Edge dowsing # 2

Edge said:

Excavating a large or small amount of overburden is relatively easy if you have the right tools, you guys keep talking out your ass.

Not moving any earth or rock whatsoever is even easier, no matter what tools you have.


Who’s to say it’s not a one-way thing?

Sir Isaac Newton.


I don’t mine with out dowsing.

When I mine I get what ever is there.
There is nothing left.

Remind me again what you do for a living? Oh, that's right- mining for gold, even with your supernatural powers, doesn't earn you enough money to do it full-time.


It’s very easy to test in the field that way.

You have yet to explain how a "mined-out" test would separate variables.


Watch me make money.

What, as a contractor?
 
I guess I have to ask, Edge, you seem to post a lot on JREF, do you feel like you are getting anything out of it? It seems like you take a lot of abuse. I am just wondering if you get a kick out of it, or whether you feel the feedback is helpful in some way.
 
I laugh a lot.

Some of the feed back has shown me different ways of looking at the paranormal.
 
Edge said:
I laugh a lot.

Some of the feed back has shown me different ways of looking at the paranormal.
So in other words, you can't or won't answer a single one of the direct questions I asked in my last post?

Thought so. :rolleyes:

Hey Folks.

Check out the clear evidence that Edges *aka Mike G's* dowsing skills are a complete delusion.

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
I see the paranorman very differently than you do. Its pretty interesting, as I see many of the ancient "tricks" such as cold reading etc. are being "standardized." For example, Miss Cleo had a two day, weekend seminar on how to do cold reading over the phone, thats it, just two days to be psychic. Its that easy. Also, "alternative medicine" is the standardization of outdated, useless ideas or outright frauds in order to sell worthless procedures, and worthless dietary supplements. You can actually go to a school where they will teach you how to scam people, such as Basra University. When I see these people in action, they are either delusional, and they become angry or confused when you ask them questions, or they deliberately lay on the BS and attack you personally instead, because they know they are ripping people off and need to divert attention. Its quite ironic that they are using a science (of manipulation, logical fallacies) to deny that science works, isn't it?
Anyway Edge, what are your impressions on other paranormal phenomena?
 
I don't believe them either.

I really do not want to speak on the spiritual issues at this time, but there are things that I have seen lately that bring me closer to God and Christ.

]
 
Edge said:

I really do not want to speak on the spiritual issues at this time, but there are things that I have seen lately that bring me closer to God and Christ.

]
Um... so what? We could care less about your rambling about your "closeness to god"....

Hey, maybe god or christ can give you the strength to actually answer some of my *and others* questions honestly for a change eh?


Hey, I'll make it really simple for you and ask you these questions one at a time.

Was the preliminary test you took at the JREF with Randi Fair?

Please answer with a "Yes" or a "No".

And support your answers with actual facts. We could care less whether you test was taken from a "different perspective" or whether you think Randi Sabotaged you with mysterious "electrical waves" coming through the wall.
Can you answer this one edge? Or will you lie and try to spin your way out of it as you have in the past?

Why not give us some honest answers Edge?

Otherwise, we'll go with the evidence we have.

Which pretty clearly shows that your dowsing "powers" exist only in your mind. :rolleyes:

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
Damn any one have a link to the the preliminary test I took at the JREF with Randi Fair?

I seemed to have lost it.
 
Edge said:
Damn any one have a link to the the preliminary test I took at the JREF with Randi Fair?

I seemed to have lost it.
Too bad you can't find any answers for even the simplest of questions involving your complete failure in the prelim test....


Perhaps you should check out the link edge.

You seem to have woven a fictional version of it in your mind where you failed only because of "gold ink in the Encyclopedia" or "electrical waves coming through the wall".

Your failure to give us any answers involving the test is pretty good evidence in itself that you have no concrete proof that you can succesfully dowse.

The only "successes" you can produce are delusional personal anecdotes.


Bleh.

We have plenty of solid evidence that you can't dowse as seen here:

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html

And absolutely no evidence that your dowsing "powers" exist anywhere except in the feverish recesses of your mind....


Still gonna duck even the easiest of questions like this one edge?

Or are you going to keep evading and lying to us.

Was the preliminary test you took at the JREF with Randi Fair?

Please answer with a "Yes" or a "No".

And support your answers with actual facts. We could care less whether you test was taken from a "different perspective" or whether you think Randi Sabotaged you with mysterious "electrical waves" coming through the wall.

It's already pretty obvious that you can't answer this or any other fair question about your test.

You know, that test you helped create and approved of 100%. :rolleyes:
 
If he wanted to sabotage the test twenty dollars of fines sprinkled through out his offices would do the trick.

Now that you mention it yes it was no fair as it was not neutral ground.

My problem now is to find that ground, in Florida, it might not exist.

So there you go wart.
The test the way it’s set up is fine and all we have to do is agree on where.
 

Attachments

  • bevis1x1.gif
    bevis1x1.gif
    17.9 KB · Views: 241
  • bevis1x1.gif
    bevis1x1.gif
    17.9 KB · Views: 241
Edge said:
If he wanted to sabotage the test twenty dollars of fines sprinkled through out his offices would do the trick.
No it wouldn't, or you would have detected them in the open test. You had plenty of time to test if there were anomalous readings and you agreed there were none. There was no difference in the setup or the targets in the open and hidden tests and you know this is true. This is a very lame and very belated excuse.
Edge said:
Now that you mention it yes it was no fair as it was not neutral ground.
If you had any objection to it not being "neutral ground" you should have voiced it before the test. You cannot make up conditions after the test is done. That is the mark of a cheater. But of course, you have already admitted you cheated on the open test, so I guess one more episode of cheating has no effect on your sense of honor. Assuming you have one.
Edge said:
My problem now is to find that ground, in Florida, it might not exist.
Are you telling us there is no place in Florida where you don't get a positive reading for gold? No wonder you are spectacularly unsuccessful as a dowser. But hell, we don't care if it is neutral. Pick a place that is incredibly prejudiced in your favor. I'm sure Randi will accede to that.

Originally posted by Edge
So there you go wart.
The test the way it’s set up is fine and all we have to do is agree on where.

I would bet that any place that is reasonably accessible would be fine. If Randi can't get there, he'll send somebody. Why don't you name the place and see if he agrees?
 
Edge said:
My problem now is to find that ground, in Florida, it might not exist.


I have stayed away from posting on this thread, but I just =have= to ask: Does this mean dowsing is useless in the entire state of Florida?

NA
 
Now that you mention it yes it was no fair as it was not neutral ground.

My problem now is to find that ground, in Florida, it might not exist.

Edge, you seem to be forgetting what you wrote to Randi before your preliminary test. After indicating that there was too much interference at your house, you went on to say,
I had to go further inland to find good clean ground. One house, my sisters was excellent, but it got sold...

Go inland, Edge, go inland!
 
It was better. My best there was 8 of !0 and an average of 5 or 6 of 10 still not perfect, not what I was use to.
Still the best, so far but, of course you'll say I'm lieing.
 
the test

Mr. Edge.

Long time lurker, first time poster.

Just have to ask you this...

1/ If the test was unfair, why did you proceed?

2/ If the room was tampered with so as to invalidate your results, why did your open test work so well?

3/ Why do objects that only look like gold provoke a reaction, like gold paint or brass? I guess this means you must dowse on cloudy days, or the sun (a prominent gold coloured object) would attract your dowsing rod and screw up the results.

I am eagerly awaiting your answers.
 
I'll answer this way, they the skeptics say it was fair myself playing skeptic show how it could not be fair if intended to be so.
Very easily done and invisibly.

The gold Leif on the books were in the path of what lay on the other side of the wall, magnetic fields are an attraction lucky for us.

I proceeded because I had to see what I was up against; I thought I had enough stuff to attract to over come any interferences.
Color means nothing and I always though that a book with gold Leif was painted with the real thing, I don't know everything, but seen later what was causing the attraction.
 
Dragon said:
Edge,

Answer Kuma's questions.
Especially #2.
Actually, Edge already answered that question some time back. He admitted that he cheated in the open test. He admits that he used his knowledge of where the target had been placed rather than his dowsing skills. He justified this with some lame excuse like, "I didn't come all that way and not even get a shot at it".

Of course, this excuse is ridiculous. If there really were interferences, he would be an idiot to go ahead with the test, knowing that he would fail and even more of an idiot for not mentioning the interferences in advance.
 
Tricky said:

Actually, Edge already answered that question some time back. He admitted that he cheated in the open test. He admits that he used his knowledge of where the target had been placed rather than his dowsing skills. He justified this with some lame excuse like, "I didn't come all that way and not even get a shot at it".

Of course, this excuse is ridiculous. If there really were interferences, he would be an idiot to go ahead with the test, knowing that he would fail and even more of an idiot for not mentioning the interferences in advance.


Absolutely. If he'd brought up the problems ahead of time, it wouldn't have meant he "wouldn't get a shot at it", because I'm sure the JREF would have accomodated his conditions by moving the test elsewhere. He defeated himself from the very beginning.
 
From Randi's account of the test -
Mike also asked that several metallic objects (trophy cups, plaques, steel devices) be removed from the bookshelves nearby. At his request, a teaspoon was taken to the next room because he said that the silver could also attract his stick; that spoon was made of aluminum. But, again, we did not correct his statements.
So why not ask for other objects (such as books with gold-coloured lettering) to be removed if they were a problem?
:confused: :confused:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom