Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

That's interesting, chalk up one complete jump-to-wrong-conclusion to me.

Dismissed with "don't be snarky to your esteemed colleagues by name in public no matter how off-the-wall their methods."

By the way, BSM, I've finished the Grauniad thread, and I have to say that your sarky comments cheered me up no end while doing some tedious marking. (OK, snivelling little college student, so you don't know the maximum permitted number of hens per square metre, even though it's in the book in front of you. So find some other number and put that in. Like 120. Don't even think about plausibility, no, why should you....) No matter where you find these pseudonyms, the style is unmistakable.

Now, wouldn't want to derail this thread while we wait for Dana, so here's my thoughts. We're waiting for a fully-documented example of homoeopathy curing a patient presenting with a confirmed diagnosis of a non-self-limiting illness. Documented diagnosis, documented treatment, and documented proof of recovery that can't be attributed to anything else but homoeopathy.

I'm rather resigned to a series of uninspiring tall tales. Like the woman on the Horizon programme who had had every anti-cancer therapy in the book but still attributed her survival to see her grandchildren grow up to "a homoeopathic solution of common salt". No documentation whatsoever of a single word of it, even the original diagnosis. Then we'll be the villains for not accepting his responses when he gives them. If he does.

Nevertheless, what sort of conditions might fit the bill? BSM mentioned metastatic carcinoma and end stage renal failure. Good start. HCN has in the past suggested hypertrophic cardiomyopathy.

I'm a fan of conditions requiring permanent hormone replacement therapy. Nice and easy to document. So, insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (cats don't count, we all know they frequently go into spontaneous remission with the right diet, so out of bounds). Addison's disease. (See my sig for what happened when that one was hypothetically presented to H'pathy Forums.) Primary hypothyroidism.

The point is we know how to confirm these diagnoses absolutely water-tight. And we know what happens if the patient doesn't get treated. So, evidence that a patient was clinically normal and had normal lab results without needing any HRT after homoeopathic treatment would be very compelling.

Any more suggestions?

Not that the challenge is limited to those conditions, but just to give an idea of what sort of "cure" we're looking for.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
I think diagnoses with what we would recognise as severe degenerative pathology. Let's see homeopathy fix a cirrhotic liver.

One attraction of this is that it is a chronic disease so very likely to have crossed the path of a homeopath because although serious it can be well-managed for a long time but with the probable presence of niggling unpleasant symptoms that would be meat and drink to a hom and something they should really be able to get to grips with using their 'complete system of medicine'. Equally though, even if a patient was willing to tell the hom they felt a bit better subjectively, unless the liver has recovered they are not going to stay symptom-free for long.

OK, it's mid-afternoon in La-La Land and

T= 02d 05h 26m 46s
 
Last edited:
A couple of people on the Bad Science blog have also suggested suitable conditions. Ebola was one. I still haven't finished reading it, but I'll go back later and try to pick them out.

BSM, you just crack me up, you know. Especially on other forums, for some reason. Does Mrs. BSM know what you get up to at nights?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
BSM, I too have perused the Grauniad thread.
Excellent stuff - It deserves to be preserved for posterity.

PS: "slop-bucket"! :) (forgive me if I nick that one in future)

PPS: Oh, and not to detract from the purpose of this thread,
Dana Ullman/James Gully, please could you:
GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION?
 
BSM, you just crack me up, you know. Especially on other forums, for some reason. Does Mrs. BSM know what you get up to at nights?

Yes, and I'd cut down my forum-time, but Ben's recent Grauniad piece was such dynamite and it's been fun to fight the good fight again.
 
PS: "slop-bucket"! :) (forgive me if I nick that one in future)

Only by prior arrangement with the estate of Michael Flanders. :)

Anyway, what were we talking about? Oh, yes.


GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION?
 
Gord, it looks like there was 48 in the control group, and 48 received the homeopathic cocktail.

Ha. Ha. On first reading I thought there were three groups -- magic water with sub-atomic quantum properties, distilled water, and tap water that after banging and thumping around in the hydrologic cycle and the city water supply had no magic properties. On further thought, I think I'd like to see this experient done. :D

And I think their conclusions were closer to your reaction than Dana/James

What the H do I know? I only have a ministership in the Unversal Life Church to put up against the homeopathic degrees. :o
 
The COPD study at the University of Vienna Hospital and published in CHEST (2005) is one such good piece of research despite what minor critique has been given to it. Although some weak critique was made about the treatment group and the control group were not perfectly comparable, there was not statistical difference between the groups, and due to the substantial differences in treatment results, this trial fits your criteria...but heck, you can never admit you're wrong, so what is the point?

Unless someone can provide a statistical analysis of why the results of this trial are not valid, please just admit that there are good reasons that CHEST published this fine piece of research...and if you and someone in your family had COPD, would you consider using the homeopathic medicine that was shown to be helpful? What is interesting and unusual about THIS study was that only ONE homeopathic medicine was given, without individualization of treatment. The results of this trial surprised me, but this medicine is known to cause (and cure) thick tracheal secretions like those with advanced COPD.

My previous reference to another trial also at the University of Vienna Hospital on patients with severe sepsis found a 50% reduced mortality rate in patients who were given an individually selected homeopathic medicine, as compared with those given a placebo. The only critique that was given to this trial was that people should avoid Vienna is the normal death rate for severe sepsis is 50%, even though the literature normally find that the death rate for this serious condition is between 40-70% (is this condition adequately beyond self-limiting?).

That said...there is so much more (but those of you who don't look will never find anything).

A small but significant study of people with brain cancer was conducted in association with M.D. Anderson Cancer Center at the University of Texas (one of the most respected cancer research centers in the world), and it was published in the prestigious journal, International Journal of Oncology). Fifteen patient diagnosed with intracranial tumors were treated with Ruta 6X and Calcarea phosphorica (calcium phosphate) 3X (Pathak, Multani, Banerji, 2003). Of the 15 patients, 8 of the 9 glioma patients showed complete regression of tumors; 1 of 3 with meningioma showed complete regression and 2 of 3 showed prolonged arrest; 1 with neurinoma showed prolonged arrest; 1 with craiopharyngioma and 1 with pituitary tumors both showed complete regression.

Providing further verification of the benefits of Ruta graveolens was an animal study (Preethi K, Kuttan G, Kuttan, 2006). An extract of Ruta graveolens was found to be cytotoxic to Dalton's lymphoma ascites (DLA), Ehrlich ascites carcinoma (EAC) and L929 cells in culture (IC100 = 16mg/ml) and also to increase the lifespan of tumour bearing animals. The extract further decreased solid tumours developing from DLA and EAC cells when given simultaneously with elongation of the lifespan of tumour-bearing animals. A homeopathic preparation of Ruta graveolens (200c) was equally effective. Neither was effective for reducing already developed tumours. The Ruta graveolens extract was found to scavenge hydroxyl radicals and inhibit lipid peroxidation at low concentrations. However, at higher concentrations the extract acted as a prooxidant as inhibition of lipid peroxidation and scavenging of hydroxyl radical was minimal. These data indicates that the prooxidant activity of Ruta graveolens may be responsible for the cytocidal action of the extract and its ability to produce tumour reduction.
These researchers also conducted several laboratory experiments in which one or both of these homeopathic medicines showed induction of survival-signaling pathways in normal lymphocytes as well as the induction of death-signaling pathways in brain cancer cells (this means that these medicines improved immune function and increased the body’s ability to kill cancer cells). The researchers also note that one of Ruta’s active ingredients is Rutin, which is know for having anti-oxidant and anti-inflammatory activities and for reducing oxidative damage. The researchers also provide additional detail about the therapeutic benefits from calcium phosphate.

Pathak S, Multani AS, Banerji P, Banerji P., Ruta 6 selectively induces cell death in brain cancer cells but proliferation in normal peripheral blood lymphocytes: A novel treatment for human brain cancer. Int J Oncol. 2003 Oct;23(4):975-82.

Preethi K, Kuttan G, Kuttan R Anti-tumour activity of ruta graveolens extract. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev. 2006 Jul-Sep;7(3):439-43.
 
The COPD study at the University of Vienna Hospital and published in CHEST (2005) is one such good piece of research despite what minor critique has been given to it. Although some weak critique was made about the treatment group and the control group were not perfectly comparable, there was not statistical difference between the groups, and due to the substantial differences in treatment results, this trial fits your criteria...but heck, you can never admit you're wrong, so what is the point?

Unless someone can provide a statistical analysis of why the results of this trial are not valid...


Try here and here.

You still haven't provided a reference to where the authors of the article "blew [this] critique out of the water", by the way.
 
More evasions

Dana,



Please try to understand, this thread is not for the discussion of more research. I started a thread for that purpose here.


The only reason for discussing research papers in this thread is to fill it more more of your jejune waffle in an attempt to divert attention from this question;

"GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION."

T = 02d 15h 20m 07s
 
garbage, see
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2007/07/homeopathy_in_thecringeicu_1.php

The control group was less healthy than the "treated" group. That happens in such small studies.

Can I ask that responses to Dana's prevarications and diversionary tactics are made in the other thread. This thread is his opportunity to answer this question;

GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.

T = 02d 15h 32m 12s
 
Yeah...those brain cancer cases don't count because you have now determined that brain cancer is self-limiting and the MD Anderson Cancer Clinic at the University of Texas is another "homeopathic clinic" that is not trustworthy. What was I thinking?

And the COPD study...the worst that Orac had to say about it was that the study didn't mention homeopathy in the title of the article and that he was personally shocked that this study made it past the IRB. Heck, Orac wouldn't want people to receive safe and effective treatment IF that treatment was a homeopathic medicine.

Do you people know what you're saying and that this is a record of it? Squirm squirm.
 
No, I think the worst Orac had to say about the study was that it was flawed because it could be demonstrated that the treatment and placebo groups were not equivalent. He also had some comments on the ethics of treating intubated patients in an intensive care unit with magic water.

At no point have you ever actually addressed those criticisms. You have stated that the criticisms are invalid, but you have never explained why.
 
Oh, if you do have a reply, you might want to put it on the other thread...my apologies for going off topic on this one....
 
Yeah...those brain cancer cases don't count because you have now determined that brain cancer is self-limiting and the MD Anderson Cancer Clinic at the University of Texas is another "homeopathic clinic" that is not trustworthy. What was I thinking?

And the COPD study...the worst that Orac had to say about it was that the study didn't mention homeopathy in the title of the article and that he was personally shocked that this study made it past the IRB. Heck, Orac wouldn't want people to receive safe and effective treatment IF that treatment was a homeopathic medicine.

Do you people know what you're saying and that this is a record of it? Squirm squirm.

Dana, the really odd thing about the brain cancer paper is how little detail it gives about the patients. It's almost a throwaway comment that they 'cured' 90% of the glioma patients. To spend a whole paper in a second-rank journal going through a load of lab stuff when you've just cured brain cancer in 90% of patients seems strange. Do you know how secure the diagnoses were;

"Diagnoses were based on radiology and/or histopathology"

That is a very odd "and/or".

I think we need the input of some actual medics on this.
 
I suppose I ought to point out that this was not an "ultramolecular" preparation so will have contained real amounts of the chemical agents, but even so a 90% "cure" of cancer is a striking claim.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom