Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Why is there an identically-named thread to this on the Paranormal forum?
 
Let's keep in focus here. These papers in no way address BSM's challenge. The main reason is that they are not case reports, and as such contain far too little data to be able to judge them in these terms.

GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.

The brain study papers aren't really addressing the issue because the original diagnosis is not demonstrated with lab and other results, and the "cure" is similarly not demonstrated. It's mostly bald assertion.

Look, Dana, I lost a very dear friend to glioblastoma last year. I know exactly how they diagnosed it, and how they followed up to see if the treatment they were trying had had any effect (no, sadly it hadn't). I know how they'd have known if indeed she had gone into remission. I also know that it wasn't expected, and that the seven months she survived from diagnosis was about what was predicted.

That's why I find that brain tumour study you posted so offensive. If there really were an effective treatment for this sort of tumour, such that six of seven patients went into remission, we'd be getting a hell of a lot more detail than that. It's window dressing.

However, I'll calm down now and give you a more measured view. First, it doesn't seem like homoeopathy at all. Yes, the remedies are described as "homoeopathic", but you could describe anything at all as homoeopathic, in that someone, somewhere will have made a homoeopathic potentisation of it - even prednisolone. The potencies used are not clear, though I'm guessing it might be 6X of the plant extract and 3X of the calcium phosphate. Not knowing the concentration of the mother tinctures is a bit of a downer, but essentially 1ppm of the former and 1,000ppm of the latter. Yeah, homoeopathic! It's a trial of some sort of herbalism. I see another paper by the same authors looking quite explicitly at μmol/l amounts of the stuff in a purely bench-top study of alleged anti-inflammatory properties. Wow, versatile stuff this!

Now, the patients. Fifteen people with "intracranial tumours". Of all sorts, apparently. I thought my esteemed colleague who did the Cushing's study on the dogs and horses was pushing it when he lumped equine pars intermedia tumours with canine pituitary-dependent Cushing's and canine adrenal tumours all together, but this one takes the biscuit. From Dana's post -

Of the 15 patients, 8 of the 9 glioma patients showed complete regression of tumors; 1 of 3 with meningioma showed complete regression and 2 of 3 showed prolonged arrest; 1 with neurinoma showed prolonged arrest; 1 with craiopharyngioma and 1 with pituitary tumors both showed complete regression.


The bolded part isn't in the abstract I've been able to find, which only has

Fifteen patients diagnosed with intracranial tumors were treated with Ruta 6 and Ca3(PO4)2. Of these 15 patients, 6 of the 7 glioma patients showed complete regression of tumors.


Dana, could you sounce your version of the abstract for us please? I may be able to get access to the full text from work, I'll see. But in the mean time, that's not much in the way of documentation, is it? But apparently lots of different diagnoses all treated the same. New sort of homoeopathy to me, I thought the point of that was that even people with the same diagnosis were treated differently, according to the individualisation.

And we're told no more than "6 of the 7 got better". Wow. If these patients had anything like what my friend had, that wouldn't be a throwaway line in an obscure journal, it would be banner headlines. Still, maybe it was a less malignant diagnosis, so we'll cut some slack here. Maybe this outcome wasn't all that unexpected in these patients anyway? In which case, what's all the fuss about. But really, to know what to make of this, we need some actual information, and what we have been given is nothing but a bald assertion.

Finally, could anything else have been responsible for the alleged, apparent recoveries. Well. These people appear to have been patients in a top cancer centre in Houston, Texas. Do we really think their oncologists just sat back and let the homoeopaths/herbalists do what they liked, and deprived the patients of any other treatment?

No, I didn't think so.

So, Dana, no documentation of the actual diagnoses, in detail, no documentation of the alleged "cure" of the brain tumours, and absolutely no way that there was nothing else that might have been responsible for this cure, if indeed it happened.

Just some herbalists being allowed to try their apparently harmless concoctions on a few patients receiving conventional treatment, and we have no idea what happened to similar patients who didn't get the herb/mineral, but I rather suspect probably not much different.

Damn, I'm doing it myself now, critiquing an academic paper in the thread devoted to case studies. Dana, that abstract in no way fulfils BSM's criteria, as discussed. And it would be nice if it was actual homoeopathy that was being practised, case-taking and individualisation and so on, don't you think? Take any further discussion of that and similar offerings to the other thread. Now go away and search your or someone else's case notes for something that does fit the bill. Have you ever "cured" anything serious, ever? Even once? Or can't you remember?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
The COPD study at the University of Vienna Hospital and published in CHEST (2005) is one such good piece of research despite what minor critique has been given to it. Although some weak critique was made about the treatment group and the control group were not perfectly comparable, there was not statistical difference between the groups,

However, I previously performed a power analysis, and there was a 70% chance that any significant differences between the groups would be missed. But I already told you this.

Call it weak if you like. It's sufficient to account for any differences in outcome without bringing magic water into it.

Linda
 
Hey Linda...
Below are some of the differences between the treatment group and the control group. On which data was your power analysis made?
The amount of tracheal secretions was reduced significantly in group 1 (the homeopathic treatment group) (p < 0.0001). Extubation (the removal of obstructive mucus from the lung with a tube) could be performed significantly earlier in group 1 (p < 0.0001). Similarly, length of stay was significantly shorter in group 1 (4.20 +/- 1.61 days vs 7.68 +/- 3.60 days, p < 0.0001 [mean +/- SD]). This data suggest that potentized (diluted and vigorously shaken) Kali bichromicum 30C may help to decrease the amount of stringy tracheal secretions in COPD patients.

In this study, all patients underwent a trial of extubation, but none (!) of the patients in group 1 had to be reintubated or needed even noninvasive ventilation to improve breathing. The amount of secretions remained stable and did not increase for patients in group 1. Also, the blood gas analyses after extubation remained stable in group 1. In contrast, four patients in group 2 had to be reintubated due to deterioration of blood gas analysis that was caused by tracheal secretions of grade 2 or 3.
 
Hey Linda...
Below are some of the differences between the treatment group and the control group. On which data was your power analysis made?
The amount of tracheal secretions was reduced significantly in group 1 (the homeopathic treatment group) (p < 0.0001). Extubation (the removal of obstructive mucus from the lung with a tube) could be performed significantly earlier in group 1 (p < 0.0001). Similarly, length of stay was significantly shorter in group 1 (4.20 +/- 1.61 days vs 7.68 +/- 3.60 days, p < 0.0001 [mean +/- SD]). This data suggest that potentized (diluted and vigorously shaken) Kali bichromicum 30C may help to decrease the amount of stringy tracheal secretions in COPD patients.

In this study, all patients underwent a trial of extubation, but none (!) of the patients in group 1 had to be reintubated or needed even noninvasive ventilation to improve breathing. The amount of secretions remained stable and did not increase for patients in group 1. Also, the blood gas analyses after extubation remained stable in group 1. In contrast, four patients in group 2 had to be reintubated due to deterioration of blood gas analysis that was caused by tracheal secretions of grade 2 or 3.

ON THE OTHER THREAD PLEASE!
 
I agree, none of this comes even close to fitting the criteria for inclusion in this thread. However, as Dana has advanced the brain tumours as being suitable, I'll just cover the small in vivo part of that study again, having now seen the full paper.

(From the Introduction)
Two of us (P.B. and P.B.) have used Ruta 6 and Ca 3(PO4)2 combination therapy to treat 15 patients diagnosed with advanced intracranial malignant brain cancer at the PBH Research Foundation, Kolkata, India.

(From the Materials and methods)​
Clinical features of patients with intracranial brain cancers.
The 15 patients (9 male, 6 female) with intracranial brain cancers who were treated with Ruta 6 + Ca3(PO4)2 at the PBH Research Foundation, Kolkata, India, had been diagnosed with glioma (9 patients), meningioma (3 patients), crainiopharyngioma (1 patient), neurinoma (1 patient), and pituitary tumors (1 patient). Diagnoses were based on radiology and/or histopathology. Most of these cases were at the advanced stage of the disease when homeopathic treatment was started in Kolkata, India. The patients gradually improved, as indicated by serial computed tomography scans and clinical examinations. The major complaints before treatment were headache, problem with vision, paralysis, convulsive seizures, vomiting, trembling of extremities, loss of memory, numbness, insomnia, and loss of taste. The age range was from 10 to 65 years, and the time required for cure/symptom-free state/static condition was 3 months to 7 years.

(From the Results)​
Outcome of brain cancer patients treated with Ruta 6 + Ca3(PO4)2.
The combination therapy of Ruta 6 and Ca3(PO4)2 was very effective in the treatment of intracranial brain cancers. Of the 9 patients with glioma, 8 (88.9%) showed complete regression, and the other patient showed partial regression. Two of the three patients with meningioma showed prolonged arrest of their tumors and the third had complete regression. The one patient with craniopharyngioma and the one patient with pituitary tumors both showed complete regression, and the 1 patient with neurinoma has had prolonged arrest of her tumor as determined by computed tomographic scan images (data not shown).

(From the Discussion)​
In the present study, we found that a combination of Ruta 6 and Ca

3(PO4)2 taken orally can either block the progression of or completely regress human glioma brain cancers, with minimal or no side effects. The patients diagnosed with glioma, when treated with Ruta 6, showed better results compared with patients having other types of intracranial cancers. Although the number of patients in our group was small, the outcome of homeopathic treatment was highly encouraging and novel.



First, although the authors describe this treatment as homoeopathic, it is clear that it is nothing of the sort. It is a trial of a herbal/mineral preparation in low but material concentrations. Not only that, but there is no actual homoeopathy involved - no case-taking, individualisation or remedy selection.

Now the results do seem interesting, however I have to say I treat them with more than a little scepticism, as the implied findings are literally too good to be true. Also, although the patients were indeed located in India, not Texas, I still see no reason to believe that conventional treatment was stopped when the herbal treatment began, so we don't know if we're just looking at a woo-woo remedy piggybacking on standard therapeutic approach. To put it simply, we are shown no control data of a complarable group of patient who were otherwise treated the same way, but who didn't get the herbalism. So we don't know how much, if anything, the herbalism contributed to the outcomes.​

It may be that this plant really does contain some pharmaceutically useful ingredient, and that seems to be what the bulk of the paper is investigating. But even if it did, so what? Just what, exactly, does this have to do with homoeopathy, Dana? Just that the authors use the word in the paper, and the plant they are investigating has (like just about everything else on the planet) also been used to make potentised homoeopathic preparations.​

Incidentally, does anyone know anything about the status of this journal? The title is impressive, as is the fact that some of the authors give their address as a cancer centre in Houston, Texas, however the quality of the paper is poor to my eyes. I haven't really looked at the benchwork part, as being even less relevant to what Dana is trying to show than the rest of it, however any journal which allows authors to present such earthshattering (or highly implausible, depending on how you look at it) clinical outcomes in the middle of what is basically an in vitro study, with so little data or confirmatory evidence for the assertions, is to my mind very suspect. I would have expected any competent scrutineer to insist on the clinical case information being removed, with the suggestion that that study be submitted for publication as a separate paper, with sufficiently detailed data and supporting evidence.​

Rolfe.​
 
Last edited:
Now the results do seem interesting, however I have to say I treat them with more than a little scepticism, as the implied findings are literally too good to be true. Also, although the patients were indeed located in India, not Texas, I still see no reason to believe that conventional treatment was stopped when the herbal treatment began, so we don't know if we're just looking at a woo-woo remedy piggybacking on standard therapeutic approach. To put it simply, we are shown no control data of a complarable group of patient who were otherwise treated the same way, but who didn't get the herbalism. So we don't know how much, if anything, the herbalism contributed to the outcomes.

I'm not sure that the findings are too good to be true. Many "brain tumours" are fairly benign (and I would propose that those that happen to show up at a homeopath's office are even moreso). For example, meningiomas tend not to cause any problems unless they happen to be in a spot where they place some pressure on an underlying structure. I wouldn't be surprised if these tumors were incidental findings in a patient who was sick from some other, self-limiting cause. However, I agree that the receipt of conventional treatment seems to be the more obvious possibility. And that these results didn't make the news tells us that they weren't particularly unexpected.

Incidentally, does anyone know anything about the status of this journal? The title is impressive, as is the fact that some of the authors give their address as a cancer centre in Houston, Texas, however the quality of the paper is poor to my eyes. I haven't really looked at the benchwork part, as being even less relevant to what Dana is trying to show than the rest of it, however any journal which allows authors to present such earthshattering (or highly implausible, depending on how you look at it) clinical outcomes in the middle of what is basically an in vitro study, with so little data or confirmatory evidence for the assertions, is to my mind very suspect. I would have expected any competent scrutineer to insist on the clinical case information being removed, with the suggestion that that study be submitted for publication as a separate paper, with sufficiently detailed data and supporting evidence.

It's not one that I had heard of before this. I did look it up and it is the publication of an NGO, The International Union Against Cancer. It states that the submissions are peer-reviewed. But this paper essentially tells us what the quality of that review is. As you said, I wouldn't have passed the paper as is.

Linda
 
OK, maybe I was too trusting of their description of the lesions.

.... advanced intracranial malignant brain cancer .... Most of these cases were at the advanced stage of the disease .... headache, problem with vision, paralysis, convulsive seizures, vomiting, trembling of extremities, loss of memory, numbness, insomnia, and loss of taste....


I'm no neurologist, and I don't know the expected outcome of the lesions named (glioma, meningioma, crainiopharyngioma, neurinoma and pituitary tumors), though "pituitary tumour" says "Cushing's disease" to my biochemist mind, and forgive me if I'm not impressed. The language suggests scary nasties though, and after having watched my friend die over a period of seven months from a glioblastoma, I did read it with the impression that these were serious cases with a poor prognosis. My bad.

OK, possibly not serious cases, no confirmation of diagnosis presented, no details given of conventional treatment which might have influenced the outcomes, no documentation of the alleged recoveries, and no control group to demonstrate what outcomes might have been expected in a comparable group treated conventionally without the herbalism. Published in a crap journal with crap scrutineering standards.

Sorry, Dana, no. Next please?

Rolfe.
 
Bump. Surely even the Merikans are awake by now? Or is Dana still frantically Googling for anything he can cut-and-paste that has some promising-looking buzzwords in it?

Just checked on the original version of this challenge, in the Bad Science blog.

pv said:
Here’s challenge. Give one incontrovertible example, with references, of a non-self-limiting condition being cured by homeopathic treatment. Here’s a few examples of such conditions in case you don’t know what is meant by “non-self-limiting”:
AIDS, typhoid, emphysema, diabetes, hypothyroidism, peritonitis, septicaemia, diphtheria, smallpox, tetanus, ebola…


By the way, which of you guys is pv? That's what I was looking for, the list of suggested non-self-limiting conditions we'd like to see case reports about. Others exist too, of course. I see someone else there ("wewillfixit") has come up with my perennial Addison's suggestion. That one is so uncompromisingly fatal, and yet the recovery with simple conventional treatment so complete and so dramatic I always think, where, homoeopaths, is your equivalent of that one? Or really, in memory of my late friend, how about a glioblastoma, properly documented of course?

Today I thought about a nice veterinary one. I was teaching some agriculture students about milk fever, and described the sudden collapse and death associated with the condition. Then I described the equally sudden and dramatic recovery with one simple injection. Homoeopathic vets, have you ever cured a case of milk fever?

No, it's always someone who knows someone who heard about a homoeopath in Nebraska, or the Punjab maybe, who had ever so many cured cases, why don't you email him about it? I'm a vet too, and I'll corroborate BSM's statement that dogs rarely eat homework. So where are all these records of cured cases of these sorts of conditions?

You know, all those deep, gentle, long-lasting and permanent cures that only individualised potentised homoeopathy can deliver, and which some of its proponents promise to every single one of their patients. I mean, there can't actually be none at all, can there? You know, you peel the pathology back from the outside in, unravelling all the layers from the most recent to the most persistent symptoms, and you get that deep and gentle cure.

Just one documented case? Of a patient who really wasn't going to get better on their own?

Rolfe.

PS. BSM, somewhere in one of those blogs, someone with access to the full text had done a great job on Allbrecht and Schutter (you remember, the one and only of Gregory's list of a handful of veterinary trials on the FacHom web site that could actually be traced online, in abstract). I can't find it now, do you have a link? I'd love to know where that guy got the full text, and peruse his analysis once more.

PPS. It's OK, I found it. Chris Lawson. Never heard of him before, and can't figure out how to contact him.
 
Last edited:
Bump. Surely even the Merikans are awake by now? Or is Dana still frantically Googling for anything he can cut-and-paste that has some promising-looking buzzwords in it?
....

Yes, even those of us on the west coast are awake, and Dana is on the west coast.... You posted this about 2pm Pacific Standard Time, it is now about 2:48 pm Pacific Standard Time. Dana must really be searching and searching.
 
<snip>

Or really, in memory of my late friend, how about a glioblastoma, properly documented of course?

<snip>

Let's be honest here: treatment for glioblastoma multiforme isn't exactly brilliant (yet).

(Father died 14 months ago, 12 months on from surgery, a few months after finishing a course of radiotherapy and temozolomide chemotherapy.)
 
I agree, none of this comes even close to fitting the criteria for inclusion in this thread. However, as Dana has advanced the brain tumours as being suitable, I'll just cover the small in vivo part of that study again, having now seen the full paper.

[/LE

Thanx Rolfe. You fell right into that trap that I placed for you. You see, you all show the real sloppiness of your thinking about homeopathy by assuming that all homeopathic medicines are beyond Avogadro's number. In fact, the majority of homeopathic medicines sold in health food stores and pharmacies are in the material dose range (under 24X or 12C).

If you now choose to only call homeopathic medicines those that are over Avogadro's number, you'll have to be arrogant enough to create your own dictionary too.

By the way, when Hahnemann first began experimenting with the "law of similars" (I prefer to consider this a type of resonance), he only used "material doses" of medicines for the first 20 years. Only in the last 20 years or so in his life did he begin testing even higher potencies. Initially, he too was extremely skeptical, but being the good scientist that he was, he was more interested in what was true than arm-chair assumptions about what he (or others) thought was true. Not all of us can be this smart.

Now that you call the medicine that was used in these brain cancer cases as non-homeopathy, you all can now start using this non-homeopathic medicines (I won't tell).

Oh...and thanx for coming to the aid of homeopaths by telling us all that THESE brain cancer cases were not "inidivudualized" and didn't have homeopathic "casetaking"--thus, this made these treatments non-homeopathic.

Cool...now you can help me damn that Shang et al "comparison" of the 110 homeopathic and allopathic trials...which got whittled down to the 21 high quality homeopathic trials and ONLY 9 (!) high quality allopathic trials...which then got whittled down to 8 homeopathic trials (7 of which only used a SINGLE MEDICINE without individualization...therefore, according to Rolfe, these trials were not homeopathic) and down to only 6 allopathic trials...which were no longer matched with each other in any way.

Perhaps, SOMEONE can finally tell us which were the 21 homeopathic trials and the 9 allopathic ones. Shang NEVER divulged, most likely because this review would show real benefits from homeopathic treatment. Isn't anyone suspicious of "black box" comparison studies like this? Why are only the homeopaths complaining here about junk science? Hmmmm.

The fact that the Lancet published this junk science just shows you how threatened they are with homeopathy. After all, to put all rationaity and ethics aside just to attack homeopathy suggest some major homeo-phobia. The Lancet does seem to believe in boogeymen.

Come out of the medicine closet people. I know that the people on this list are smart, but smart and narrow-minded isn't smart at all.

I am STILL waiting for someone (!) to speak in defense of the Shang "study." Waiting...waiting...
 
Cool...now you can help me damn that Shang et al "comparison" of the 110 homeopathic and allopathic trials...which got whittled down to the 21 high quality homeopathic trials and ONLY 9 (!) high quality allopathic trials...which then got whittled down to 8 homeopathic trials (7 of which only used a SINGLE MEDICINE without individualization...therefore, according to Rolfe, these trials were not homeopathic) and down to only 6 allopathic trials...which were no longer matched with each other in any way.

Perhaps, SOMEONE can finally tell us which were the 21 homeopathic trials and the 9 allopathic ones. Shang NEVER divulged...

http://apgaylard.wordpress.com/2007/11/28/the-myth-of-the-secret-eight/
 
You fell right into that trap that I placed for you. You see, you all show the real sloppiness of your thinking about homeopathy...


So all that case-taking, individualisation and remedy selection that homoeopaths do is just a waste of the patient's time and money?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom