Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Are you going to ask *THEIR SIDE* any questions Belz? Honestly, I'd *LOVE* to hear you ask Clinger how he intends to get an electrical discharge from his vacuum contraption, or how he expects a B field to form at the X without a single plasma particle to work with, and no possibility of current flow at that location. That would not be a comfortable conversation for Clinger, in fact I suspect he'd run like hell from it.

See the problem? This guy is so intellectually paralyzed by his own delusions, that he fantasizes that everyone has a "side."
I am not a physicist, so when I ask a question, it is asked out of genuine curiosity. Some people have given me useful answers, which have enhanced my understanding in matters where I have no training. Mozina invariably misunderstands the question, obfuscates, seems to be confused by my questions, is evasive, changes the subject and inevitably becomes combative because I have taken a "side."
Now, I have never studied plasmas or solar physics and my electromagnetism training is based only on my physics minor (math major) over 40 years ago.
Mozina, with less training than I have, reads "papers" without the mathematics background and physics training to understand them, comes to an uninformed conclusion and challenges those who have training and knowledge in these matters.
So, Belz..., soon you too will soon have taken a "side" and will be cast in the role of adversary. This thread is really just an exercise in futility and, if it were not for the informative comments made by knowledgeable people here, it would be a total waste of time.
 
Again, you have not understood a thing, have you?

About Clinger's handwavy "experiment"? Nah. I don't profess to either. I can't imagine how he intends to get an electrical discharge to occur in a "vacuum", let alone get B lines to "begin" and "end" at X. Beats me (shrug). I doubt any of it will make any sense to me in fact until we get to installment five where he pulls the switcheroo and replaces his vacuum with a real plasma. Maybe then it will work. :)

The X lines forms in the, as you so often call is, continuum that is the B field, between oppositely directed magnetic field lines that are pressed together.

So they don't actually "begin" at the X?
 
See the problem? This guy is so intellectually paralyzed by his own delusions, that he fantasizes that everyone has a "side."

Did you call Clinger a "fraud" PS? You *MISREAD* some website in cyberspace and YANKED ONE IMAGE from that page, providing me me with NO information about it. I still CORRECTLY explained to you that it described "solid magnet reconnection", not an electrical discharge in a plasma. You then proceeded to BERATE me personally for 'not answering your questions', while AVOIDING answering any of the questions I asked you that would have helped me to understand the idea that you were trying to convey (changing magnetic flux). In the end, you never apologized for YOUR error, and you still continue to attack me personally every few weeks. If you don't have a "side", what's with all the BS about me being a "fraud" and where is my apology for YOUR error?

What kinds of relevant questions have you asked Clinger about his handwavy experiment in terms of all that missing plasma and that BS about B lines "beginning" in a vacuum?
 
Last edited:
The paper is Three-dimensional current systems generated by plasmas colliding in a background magnetoplasma by Gekelman, Collette & Vincena; Physics of Plasmas 14(6): 062109, June 2007. The claim is found in the final section, summary and conclusions: "In the first microsecond of the process, it seems that the initial electron current is driven by magnetic field-line reconnection." There is a similar later comment, but I am not sure whether the authors are referring to their own experiment, or another that they are also talking about: In this experiment, magnetic field line reconnection sites pepper the plasma volume and are identified with the Alfven wave structures."
That other paper, the 1958 Dungey paper, also explicitly identifies the reconnection of magnetic field lines as the initial source of energy for his "electric discharge". Not, mind you, the reconnection of "field aligned currents", but rather the reconnection of the lines of force of the magnetic field.

Actually Tim, you caught me. I haven't finished that entire paper yet, and I haven't gotten to the summary yet. It was a busy day yesterday and I took my time reading through the whole paper rather than just reading the abstract and conclusion. I've seen the concept of induced E field and field aligned currents used a TON of times. I'll have to wait to comment on those FEW instances where the used the term 'line'. It's not clear yet to me if he means the 'field aligned current line', or an actual magnetic line. I won't forget your question, but you'll need to be patient. I'm not done.

In terms of the inducement of an E field as Dungey and Somov describe it, that actually only requires "changing magnetic flux" (bending, twisting), not necessarily "reconnection". Therein lies the rub for me (and Alfven as well). How can any of you be POSITIVE that the MAGNETIC lines actually disconnect or reconnect rather than simply 'flux', particularly when were talking about FIELD ALIGNED CURRENTS, not just magnetic lines?
 
Last edited:
Are you with us so far, or am I going too fast for you?

I actually do have a "basic" question about your formulas that still makes no sense to me. How did you arbitrarily decide that BW and BE (and BS and BN) were DIFFERENT, and INDEPENDENT B lines? In other words, why not just a B(n/s) and a B(e/w)? Why four lines rather than two?

Since you have no "current" at the X and no "magnet" at the X, but you claim that the magnetic lines "begin" and "end" at the X, what GENERATES the B fields at X in the first place?
 
Last edited:
However, without a plasma you will not get interesting effects, like e.g. the creation of aurorae.

Ya, it also creates that interesting effect of "electrical discharges" that Clinger is NEVER going to create in a vacuum. It's one thing to say that the lines come "together" at the X and create "flux" at that X. It's another thing entirely to claim they BEGIN at X and END at X. Is Clinger right or wrong about that claim in your opinion?
 
Last edited:
W.D. Clinger may get to magnetic reconnection in plasma. But then he will not be able to include any 'electrical discharge' because electrical discharges are impossible in plasma.

OMG are you confused. He won't get an "electrical discharge" *WITHOUT* a plasma! No electrons, no protons, no discharge. Get it?
 
Last edited:
Are you going to ask *THEIR SIDE* any questions Belz? Honestly, I'd *LOVE* to hear you ask Clinger how he intends to get an electrical discharge from his vacuum contraption, or how he expects a B field to form at the X without a single plasma particle to work with, and no possibility of current flow at that location. That would not be a comfortable conversation for Clinger, in fact I suspect he'd run like hell from it.

I already have. You haven't been following.

Also, I'm the least of your troubles here.
 
I already have. You haven't been following.

Also, I'm the least of your troubles here.

You're not any trouble because you're not a hater. You're just having fun and asking logical questions. If you simply redirect that electrical discharge without electrons question at Clinger, I assure you that you'll have more fun. :)

I'm totally cool with skeptics like you. That's what skepticism is about. PS handwaves around an artists illustration at me of changing magnetic flux, and solid magnet reconnection, with no references or text whatsoever. He erroneously claimed it was "magnetic reconnection". When it finally became clear that he simply MISREAD the website (as did RC), he never apologized for calling me a fraud. PS is trouble because he's an EU hater. His actions and statements are not based on logic, but upon EMOTION. His skepticism is not applied to ALL sides of the debate, just at EU oriented idea, and his attacks are not directed at the scientific argument, but upon the individual ("fraud"). That behavior is "trouble". Skeptics like you are "fun". I'm enjoying your input thus far and I've copped to my "sin" of exasperation with RC. You're no trouble at all. :)
 
Last edited:
Okee-Dokee ... Dated 7 Dec 2010 ...


"Certain other features of flares may be accounted for by the bulk motion resulting from a discharge at a neutral point. The effect of the discharge is to 'reconnect' the lines of force at the neutral point, and this happens quickly. The 'reconnection' upsets the mechanical equilibrium in the neighborhood in a way that can be visualized, if the lines of force are seen as strings. Then the mechanical disturbance will spread from the neutral point and may have energy comparable to the energy of the spot field in the solar atmosphere."
Dungey, 1958, page 139

So, you're fine, I take it, with Dungey pegging the reconnection of the magnetic field lines of force as the source of the energy for his "electric discharge"?

I'm fine as long as you and I can agree that the lines of force and "strings" include plasma filaments and include a discharge current that is flowing through it. That is why I'm fine with the term "current reconnection". Honestly Tim, I wish you would just meet me in the middle. :(
 
Last edited:
The comedy continues...

That's the kind of BS that has no place in a real scientific debate. Ditto on Clingers so called handwavy "experiment". I mean the guy doesn't have a single electron or plasma particle to his name to work with, so he is never going to get an "electrical discharge" from that contraption. He doesn't even have CURRENT to generate any B fields at his X point.
The highlighted statement is absurd on several levels.

As I have been telling you since last December, the experiment I suggested reproduces the magnetic fields shown in Dungey's 1958 paper by the bog-simple expedient of running current through four parallel rods. As I stated in part 3 of my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, I'm using 1000 amperes of current in each of the four rods to generate the magnetic field.

What's more, the B field is zero at the X point; that's why Dungey and everyone else call it a neutral (or null or zero) point. We want B to be zero at that point, because we're trying to demonstrate magnetic reconnection, which can only happen where the B field is zero.

Honestly, I'd *LOVE* to hear you ask Clinger how he intends to get an electrical discharge from his vacuum contraption, or how he expects a B field to form at the X without a single plasma particle to work with, and no possibility of current flow at that location. That would not be a comfortable conversation for Clinger, in fact I suspect he'd run like hell from it.
You are arguing as though you think the B field must be zero wherever the current density is zero.

The proper scientific term for your apparent belief is "abject ignorance". As tusenfem wrote:

Again, you have not understood a thing, have you?
The X lines forms in the, as you so often call is, continuum that is the B field, between oppositely directed magnetic field lines that are pressed together.
The X line is not creating the magnetic field, as you seem to imply here, cf. "a B field to form at the X".
Bringing fields together does that automatically, there need not be a plasma. However, without a plasma you will not get interesting effects, like e.g. the creation of aurorae.

Again, you have not understood a thing, have you?

About Clinger's handwavy "experiment"? Nah. I don't profess to either.
None of us expect you to understand a thing. You aren't trying to understand. You're trying your best not to understand.

I can't imagine how he intends to get an electrical discharge to occur in a "vacuum",
I do not intend to get an electrical discharge to occur within a vacuum, and have never claimed that I would. That's just another of your straw men, endlessly repeated.

What I have been saying is that you (and many others) would find it easier to understand magnetic fields and magnetic reconnection in a vacuum than in plasma. Once you understand magnetic fields and magnetic reconnection, we can then add plasma and try to understand the far more complex phenomena that can occur when plasma interacts with magnetic fields.

let alone get B lines to "begin" and "end" at X. Beats me (shrug).
So after all your absurd remarks about the hand-waving of my math, followed by your explicit request to "please show us the math", you aren't even trying to understand the math.

How could I ever have seen that coming?

I doubt any of it will make any sense to me in fact until we get to installment five where he pulls the switcheroo and replaces his vacuum with a real plasma. Maybe then it will work. :)
I will indeed add plasma in part 5, and yes it will work. After all, I'm just going through exactly the same math and physics that Dungey used in his 1958 paper.

The X lines forms in the, as you so often call is, continuum that is the B field, between oppositely directed magnetic field lines that are pressed together.

So they don't actually "begin" at the X?
Two magnetic field lines actually begin at the neutral (X) point. I have already sketched a proof of that, complete with algebra you were unable to do on your own. (I'll give up on you now and post a grown-up derivation of the fact that magnetic field lines can begin or end at neutral points, because it's an interesting fact that contradicts a popular myth.)

I doubt it will make a lot of sense to me until I see that electrical discharge process explained mathematically in your "vacuum".

:popcorn1
I doubt whether it will make any sense at all to you even after you've seen the math.

How can any of you be POSITIVE that the MAGNETIC lines actually disconnect or reconnect rather than simply 'flux', particularly when were talking about FIELD ALIGNED CURRENTS, not just magnetic lines?
Because we've done the math. Because we know how magnetic flux and magnetic field lines are defined. Because we know the differences between magnetic reconnection, magnetic flux, and field aligned currents.

I actually do have a "basic" question about your formulas that still makes no sense to me. How did you arbitrarily decide that BW and BE (and BS and BN) were DIFFERENT, and INDEPENDENT B lines? In other words, why not just a B(n/s) and a B(e/w)? Why four lines rather than two?
You are very confused. BE, BW, BN, and BS are magnetic fields, not magnetic field lines. B4 is their linear superposition; it is also the magnetic field shown in Dungey's figure 1. With a linear superposition of BE and BW, you get Dungey's figure 2.

You may view those magnetic fields by clicking on the hyperlinks I just gave you.

Since you have no "current" at the X and no "magnet" at the X, but you claim that the magnetic lines "begin" and "end" at the X, what GENERATES the B fields at X in the first place?
Once again, you sound as though you think the B field must be zero wherever the current density is zero. Once again, the proper scientific term for that belief is "abject ignorance".

The magnetic field B4 (which is essentially the same as the magnetic field shown in Dungey's figure 1) is generated by the current that's running through four parallel rods that lie outside the area shown in my zoomed graph and Dungey's figure 1.

For details, please pay attention to the experiment I've been recommending to you for most of the past year.

It's one thing to say that the lines come "together" at the X and create "flux" at that X. It's another thing entirely to claim they BEGIN at X and END at X. Is Clinger right or wrong about that claim in your opinion?
The reason we call it a neutral point is that there is no magnetic flux at that X point. There is magnetic flux everywhere else, but not at that neutral point. That's why magnetic reconnection can happen at the X, but can't happen anywhere else. That's also why magnetic field lines can begin and end at the neutral point. (By Gauss's law for magnetism, magnetic field lines can't begin or end anywhere except at a neutral point.)
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7668879&postcount=3861

I suggested that experiment to you because it would have helped you to understand that

Dungey is describing magnetic reconnection.
There is no "circuit reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
There is no "current reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can be reproduced without plasma.
The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can occur with a near-zero electric (E) field.

How many of these statements do you still stand by Clinger?
 
Last edited:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7668879&postcount=3861

I suggested that experiment to you because it would have helped you to understand that

Dungey is describing magnetic reconnection.
There is no "circuit reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
There is no "current reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can be reproduced without plasma.
The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can occur with a near-zero electric (E) field.

How many of these statements do you still stand by Clinger?
That's a trick question. I still stand by the five indented statements, of course, but the highlighted part is false: Nothing will help you to understand.
 
That's a trick question. I still stand by the five indented statements, of course, but the highlighted part is false: Nothing will help you to understand.

Then you learned nothing by your efforts. What you should have learned is that the following four statements are false:

There is no "circuit reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
There is no "current reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can be reproduced without plasma.
The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can occur with a near-zero electric (E) field.

Dungey's paper *INCLUDED* (didn't exclude) an E induced "electrical discharge" inside of a plasma. That is the actual single sentence "definition" (*DUNGEY's DEFINITION*) of "magnetic reconnection".

There is current flowing through the plasma that "reconnects' all over the place. There are "circuits" in plasma that exchange PARTICLES.

The magnetic reconnection described by Dungey, the one that explains solar flares in plasma could NEVER be reproduced without plasma. That was and is a flat out lie.
 
Last edited:
About Clinger's handwavy "experiment"? Nah. I don't profess to either.

Clinger's model/experiment is the point at which every reconnection course starts. Like I say, maybe you should understand the simple models first and then move on to more complicated stuff.

So they don't actually "begin" at the X?

Why on Earth would they "begin at the X" that makes no sense at all!

Again, read up on the first chapters of a book on reconnection, that you actually understand the basics of Petschek and Sweet-Parker.
 
Ya, it also creates that interesting effect of "electrical discharges" that Clinger is NEVER going to create in a vacuum. It's one thing to say that the lines come "together" at the X and create "flux" at that X. It's another thing entirely to claim they BEGIN at X and END at X. Is Clinger right or wrong about that claim in your opinion?

discharge, schmischarge!

Like I said the same thing happens to the B field lines in vacuum, however there are no interesting effects associated with the process. Don't state the obvious as if it is a revelation, that in vacuum there are no particles to accelerate.

And if you would actually know something about electrodynamics, you would understand that there is no "created flux at the X" because at the X the field strength is zero.

The claim has never been (at least not by me) that they (the field lines I guess) start and end "at the X."

Once more, try to learn the basics, you have to know how to walk before you can run (and more platitudes like that).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom