Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Because the rule which makes your god necessary is "everything needs a cause". If your god does not need a cause, then he is an exception to that rule, and you have therefore committed the special pleading fallacy.
[/QUOTE]

Note here that he posted the "Kalam" version of the Cosmological Argument, which has its special pleading built right into the premises.

Notice how the premise reads that "everything that begins to exist has a cause." They've responded to the idea that the regular ol' cosmological argument would imply that God himself needs a cause, by adding this bit of semantic trickery. The fact that they think it solves the problem with the argument just shows how poor they are at logic.
 
Note here that he posted the "Kalam" version of the Cosmological Argument, which has its special pleading built right into the premises.

Notice how the premise reads that "everything that begins to exist has a cause." They've responded to the idea that the regular ol' cosmological argument would imply that God himself needs a cause, by adding this bit of semantic trickery. The fact that they think it solves the problem with the argument just shows how poor they are at logic.

Oh, hey, I didn't even notice that.

Okay, GIBHOR, your entire argument is bunk. Go back to the drawing board and come back with another version.
 
Last edited:
There are absolutely no empirical observations supporting creation ex nihilo.

leaderu.com/offices/billcraig/docs/morriston.html


"creation out of nothing is at least as counterintuitive as is beginning to exist without a cause."{9} Now there is no doubt that creatio ex nihilo is deeply baffling. I well recall thinking, as I began to study the kalam cosmological argument, that all of the alternatives with respect to the universe's existence––the infinitude of the past, creation ex nihilo, spontaneous origination ex nihilo ––were so bizarre that the most reasonable option seemed to be that nothing exists! Since our existence is, however, undeniable, we must settle, however uncomfortably, on one of the above three. Since we assume for the sake of argument in the present discussion the finitude of the past, our choices are creation ex nihilo or an uncaused origination ex nihilo. It seems to me that there is a very simple and yet decisive reason for preferring creation, namely, whereas creation ex nihilo is counter–intuitive in denying to the universe a material cause, it at least ascribes to it an efficient cause, whereas the spontaneous origination of the universe ex nihilo is doubly counter–intuitive in that it denies of the universe both a material and (especially) an efficient cause. Thus, even if one agrees with Morriston's observation, "When I do the relevant 'thought experiments,' I find the absence of a material cause at least as troubling as the absence of an efficient cause,"{10} one cannot agree with his objection, since an uncaused origin of the universe lacks both sorts of cause and so is doubly implausible.

This reasoning doesn't actually support your assertion. From a purely scientific viewpoint, the law of conservation of energy kicks in. Even when fuel is expended, energy is only ever transformed into other forms of energy. Our modern understanding is that mass is energy.

doesgodexist.org/JulAug06/TheLawsofThermodynamics.html

The second law says that like us, all stars and all galaxies will eventually die. The cosmos is not eternal, and there had to be a specific point at which there was no energy in an unusable form in the cosmos--no entropy. The biblical statement that there was a beginning is strongly attested to by the second law. We would like to point out that it is incorrect to apply the second law to the earth or to anything on the earth.

Now you do have less useful energy, but that doesn't help your argument, because you're trying to argue that something isn't eternal. But the law of conservation of energy betrays you.
Then why not save a step? If you have to have something that isn't created, why not the universe itself?

because all scientific evidence shows us , that the universe had a absolute beginning.

thekeyboard.org.uk/What%20is%20infinity.htm

Strictly speaking, according to Einstein's Theory of Relativity, a singularity does not contain anything that is actually infinite, only things that MOVE MATHEMATICALLY TOWARDS infinity. A black hole is formed when large stars collapse and their mass has been compressed down to a very small size and the powerful gravitational field so formed prevents anything, even light, from escaping from it. A black hole therefore forms a singularity at its centre from the concentrated mass of the collapsed star itself and from the accumulated mass that is sucked into it. A singularity's mass is therefore finite, the 'infinity' refers only to the maths.

Sticking your god there is quite an arbitrary thing to do. It's unnecessary and speculative. You're saying that god must be there in order to explain the universe because the universe cannot be there without this god. But your reasoning doesn't apply to the god in itself, because he's an exception.

elshamah.heavenforum.com/does-god-exist-origin-of-god-metaphysical-reality-f10/who-created-god-t77.htm

1. Whatever exists has a reason for its existence, either in the necessity of its own nature or in an external ground.
2. Whatever begins to exist is not necessary in its existence.
3. If the universe has an external ground of its existence, then there exists a Personal Creator of the universe, who, sans the universe, is timeless, spaceless, beginningless, changeless, necessary, uncaused, and enormously powerful.
4. The universe began to exist.
From (2) and (4) it follows that

5. Therefore, the universe is not necessary in its existence.
From (1) and (5) it follows further that

6. Therefore, the universe has an external ground of its existence.
From (3) and (6) it we can conclude that

7. Therefore, there exists a Personal Creator of the universe, who, sans the universe, is timeless, spaceless, beginningless, changeless, necessary, uncaused, and enormously powerful.
And this, as Thomas Aquinas laconically remarked,{67} is what everybody means by God.
 
that goes agianst all empirical observations. Everything from nothing is not reasonable. Actually, its complete b****s*****.
You are acting on a false dichotomy. "Everything from nothing" is not the only alternative to "God did it".

From a purely scientific standpoint, it is easy to demonstrate that matter cannot be eternal in nature. The universe is expanding from what appears to be a beginning point in space/time, which appears to be a one time event. Hydrogen is the basic fuel of the cosmos, powering all stars and other energy sources in space. If the fuel of the universe has been used eternally, that fuel will eventually be depleted; but the evidence is that the cosmological gas gauge, while moving toward “empty,” is yet a long way from being there—a condition incompatible with an eternal universe. The second law of thermodynamics insists that the cosmos is moving toward a condition of disorder, sometimes referred to as “heat death.” Even in an oscillating universe, things ultimately run out of energy and “die.” All of these evidences, and several others we have not made reference to, show that matter cannot be eternal,
The above is scientifically ignorant drivel.

If God is a being that is unlimited in time, and if He has access to every piece of time as if it were now, the question of who created God is an invalid question. The problem is like asking a student to draw a four-sided triangle. The terminology is self-contradictory.
When asked “Who or what created God?” we are making the assumption that God was created. If God exists outside of time and space, and if He is the Creator of time and space, He obviously was not created! God began the beginning! This is why He says, “I am Alpha and Omega, the beginning and the end, the first and the last” (Revelation 22:13).
God created time. The statement of Genesis, “In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth,” is making reference to the creation of time. The reason that things like heat death, the expansion of the universe, and the depletion of hydrogen do not apply to God is because He is outside of time. God has always been. He did things before time began (see 1 Corinthians 2:7). He not only began time; He will also end it. When time ends, all matter and all mankind will enter eternity—a timeless condition free of the negative things that time brings upon us now.
If God is whatever you want it to be...
 
"creation out of nothing is at least as counterintuitive as is beginning to exist without a cause."{9} Now there is no doubt that creatio ex nihilo is deeply baffling.

<snip>

Say it with me:

REPETITION DOES NOT EQUAL TRUTH. You are repeating what we have already debunked. Reasserting it does not make it any more valid. At all.
 
because all scientific evidence shows us , that the universe had a absolute beginning.
No, it does not. You really need to read more about the Big Bang cosmological models. There very likely is no "before" the Big Bang. As I pointed out before, only to be ignored, evidence suggests that the universe is both boundless and finite, like the surface of a sphere. It is very likely that "before the Big Bang" makes no more sense than "north of the North Pole".
 
To address your last point, you need to understand that what you're proposing as "outside the universe" and "outside time" is in essence, "outside reality". And of course, things that are outside reality is not real.

its not real in OUR reality. It can be real in a other dimension. For a flatlander,
a tridimensional being is not real. He cannot perceive it, it is above HIS reality. But the tridimensional reality exists, despite that fact.

If you'd like to retort to that and suggest that is merely outside "our reality", go right a head, but we can immediately posit the possibility of a natural, non-god-related forces that would accomplish the creation of the universe just the same. Your god solution remains unnecessary.

You forget, that before the Big Bang, no forces did exist.

To address your first point, you're cherry picking scientific lore. That same set of thermodynamic laws suggests that matter and energy cannot be created or destroyed, only converted from one form to the other. Heat death, therefore, is not a loss of energy.

So what. If that energy existed eternally, we would already be at heath death. But we are not. We are here. therefor, Energy was created at a starting point, and is heading to max entropy, where no work can be done anymore, and heath death takes place.

If it were, thermodynamic laws would be contradictory. Further, you're line of argument suggests that you have a rather primitive and naive understanding of Big Bang theory, which is understandable since that's the way it is always explained. All that theory does, however, is describe the observations. It in no way suggests that what we see is the entire universe. While you're certainly in good company, taking it any further than that is speculation only.

I guess i am in good company with Hawking, Paul Davies, Penrose, Vilenkin, which all state that the universe had a absolute beginning.

thekeyboard.org.uk/What%20is%20infinity.htm

An infinite universe for example would exist in every direction forever, there could be nothing else, ONLY the universe. It is then very easy to understand why our universe cannot be infinite, it is because it is expanding. It cannot be both infinite and expanding. It could be infinite OR expanding, but CANNOT possibly be both, that is a contradiction in terms, and we do know it is expanding. For an explanation of the Big Bang and why we know the universe is expanding. See The Big Bang Theory

In a similar maneuver, you're taking currently understood physical laws and principles, declaring them all that must exist and can be understood, and drawing conclusions from them. This is too hasty. As everyone else here has been telling you, all that can honestly be said is that we don't know.

If you take the fossil record, you make also predictions, i.e. Evolution theory, for example. The same, we can take scientific data of the Big Bang , and make logical deductions.

While suggesting that our observable universe might be only one of an infinite number of universes, or that we're a pimple on the "real" universe's face isn't any better than suggesting positing a god to explain an apparent finite status something like thermodynamics suggests, without more knowledge of how things work, it's difficult profess anything conclusively.

I do not profess any thing conclusively. I do just say, what i think is the best explanation based on the data on hand.
 
Say it with me:

REPETITION DOES NOT EQUAL TRUTH. You are repeating what we have already debunked. Reasserting it does not make it any more valid. At all.

you have not debunked any thing. just expressed your incredulity....
 
Why must every thread in the JREF Forum turn into a science discussion?

This is the Religion and Philosophy section. If God "makes sense" according to one's philosophy, it hardly makes sense to cite scientific evidence as an argument against that.


Though, I for one, would like to know what some of these "objective moral values" are.

And, how can "God can be immediately known and experienced"? Some of the lines I will grant to a believer. But, this claim seems to diminish faith as some sort of delusion.

elshamah.heavenforum.com/does-god-exist-origin-of-god-metaphysical-reality-f10/evidence-of-god-the-moral-argument-t186.htm

The moral argument begins with the fact that all people recognize some moral code (that some things are right, and some things are wrong). Every time we argue over right and wrong, we appeal to a higher law that we assume everyone is aware of, holds to, and is not free to arbitrarily change. Right and wrong imply a higher standard or law, and law requires a lawgiver. Because the Moral Law transcends humanity, this universal law requires a universal lawgiver. This, it is argued, is God.

In support of the moral argument, we see that even the most remote tribes who have been cut off from the rest of civilization observe a moral code similar to everyone else's. Although differences certainly exist in civil matters, virtues like bravery and loyalty and vices like greed and cowardice are universal. If man were responsible for that code, it would differ as much as every other thing that man has invented. Further, it is not simply a record of what mankind does—rarely do people ever live up to their own moral code. Where, then, do we get these ideas of what should be done? Romans 2:14-15 says that the moral law (or conscience) comes from an ultimate lawgiver above man. If this is true, then we would expect to find exactly what we have observed. This lawgiver is God.

To put it negatively, atheism provides no basis for morality, no hope, and no meaning for life. While this does not disprove atheism by itself, if the logical outworking of a belief system fails to account for what we instinctively know to be true, it ought to be discarded. Without God there would be no objective basis for morality, no life, and no reason to live it. Yet all these things do exist, and so does God. Thus, the moral argument for the existence of God.
 
No, it does not. You really need to read more about the Big Bang cosmological models. There very likely is no "before" the Big Bang. As I pointed out before, only to be ignored, evidence suggests that the universe is both boundless and finite, like the surface of a sphere. It is very likely that "before the Big Bang" makes no more sense than "north of the North Pole".

You contradict yourself. If the evidence suggests, the universe is finite, than it is based on this that we shall base our reasoning. And so : If the universe is finite, it had a absolute beginning, thus, a cause.
 
its not real in OUR reality. It can be real in a other dimension. For a flatlander,
a tridimensional being is not real. He cannot perceive it, it is above HIS reality. But the tridimensional reality exists, despite that fact.

The tridimensional reality MIGHT exist. There is no way for the flatlander to know.

You forget, that before the Big Bang, no forces did exist.

Yes. That includes your god, though.

So what. If that energy existed eternally, we would already be at heath death. But we are not. We are here. therefor, Energy was created at a starting point, and is heading to max entropy, where no work can be done anymore, and heath death takes place.

You're right. If we had been around for an infinity of time, entropy would have put us at heat death already. But we haven't been here for an infinity of time. Where you go wrong is in stating that there was something before the beginning.

I guess i am in good company with Hawking, Paul Davies, Penrose, Vilenkin, which all state that the universe had a absolute beginning.

thekeyboard.org.uk/What%20is%20infinity.htm

An infinite universe for example would exist in every direction forever, there could be nothing else, ONLY the universe. It is then very easy to understand why our universe cannot be infinite, it is because it is expanding. It cannot be both infinite and expanding. It could be infinite OR expanding, but CANNOT possibly be both, that is a contradiction in terms, and we do know it is expanding. For an explanation of the Big Bang and why we know the universe is expanding. See The Big Bang Theory

But no one said otherwise. What's your point?

you have not debunked any thing. just expressed your incredulity....

I've debunked you completely. You denying this fact doesn't change it.

The moral argument begins with the fact that all people recognize some moral code (that some things are right, and some things are wrong). Every time we argue over right and wrong, we appeal to a higher law that we assume everyone is aware of, holds to, and is not free to arbitrarily change. Right and wrong imply a higher standard or law, and law requires a lawgiver. Because the Moral Law transcends humanity, this universal law requires a universal lawgiver. This, it is argued, is God.

Circular logic.

1) People argue over morality.
2) When they argue over morality, they must appeal to a transcendental moral law.
3) A transcendental moral law exists.

You assume your conclusion in your premises.

In support of the moral argument, we see that even the most remote tribes who have been cut off from the rest of civilization observe a moral code similar to everyone else's.

You don't include cannibals, I assume?

Although differences certainly exist in civil matters, virtues like bravery and loyalty and vices like greed and cowardice are universal. If man were responsible for that code, it would differ as much as every other thing that man has invented. Further, it is not simply a record of what mankind does—rarely do people ever live up to their own moral code. Where, then, do we get these ideas of what should be done? Romans 2:14-15 says that the moral law (or conscience) comes from an ultimate lawgiver above man. If this is true, then we would expect to find exactly what we have observed. This lawgiver is God.

To put it negatively, atheism provides no basis for morality, no hope, and no meaning for life. While this does not disprove atheism by itself, if the logical outworking of a belief system fails to account for what we instinctively know to be true, it ought to be discarded. Without God there would be no objective basis for morality, no life, and no reason to live it. Yet all these things do exist, and so does God. Thus, the moral argument for the existence of God.

But evolution can explain morality.
 
You contradict yourself. If the evidence suggests, the universe is finite, than it is based on this that we shall base our reasoning. And so : If the universe is finite, it had a absolute beginning, thus, a cause.

No, because - as I have explained countless times - the laws of cause and effect do not apply without time, and time does not exist outside our universe.
 
Yup, as I pointed out earlier, Gibhor is simply answering the questions that his indoctrination has already provided excuses for. He is not answering any questions that prove his knowledge fallacious

now theres something we haven't seen before
Epic fail
:confused:
 
The moral argument begins with the fact that all people recognize some moral code (that some things are right, and some things are wrong).

You're moving on, so that implies that you've conceded that your cosmological argument is not valid. I'm willing to move on, but I'd like to hear you admit that you concede the point.
 
that goes agianst all empirical observations. Everything from nothing is not reasonable. Actually, its complete b****s*****.

OH MY - This one is PRICELESS! The fact that gibhor typed this and obviously does not see the giant irony is jus another classic example of why I believe that people like him suffer from a mental illness.
 
Once again, we could not exist to observe a universe which did not lead to our existence as observers. This fact leads to absolutely no revelations, and does not imply that the universe was made for us, or anything else. To suggest that it does is known as the fallacy of affirming the consequent.

Not fallacious at all. Suppose you won the lottery 100 times in a row. Would you think it just luck, or was someone rigging the lottery in your favor? But you would not be speculating on winning the lottery 100 times in a row unless you had won 100 times in a row. Despite that, you would still conclude the lottery was rigged in your favor. See the Firing Squad Analogy

"Suppose you are dragged before a firing squad consisting of 100 marksmen. You hear the command to fire and the crashing roar of the rifles. You then realize you are still alive, and that not a single bullet found its mark. How are you to react to this rather unlikely event?"

If we applied a sort of WAP [Weak Anthropic Principle] to the firing squad scenario, we could state the following: 'Of course you do not observe that you are dead, because if you were dead, you would not be able to observe that fact!' However, this does not stop you from being amazed and surprised by the fact that you did survive against overwhelming odds. Moreover, you would try to deduce the reason for this unlikely event, which was too improbable to happen by chance. Surely, the best explanation is that there was some plan among the marksmen to miss you on purpose. In other words, you are probably alive for a very definite reason, not because of some random, unlikely, freak accident."

http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/michael_hurben/univ.html

It is not fallacious to counterfactually ask how likely an event is even after the event has already happened. If you see a video of a die landing 3 a hundred times in a row, are you precluded from making a conclusion about the die just because the event has already happened? In the same way, we can wonder about the odds of a life-permitting universe arising, even though we know the universe is life-permitting.
 
In support of the moral argument, we see that even the most remote tribes who have been cut off from the rest of civilization observe a moral code similar to everyone else's. Although differences certainly exist in civil matters, virtues like bravery and loyalty and vices like greed and cowardice are universal. If man were responsible for that code, it would differ as much as every other thing that man has invented.

Many of these tribes live by the code "Don't mess with tigers". That can only be explained as a God-given universal? No chance that this was independently learned?

To put it negatively, atheism provides no basis for morality, no hope, and no meaning for life. While this does not disprove atheism by itself, if the logical outworking of a belief system fails to account for what we instinctively know to be true, it ought to be discarded.

I'm not convinced that these are instinctive. Take Greed for example. Most kids need to be taught that "its nice to share." I don't think its instinctive at all, but rather counter-intuitive. I think that people learn that sharing and cooperation is in their best interest, and they teach it to their kids, and everybody lives happily ever after.
 
Not fallacious at all. Suppose you won the lottery 100 times in a row. Would you think it just luck, or was someone rigging the lottery in your favor? But you would not be speculating on winning the lottery 100 times in a row unless you had won 100 times in a row. Despite that, you would still conclude the lottery was rigged in your favor. See the Firing Squad Analogy

You don't seem to comprehend that the probability of us observing a universe which allowed us to come into existence as observers, is 1. uno. ONE.

You aren't winning the lottery 100 times in a row, you aren't even winning on a 50/50 bet. It is impossible for you to lose this lottery. You are pretending that it is somehow improbable that we see a universe that displays apparent fine tuning, when in fact there is no possibility of us observing a universe that does not.

You are then affirming the consequent based on your erroneous interpretation of this probability.

1. If P(something fine tuned the universe) then Q(the universe appears fine tuned).
2. Q
3. Therefore P.

This is an obvious fallacy.

Edit: I am not saying that you can't say that it is improbable that the constants are what they are, so long as you understand the possible range in which they could have fallen(which you don't). I am saying that you cannot use the observation that "the universe appears remarkably fine tuned for me!" to reason backwards as to why it appears fine tuned, because it is NOT improbable that you observe apparent fine tuning.
 
Last edited:
Not fallacious at all. Suppose you won the lottery 100 times in a row. Would you think it just luck, or was someone rigging the lottery in your favor? But you would not be speculating on winning the lottery 100 times in a row unless you had won 100 times in a row. Despite that, you would still conclude the lottery was rigged in your favor. See the Firing Squad Analogy

"Suppose you are dragged before a firing squad consisting of 100 marksmen. You hear the command to fire and the crashing roar of the rifles. You then realize you are still alive, and that not a single bullet found its mark. How are you to react to this rather unlikely event?"

If we applied a sort of WAP [Weak Anthropic Principle] to the firing squad scenario, we could state the following: 'Of course you do not observe that you are dead, because if you were dead, you would not be able to observe that fact!' However, this does not stop you from being amazed and surprised by the fact that you did survive against overwhelming odds. Moreover, you would try to deduce the reason for this unlikely event, which was too improbable to happen by chance. Surely, the best explanation is that there was some plan among the marksmen to miss you on purpose. In other words, you are probably alive for a very definite reason, not because of some random, unlikely, freak accident."

http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/michael_hurben/univ.html

It is not fallacious to counterfactually ask how likely an event is even after the event has already happened. If you see a video of a die landing 3 a hundred times in a row, are you precluded from making a conclusion about the die just because the event has already happened? In the same way, we can wonder about the odds of a life-permitting universe arising, even though we know the universe is life-permitting.

This is called "conditional probability", I think. Essentially, someone has fired a pistol at the side of a barn while blindfolded, then pointed at the bullet hole and proclaimed "HA! See? What are the odds of it hitting that spot?"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom