Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
If we applied a sort of WAP [Weak Anthropic Principle] to the firing squad scenario, we could state the following: 'Of course you do not observe that you are dead, because if you were dead, you would not be able to observe that fact!' However, this does not stop you from being amazed and surprised by the fact that you did survive against overwhelming odds. Moreover, you would try to deduce the reason for this unlikely event, which was too improbable to happen by chance. Surely, the best explanation is that there was some plan among the marksmen to miss you on purpose. In other words, you are probably alive for a very definite reason, not because of some random, unlikely, freak accident."

Good point. One would expect there to be a reasonable explanation. I could presume that of the 100 marksmen, only one had a real bullet, and therefore only one marksmen missed me. Or I could presume the ever more likely scenario that a supernatural, bullet-eating invisible tasmanian devil appeared just as the shots were fired and intercepted all of the bullets before they hit me, letting out a smoke filled belch as it mysteriously disappeared. I would obviously believe the latter, because the other scenario would be just dumb luck.
 
Good point. One would expect there to be a reasonable explanation. I could presume that of the 100 marksmen, only one had a real bullet, and therefore only one marksmen missed me. Or I could presume the ever more likely scenario that a supernatural, bullet-eating invisible tasmanian devil appeared just as the shots were fired and intercepted all of the bullets before they hit me, letting out a smoke filled belch as it mysteriously disappeared. I would obviously believe the latter, because the other scenario would be just dumb luck.

personally I would instantly presume that I had suddenly become bullet proof and leg it as fast as possible before it wore off.
;)
 
personally I would instantly presume that I had suddenly become bullet proof and leg it as fast as possible before it wore off.
;)

Don't be absurd. Nobody is bullet proof ... well ... except supernatural, bullet eating, invisible tasmanian devils. Plus, you're probably tied to the pole.
 
I get what Malerin is doing now.

He is conflating the probability of the constants being what they are(we have no idea if it is even possible for them to be different, or what their possible ranges could be), with the probability that we observe apparent fine-tuning.

A. The probability that the constants turned out to be what they are could be VERY low, but we really don't know.

B. The probability that we observe apparent fine-tuning is 1. 100% chance.

He conflates A and B and appeals to the improbability of A, attempting to push those potentially very improbable numbers(again, we have no idea) off onto B for the sake of making his argument for fine-tuning.

How about you argue only about A and leave B out of it? Right, because you couldn't try to wedge in god!
 
Last edited:
I get what Malerin is doing now.
You only got that? That seems to be all theistic apologetics has left. They don't have any facts so all they can do is hide in the butt cracks of science or the realm of unfalsifiablity.
 
There's more than one?

O_o

1. "Before the big bang / what caused the big bang"
2. "Outside of the universe"
3. "Inside of the universe but very sneaky!"(you don't have perfect knowledge of everything neener neener)
4. "Quantum mechanical personal incredulity"

Those are the four extremely debatable gaps that apologists tend to work with nowadays.

I'm sure there are more.
 
1. "Before the big bang / what caused the big bang"
2. "Outside of the universe"
3. "Inside of the universe but very sneaky!"(you don't have perfect knowledge of everything neener neener)
4. "Quantum mechanical personal incredulity"

Those are the four extremely debatable gaps that apologists tend to work with nowadays.

I'm sure there are more.

Snark detector off, huh?

:cs:
 
The moral argument begins with the fact that all people recognize some moral code (that some things are right, and some things are wrong). Every time we argue over right and wrong, we appeal to a higher law that we assume everyone is aware of, holds to, and is not free to arbitrarily change. Right and wrong imply a higher standard or law, and law requires a lawgiver. Because the Moral Law transcends humanity, this universal law requires a universal lawgiver. This, it is argued, is God.

Oh, this is just priceless. Really. Special olympics kind of priceless ;)

Please, if you're going to use arguments boiling down to "_all_ people do X", the least you can do is read a bit of anthropology first. You might be surprised.

E.g., there are tribes in which being a murderer actually increases one's social status and likelihood to find a mate. And the Spartans had it as a rite of passage into adulthood to be sent off to murder a Helot or two (slaves) to keep them in line.

E.g., speaking of Spartans giving your newborn baby a bath in wine, to see if he/she dies of alcoholic shock or not, was actually mandatory. And if he survived, then the elders would decide if the baby isn't properly shaped and proportioned or if it is underweight, and would kill him/her if so.

E.g., most primitive tribes are engaged in endemic warfare, with attrition rates sometimes as high as 60%. Attacking your neighbours just because momentarily they have food and you don't, is perfectly good behaviour. The most "peaceful" tribes of American Indians for example, "only" attacked their neighbours about once a year.

E.g., kidnapping a woman and raping her is perfectly acceptable behaviour in war not only for primitive tribe, but it's in the OT too, it was a major cause of war for ancient Greeks, and Romans as late as the victory over the Teutones in the Battle of Aquae Sextiae in 102 BC demanded women as wifes as part of the reparation payment... even if they don't want it. (And they didn't. Those women commited mass-suicide.)

E.g., killing prisoners, sometimes slowly and painfully, was perfectly good behaviour for not only a lot of tribes, but the Azteks even built their whole warfare system around capturing instead of killing... so they can be properly sacrificed later.

E.g., attitude to homosexuality ranged across history from "OMG, die! die! die!", to accepted (ancient Greece and Rome, for example), to _mandatory_. Wrap your head around the last one. You heard that right. At least one tribe thought that a young male can't be fertile unless he gets the seed orally from an older male. And put severe limits on how often and where you can have sex with a woman, as a form of population control, but among the guys, hey, it was actually encouraged.

Etc.

So, please. The notion that there is some objective morals is already so much BS it could fertilize the whole mid-west. Taking it as proof of God only adds a complete nonsequitur to the falsehood.
 
It's not real in OUR reality. It can be real in a other dimension. For a flatlander, a tridimensional being is not real. He cannot perceive it, it is above HIS reality. But the tridimensional reality exists, despite that fact.
.................
You forget, that before the Big Bang, no forces did exist.
.................
I guess i am in good company with Hawking, Paul Davies, Penrose, Vilenkin, which all state that the universe had a absolute beginning.

I apologize for not making myself more clear in my last post. The problem here is that you're not appreciating all the equivocation going on with the concept of "universe". This isn't unusual since things like the Big Bang are usually explained either by people who don't understand it or who understand it so well they're unable to recognize when they haven't articulated it in a way that can be understood. Articulation is difficult for the best of us at any rate.

"Universe" has at least three common meanings. First, there is the overarching one that encompasses everything that exists. Second, there is the colloquial one, the one we use as a name for the observed or observable universe. Third is basically a reference to analogs of the second definition. You referenced Hawking, who you might recall wrote a book called Black Holes and Baby Universes. Consider the plural there. Clearly Hawking is a man who understands that our universe (like our galaxy, our star system, or our planet) is or at least could be one of many. And if you had a universe or two, where would you put them? Why, in the universe of course.

Confusing right? We need better terms. Commonly you see terms like megaverse or multiverse, but those are often associated with specific multidimensional theories. I prefer omniverse for that sort of universe that contains all others. For our own, it will suffice to just pedantically ensure we call it our universe. Bear in mind of course that none of this precludes clusters of universes and clusters of clusters of universes, etc., just like we have have for stars. Why not?

The upshot of all of this is that your explanations that do not take these distinctions into account all fail because of definitional and equivocation fallacies of logic. Since you're basing your deduction of your god's existence on logic, you'll want to be consistent with its rules.

Specifically, your claim that there was necessarily nothing before the Big Bang is wrong on several counts. First, as above you are conflating our universe with the omniverse, in which it is necessarily contained. Second, you don't know what the rules of the environment in which our universe is contained are, so making a deduction based on it doesn't make sense, except to say that it has rules, and those rules allowed for the Big Bang within it.

And lastly, Big Bang theory does not state that our universe or any other universe (let alone the omniverse!) came from nothing. Big Bang theory, being based on observations and understood laws of physics, concerns itself only with the moments after the big bang in question and afterward. It is predicted that the initial starting point was maybe the size of a basketball, or an apple, or a grape, or whatever, but it most certainly is stated that it was and thing, because currently understood physics isn't up to the task of understand what that might have been. (And making deductions based on ignorance isn't logical.)

It should also be noted that your comments about flatlanders and reality do not preclude deduction. I expect that was your point, but it's not accurate to say that a three dimension object "is not real" in a two dimensional universe. Such an object would certainly be detectable if it passed through, and analysis of all the outlines formed in its passing would allow the flatlanders to reconcile its true, three dimensional, shape. This works for dimensions within dimensions, universes within universes, but not omniverses within nothing. Logically, if the omniverse is all that exists, then anything outside the universe is by definition nonexistent. That was my point, and your own point doesn't speak to that.


So what. If that energy existed eternally, we would already be at heat death. But we are not. We are here. therefore, energy was created at a starting point, and is heading to max entropy, where no work can be done anymore, and heat death takes place.
..............
An infinite universe for example would exist in every direction forever, there could be nothing else, ONLY the universe. It is then very easy to understand why our universe cannot be infinite, it is because it is expanding. It cannot be both infinite and expanding. It could be infinite OR expanding, but CANNOT possibly be both, that is a contradiction in terms, and we do know it is expanding. For an explanation of the Big Bang and why we know the universe is expanding.
................
If you take the fossil record, you make also predictions, i.e. Evolution theory, for example. The same, we can take scientific data of the Big Bang , and make logical deductions.


I can see by your statements here that on some level you understood what I said in the first comments here but weren't fully appreciating it. While you're successfully concluding that, if true, our universe might be finite and have come from something, your conflation of terms prevented you seeing that it might have just come from some larger universe, not necessarily out of nothing at all.

In light of all this, your argument regarding our expanding universe fails. If the omniverse is infinite and our universe is expanding within it, there is no problem. Further, heat death is predicated on infinite expansion. That the universe is currently expanding does not imply that it must continue. In fact, infinite expansion would require infinite energy, would it not?

Now, again about logic. You're trying to make deductions, but you're still picking and choosing which rules to follow and which to ignore -- both in logic and in science. The laws of entropy and the laws of conservation are not in not in conflict, but you're speaking as if they were, and are in fact acting as if conservation laws don't exist at all. That's cherry picking and if you want this to be a logical discussion, you need to stop.
 
Last edited:
Oh, this is just priceless. Really. Special olympics kind of priceless ;)

Please, if you're going to use arguments boiling down to "_all_ people do X", the least you can do is read a bit of anthropology first. You might be surprised.

E.g., there are tribes in which being a murderer actually increases one's social status and likelihood to find a mate. And the Spartans had it as a rite of passage into adulthood to be sent off to murder a Helot or two (slaves) to keep them in line.

E.g., speaking of Spartans giving your newborn baby a bath in wine, to see if he/she dies of alcoholic shock or not, was actually mandatory. And if he survived, then the elders would decide if the baby isn't properly shaped and proportioned or if it is underweight, and would kill him/her if so.

E.g., most primitive tribes are engaged in endemic warfare, with attrition rates sometimes as high as 60%. Attacking your neighbours just because momentarily they have food and you don't, is perfectly good behaviour. The most "peaceful" tribes of American Indians for example, "only" attacked their neighbours about once a year.

E.g., kidnapping a woman and raping her is perfectly acceptable behaviour in war not only for primitive tribe, but it's in the OT too, it was a major cause of war for ancient Greeks, and Romans as late as the victory over the Teutones in the Battle of Aquae Sextiae in 102 BC demanded women as wifes as part of the reparation payment... even if they don't want it. (And they didn't. Those women commited mass-suicide.)

E.g., killing prisoners, sometimes slowly and painfully, was perfectly good behaviour for not only a lot of tribes, but the Azteks even built their whole warfare system around capturing instead of killing... so they can be properly sacrificed later.

E.g., attitude to homosexuality ranged across history from "OMG, die! die! die!", to accepted (ancient Greece and Rome, for example), to _mandatory_. Wrap your head around the last one. You heard that right. At least one tribe thought that a young male can't be fertile unless he gets the seed orally from an older male. And put severe limits on how often and where you can have sex with a woman, as a form of population control, but among the guys, hey, it was actually encouraged.

Etc.

So, please. The notion that there is some objective morals is already so much BS it could fertilize the whole mid-west. Taking it as proof of God only adds a complete nonsequitur to the falsehood.

those were the days.....
:D
 
You don't seem to comprehend that the probability of us observing a universe which allowed us to come into existence as observers, is 1. uno. ONE.

The Pr of any event (or evidence) that has already happened is 1. Again, I ask you if you could conclude anything from watching a video of a die landing 3 a hundred times in a row. Of course. You would conclude the die was biased, even though the event has already happened. This is because, counterfactually, you assign low odds to any fair die landing that many times in a row, even though it's already happened.

You aren't winning the lottery 100 times in a row, you aren't even winning on a 50/50 bet. It is impossible for you to lose this lottery.

Is it possible for Mercury not to have an eccentric orbit? If Pr Mercury's eccentric orbit = 1, then relatavity theory receieves no confirmation for "predicting" Mercury's orbit. But relatavity theory was confirmed by a tremendous degree by predicting evidence that had been known for many years. You're getting hung up on old evidence.

You are pretending that it is somehow improbable that we see a universe that displays apparent fine tuning, when in fact there is no possibility of us observing a universe that does not.

Is there a possibility of contemplating the success of a firing squad that kills you?

You are then affirming the consequent based on your erroneous interpretation of this probability.

1. If P(something fine tuned the universe) then Q(the universe appears fine tuned).
2. Q
3. Therefore P.

This is an obvious fallacy.

Good thing that's not the FT argument:

1. If the universe appears fine-tuned for life, it is reasonable to believe it was actually fine-tuned for life.
2. The universe appears fine-tuned for life
3. Therefore, it is reasonable to believe the universe was actually fine-tuned for life.

The FT argument is a probabilistic argument. It stars with the apparent fine-tuning of the physical constants, and looks for reasonable explanations for the apparent fine-tuning. There are two explanations:
1. Chance
2. Design

The objection that we can't evaluate the odds because our existence is contingent on the universe being a certain way fails completely with analogies like the sharpshooter analogy. If 100 people shoot at you and miss, you would naturally suspect something, even though your existence is contingent on them missing. Please, read up on the objections to the argument. I'm not going to keep arguing the same point. You and I both know you would be extremely surprised to find yourself alive after such a scenario.

Edit: I am not saying that you can't say that it is improbable that the constants are what they are, so long as you understand the possible range in which they could have fallen(which you don't).

We don't know if the constants are set or not (which really doesn't matter) But we can construct models of universes where the constants are changed by very small degress. Small changes invariably produce a universe where life as we know it could not exist. If you dispute this, you are going against a nearly universal scientific consensus.


I am saying that you cannot use the observation that "the universe appears remarkably fine tuned for me!" to reason backwards as to why it appears fine tuned, because it is NOT improbable that you observe apparent fine tuning.

We do this all the time: Hmmm, five royal flushes in a row seems remarkably suspicious.... I think the dealer is cheating! What do you think homicide detectives do? As a rule, they reason backwards from an event they know with certainty has already happened. "This crime scene appears remarkably staged"... perhaps because it was... actually staged? :eek:
 
The Pr of any event (or evidence) that has already happened is 1. Again, I ask you if you could conclude anything from watching a video of a die landing 3 a hundred times in a row. Of course. You would conclude the die was biased, even though the event has already happened. This is because, counterfactually, you assign low odds to any fair die landing that many times in a row, even though it's already happened.

<snip>

You don't seem to understand. It's hundreds of dice all being rolled at once, one time. Then you're pointing at the resultant combination of numbers and saying "What are the odds of that?"
In essence, it had to happen to someone. Why not us?
 
Good thing that's not the FT argument:

1. If the universe appears fine-tuned for life, it is reasonable to believe it was actually fine-tuned for life.
2. The universe appears fine-tuned for life
3. Therefore, it is reasonable to believe the universe was actually fine-tuned for life.

The FT argument is a probabilistic argument. It stars with the apparent fine-tuning of the physical constants, and looks for reasonable explanations for the apparent fine-tuning. There are two explanations:
1. Chance
2. Design

The objection that we can't evaluate the odds because our existence is contingent on the universe being a certain way fails completely with analogies like the sharpshooter analogy. If 100 people shoot at you and miss, you would naturally suspect something, even though your existence is contingent on them missing. Please, read up on the objections to the argument. I'm not going to keep arguing the same point. You and I both know you would be extremely surprised to find yourself alive after such a scenario.



We don't know if the constants are set or not (which really doesn't matter) But we can construct models of universes where the constants are changed by very small degress. Small changes invariably produce a universe where life as we know it could not exist. If you dispute this, you are going against a nearly universal scientific consensus.




We do this all the time: Hmmm, five royal flushes in a row seems remarkably suspicious.... I think the dealer is cheating! What do you think homicide detectives do? As a rule, they reason backwards from an event they know with certainty has already happened. "This crime scene appears remarkably staged"... perhaps because it was... actually staged? :eek:

1. If life appears fine-tuned for the universe, it is reasonable to believe it was actually fine-tuned for the universe.
2. Life appears fine-tuned for the environment it finds itself in
3. Therefore, it is reasonable to believe that life was actually fine-tuned for the environment it finds itself in.

tah-dah.
 
1. If life appears fine-tuned for the universe, it is reasonable to believe it was actually fine-tuned for the universe.
2. Life appears fine-tuned for the environment it finds itself in
3. Therefore, it is reasonable to believe that life was actually fine-tuned for the environment it finds itself in.

tah-dah.

Sentient puddle much?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom