That may in fact be true that nobody at NASA believes it's a rigid surface in that image, but NASA did create the images. I doubt most folks who read my website or who read my papers doubt the fact that most folks (including most folks at NASA) think that the sun is a PLASMA, without a solid surface. That's pretty much a given.
For good reason. No quantitative objective evidence exists to suggest otherwise. That's why the electric/iron Sun conjecture is likely to remain forever in the realms of crackpot pseudoscience.
Someone took those images and put them through a running difference process. It wasn't me and it wasn't Manuel. It absolutely was someone at NASA and/or LMSAL because the images came from them. That was all that was meant by the line in question in the first place.
The actual words in the acknowledgements of "On the Cosmic Nuclear Cycle and the Similarity of Nuclei and Stars" are
"NASA and Lockheed Martin’s TRACE satellite team made the image of rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere and the movie of a solar flare coming from that region (Fig. 2)." That is an attempt to imply that NASA and LMSAL made images of rigid structures, which is a lie of course. Oliver Manuel is a crackpot and a fraud. He can retract that falsehood. To the best of my knowledge he never has.
BS. The images exist. NASA created them. We can argue over the INTERPRETATION of the images, but the source and their existence isn't debatable.
They absolutely, positively did create the images in question, including the RD images in question.
Of the hundreds of thousands of images NASA and the LMSAL did create, none of them were images of "rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere" as the acknowledgements in that paper imply. As for the interpretation, it is 100% looks-like-a-bunny crackpot pseudoscience. And even when given every opportunity, there is not now nor has there ever been any quantitative analysis of the imagery which would objectively indicate that it shows "rigid structures beneath the fluid photosphere".
No, you're a a scientific fraud when it comes to claiming expertize in *SOLAR* satellite image analysis. "Electrical discharges? What discharges?" You incorrectly described the transition region color as a MISALIGNMENT of RGB images! You don't understand the light sources of a SINGLE STANDARD iron ion wavelength image, so there is no hope you could EVER understand a running difference or running averaged *SOLAR* image on one of those wavelengths.
The persistent incivility and unsupported personal attacks are noted.
What you might understand is pixels, and pixel intensities, and distances. What you won't understand is the PHYSICS. Do you even own a plasma physics textbook yet?
My expertise is in the acquisition and processing of the satellite imagery under discussion. Much of my understanding of the associated physics comes from exchanging communication with people at NASA and LMSAL who are directly involved in acquiring and processing those images. My analysis corresponds exactly with theirs. No alternative objective analyses have ever been provided by anyone.
And I'm not sure if I own any textbooks on the subject of plasma physics. But I have been around the web for over 20 years reading some of the crazy nonsense being spouted by various against-the-mainstream crackpots, cranks, and physics-expert wannabes. It is certain that I understand the topic far better than some people who do claim to own plasma physics textbooks.
No, Kosovichev located a "stratification subsurface" located under the photosphere that redirected the vertical flow of plasma horizontal at around 4800 KM. I used that information to predict the location of the so called "transition region" which is located UNDER the photosphere/chromosphere boundary in the SDO first light images.
No. Kosovichev did not predict the transition region is below the photosphere. He's not stupid. To suggest he did is a severe misunderstanding of Kosovichev's helioseismology research, willfully ignorant of previous discussions on the issue, or intentionally dishonest. What his helioseismology research does show is that there is plasma moving up, down, and sideways at thousands of kilometers per hour directly through the region that some claim is rigid or solid. Kosovichev's findings directly refute that solid/rigid surface nonsense.
I already went through a whole conversation with you over opacity of your MISUSE of that term. I also explained that the atmosphere would need to be highly ionized (+4,+5 for neon) for the light to be seen at such depth. You don't care about those conversations.
I just don't have the time today (or any day) to rehash a 15 thread, multi-MONTH conversation with you about pixel counts and intensities of pixels, and processing methods with you. You and I already had that conversation at a completely DIFFERENT website, more than 5 years ago! I probably still have the original movie that Dave presented of the original images. As I recall you even posted the exact CODE that was used in the RD imaging process. As I remember, you then described the PROCESSING METHOD correctly, but utterly botched the solar physics. You completely ignored the rigid/persistent features in the image (over 1:40 minutes in length), the lack of any plasma drift between those persistent features, and claimed: "Flying stuff? What flying stuff?" when I asking you questions about the flare event as observed in the RD image. Sheesh.
The persistent uncivil and dishonest misrepresentation of my position and lack of relevance to, well, any part of reality is noted.
But relevant to the topic, never in any discussion about the TRACE running difference image has any solid/rigid surface proponent ever provided a quantitative objective analysis. All the quantitative analyses have been done by other people, and have objectively concluded that the solid/rigid surface claims cannot be supported by that sort of image processing. I have asked again for such an explanation and posted images to facilitate it. The six-plus years of willful ignorance of that request and the continuing refusal to address the issue is noted.
Maybe when I post some samples of SDO images we can get a quantitative objective analysis showing how a simple RGB composite with a semi-transparent black disk overlay allegedly lets us to see through 80,000 kilometers of opaque plasma. I do predict that will also be met with the same willful ignorance and refusal to quantitatively explain it.