Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
You are really determined to record your inability to read.
Peratt gives no definition or examples of an electrical discharge *IN* plasma.

:id:

1 .5 Electrίcal Discharges in Cosmic Plasma
An electrical discharge is a sudden release of electric or magnetic stored energy. This generally occurs when the electromagnetic stress exceeds some threshold for breakdown that is usually determined by small scale properties of the energy transmission medium. As such, discharges are local phenomena and are usually accompanied by violent prαesses such as rapid heating, ionization, the creation of pinched and filamentary conduction channels, particle acceleration, and the generation of prodigious amounts of electromagnetic radiation. As an example, multi-terawatt pulsed-power generators on earth rely on strong electrical discharges to produce intense particle beams, Χrays, and microωανes . Megajoules of energy are electrically stored in capacitor banks, whose volume may encompass 250 m^3 . This energy is then transferred to a discharge regίοn, located many meters from the source, vi α a transmission line.

The discharge region, or load, encompαsses at most a few cubic centimeters of space, and is the site of high-variability, intense, electromagnetic radiatιοη (Figure 1 .2) .On earth, lightning is another example of the discharge mechanism at work where electr-o-static energy is stored in clouds whose volume may be of the order of 3,000 km3. This energy is released in a few cubic meters of the discharge channel.

The aurora is a discharge caused by the bombardment of atoms in the upper atmosphere by 1–20 keV electrons and 200 keV ions spirιlling down the earth's magnetic field lines at high latitudes . Here, the electric field accelerating the charged particles derιves from plasma moving across the earth's dipole magnetic field lines many earth radii into the magnetosphere .
 
Let's try this Clinger:

Since I'm personally dying to find out if you come out of the closet in part 5, let's try this plan: When you can personally explain that same VACUUM process *WITHOUT* using the term "reconnection", or claiming any B lines start or end at X, or relying upon any PROCESS involving plasma physics, like any other freshman physics student, I'll let you move on to part 5.
 
Last edited:
Just stumbled upon this from the 11th
Wow. I can't believe you folks removed my recent post to Clinger where I gave him a grade on his experiment. It's evidently fine for you folks to call me a fraud, and lie about my physics skills on a daily basis, but God forbid I should point out that Clinger KLUDGED a simple quadrapole magnetic field experiment.
Do you have the idea that the rest of the posters are moderators with the power to remove posts?

If a post was moved by the moderators it would be because it violated the Membership Agreement. This suggests that you did more than "give a grade". Looking at the probable post in AAH does suggest a reason for it being moved - attacking the person, not the argument.

BTW: A grade is missing. You would need to go through W.D. Clinger's posts on the experiment and show where he went wrong (using science and mathematics rather than your personal opinion) in order to give a grade, e.g. X equations presented, Y wrong thus a grade of Y/X.
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina's fantasy about Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge

The Michael Mozina's fantasy about Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge! post midded out Michael Mozina's inability to understand the difference between a title and a definition.
Do you know the difference between a title and a definition
First asked 11 January 2011

Of course the title is not a definition. It is a description of the contents of the section.
The definition never mentions plasma.
The section never mentions electrical discharges in plasma (cosmic or otherwise!).

The full text of the section (all 4 paragrapghs!) is quoted in Peratt and Electrical Discharges in Cosmic Plasma
And you have to ask the question: Why is the magical property of the 'cosmic plasma' in the title "Electrίcal Discharges in Cosmic Plasma" been ignored by the scientific literature?
 
MM: What is the areal density of magnetic field lines where the magnetic field = 0

Let's try this Clinger:

Since I'm personally dying to find out if you come out of the closet in part 5, let's try this plan: When you can personally explain that same VACUUM process *WITHOUT* using the term "reconnection", or claiming any B lines start or end at X, or relying upon any PROCESS involving plasma physics, like any other freshman physics student, I'll let you move on to part 5.
Let's try you forcing W.D. Clinger into following your lead and ignoring the actual science!

  • The VACUUM process is called magnetic reconnection (in a VACUUM) as stated in the scientific literature.
  • The B field lines do end at X as is obvious from his posts and the scientific literature.
  • Plasma physics is not taught at freshman level.
  • W.D. Clinger's posts so fare use freshman EM theory and calculus.
  • W.D. Clinger's next post will introduce some plasma.
Abandon any fantasy that you can stop W.D. Clinger from moving onto part 5. His post 5 will not be delayed because you are unable to understand any of the preceding posts.

P.S.

MM: What is the areal density of magnetic field lines where the magnetic field = 0
 
Last edited:
Let's try you forcing W.D. Clinger into following your lead and ignoring the actual science!

I didn't ask Clinger to handwave away about some sort of vacuum contraption that would produce magnetic reconnection, he did. I'm just trying to find a logical way to let him move forward because my curiosity is killing me about part 5 and whether or not he comes out of the closet.

As Clinger explained to us earlier, his freshman physics textbook doesn't even mention the term 'reconnection', but I'm sure it includes the information necessary to explain that process WITHOUT the term "reconnection". When he can do that, like any other freshman student, *WITHOUT* the term "reconnection" and without beginning and ending B field lines, I'll be happy. Until then he hasn't even grasped BASIC EM theory! He doesn't even NEED the term "reconnection" to explain that experiment in a vacuum.
 
Last edited:
MM: What is the areal density of magnetic field lines where the magnetic field = 0

I didn't ask Clinger ...
...insanity about about magnetic reconection without the term 'reconnection'.. snipped
Duh - we know that you did not ask him.
We can read that W.D. Clinger has presented a freshman level description of an experiment that demonstrates magnetic reconnection.
What you are still unable to understand tis that this is freshman EM theory and calculus.
This is not MR theory which is usually a graduate course. It is thus idiotic to complain about MR theory not appearing in freshman EM textbooks.

The insanity in the rest of your post s that you ignore that the scientific term to "explain that experiment in a vacuum" is magnetic reconnection.

P.S.
MM: What is the areal density of magnetic field lines where the magnetic field = 0
 
Last edited:
What a bunch of BS.

We *ALL* know that Clinger's "vacuum contraption" has to *EVENTUALLY* be swapped out for a PLASMA contraption. A plasma contraption actually might experience induced E fields and might (depending on how fast he changes B) actually work as described to produce an electrical discharge in a plasma. I'm curious what he expects me to say about his blatant bait and switch routine when he gets to Part 5, but I'm much more curious if he finally embraces electrical discharges in flares and plasma in part 5. Hell, I'll even postpone the reaming he's going to get for the blatant bait and switch routine until AFTER I hear the whole story. :) Inquiring minds want to know. :)

What he will understand at the end is the difference between a PLASMA DISCHARGE PROCESS in a plasma contraption and an ordinary quadrapole magnetic field in a vacuum contraption.
 
Last edited:
What a bunch of BS.
What a bunch of BS.

We *ALL* know that Clinger's "vacuum contraption" has to *IN PART 5* have some plasma added because that is what W.D. Clinger has said that he will do :jaw-dropp!

There will be no 'bait and switch' because he will just do what he stated he will do (and knows that posters can read and will see any switch).

What he will understand at the end is the difference between a PLASMA DISCHARGE PROCESS in a plasma contraption and an ordinary quadrapole magnetic field in a vacuum contraption.
This gibberish because it has nothing to do with part 5.
a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 4
In part 5, I will explain the two main points of [Dungey 1958] by adding a little plasma to the magnetic field B4. It is not really possible to understand Dungey's paper without first understanding the neutral point and magnetic field lines of B4 or similar fields in a vacuum.
 
http://sdo.gsfc.nasa.gov/assets/img/latest/latest_1024_0304.mpg
http://sdo.gsfc.nasa.gov/assets/img/latest/latest_1024_0171.mpg

FYI the sun is experiencing one of the "weirdest" dark filament eruptions/dissipation processes I've seen thus far in SDO this cycle. It's a very long filament oriented toward the 11:00 position. Part of it (near the limb) more or less "erupted/dissipated/dissolved", while some of it did not. That's cool IMO!
FYI: Really cool pictures but nothing to do with this thread.
 
Originally Posted by Reality Check
I have (and will continue to) call you a liar......
Originally Posted by Reality Check
Yes I do: MM: I have called you a liar becuase you have lied as documented in this post
Quote mining is a lie.
Originally Posted by Reality Check
And once again we get your your obsession with the obsolete use of the term 'electrical discharge'

The exchange I had with Mozina some days ago about moving magnets is classic. On this any many other threads Mozina dances, dodges, obfuscates and, of course, LIES! No matter what you and Clinger and others say and demonstrate, his delusions will persist. I have come to believe that, in addition to his inability to understand mathematics, he has trouble following the logic of these discussions and resorts to these tactics to mask his intellectual deficiencies and ignorance. These problems and the religious zeal associated with EU cult thinking makes any discussion with him hopeless!
As you said:
No MM. You don't even know enough to know what is a fantasy and what is the science. You don't take the time to find out either. Physics cranks are all alike. The topic changes, but the physics crank behaviors are exactly the same.
•Displays of ignorance of science
•A determination not to learn science.
•Fantasies about science
•Going off on rants when their fantasies are challenged with actual science.
•Obsessions with semantics rather then looking at the science.
•A refusal to even look at questions which might teach them about science.
Isn't this what we are seeing demonstrated again and again?
 
Just to set the record straight: I have never alleged that "Origin" was the great "beginor and endor" of all B field lines. In fact, I said quite clearly that the set of B4's field lines that begin or end at the origin form a set of measure zero.

Never mind, Clinger, this is just envy and hatred speaking from MM, because you "show off" your mathematical prowess, which MM lacks (and probably would love to have).

As a side note, like I said before, the separatrices are special cases. Now, what MM does not seem to understand is that there is still continuity, because the two lines come in, two lines go out. However, the field is zero, by necessity, because otherwise the field would have four directions at that specific point.
 
Never mind, Clinger, this is just envy and hatred speaking from MM, because you "show off" your mathematical prowess, which MM lacks (and probably would love to have).

What? OMG. While I admit to being envious of sol's basic prowess in physics and Tim's knowledge in general, Clinger and rest of the hater crew don't even have a CLUE about basic theory. In fact the four of them *COMBINED* can't even *CORRECTLY* explain a standard quadrapole magnetic field in a vacuum! Holy Cow! I'd be EMBARRASSED AS HELL to have posted the nonsense to this thread that Clinger has posted!

As a side note, like I said before, the separatrices are special cases. Now, what MM does not seem to understand is that there is still continuity, because the two lines come in, two lines go out. However, the field is zero, by necessity, because otherwise the field would have four directions at that specific point.

Quit confusing him with plasma physics. He doesn't even understand BASIC theory or he would be able to explain his vacuum contraption *WITHOUT* the term "reconnection" and without ERRONEOUSLY claiming that B lines begin and end at the X!. When he can do that LITTLE, then he can think about gloating over his math skills. Until then, those math skills seem pretty damn useless to me, as well as the math skills of all the rest of haters. They couldn't even help him find his BUSH-LEAGUE mistakes as a GROUP! Evidently every single one of them thinks that magnetic B field lines begin and end at a null point in a vacuum of an ordinary quadrapole magnetic field experiment. Sheesh.
 
Last edited:
The exchange I had with Mozina some days ago about moving magnets is classic.

Yep, it was absolutely "classic" hater dialog. Instead of providing a real published paper to support your claim, you misread a website, and utterly abused and misused one of their images as a "scientific argument" by itself.

Even though I *CORRECTLY* explained that process to you, you *STILL* do not understand it. Instead of admitting YOUR mistake, you attack the individual. Yep, "classic" hater behavior alright.
 
Last edited:
Quit confusing him with plasma physics.

What plasma physics?
Talking about epic fail, sheesh, you just read the words and then fill in what you want to read.
I said:

me said:
As a side note, like I said before, the separatrices are special cases. Now, what MM does not seem to understand is that there is still continuity, because the two lines come in, two lines go out. However, the field is zero, by necessity, because otherwise the field would have four directions at that specific point.

What exactly is here plasma phyiscs, I am just talking about magnetic fields, field lines and separatrices. I have not talked about plasma physics.
 
What plasma physics?
Talking about epic fail, sheesh, you just read the words and then fill in what you want to read.
I said:



What exactly is here plasma phyiscs, I am just talking about magnetic fields, field lines and separatrices. I have not talked about plasma physics.

Do the B field lines begin (and end) at X *IN A VACUUM* (no particles whatsoever), not even a "monopole"?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom