Of the 15 patients, 8 of the 9 glioma patients showed complete regression of tumors; 1 of 3 with meningioma showed complete regression and 2 of 3 showed prolonged arrest; 1 with neurinoma showed prolonged arrest; 1 with craiopharyngioma and 1 with pituitary tumors both showed complete regression.
Fifteen patients diagnosed with intracranial tumors were treated with Ruta 6 and Ca3(PO4)2. Of these 15 patients, 6 of the 7 glioma patients showed complete regression of tumors.
The COPD study at the University of Vienna Hospital and published in CHEST (2005) is one such good piece of research despite what minor critique has been given to it. Although some weak critique was made about the treatment group and the control group were not perfectly comparable, there was not statistical difference between the groups,
Hey Linda...
Below are some of the differences between the treatment group and the control group. On which data was your power analysis made?
The amount of tracheal secretions was reduced significantly in group 1 (the homeopathic treatment group) (p < 0.0001). Extubation (the removal of obstructive mucus from the lung with a tube) could be performed significantly earlier in group 1 (p < 0.0001). Similarly, length of stay was significantly shorter in group 1 (4.20 +/- 1.61 days vs 7.68 +/- 3.60 days, p < 0.0001 [mean +/- SD]). This data suggest that potentized (diluted and vigorously shaken) Kali bichromicum 30C may help to decrease the amount of stringy tracheal secretions in COPD patients.
In this study, all patients underwent a trial of extubation, but none (!) of the patients in group 1 had to be reintubated or needed even noninvasive ventilation to improve breathing. The amount of secretions remained stable and did not increase for patients in group 1. Also, the blood gas analyses after extubation remained stable in group 1. In contrast, four patients in group 2 had to be reintubated due to deterioration of blood gas analysis that was caused by tracheal secretions of grade 2 or 3.
ON THE OTHER THREAD PLEASE!
(From the Introduction)
Two of us (P.B. and P.B.) have used Ruta 6 and Ca 3(PO4)2 combination therapy to treat 15 patients diagnosed with advanced intracranial malignant brain cancer at the PBH Research Foundation, Kolkata, India.
(From the Materials and methods)Clinical features of patients with intracranial brain cancers.
The 15 patients (9 male, 6 female) with intracranial brain cancers who were treated with Ruta 6 + Ca3(PO4)2 at the PBH Research Foundation, Kolkata, India, had been diagnosed with glioma (9 patients), meningioma (3 patients), crainiopharyngioma (1 patient), neurinoma (1 patient), and pituitary tumors (1 patient). Diagnoses were based on radiology and/or histopathology. Most of these cases were at the advanced stage of the disease when homeopathic treatment was started in Kolkata, India. The patients gradually improved, as indicated by serial computed tomography scans and clinical examinations. The major complaints before treatment were headache, problem with vision, paralysis, convulsive seizures, vomiting, trembling of extremities, loss of memory, numbness, insomnia, and loss of taste. The age range was from 10 to 65 years, and the time required for cure/symptom-free state/static condition was 3 months to 7 years.
(From the Results)Outcome of brain cancer patients treated with Ruta 6 + Ca3(PO4)2.
The combination therapy of Ruta 6 and Ca3(PO4)2 was very effective in the treatment of intracranial brain cancers. Of the 9 patients with glioma, 8 (88.9%) showed complete regression, and the other patient showed partial regression. Two of the three patients with meningioma showed prolonged arrest of their tumors and the third had complete regression. The one patient with craniopharyngioma and the one patient with pituitary tumors both showed complete regression, and the 1 patient with neurinoma has had prolonged arrest of her tumor as determined by computed tomographic scan images (data not shown).
(From the Discussion)In the present study, we found that a combination of Ruta 6 and Ca
3(PO4)2 taken orally can either block the progression of or completely regress human glioma brain cancers, with minimal or no side effects. The patients diagnosed with glioma, when treated with Ruta 6, showed better results compared with patients having other types of intracranial cancers. Although the number of patients in our group was small, the outcome of homeopathic treatment was highly encouraging and novel.
Now the results do seem interesting, however I have to say I treat them with more than a little scepticism, as the implied findings are literally too good to be true. Also, although the patients were indeed located in India, not Texas, I still see no reason to believe that conventional treatment was stopped when the herbal treatment began, so we don't know if we're just looking at a woo-woo remedy piggybacking on standard therapeutic approach. To put it simply, we are shown no control data of a complarable group of patient who were otherwise treated the same way, but who didn't get the herbalism. So we don't know how much, if anything, the herbalism contributed to the outcomes.
Incidentally, does anyone know anything about the status of this journal? The title is impressive, as is the fact that some of the authors give their address as a cancer centre in Houston, Texas, however the quality of the paper is poor to my eyes. I haven't really looked at the benchwork part, as being even less relevant to what Dana is trying to show than the rest of it, however any journal which allows authors to present such earthshattering (or highly implausible, depending on how you look at it) clinical outcomes in the middle of what is basically an in vitro study, with so little data or confirmatory evidence for the assertions, is to my mind very suspect. I would have expected any competent scrutineer to insist on the clinical case information being removed, with the suggestion that that study be submitted for publication as a separate paper, with sufficiently detailed data and supporting evidence.
.... advanced intracranial malignant brain cancer .... Most of these cases were at the advanced stage of the disease .... headache, problem with vision, paralysis, convulsive seizures, vomiting, trembling of extremities, loss of memory, numbness, insomnia, and loss of taste....
pv said:Here’s challenge. Give one incontrovertible example, with references, of a non-self-limiting condition being cured by homeopathic treatment. Here’s a few examples of such conditions in case you don’t know what is meant by “non-self-limiting”:
AIDS, typhoid, emphysema, diabetes, hypothyroidism, peritonitis, septicaemia, diphtheria, smallpox, tetanus, ebola…
Bump. Surely even the Merikans are awake by now? Or is Dana still frantically Googling for anything he can cut-and-paste that has some promising-looking buzzwords in it?
....
<snip>
Or really, in memory of my late friend, how about a glioblastoma, properly documented of course?
<snip>
I agree, none of this comes even close to fitting the criteria for inclusion in this thread. However, as Dana has advanced the brain tumours as being suitable, I'll just cover the small in vivo part of that study again, having now seen the full paper.
[/LE
Thanx Rolfe. You fell right into that trap that I placed for you. You see, you all show the real sloppiness of your thinking about homeopathy by assuming that all homeopathic medicines are beyond Avogadro's number. In fact, the majority of homeopathic medicines sold in health food stores and pharmacies are in the material dose range (under 24X or 12C).
If you now choose to only call homeopathic medicines those that are over Avogadro's number, you'll have to be arrogant enough to create your own dictionary too.
By the way, when Hahnemann first began experimenting with the "law of similars" (I prefer to consider this a type of resonance), he only used "material doses" of medicines for the first 20 years. Only in the last 20 years or so in his life did he begin testing even higher potencies. Initially, he too was extremely skeptical, but being the good scientist that he was, he was more interested in what was true than arm-chair assumptions about what he (or others) thought was true. Not all of us can be this smart.
Now that you call the medicine that was used in these brain cancer cases as non-homeopathy, you all can now start using this non-homeopathic medicines (I won't tell).
Oh...and thanx for coming to the aid of homeopaths by telling us all that THESE brain cancer cases were not "inidivudualized" and didn't have homeopathic "casetaking"--thus, this made these treatments non-homeopathic.
Cool...now you can help me damn that Shang et al "comparison" of the 110 homeopathic and allopathic trials...which got whittled down to the 21 high quality homeopathic trials and ONLY 9 (!) high quality allopathic trials...which then got whittled down to 8 homeopathic trials (7 of which only used a SINGLE MEDICINE without individualization...therefore, according to Rolfe, these trials were not homeopathic) and down to only 6 allopathic trials...which were no longer matched with each other in any way.
Perhaps, SOMEONE can finally tell us which were the 21 homeopathic trials and the 9 allopathic ones. Shang NEVER divulged, most likely because this review would show real benefits from homeopathic treatment. Isn't anyone suspicious of "black box" comparison studies like this? Why are only the homeopaths complaining here about junk science? Hmmmm.
The fact that the Lancet published this junk science just shows you how threatened they are with homeopathy. After all, to put all rationaity and ethics aside just to attack homeopathy suggest some major homeo-phobia. The Lancet does seem to believe in boogeymen.
Come out of the medicine closet people. I know that the people on this list are smart, but smart and narrow-minded isn't smart at all.
I am STILL waiting for someone (!) to speak in defense of the Shang "study." Waiting...waiting...
Cool...now you can help me damn that Shang et al "comparison" of the 110 homeopathic and allopathic trials...which got whittled down to the 21 high quality homeopathic trials and ONLY 9 (!) high quality allopathic trials...which then got whittled down to 8 homeopathic trials (7 of which only used a SINGLE MEDICINE without individualization...therefore, according to Rolfe, these trials were not homeopathic) and down to only 6 allopathic trials...which were no longer matched with each other in any way.
Perhaps, SOMEONE can finally tell us which were the 21 homeopathic trials and the 9 allopathic ones. Shang NEVER divulged...
You fell right into that trap that I placed for you. You see, you all show the real sloppiness of your thinking about homeopathy...
Blah blah blah
I see someone else there ("wewillfixit") has come up with my perennial Addison's suggestion.