On the Solar Neutron-Star Core
At some point the outside shell of the neutron repulses other neutrons to the point that further compression due to gravity is offset by far stronger EM forces that push them apart. Somewhere I've posted a paper about recent experiments that show that a neutron actually looks more like an Oreo cookie with out outside negative shell, a positively charged middle and another negatively charged core. Manuel's work does suggest there is an upper limit to the amount of compression you can hope to get before it simply won't compress any further.
http://www.livescience.com/4601-discovery-understanding-neutrons.html
This is the link I was looking for ben. The outside shell of the neutron acts to "repulse" other neutrons. Gravity is no match from EM forces at small enough distances, and the neutron soup simply grows in size, it no longer compresses.
To begin with, this description of how neutrons avoid compression is not logically self consistent. After all, if you are going to argue that electrostatic repulsion of the negative outer layer is the explanation for neutron-neutron repulsion, then why don't you argue with equal force that the positive inner layer is electrostatically attracted to the negative core and negative outer layer, destroying the layered structure altogether? Or, ignoring that, just notice that while each negative shell sees another negative shell next door, they also each see a positive core a mere 10
-13 centimeters away behind that other negative shell. Clearly the positive-negative attraction will do much to weaken the negative-negative repulsion, such that the net repulsive effect is quite weak, considering the small distances involved and the inverse square Coulomb repulsion/attraction forces. Obviously, the logic embedded in these comments has problems that must be dealt with.
The webpage in question,
Discovery Changes Understanding of Neutrons is dated 17 September 2007. That webpage says, in part:
Live Science Webpage said:
Since 1947, physicists have thought the neutron, an electrically neutral elementary particle and a primary component of an atom, actually carries a positive charge at its center and an offsetting negative charge at its outer edge.
But new research shows the setup is more complex.
The neutron has been found to have a negative charge both in its inner core and its outer edge, with a positive charge sandwiched in between to make the particle electrically neutral. "Nobody realized this was the case," said Gerald A. Miller, a University of Washington physicist. "It is significant because it is a clear fact of nature that we didn't know before. Now we know it.
The webpage also tells us that the results were published in Physical Review Letters. Here is that paper:
Charge Densities of the Neutron and Proton, Gerald A. Miller, Physical Review Letters 99: 112011 14 September 2007 (paper published online 13 September 2007; you will need a subscription to read the paper or you will need to purchase it).
The abstract reads thus:
Miller said:
A model-independent analysis of the infinite-momentum-frame charge density of partons in the transverse plane is presented for the nucleon. We find that the neutron-parton charge density is negative at the center, so that the square of the transverse charge radius is positive, in contrast with many expectations. Additionally, the proton’s central d quark charge density is larger than that of the u quark by about*30%. The proton (neutron) charge density has a long range positively (negatively) charged component.
The abstract is not quite so informative in this case, so here is a relevant paragraph, which I think is more pointed in telling us what is being done here, short of simply reproducing the paper in its entirety:
Miller said:
A proper determination of the charge density requires that the quantity be related to the square of a wave function or of a field operator. The technical solution to the problem of determining the relevant density operator has been known for a long time [2], and has been elegantly explained recently [3, 4] in terms of generalized parton distributions GPDs. The charge density ρ(b) [5] of partons in the transverse plane is a two-dimensional Fourier transform of the F1 form factor. Here we present the first phenomenological analysis of existing data to determine ρ(b) for the neutron and proton. The results for the neutron contradict the long standing notion, derived from both gluon-exchange and meson-cloud models [6, 7], that the nonvanishing charge density at the center of the neutron is positive.
If we pay attention to the language of the paper, rather than the language of the PR website, we can see what is the problem I previously alluded to.
Mozina's model of neutron-neutron repulsion relies on a classical interpretation of electromagnetism, the low-energy limit where Maxwell's equations rule. Even in that context, it happens to be quite wrong, ignoring the part of the physics that would destroy the charge-layered structure instantly, and ignoring the fact that the repulsion would be weak anyway on account of the presence of attractive positive charges only 10
-13 centimeters away. But, aside from being internally self-contradictory, it is also the wrong basic physics to begin with. Classical electromagnetism does not apply in this scenario, where the physics of quantum mechanics holds sway. The square of a wave function in quantum mechanics is interpreted as a probability distribution, so we are not talking about any kind of classical charge carrier distribution inside the neutron, but rather a quantum mechanical probability distribution for the electric charge. In such circumstances, Maxwell's classical equations do not apply.
We already know the root of neutron-neutron repulsion, and have known it at least since
Oppenheimer & Volkoff, 1939. Neutrons are fermions and are therefore restricted by the Pauli exclusion principle, which forbids two neutrons from sharing the same energy state. It's the same principle which allows electron degenerate matter to form white dwarf stars.
Gravity is no match from EM forces at small enough distances, and the neutron soup simply grows in size, it no longer compresses.
This is another statement that has been known to be wrong for a long time. In fact, gravity
always overwhelms all other forces, even over very short distances, in the high energy limit. This is a fundamental principle of general relativity, and if
Mozina sticks to his guns, then he must deny the validity of general relativity, whether he likes it or not (see for instance,
Tolman, 1939). Electrostatic repulsion is insignificant to the stability of a neutron star, for the fairly obvious reason that neutrons have no net charge to repel with. It's the Fermi pressure from the Pauli exclusion principle (see above), which is far stronger than electromagnetic forces in any case. Were it not for the overwhelming force of gravity, a neutron star would blow itself to bits instantaneously due to the enormous Fermi pressure. The only reason that a neutron star can exist at all is that gravity overwhelms all other forces.
{ ... } Start by explaining to me WHY you think a RAW NEUTRON STAR is somehow going to experience "runaway fusion" just because it spits out protons and electrons around itself?
Why would they be ejected in the first place?
As for why the neutron star will experience runaway fusion,
ben_m answered well enough
in post #6304. But
Phunk asks a perfectly reasonable question, which has thus far gone unanswered. As one might guess by now, the correct answer is that a neutron star will not spit out neutrons, protons, electrons, or much of anything else, in quantity sufficient to explain any observed phenomena. This should not be surprising, since the surface gravity of a neutron star is on the order of 2x10
14 cm/sec
2 or roughly 2x10
11 Earth surface gravities. If anything is going to escape from that, it will be only the extraordinarily high velocity tail of the velocity distribution of particles in the neutron star crust. But this also explains the point
ben_m has made. If you put an object into the core of a main sequence star like the sun, with that kind of surface gravity, how do you not get runaway fusion?
For the technical detail & scientific background to support my claims, I refer the reader to the book
Compact Stars: Nuclear Physics, Particle Physics, and General Relativity by
Norman Glendenning (2nd edition, Springer-Verlag, New York, 2000) and to the book
Theoretical Astrophysics Volume II: Stars and Stellar Systems by
Thanu Padmanabhan (Cambridge University Press, 2001, particularly chapter 5, "White Dwarfs, Neutron Stars and Black Holes"). A few good examples of recent papers on neutron star physics are
The Physics of Neutron Stars (Aleksandr Potekhin, Physics Uspekhi 53(12): 1235-1256, December 2010;
The Physical Properties of Neutron Stars (J. Trümper, Proceedings of the 9th International Conference of the Hellenic Astronomical Society, proceedings of a conference held 20-24 September 2009 in Athens, published July 2010) and
Nuclear Physics of Neutron Stars (J. Piekarewocz, BULK NUCLEAR PROPERTIES: 5th ANL/MSU/JINA/INT FRIB Workshop. AIP Conference Proceedings, Volume 1128, pp. 144-153, May 2009). Most of these cited sources are dedicated either to an overall review or primarily to the internal physics of neutron stars. This discussion of ours depends mostly on the physics of the crust of a neutron star; see
The Physics of Neutron Star Crusts (Nicolas Chamel & Pawel Haensel, Living Reviews of Relativity {this is an open access online journal}, volume 11, published online 12 December 2008; this is a book-length paper with in-depth analysis of the topic).
Faced with the realities of the known physics of neutron stars, I assert that the idea that our own sun could have a neutron star or neutron star fragment anywhere inside itself is absurd in the extreme.