Michael Mozina
Banned
- Joined
- Feb 10, 2009
- Messages
- 9,361
Certainly not. The equivocation fallacy is "the misleading use of a term with more than one meaning or sense (by glossing over which meaning is intended at a particular time)". In this case, the word "flux" is not at all ambiguous to anyone who actually knows what they are talking about ...
But you're simply mislabeling several *DIFFERENT* things "magnetic reconnection", and failing to support your claim with *PUBLISHED* material that plasma is OPTIONAL Tim! How can I deal with that "scientifically"?
First you seem to be relabeling "magnetic flux change/time in a vacuum" = "magnetic reconnection". Then you're relabeling an INDUCEMENT OF CURRENT IN A PLASMA that results in an "electrical discharge" the EXACT SAME TERM! See a problem there Tim?
Furthermore your argument comes right back the coil example. You're claiming that we don't need a secondary winding in there (no more conductors), and we don't need that metallic rod either. We don't need to get an "electrical discharge" from the coil, all we have to do is break the connection to the primary coil, and thereby change the magnetic field and that too is "magnetic reconnection". Every and ANY change in the magnetic field strength due to movement is now relabeled "reconnection".
The fallacy of equivocation rests entirely with you & you alone. You are the one who is guilty of the misleading use of the term "flux". As for my definition of magnetic reconnection, there is neither equivocation nor ambiguity, and I once again refer the reader to my post from 24 January, Magnetic Reconnection Defined and Described as an objective substantiation of my assertion.
FYI, several of your own citations were based upon PLASMA PHYSICS Tim. In fact you highlighted the relevant quotes in some cases! You can't then ignore the fact that the maths are all based upon FLUID DYNAMICS, not basic EM fields!
It most certainly is not. And to the surprise of no one, we have already been down this road. The key to understanding why it cannot be induction is that induction can change only the geometry of a magnetic field, but can never change its topology.
The experiments all demonstrate that the topology change of the 'circuits' is a direct result of the change in CURRENT.
From 24 December 2009, over two years ago ...
From 30 December 2009 ...
Induction is a motion of the magnetic field relative to the plasma as illustrated by the induction equation given above, which depends on the magnetic diffusivity of the plasma and is therefore limited to the diffusion timescale, and which cannot change the topology of the field. Magnetic reconnection is a change in the topology of the field and therefore cannot be induction in any way. And all of this was hashed out over two years ago, and here we are, right back to where we were then. I am right and you are dead wrong, just as wrong now as you were two years ago.
And for two years now you've utterly ignored that paper by Mann and Onel that disprove your claim. Why is that?
To begin with, no the simple coil in a car does not change the topology of the magnetic field, it changes only the geometry, and it is therefore magnetic induction and certainly not magnetic reconnection. You could not tell the difference between a coil of wire and a plasma two years ago, and you still can't tell the difference ...
I can tell denial when I see it, including the fact you cling to that claim IN SPITE OF MANN's paper showing that the release of circuit energy need not be confined to ONE SPECIFIC SPOT, and can occur along a WHOLE SECTION OF THE CIRCUIT simultaneously. When you accept that fact, let me know.
So we come full circle? Two years ago you were ignorant about plasma physics.
There you go again fixating on the individual because you can't handle the implications of your own mathematical models. All the *PUBLISHED* maths describing "reconnection", every single one of them, all REQUIRE MHD theory. Plasma is therefore NOT optional in the reconnection process. When, oh when did you folks intend to start arguing like scientists with *PUBLISHED MATERIALS* instead of this juvenile "attack the messenger" baloney?
Come up with a LEGITIMATE PUBLISHED CITATION that is NOT based upon MHD theory, or admit that you've got NOTHING but irrational, emotional concept for the E orientation to events in space, and I just busted your show and therefore you blame me.

!