Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Thanx Rolfe. You fell right into that trap that I placed for you. You see, you all show the real sloppiness of your thinking about homeopathy by assuming that all homeopathic medicines are beyond Avogadro's number. In fact, the majority of homeopathic medicines sold in health food stores and pharmacies are in the material dose range (under 24X or 12C).

If you now choose to only call homeopathic medicines those that are over Avogadro's number, you'll have to be arrogant enough to create your own dictionary too.

By the way, when Hahnemann first began experimenting with the "law of similars" (I prefer to consider this a type of resonance), he only used "material doses" of medicines for the first 20 years. Only in the last 20 years or so in his life did he begin testing even higher potencies. Initially, he too was extremely skeptical, but being the good scientist that he was, he was more interested in what was true than arm-chair assumptions about what he (or others) thought was true. Not all of us can be this smart.

Now that you call the medicine that was used in these brain cancer cases as non-homeopathy, you all can now start using this non-homeopathic medicines (I won't tell).

Oh...and thanx for coming to the aid of homeopaths by telling us all that THESE brain cancer cases were not "inidivudualized" and didn't have homeopathic "casetaking"--thus, this made these treatments non-homeopathic.


Ooooh, look people, IT'S A TRAP!!!!! :eek:

Get over yourself. Of course I know that homoeopaths occasionally use "low-potency" preparations (though not often, as far as I can see). And of course I know that Hahnemann started off using material doses, and only came up with the dilute-out-of-existence idea after he'd killed a few people.

For example, if the patient had a gray pallor, was sweating profusely, and said that he or she suffered from abdominal cramps, Hahnemann would in effect look up "gray pallor," "sweating," and "abdominal cramps" in his tome; use cross-references to narrow down possible remedies; and thus decide that strychnine—a toxic alkaloid—was the ideal cure for the patient's condition.

If it is ingested in significant quantities, strychnine will indeed cause sweating and severe abdominal cramps. Hahnemann's original records on his patients detail his prescribing many noxious substances according to the doctrine of similia similibus curentur ("like cures like"). For stomach pains he regularly prescribed quarter-ounce "doses" of mercury. He instructed one poor soul to take half an ounce of sulfuric acid in the morning and another half-ounce later that day. A purported healing system that Hahnemann asserted God had revealed to him was having devilish effects on his patients, who were "dropping like flies."


If indeed we had brain cancer case reports detailing the case-taking and individualisation as above, then of course the case would be homoeopathic even if the subsequent decision was to use a 3X or a 6X remedy - potentised, I would imagine.

However, that is not the case. I would not expect you to have to rely on me to tell you that homoeopathy involves case-taking and individualisation. I presume you would agree that is the case? Therefore, why do you present that paper as representing homoeopathy in any way?

It might be helpful if you would actually tell us what you would define as being "homoeopathy". You see, there are so many trials around where people have performed what they honestly believed to be homoeopathy, and which some homoeopaths had actually confirmed was homoeopathy - indeed, some using actual homoeopaths to do the case-taking and remedy selection. Many of these trials replicate the conditions of earlier trials hailed by the homoeopathic community. Nevertheless, when a negative result is obtained, we suddenly find the methods denounced as being "not real homoeopathy" for one reason or another. So, it would be nice if you were to define for us what you consider the defining characteristics of this homoeopathy you espouse so fervently, so that we'll know it when we see it.

And if you want to discuss Shang, GO TO THE OTHER THREAD. Maybe you think that if you bluster and obfuscate enough, nobody will notice that you cannot produce a single well-documented case report of a patient recovering from a non-self-limiting illness using homoeopathic treatment alone.

Won't work.

My God, homoeopathy is in fact older than "modern" medicine. 200 years in fact. Can you just imagine the outcry if even in that past 50 years modern pharmacotherapeutic medicine was unable to produce even one single well-documented case report showing a patient recovering from a non-self-limiting illness!!!!

And you don't have even one. For something that is supposed to be a complete system of medicine, which boasts ever so many poorly or non-documented anecdotal miracle cures of all sorts of things. But not a single one properly documented and verifiable.

What an indictment.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Oh...and thanx for coming to the aid of homeopaths by telling us all that THESE brain cancer cases were not "inidivudualized" and didn't have homeopathic "casetaking"--thus, this made these treatments non-homeopathic.

I suspect that these cases were all examples of individualized homeopathy. I suspect that someone simply went through a bunch of old case files and pulled out those in which the diagnosis was brain cancer and the prescribed remedy was Ruta. It would explain the offhand way in which they were mentioned, plus the lack of any reasonable attempt at meeting the standards for clinical research.

Cool...now you can help me damn that Shang et al "comparison" of the 110 homeopathic and allopathic trials...which got whittled down to the 21 high quality homeopathic trials and ONLY 9 (!) high quality allopathic trials...which then got whittled down to 8 homeopathic trials (7 of which only used a SINGLE MEDICINE without individualization...therefore, according to Rolfe, these trials were not homeopathic) and down to only 6 allopathic trials...which were no longer matched with each other in any way.

Perhaps, SOMEONE can finally tell us which were the 21 homeopathic trials and the 9 allopathic ones. Shang NEVER divulged, most likely because this review would show real benefits from homeopathic treatment. Isn't anyone suspicious of "black box" comparison studies like this? Why are only the homeopaths complaining here about junk science? Hmmmm.

The fact that the Lancet published this junk science just shows you how threatened they are with homeopathy. After all, to put all rationaity and ethics aside just to attack homeopathy suggest some major homeo-phobia. The Lancet does seem to believe in boogeymen.

Come out of the medicine closet people. I know that the people on this list are smart, but smart and narrow-minded isn't smart at all.

I am STILL waiting for someone (!) to speak in defense of the Shang "study." Waiting...waiting...

Ah. Your choice to ignore what we said and attempt to distract us with lies (and I call them lies, because you have been shown several times that many (I'll be generous and avoid the use of the more accurate 'most' or 'all') of your statements are untrue) speaks volumes. It tells us that we are on the right track. Our criticisms are proving fatal to your cause.

Linda
 
I suspect that these cases were all examples of individualized homeopathy. I suspect that someone simply went through a bunch of old case files and pulled out those in which the diagnosis was brain cancer and the prescribed remedy was Ruta. It would explain the offhand way in which they were mentioned, plus the lack of any reasonable attempt at meeting the standards for clinical research.


It wasn't how I interpreted the paper, but it's a thought. Where did they get 15 cases of brain tumour, and over what period of time were they presented? Who was actually treating them, and was the Ruta given as part of this study, or independently?

This simply underlines the fact that the paper presents nowhere near enough information to be able to make any judgement.

I think these guys are big enthusiasts for this concoction - I see another paper where they are investigating suspected anti-inflammatory effects. And whether or not they came to it through homoeopathy, they are postulating and investigating perfectly normal, rational material effects on telomeres and so on. I suspect their optimism may be outrunning the real potential of the stuff, but time will tell.

However, even if their research results in the isolation of a novel pharmaceutical with useful properties from this botanical source, it still won't be homoeopathy.

Rolfe.
 
Just to clarify, Dana, none of us has much doubt that "Mother Tincture" Belladonna would yield incontrovertible evidence of 'curing' that medical condition known as life whether it was prescribed with the usual rigmarole of case-taking and checking the patient's credit score. You would still be faced with the problem that 'like cures like' simply is not a generalisable medical principle. That, however, can be an argument for another day. Let's confine ourselves to 'high-potency' homeopathy so you can't be so silly again. That is unless you'd like to show me a case of tachycardia, mydriasis and dry mouth 'cured' by pharmaceutical quantities of atropine prescribed in a homeopathic manner. Now that would be a good trick.



All of which brings us back to square one;

GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.

T = 04d 22h 18m 41s
 
Just to clarify, Dana, none of us has much doubt that "Mother Tincture" Belladonna would yield incontrovertible evidence of 'curing' that medical condition known as life whether it was prescribed with the usual rigmarole of case-taking and checking the patient's credit score.


I did start to wonder whether that Ruta stuff might be some good for milk fever, as it seems to contain a fair bit of calcium phosphate. But then, I don't think you'd be allowed to inject it i/v.

Rolfe.
 
No, the nearest I get to Bagpuss fame is that I know the woman who did the music and the voice of Madeleine the Ragdoll. Oh and I have shaken Oliver Postgate's hand and touched the real Bagpuss and Clangers.

Oliver Postgate let you touch his Clangers??!!

I'll notify the authorities.

At Cambridge Folk Festival a couple of years ago the kids' show was the music from Bagpuss performed by the original couple together with Nancy Kerr and James Fagan because Nancy is their daughter. A very jolly show it was.

"We will wash it, we will scrub it, we will polish it up, up, up..."

Meanwhile;

T = 04d 23h 26m 54s

Can anyone else feel a game of Mornington Crescent coming on?

Dare I even hazard a Canning Town?

(Dana's in knip and only an INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION can get him out).

Double spoon.
 
Oliver Postgate let you touch his Clangers??!!

I'll notify the authorities.

At Cambridge Folk Festival a couple of years ago the kids' show was the music from Bagpuss performed by the original couple together with Nancy Kerr and James Fagan because Nancy is their daughter. A very jolly show it was.

"We will wash it, we will scrub it, we will polish it up, up, up..."

Meanwhile;

T = 04d 23h 26m 54s

Can anyone else feel a game of Mornington Crescent coming on?

Dare I even hazard a Canning Town?

(Dana's in knip and only an INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION can get him out).

Double spoon.

I'll see your Canning Town, and raise you a Seven Sisters.

We will mix it, we will fix it, we will stick it with glue, glue, glue. . .

We will stickle it, every little bit of it, we will make it like new, new, new.
 
I'll see your Canning Town, and raise you a Seven Sisters.

We will mix it, we will fix it, we will stick it with glue, glue, glue. . .

We will stickle it, every little bit of it, we will make it like new, new, new.

I don't want Dana to feel left out so I'm invoking Wide Receiver!!

Powell Street

But I'd still like ONE INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION to read as we play.
 
This isn't fair.

I was a part of the Guardian debate, and have been getting to know Dana quite well. I feel like squabbling siblings to be honest!

But asking for proof and an example of homeopathy curing something, especially a named disease is against the Society of Homeopaths Code of Conduct, which states a homeopath (point 73) is expected to:

To avoid making claims (whether explicit or implied; orally or in writing) implying cure of any named disease.

On a side note, I have asked 3 different homeopaths for an explanation of this point, since many are adamant that homeopathy can cure illness, or why it is often broken, but no action taken. No reply has ever come.
 
Welcome Mattbee. Point of clarification. They may be prohibited from making advertising claims that they can cure a named disease, but that doesn't stop them from claiming that they have cured people with all sorts of things wrong with them - or at least it doesn't seem to.

So, no doubt a homoeopath wouldn't see a patient with a brain tumour as having a brain tumour, he'd see them as someone with their vital force disordered in a certain way so that it produced certain symptoms. Then he'd discover the perfect simillimum and restore them to perfect health. By his way of seeing it.

However, what BSM is looking for is simply such a cure on a patient who, before homoeopathic treatment, had a confirmed documented medical diagnosis of something non-self-limiting, and afterwards had confirmed documented evidence that the condition was no longer present. And that there was no conventional treatment which might have caused the recovery.

The homoeopath doesn't have to recognise the medical diagnosis at all, as part of the process.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
I'll flummox you with a counter move (if I'm allowed the Cross variation)
Holland Park

Dana, can we have ONE INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION?
 
Last edited:
Wow...I obviously touched a nerve (or main vein) in Linda. She has now devolved into calling me a liar...though didn't say where I lied in the above statement.

In fact, she previously gave us her power calculation to the COPD study but didn't tell us to what results she was referring (whoops).

By the way, David Colquhoun's published "critique" of the COPD study did not question the statistically analysis of this study (no one yet has published a critique of this study that questioned its statistical analysis), nor did he question the study's design or how it was conducted. He primarily questioned that anyone would allow seriously ill people to be treated with homeopathy (the fact that the homeopathic treated group experienced substantial improvement really irritated him). He also insisted that the homeopathic medicine could not work...and thus research on homeopathy is dangerous.

I wonder if he thinks that the atomic bomb was a placebo too, especially since those tiny tiny atoms are way too small to have any effect even when they collide (or are shaken).

One must assume that the randomized double-blind placebo control trial is the problem here. Wow, what cynical view of the scientific method.

Finally, this thread has my name on it. Some people insist that this thread has only one question. Obviously, it has many questions.

No one has yet to provide a knock-out blow to the COPD study...the weak references to the differences between the treatment group and the control group showed no statistically significant differences, especially in the light of the substantial results!

...nor have there been knock-out blows to the severe sepsis study, also conducted at the University of Vienna...and there are many more that I can reference...the four studies by Reilly at the University of Glasgow for further reference (all of these four trials were with the 30C dose!).

And as for the brain cancer cases...now that you know that various homeopathic medicines can have powerful effects of serious illnesses, you must be wondering if they can help various other conditions. I now assume that you all are going to be using the over-the-counter homeopathic medicines that are not beyond Avogadro's number.
 
Dana, there is another thread with your name on it, totally dedicated to discussing academic papers. You still haven't posted even once in it.

This thread is dedicated to any evidence you have for homoeopathic treatment ever having cured a non-self-limiting condition. We're still waiting.

Everybody and his auntie knows that herbal remedies have real effects, sometimes very powerful. Cannabis, anyone? Or opium? Whether this Ruta stuff contains anything of that nature is still an open question, as far as I can see. If the Indian guys have any really impressive results, it might fit them better to publish in a higher-quality journal.

But you really can't go round claiming every material effect of a herbal preparation as "homoeopathy", just because homoeopaths also use potentised preparations of the same plant in their case-taking sillymum like-cures-like antics. That's taking intellectual dishonesty a bit far, even for you!

So, while you're still dredging the literature, and your own and your colleagues' casebooks, for that single, elusive documented cure, why not do as I asked and give us your definition of homoeopathy? Does it require case-taking? Does it require finding a simillimum according to the doctrine of "like cures like"? Do you subscribe to the single remedy doctrine, and waiting to see what effect that has, or do you allow polypharmacy?

Inquiring minds want to know.

But they'd rather know about the academic papers in the thread created for that purpose.

Rolfe.

PS. Oh no not Reilly! Isopathy, anyone? Really, really dodgy statistics anyone? And the whole house of cards relies on the condition being treated (allergic rhinitis I think, hay fever to the rest of us) being.... ta-dah.... SELF-LIMITING!
 
Last edited:
A couple of people on the Bad Science blog have also suggested suitable conditions. Ebola was one.

Amoung people in good health mortality rate may be sub 70%
 
Wow...I obviously touched a nerve (or main vein) in Linda. She has now devolved into calling me a liar...though didn't say where I lied in the above statement.

In fact, she previously gave us her power calculation to the COPD study but didn't tell us to what results she was referring (whoops).

By the way, David Colquhoun's published "critique" of the COPD study did not question the statistically analysis of this study (no one yet has published a critique of this study that questioned its statistical analysis), nor did he question the study's design or how it was conducted. He primarily questioned that anyone would allow seriously ill people to be treated with homeopathy (the fact that the homeopathic treated group experienced substantial improvement really irritated him). He also insisted that the homeopathic medicine could not work...and thus research on homeopathy is dangerous.

I wonder if he thinks that the atomic bomb was a placebo too, especially since those tiny tiny atoms are way too small to have any effect even when they collide (or are shaken).

One must assume that the randomized double-blind placebo control trial is the problem here. Wow, what cynical view of the scientific method.

Finally, this thread has my name on it. Some people insist that this thread has only one question. Obviously, it has many questions.

No one has yet to provide a knock-out blow to the COPD study...the weak references to the differences between the treatment group and the control group showed no statistically significant differences, especially in the light of the substantial results!

...nor have there been knock-out blows to the severe sepsis study, also conducted at the University of Vienna...and there are many more that I can reference...the four studies by Reilly at the University of Glasgow for further reference (all of these four trials were with the 30C dose!).

And as for the brain cancer cases...now that you know that various homeopathic medicines can have powerful effects of serious illnesses, you must be wondering if they can help various other conditions. I now assume that you all are going to be using the over-the-counter homeopathic medicines that are not beyond Avogadro's number.

Still ducking the question.

Still unable to address our criticisms with anything other than a pretense that you can't see them.

We can add your references to the list in the other thread, but I'm already familiar with them and they will fare no better than the others I'm afraid.

Linda
 
Oliver Postgate let you touch his Clangers??!!

I'll notify the authorities.

At Cambridge Folk Festival a couple of years ago the kids' show was the music from Bagpuss performed by the original couple together with Nancy Kerr and James Fagan because Nancy is their daughter. A very jolly show it was.

"We will wash it, we will scrub it, we will polish it up, up, up..."

Nancy is Sandra's daughter, but not John Faulkner's. Nancy's dad was a Northumbrian piper Ron Elliot. I knew Nancy quite well too, but haven't seen her since we were both teenagers.

Sorry for the total derail.
 
No one has yet to provide a knock-out blow to the COPD study...the weak references to the differences between the treatment group and the control group showed no statistically significant differences, especially in the light of the substantial results!

...nor have there been knock-out blows to the severe sepsis study, also conducted at the University of Vienna...and there are many more that I can reference...the four studies by Reilly at the University of Glasgow for further reference (all of these four trials were with the 30C dose!).

Oh. I should point out that none of these qualify for this thread. The COPD study and severe sepsis study both involved controls groups which recovered as well as the homeopathy groups. And allergic rhinitis is a self-limiting condition.

Linda
 
Linda,
Excuse me?! Please answer my question about your statistical critique of the COPD study. Your silence on this issue says everything...and your decision to not answer it and instead to call me a "liar" creates a red flag (alerting "danger") and a white flag ("surrender"). Fret not, I don't waterboard prisoners.
People on this list asked for ONE condition for which homeopathy was proven to be effective...this COPD trial was conducted at the University of Vienna Hospital. Check out the lead investigator: Michael Frass, MD. See ALL of his non-homeopathic research.
Heck...admit you're wrong...or better, learn something new.

Just as good homeopaths refer to conventional docs for certain patients in certain circumstances, a large percentage of doctors in Europe refer patients to homeopaths or prescribe these medicine themselves: 42% of British docs refer to homeopaths, 20%+ of German docs prescribe homeopathic medicines, and 30-40% of French docs prescribe them too...and high percentages in Italy and the Netherlands.

And did you see the new issue of the Lancet that remarked that 100 milliion Indians rely ONLY upon homeopathic treatment. YOU try to prescribe just placeboes to patients and see how long you last. Any takers? Didn't think so.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom