause must either be an abstract object or a mind, because it could be a physical object or principle that in itself transcends time.

It does not evidentially follow that such a cause must either be an abstract object or a mind, because no observation rules out that it could be a physical object or principle that transcends time.

But regardless, you are trying to win by default by refuting an assertion not made. This is not rational.
However, all abstract objects do not have a casual relationship, otherwise, it’s not abstract! Therefore, the only explanation is an immaterial mind which has been commonly referred to as God.
This is a pattern of yours. You present a black and white fallacy, putting what you can't imagine to be true on one side, and declaring what is essentially God on the other side, and you declare those two things to be the only two possibilities. Then you attempt to argue against the thing you can't imagine, and conclude that therefore it must be God.

This fails because you don't actually ever seriously consider whether or not the things you present really are the only possibilities, nor do you ever seriously consider the alternative you present. And you don't do this because, emotionally, all you want is to win by default.

But the very reason you have to try to argue your case like this is very suspiciuos. Can't you support your God case, by supporting it? Why is it that the only means you have of supporting it is to present what you believe to be absurd alternatives and attack those? This pattern is more reminiscent of someone trying to rationalize--trying to fool themselves--than it is someone trying to discover what's true.
 
Last edited:
Are we doing the Black Knight bit from Monty Python and the Holy Grail?

That's been the image going through my mind too. At least the Black Knight had the honesty to finally concede he had been comprehensively delimbed. Like many we see debating on JREF, you can be sure he won’t even concede a flesh wound.
 
The existance of satan, hell, human suffering, evil, disease, earthquakes etc necessarily means that your god character is either not omnibenevolent or not omnipotent. I would greatly appreciate it if you indicated which you believe he is not.
Well, when not talking about God, GIBHOR says that an actual infinite is impossible because it leads to contradictions.

But I suppose when talking about God, suddenly it becomes possible and non-contradictory, in such a way that it also doesn't contradict this principle.
 
if you learned physics, you should know this....

<snip drivel>


Are you ever actually going to reply to my point, or should I just expect further nonsensical and non-relevant ramblings copied from other sources?



Oh, and for the record: Elizabeth I was not asking for proofs, she was showing where you attempted to make an argument using circular logic.
This, I figure, is a misunderstanding based on language issues (English does not appear to be your native tongue, in which case: congratulations on having learned a second (or more) language) and thus I figured I should point that out. Just so you know for next time.
 
Thanks yy2bggggs, I think that I'm learning something....I mean, my brain hurts so some learnin' must be going on, right?

Seriously though, these forums are a genuine education.
 
It's more frightening than funny to see how some thinkers are so mentally subordinate to the Roman Catholic Church and its notion of God's personality that they try to fit into their philosophical schemes. Their search for God's hand is based on an assumption that the Church is correct in its attributes. You can't make a mistake like that and hope to get anywhere.
 
The Condemnation of the Unrighteous

1:18 For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of people39 who suppress the truth by their40 unrighteousness,41 1:19 because what can be known about God is plain to them,42 because God has made it plain to them. 1:20 For since the creation of the world his invisible attributes – his eternal power and divine nature – have been clearly seen, because they are understood through what has been made. So people43 are without excuse. 1:21 For although they knew God, they did not glorify him as God or give him thanks, but they became futile in their thoughts and their senseless hearts44 were darkened. 1:22 Although they claimed45 to be wise, they became fools.

this is true today , more than ever before.

Revelation 21.8 :

To the one who is thirsty I will give water13 free of charge14 from the spring of the water of life. 21:7 The one who conquers15 will inherit these things, and I will be his God and he will be my son. 21:8 But to the cowards, unbelievers, detestable persons, murderers, the sexually immoral, and those who practice magic spells,16 idol worshipers,17 and all those who lie, their place18 will be in the lake that burns with fire and sulfur.19 That20 is the second death.”

34that48is99no77justification105for66infinite76punishment54for43finite34"sins"11
 
Why is christianity the only true religion ?

The Mathematical Odds of Jesus Fulfilling Prophecy

http://elshamah.heavenforum.com/bib...e-christianity-the-only-true-religion-t96.htm

"The following probabilities are taken from Peter Stoner in Science Speaks (Moody Press, 1963) to show that coincidence is ruled out by the science of probability. Stoner says that by using the modern science of probability in reference to eight prophecies, ‘we find that the chance that any man might have lived down to the present time and fulfilled all eight prophecies is 1 in 1017." That would be 1 in 100,000,000,000,000,000. In order to help us comprehend this staggering probability, Stoner illustrates it by supposing that "we take 1017 silver dollars and lay them on the face of Texas. They will cover all of the state two feet deep. Now mark one of these silver dollars and stir the whole mass thoroughly, all over the state. Blindfold a man and tell him that he can travel as far as he wishes, but he must pick up one silver dollar and say that this is the right one. What chance would he have of getting the right one? Just the same chance that the prophets would have had of writing these eight prophecies and having them all come true in any one man."

Stoner considers 48 prophecies and says, "We find the chance that any one man fulfilled all 48 prophecies to be 1 in 10157, or 1 in 10,00,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000, 000,000,000,000,000, 000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000, 000, 000,000,000,000,000,000,000, 000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 000,000,000." 1

Don't you just love self-fulfilling prophecies? I know I do...

The resurrection

Christ's resurrection from the dead is the basis for our faith (1 Cor. 15:14). To somehow disprove the resurrection would destroy the entire foundation of Christianity. On the other hand, proving it as an actual historical event establishes the Christian faith throughout all ages.

Whoa, hold your horses! When was the resurrection proved? Or even Jesus' existence for that matter?

There are several legitimate evidences for Christ's resurrection: the empty tomb; multitudes of eyewitnesses; the outpouring of the Holy Spirit on the day of Pentecost; miracles performed by the apostles; the silence of critics. Without going into detail about each of these, it is sufficient to say that these provide ample evidence for Christ's resurrection as an historical event. And His resurrection proves that He is the only way to God because He is the only man to win the victory over death.

Oh yeah, Bible references, invisible spirit-sighting, unproven "miracles" provide ample evidence... NOT.

The most reasonable world view

It just makes sense that for a religion to be true then it must answer the crux of life's spiritual questions such as the creation, death, sin, righteousness, and love. But not only should it address the spiritual but also the issues of daily life like family, marriage, divorce, money, work, politics and ministry. No other religion touches on so many areas of life than the Bible.

Would you care to tell me the Bible's position on slavery? Child-beating? Contraception? Blood transfusions? Stoning? I didn't think so...

I know a lady who is diligently seeking the one true religion among many. Along with my wife witnessing to her about Christ, she is also being pursued by a Muslim who gave her a Koran. One day she read in it that it is acceptable for a man to beat his wife. This really turned her off to that religion and rightly so. We need to recognize that the Bible portrays men and women in their proper roles and gives dignity to both.

Proper roles? Dignity? That's tough, even for you.

Conclusion

Some people try to test God by stating that if He is real then why does He not just show Himself or else give us overwhelming evidence of His existence and His will. Actually, God is not obligated to give us anything at all. It is His own prerogative to do as He pleases. But He did choose to show Himself to us in the Person of His Son Jesus Christ. He said, "He who has seen Me has seen the Father" (John 14:9). And in order that we would have strong faith, He gave us not only sufficient evidence but also overwhelming evidence of Him. All the evidence we need is right there in Scripture and mankind is left without excuse.

Which is it? Please try to stay coherent for a few sentences at least.
 
I well understand it. But i am not willing to prove anything. Capiche.

Then you misuse the word "evidence". Capische?

Or in the words of Inigo Montoya, "You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means."
 
Now let's apply this to the universe, again. We'll start with there being a beginning of time.
1. No thing, including nothingness, existed before T=0​
Now let's apply your metaphysical rule:
2. Nothingness has no potentialities (to begin to exist)
3. Therefore, the universe was created.​
It's the same error. As you see, in 1, there was never a metaphysical "nothingness".

In fact, since we exist, there could never be a metaphysical nothingness, or no thing ( however you want, i don't understand your differenciation anyway ). Therefor , something had to exist : God. If you think, it was not God, you need to present a better explanation, and cause of our unverse. Anything in mind ?

But that does not mean, there is a physical need of always something to exist.
It could very well be, that absolutely nothing were, then, never something would come into existence.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom