Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Apparently, Mozina does not even know the definition of a plasma.
Mozina can stop reading right now.




For all others:
For those interested I once started a "plasma physics for dummies on BAUT.

Hey, Clinger should read your website. He might learn something about magnetic field lines:

1. There are no magnetic “charges” called monopoles, magnetic field lines are closed loops

He keeps squawking about magnetic lines "beginning" and "ending". You really need to explain to him that they don't begin and end. It's really silly that he still thinks that is true. :)
 
Last edited:
Hey, Clinger should read your website. He might learn something about magnetic field lines:



He keeps squawking about them "beginning" and "ending". You really need to explain to him that they don't begin and end. It's really silly that he still think that is true. :)

And that, of course, leads us back to Post 6774

So, do field lines get wound up like that?
 
And that, of course, leads us back to Post 6774

So, do field lines get wound up like that?

I don't think so. I think they move (vertically around the magnet if necessary) and reorient themselves somewhere between 4) and 5), long before they look look like 6) or 7). There are flux changes going on all around the magnetic as I'm sure you know, and those changes will induce current in a conductor like a plasma.
 

The only way you're going to generate a magnetic field inside that vacuum is to introduce currents and a conductor into that vacuum. Whether you introduce plasma, or you introduce wires, you'll need something PHYSICAL to do any 'reconnecting'.
 
I don't think so. I think they move (vertically around the magnet if necessary) and reorient themselves somewhere between 4) and 5), long before they look look like 6) or 7). There are flux changes going on all around the magnetic as I'm sure you know, and those changes will induce current in a conductor like a plasma.

Hmm. So you think that figure 4 is correct, then?

ETA: for those of you watching at home, we're talking about this figure:
picture.php
 
Last edited:
The whole concept of individualized 'lines' is really primitive when trying to explain FULL FIELD interactions between rotating magnetic FIELDS.
 
Correct? :) No, I'm giving you LOTS of license with your hand drawing is what I'm doing. :)

Well, yeah, it's hard to make pretty curves in powerpoint on short notice.

Anyway the salient feature of 4) is that the line that connected "Left magnet, south pole, top corner" (hereafter referred to as "left-south-top") to right-north-top is still there, stretched and twisted to reach the formerly-top corner of the north pole of the right magnet.

Do you agree that the field line connecting those two corners would still be there*?

Boy, do I wish I'd put more labels on that drawing.

ETA *I don't think it would; I'm trying to come up with an easily testable difference between our concepts of magnetic fields
 
Last edited:
The breaking and reconnection of magnetic field lines is obvious, simply explained and elementary, as has been unambiguously demonstrated again and again in this thread. However, I see, based on the responses to Mozina, that the diversions, distortions, denials and deflections continue unabated. When someone knowingly and purposely embraces ignorance, there is no resolution.
 
The breaking and reconnection of magnetic field lines is obvious,

No PS. The website where you got YOUR image said "twisting and bending". It didn't say SQUAT about "reconnecting lines". You made that up all on your own.

simply explained and elementary, as has been unambiguously demonstrated again and again in this thread.

Well, the claim seems to be repeated a lot on this particular website, that's for sure. Of course when asked to provide a PEER REVIEWED AND *published* REFERENCE that claims plasma is optional, you've got NOTHING TO SHOW.

When someone knowingly and purposely embraces ignorance, there is no resolution.

That does seem to be true. When asked to provide a "rate of reconnection" in the absence of plasma, you folks have ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to show and never will have anything to show. All you'll EVER do is attack the individual. Speaking of self imposed ignorance, did you ever buy yourself a book on plasma physics yet?
 
Last edited:
Do you agree that the field line connecting those two corners would still be there*?

Hmm. The field would "strengthen" and "weaken" depending on orientation, but I suppose it's possible for them to "form" and "dissolve" for all I know. I'm not even comfortable thinking about fields in terms of "lines" to be honest. That just seems "goofy" to me, like thinking about gravity as a series of "lines" or something.

Let me think about it (over a beer). :)
 
I must say...

I'm finding it to be absolutely fascinating that all the math aficionados in this thread can't even think of a way to describe the rate of reconnection mathematically in the absence of plasma, but you're all sure reconnection happens in a vacuum without it. Wow! I want to stress again that NONE of you ever better tell me that physics is about math and peer reviewed science. You don't care one bit about the math or peer review. You don't even have any math to support your beliefs.
 
Last edited:
Hmm. The field would "strengthen" and "weaken" depending on orientation, but I suppose it's possible for them to "form" and "dissolve" for all I know. I'm not even comfortable thinking about fields in terms of "lines" to be honest. That just seems "goofy" to me, like thinking about gravity as a series of "lines" or something.


It's math. Given the already demonstrated lack of understanding the mathematical concept of lines at a fundamental level, it's possible that the entire concept of lines as they apply to magnetic reconnection is just too complicated to grasp.

Let me think about it (over a beer).


Unless beer makes math easier to comprehend, it's not likely to help.
 
It's math. Given the already demonstrated lack of understanding the mathematical concept of lines at a fundamental level, it's possible that the entire concept of lines as they apply to magnetic reconnection is just too complicated to grasp.

Who cares if I can "grasp" it? Just provide the math related to the rate of reconnection in the absence of plasma and that should speak for itself. You'll NEVER do that of course, but that's what it would take to demonstrate that "reconnection" is a plasma optional process and occurs in a pure vacuum WITHOUT any charged particles.

Unless beer makes math easier to comprehend, it's not likely to help.

The beer only makes your personal attack crappola more tolerable. That's a plus.

Show us your superior math skills and provide us with a mathematical definition for the rate of RECONNECTION that has nothing do with charged particles. Then again, maybe your math skills are as useful as your solar physics skills. "Electrical discharges in plasma? What discharges?" "Formula for the rate of reconnection without charged particles? What formula?"
 
Last edited:
Who cares if I can "grasp" it? Just provide the math related to the rate of reconnection in the absence of plasma and that should speak for itself. You'll NEVER do that of course, but that's what it would take to demonstrate that "reconnection" is a plasma optional process and occurs in a pure vacuum WITHOUT any charged particles.



The beer only makes your personal attack crappola more tolerable. That's a plus.

Show us your superior math skills and provide us with a mathematical definition for the rate of RECONNECTION that has nothing do with charged particles. Then again, maybe your math skills are as useful as your solar physics skills. "Electrical discharges in plasma? What discharges?" "Formula for the rate of reconnection without charged particles? What formula?"


The dishonest attempt to deflect the burden of proof and persistent incivility is noted. Apparently the electric/iron Sun conjecture is unsupportable since there is no effort being made to actually support it.
 
The dishonest attempt to deflect the burden of proof and persistent incivility is noted.

What are you talking about? Every single paper that uses MHD theory to describe "reconnection" demonstrates that plasma is REQUIRED in the process called "reconnection". If you feel otherwise you need to provide a formula for the rate of reconnection that is NOT based upon the flow of charged particles. Do you have one, yes or no? Let me guess? "Formula for the rate of reconnection without plasma? What formula?"

Talk about *DISHONEST* and crackpot nonsense. You can't even come up with a formula to explain the rate of reconnection in the absence of charged particle flow. Wow!
 
Last edited:
What are you talking about? Every single paper [...]


Tim has already shown that to be a lie. Apparently the electric/iron Sun conjecture is unsupportable. All we're seeing is complaints about failing to support it rather than any actual quantitative objective efforts to do so. We already acknowledge the failure to support it. The complaints are hardly necessary and certainly aren't going to help.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom