Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
When you posted "heath death" the first time, I thought it was a typo. The second time, I thought you were copying/pasting from something with a typo. But then you post "heath" a third time with different wording: "the energy would be already transformed in heath." Now I don't think it was a typo, I think you're posting stuff from other places that you haven't the slightest clue what the words mean. Do you think that the universe would become a field of heather?!?
I was about to comment on this extremely peculiar pattern as well, in my reply, until I noticed that he referred independently to some entity called "heath", which I presume is related somehow to warmt.
 
My assumption was that after he cut and pasted everything to his "virtual library", he then accidentally performed a massive search and replace on that word. But perhaps he was really affected by the death of Heath Ledger.
 
It seems you don't get the point. If energy is eternal, we would at this moment already be in a state of heath death, because of the second law of thermodynamics. The energy would be there, since it cannot be destroyed, but it would not be able to fuel our universe in the way we could live in. The energy would be already transformed in heath, which is not usable to sustain life.

The point to be got is yours to get. The universe can be finite and yet have no origin, no creation. Again, read Hawking. He explains it in A Brief History of Time. You might also benefit from reading Michio Kaku's Hyperspace.
 
I can give you lots of reasons, but a picture says a thousand words:

Flying_Spaghetti_Monster_2-thumb-514x514.jpg


Come on... you're so close. Just a few more baseless assertions...
god.jpg

Yes. It's that funny.
 
without the ressurrection of christ, there would not be any christianity, as we know it today.

http://www.tektonics.org/lp/nowayjose.html

That a god would descend to the realm of matter and suffer in this ignominious fashion "ran counter not only to Roman political thinking, but to the whole ethos of religion in ancient times and in particular to the ideas of God held by educated people." (10, 4) Announcing a crucified god would be akin to the Southern Baptist Convention announcing that they endorsed pedophilia. >{?If Jesus had truly been a god, then by Roman thinking, the Crucifixion should never have happened. Celsus, an ancient pagan critic of Christianity, writes:

But if (Jesus) was really so great, he ought, in order to display his divinity, to have disappeared suddenly from the cross.
This comment represents not just some skeptical challenge, but is a reflection of an ingrained socio-theological consciousness. The Romans could not envision a god dying like Jesus - period. Just as well to argue that the sky is green, or that pigs fly, only those arguments, at least, would not offend sensibilities to the maximum. We need to emphasize this (for the first but not the last time) from a social perspective because our own society is not as attuned as ancient society to the process of honor.

http://www.thinkingchristian.net/C278308471/E20060628222403/index.html

1. After his crucifixion Jesus was buried by Joseph of Arimathea in a tomb.
2. On the Sunday after the crucifixion, Jesus' tomb was found empty by a group of his women followers.
3. On different occasions and under various circumstances different individuals and groups of people experienced appearances of Jesus alive from the dead. [Not all of these scholars accept these as experiences of an embodied and glorified Christ, in accord with Biblical theology; some would view them as hallucination or as spiritual visions.]
4. The original disciples suddenly and sincerely came to believe that Jesus was risen from the dead despite their having every predisposition to the contrary.

These are accepted by scholars for basically the same two reasons in each case: they are multiply-attested by independent sources; and they are unexpected, even embarrassing facts for the early church, unlikely to have been made up as part of a Christ story.

No. There's no reason to assume that the resurrection ever occured, unless you believe the bible to be true and accurate, which it is demonstrably not the case. If you have some good reason and/or evidence of the resurrection, present it over on the thread "Evidence for why we know the New Testament writers told the truth", 200+ pages, 8500+ posts and still no evidence - surely you have some? (The other thread that was already mentioned - was jesus ressurected - is younger and may be more applicable, your choice).
 
As you may have noticed with GIBHOR, I don't accept references and quotes from experts as evidence, let alone references to threads in forums in which none of your opponents would agree you'd won. It's nothing personal, and I don't mean to be insulting by that. It's just that I don't accept anyone's word for anything, let alone things with which I disagree. My personal take on being a skeptic requires that I defend my ideas in my own words to the greatest degree possible and I expect the same from people who wish to convince me otherwise.

Um, I was suggesting you read the thread, not adopt it.

And quotes from experts are evidence.
 
No, but your whole objection - "life can't exist in the center of the sun" - is.

You think it can? Is there a tea cup floating around Jupiter, perhaps?

Let's be clear, I'm a bit of an idealist, and I think that quite a few things are possible. That's why assigning an epistemic value to a belief can be useful. How possible is it?
What value do you give to the hypothesis "Life exists in the sun's core"?
Between 0 and 1, with .5 being the default agnostic position (sounds kinky).

One of the objections to the fine-tuning argument has been that the universe is a remarkably hostile place for life. But now there are people saying life could exist in the center of stars? On Pluto? In Saturn's Rings? So is the claim now that maybe the universe is a very hostile place? Maybe it's teeming with exotic life?

I think we need another poll...
 
No, but your whole objection - "life can't exist in the center of the sun" - is.

My objection is actually there is no evidence life exists in the center of the sun and plenty of evidence that it doesn't.

Do you dispute this?
 
You think it can? Is there a tea cup floating around Jupiter, perhaps?

Nice try, but that doesn't work. It's entirely possible that Russell's Teapot does exist, but the whole point is that we don't believe it without evidence. I'm not saying that life does exist in the center of the sun. I'm saying that it's possible. And no, there is no evidence to the contrary. There is evidence that life similar to Earth's life could not live in the center of the sun.

Let's be clear, I'm a bit of an idealist, and I think that quite a few things are possible. That's why assigning an epistemic value to a belief can be useful. How possible is it?
What value do you give to the hypothesis "Life exists in the sun's core"?
Between 0 and 1, with .5 being the default agnostic position (sounds kinky).

One of the objections to the fine-tuning argument has been that the universe is a remarkably hostile place for life. But now there are people saying life could exist in the center of stars? On Pluto? In Saturn's Rings? So is the claim now that maybe the universe is a very hostile place? Maybe it's teeming with exotic life?

I think we need another poll...

And again, that is not the point. The point is that life, no matter where it forms or what the conditions are, will always see a place with conditions that allowed it to form.
 
No, but your whole objection - "life can't exist in the center of the sun" - is.

I don't think so. Everything we know about life tells us it could not survive the core of the sun. One could imagine a potential life form that could exist there but we don't have any evidence to prove it is actually there. That's not incredulity, that's reasonable extroplation from currently available data.
 
That isn't a very well worded description. It is overly simplified and can lead to misconceptions such as yours. You are still conceptualizing the universe as existing inside of something else: a great eternity of empty space.

i have not said that.

But there is no eternity without time. Modern cosmology strongly suggests that the universe my be self contained. When they say that there is nothing beyond the Big Bang they mean it in the most profound way imaginable: no space, no matter, no energy, no time.

exactly. thus the universe had a absolute beginning.
 
When you posted "heath death" the first time, I thought it was a typo. The second time, I thought you were copying/pasting from something with a typo. But then you post "heath" a third time with different wording: "the energy would be already transformed in heath." Now I don't think it was a typo, I think you're posting stuff from other places that you haven't the slightest clue what the words mean. Do you think that the universe would become a field of heather?!?


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_death_of_the_universe

The heat death is a possible final thermodynamic state of the universe, in which it has "run down" to a state of no thermodynamic free energy to sustain motion or life. In physical terms, it has reached maximum entropy. The hypothesis of a universal heat death stems from the 1850s ideas of William Thomson, 1st Baron Kelvin who extrapolated the theory of heat views of mechanical energy loss in nature, as embodied in the first two laws of thermodynamics, to universal operation.
 
The point to be got is yours to get. The universe can be finite and yet have no origin, no creation. Again, read Hawking. He explains it in A Brief History of Time. You might also benefit from reading Michio Kaku's Hyperspace.

i have answered this already.

http://elshamah.heavenforum.com/ast...ng-no-boundary-proposal-why-it-fails-t202.htm

The Hartle and Hawking No-Boundary Proposal why it fails

Hawking’s no-boundary proposal. Others point to Stephen Hawking’s no-boundary proposal for space-time as an alternative to a beginning and a Beginner. Carl Sagan said that Hawking’s proposal is about "the absence of God." But when I asked Stephen Hawking himself about it, he told me: "I do not believe the no-boundary proposal proves the nonexistence of God, but it may affect our ideas of the nature of God." The question Hawking raises is this: Is God’s nature such that He is merely related to the beginning of the universe? Or is He related to the universe as a whole?

The "imaginary time" of Hawking’s proposal would not eliminate God, but only the deist’s weak notion of a God who winds up the universe and then lets it go. In his no-boundary model, Hawking told me, "We do not need someone to light the blue touch paper of the universe." But even a universe without a hard beginning does not necessarily result in a universe with nothing for a Creator to do, for there is apparently more to running our universe than merely igniting it in a big bang.

From a biblical perspective, Christians agree that it is even more in God’s nature to be the ruler of the universe than to be the mere initiator of it. The Bible tells us that everything in the universe is subject to the upholding power of God and could not exist on its own (Hebrews 1:3 and Colossians 1:15-17). Physicist Robert Gange says that, according to quantum physics, any universe that lasts more than a Planck time (10-43 seconds) requires more than chance to explain it. Gange believes that quantum physics points to an outside sustainer, not merely an outside initiator.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom