Originally posted by Edge
Damn wart your more anti-dowsing fanatical that I am pro-dowsing fanatical.
Nope, I just want some actual credible proof that you can sucessfully dowse under fair test conditions. Right now, we have nothing but your word on it. In fact, we have lots of credible evidence that quite clearly indicates that you
can't dowse. And that evidence is right here.
http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
The test was done from their perspective
◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊.
You helped create the test with Randi. So I guess it had to be from your "perspective" also or you never would have agreed to it.
Besides, "perspective" or no, you still managed to fail miserably at a test you helped design and that you approved 100%.
and yes I accepted the challenge,
Of course you did. You helped create it and accepted the test conditions 100% according to Randi. Unless you're accusing him of "making false statements again".
I probably would not have accepted but the thing took so long to set up.
Another excuse. Regardless of how long it took to setup, you could have backed out or changed the test conditions at any time. The reason is took so long to setup is because you and Randi *Both* had to agree that the test conditions were fair to you both. The fact it took a while shows that the test was fully thought out and approved by both of you. It actually strengthens the fact that the test was fair.
Ok, Now let's try this.
Can you answer this question clearly Edge?
Was the preliminary test you took at the JREF with Randi Fair?
Please answer with a
"Yes" or a "No".
And support your answers with actual facts. We could care less whether you test was taken from a "different perspective" or whether you think Randi Sabotaged you with mysterious "electrical waves" coming through the wall. Give us a straight answer and we'll give you some crediblity.
I had a pressing need to do it only De-Bunk knows why.
And you helped create the test, agreed to it 100%, failed miserably, and now want to lie and spin excuses to explain that failure. Bleh.
It was not a scientifically controlled theater of operation from the believers’ point of view or from a scientific point of view.
Irrelevant. I could care less whether you now want to claim the test condition were "unscientific" or not. You agreed to them 100%, so no bitching about them now.
I just care whether or not you can actually dowse successfully under fair test conditions.
Nice attempt to change the subject again.
False positive results are something I have never had to deal with as in the field when mining they rarely happen and I can't think of one mistake that dowsing has caused me when mining.
Ahh... The old "It only works in the field" excuse.
When asked about the targets you used in the Prelim test (Sacajawea "gold" dollars, etc), you stated....
He said he had always been successful in detecting each and all of these seventeen items, when his forked stick was specifically "tuned" to pick up gold — by having a small scrap of gold fastened to its tip. That's a common claim made by dowsers, that their stick/rod/pendulum is sensitive to the substance attached to it. We decided to use the entire package of seventeen items, sealed in a plastic bag, to give Mike the maximum chance of finding his target
Are you saying that you always found these particular items before only in a field by mining for them? Or are you going to claim Randi is "old" "forgetful" and simply making "false statements" again?
Anyways, that brings us to another question you haven't answered. You ramble on about "false positives" not understanding that the "open test" was designed to eliminate that exact possibilty.
To wit.
(4) The performer has the opportunity of deciding for himself — in the "open" tests — whether it's his powers, or just his foreknowledge of the answer, that is actually at work. Mike was convinced of the former.
In his office it seemed when I found it to be clear it would show up later in or under a new cup.
But conveniently you were able to find the target 100% of the time in the open test.
Once again, you're wriggling away from another question you won't answer. I'll repeat it and see if you ignore it or spin more excuses
You've claimed that your dowsing "skills" were at work in the open test with the target in the coffee mugs.
You scored 100% in this test and then moments later, failed miserably in the actual test.
If your powers were working so well one moment, what happened?
Did that "old" "Forgetful" Randi sabotage your test somehow in the short interval from the open to the real test?
Randi asked you if you believed your 100% success was due to your dowsing "Skills". You answered in the affirmative.
Were you lying at that point or simply making "false statements"?
Further more I think the explanation of it is wrong and I don’t think it's paranormal.
Hey, we could care less wheter you consider dowsing 'paranormal" or not. Just quit yapping about it, and actually prove you can do it under fair test conditions. Another attempt to change the subject duly noted and ignored.
My main concern is that it’s not against Gods law.
Irrelevant. Yet another lame attempt to change the subject noted.
I’m trying to figure out how to re do it so it’s fair
Ok, this brings us to another question you won't give us a straight answer to.
Why not submit this potential re-test idea to Randi himself?
For that matter, why aren't you in contact with Randi now about setting up for a fair re-test in March?
And why not tell us specifically what you find "unfair" about the test that Tricky proposed?
Why not simply have you scan an area to be free of gold and "distractions" and simply repeat the test with the mugs there?
Tell us that we need to take your word on it that you're searching for a fair test isn't good enough. Why wouldn't you involve Randi and the JREF now to be ready for your Re-test as soon as possible in March. I'd suggest you're afraid to fail again and simply are looking for excuses not to take a fair re-test with the JREF.
And please, no more lame excuses about your availability or unwillingness to travel. We see them for the transparent evasions they are...
and if I say it is the next time and I fail “which I doubt” I will admit to it,
Nah, you failed once under fair test conditions that you
Helped create
And
Approved of 100%
After your abject failure to dowse under these condtions, all you've done is lie and give us excuses so you can still maintain that you're a successful dowser.
But if it goes the way I think it will either there or in the field
More excuses. No reasons exists that you can't talk to the JREF and setup a test in a field. You can even use tricky's sugggestion to use a field that you dowse to be free of gold and then use the same exact test you did before.
Please explain to use why using tricky's suggestion would be unfair or wouldn't work for you?
you my friend will have to place a retraction of all your crap.
You pass a fair prelim test with the JREF and Randi and I'll gladly do so.
Since you've claimed you have a "secret weapon" for the next time, I'm sure you'll take the JREFS money easily eh?
I'm really not too worried about it....
You see it has worked for me and made me lots of money and I haven’t done it or been back since 95 but I will go to the gold fields again soon.
As we told you before, we're not a damn bit interested in your unveriable personal anecdotes.
Pass the test with the JREF and we'll respect that.
Anything else is just talk.
I don’t see any reason why it should not be tested there.
And as stated before, you need to take this up with the JREF. Statements like this are a transparent ploy to make an excuse later on for not taking a fair re-test with the JREF.
I’m sure if they went there they would see how hard it is to fake it as we go down through the layers of over burden and a geologist could examine the ground as we descend and tell if it was naturally there or seeded you see no one has control, that is the truth, not me, not Jref, not James.
Another attempt to change the subject.
Since you're so good at dowsing.
Dowse and area to be free of gold to your satisfaction.
Repeat the test you took with Randi originally in that "gold free" area.
Take your lumps as you fail again miserably.
And don't waste our time trying to make the re-test sound so difficult that you can't *won't* take it.
He will lose at that point I will hit what ever is there a little or a lot 10 out of 10 times.
Sure, do it under conditions agreeable to Randi and JREF and we'll believe you.
All I'm hearing from you is talk.
Let's see you actually do it with Randi and the JREF.
I can’t explain it any better or easier than that. If it is against Gods laws then I will lose, but how come when mining I do not lose?
Another completely irrelevant attempt to change the subject. We don't give a damn what your deity thinks.
We just want to see you do what you say you can do under fair test conditions with the JREF.
My explanations if I am correct opens up a whole new field that will deal with gravity and movement if I am correct.
That is something that is yet to be proved but if I am right about this well then it opens up a whole new field.
Stop wasting our time talking about it and prove it then. With the JREF and Randi, not with your own anecdotal "self tests" please.
Only De-bunk knows that I will probably take it again.
Even Randi thinks you'll re-take the test.
Why not talk to Randi
now so you can take the test in March and prove us all wrong eh?
Right now, everyone can see you making excuses not to do so.
Make us eat our words if you can.
And now so do you, but I will not agree to do it inside a building again, and the ground down in ft. Lauderdale has to be checked, which will take time and money.
Once again trying to use excuses which don't wash.
Here are some facts for you edge.
JREF doesn't require that you take the test in Fort Lauderdale.
You can easily check any piece of ground near you to make sure it's suitable. JREF has operatives all over the world and I'm sure you and Randi could work something out.
Geologists need not be involved at all if you can really (as you claim) dowse an area to be "gold free"
Please discontinue using this as a possible excuse not to take the fair re-test with Randi and the JREF. We see right through such lame attempts.
I will say if checked and not acceptable to me right off the bat,
Yep, and since you can check an area so easily and quickly, that should make finding a suitable area fairly painless. Than you can re-take the exact same test you took before on that spot. And you'll fail again.
the next move is theirs because it will be in the field if they want to pursue
Nope! The next move is yours!
You are the one who has to reapply for the test
You are the one who has to contact the JREF about setting up fair test conditions.
The burden isn't on Randi and the JREF to pursue you to set-up the re-test. That burden is on
you.
The only thing the JREF is resposible for is accepting your application and then working with you to to setup a fair test as agreed to by both parties.
Gee, by putting the theortical burden on them, you wouldn't be looking for another excuse to get out of a fair re-test now would you edge?
Randi spent a lot of his valuable time working out a fair test with you before. If you fill out the proper application, there is no reason to believe he will be any less than fair with you again.
you understand period?
Because you sound like your having one!!!! HeHeH
*sigh*
Anyways, this is a long post, so for those who might miss it, here is plenty of evidence that Edge is a complete fraud when he claims he can succesfully dowse.
http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
Can Edge offer us any
credible proof to support his claims?
Ummm. No.