Edge dowsing # 2

Crossbow said:
'Edge' is starting to remind me of 'Lyndale Queensbury' aka 'I Can Take Pictures Of Demons'.

Both refuse to test under JREF terms, dodges questions with angry responses, and by quoting the Bible.

Oh Edge (aka Mike G.) really did take the test and failed miserably.

When you see this link, that is Edge!

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html

What you see here is his attempt to spin his failure whilst still claiming to have dowsing "powers".

He desperately wants to keep his delusion intact. I'd feel sorry for him if he didn't have such a tendency towards vulgar attacks and outright non-sequitur...
 
It means you can only find the targets when you can physically see them. Also helps to prove that you can't dowse under fair test conditions that you've even approved of yourself.

No It doesn’t as I have pointed out before when mining you can't see the target or the trap that's holding it most of the time, the traps such as a crack in the clay once in a while will extend out of the river bed and out into the high bar, which is a clue but is it holding or a waste of time?

I approved of the test at that time, but will not approve of the same test in the same place. You are a dunderhead.

Once again, harping on spelling the the refuge of someone who has no answers.
You must be talking about Tricky and Richard then too right?

Nope, I expect you to take take a fair re-test and agree on terms agreeable to yourself and JREF.You know, like you did the first time you failed miserably.
A lot of miss spelled words in this one. “ take take”

Let me get this straight you want the same thing to happen again?
I will not fail a second time I have figured out why, if they can't understand a new test with new controls that are acceptable to both of us then too bad for you and them.


In other words, you're trying to disavow that the first test was fair? Or do we hear more lies and evasions about it?Calling Randi "old, forgetful, one sided" is just a totally transparent and lame way of trying to discredit he and the the fairness of the first test.
it's obvious to anyone reading your posts edge

The the, are you stuttering as you type?

What a line of ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ that is.

Someone is getting excited "the the" I have figured out why I failed the first test, now I have figured out how to pass the second why are you worried about it, and I'll say it again I do not carry crystals in my pocket that was a false statement made by him not me what ever the reasons.

Hey how convenient for you. Maybe you can find someone out their who will let you keep your self delusion intact?
It’s “there”

Why would I even do something like that if it didn't work for me I would disregard it just like a tire that had a blow out.
But the fact remains that in the field while mining it works very well so the opposite is true and I will fight you to the end on it.
Come on we'll go mining in lets say May and you can be next to me in the creek or can you afford to do such a test? And then to fail, as I know you will.

Ah... I'm just guessing you don't like your shortcomings so easily exposed. I'm not going anywhere edge. I work in computers and have access all day long...

So you’re cheating your boss eh.

Don't give us lame crap like "well, I was there so I had to try" or "those mysterious waves from the copier beyond the wall sabotaged me".

Damn that wasn't the only thing that happened I seen it point to the florescent lights several times to the ballast, I would think, almost to the point of not being able to go on but I did, My bad.
It was defeating gravity. Flatworm I'll address your thoughts next I have to brake now I'll be back later tonight.
 
Edge said:


No It doesn’t as I have pointed out before when mining you can't see the target or the trap that's holding it most of the time, the traps such as a crack in the clay once in a while will extend out of the river bed and out into the high bar, which is a clue but is it holding or a waste of time?
Yep, another excuse. You specifically said that the targets you were using in the test were ones that you could dowse 100% of the time successfully. Are you telling us you found the Sacajawea dollars by dowsing them from under the ground originally?

Another lame excuse heard *again* and disregarded.


I approved of the test at that time, but will not approve of the same test in the same place.
So you're saying that the test was unfair?

The test that you approved of 100%? The test that you even personally helped set up and design? That test?

Please give us a straight yes/no answer here? Was the test fair or not?


A lot of miss spelled words in this one. “ take take”
Wow, now if you would only spend some of that time in actually giving us some straight answers! :)

But of course, the best place for straight answers concerning your failure to dowse and your subsequent lame excuses can be found here:

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html

Let me get this straight you want the same thing to happen again?
Nope, I just want you to take another fair test approved off and administered by the JREF that is acceptable to both of you.

I think we're all agreed that Tricky's suggestion is more than fair. Why not contact Randi and start setting up terms for the test now so that you'll be ready to reapply once your year has expired? Or could all your evasions be indicating *and pretty obviously so* that you fear a fear second re-test with Randi? :)

Your failure in the second test will speak for itself.

Besides, didn't you claim to have some mysterious "secret weapon" that you were going to use to take Randi's money? Or was that just another blustery delusion?


I will not fail a second time I have figured out why, if they can't understand a new test with new controls that are acceptable to both of us then too bad for you and them.
In other words, you'll disagree with the testing procedures just enough so that you have an excuse for never actually taking a fair re-test.

Bleh. Do you ever run out of excuses edge? How about some JREF approved testing results instead?


I have figured out why I failed the first test,
Sure, so have we.

You can't dowse when you're being fairly tested under conditions you approved of and even helped to set up.

now I have figured out how to pass the second why are you worried about it,
Really? and what was the "true" reason for your failure? It wasn't the "electrical waves" and "gold ink in the encyclopedia" as you've claimed in the past?

and I'll say it again I do not carry crystals in my pocket that was a false statement made by him not me what ever the reasons.
So now Randi is a lair eh? Conveniently lets you try to discredit the fairness of the test.
During the dowsing process, he kept up a running commentary to me on such matters as a rare "Indian root" with which he was familiar and which was a sure cure for the 'flu, a special crystal he carried on his person to ensure his good health, and a few "free energy" machines that he thought I should know about.
So are we to believe that Randi was also lying about your belief in "free energy machines" and "roots that help cure the flu"?

You've proven to play fast and loose with the truth, so why should we take your word over Randi's. And yes, we all see that arguing about the crystal in another one of your weak attempts to change the subject away from your fantasy dowsing "powers"


But the fact remains that in the field while mining it works very well so the opposite is true and I will fight you to the end on it.
Come on we'll go mining in lets say May and you can be next to me in the creek or can you afford to do such a test? And then to fail, as I know you will.
Hey, your first test was conducted previous to March 21, 2002, so May 2003 is past the one year deadline for you to have a fair re-test with Randi. Why not get in touch with him now to set it up? Unless you're afraid to fail publicly again of course? :)


Damn that wasn't the only thing that happened I seen it point to the florescent lights several times to the ballast,
Dutifully adding "florescent lights" to the long long list of excuses we've heard from Edge....

I would think, almost to the point of not being able to go on but I did, My bad.
Oh, you're just such a victim edge. [sarcasm]That "old, forgetful, lying" Randi really sabotaged you eh?[/sarcasm]

Hey, we can point to lots of evidence that your dowsing powers are non existent edge.

Why not take a fair re-test in March or May with JREF approval and prove us all wrong?

When you pass that test, I'll gladly admit to being wrong about you.

But somehow, I'm not too worried about that particular eventuality.
:rolleyes:

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
Answer the question you little ◊◊◊◊.

Come on we'll go mining in lets say May and you can be next to me in the creek or can you afford to do such a test? And then to fail, as I know you will.


Wart said “ So now Randi is a lair eh? Conveniently lets you try to discredit the fairness of the test.”

Quote: and I'll say it again I do not carry crystals in my pocket that was a false statement made by him not me whatever the reasons.

Nowhere did I say he lied. I said false statement. That leaves him plenty of wriggle room.
Why do you lie?

Wart said>> In other words, you'll disagree with the testing procedures just enough so that you have an excuse for never actually taking a fair re-test.<<
Another lie when it’s fair I’ll take it and the money if and when they agree that it’s also fair.

He's the one to say that not you, if it's fair then we'll do it, if he thinks it's not then we won't, If I think it's not then we won't damn your dumb. We have to both agree don't we?



Yep, another excuse. You specifically said that the targets you were using in the test were ones that you could dowse 100% of the time successfully. Are you telling us you found the Sacajawea dollars by dowsing them from under the ground originally?

I never said that, that's another lie perpetuated by you.
You really are a dill weed , What I said was that while checking indoors they had an attraction too, your memory sucks big time.

Why don't you read back in all the threads and put it together?

Now answer my question, “The the,” are you stuttering as you type computer whiz?

What’s your boss think about you being on the forum you little cheater while at work for him?


So are we to believe that Randi was also lying about your belief in "free energy machines" and "roots that help cure the flu"?

No we are to believe your the one lying about it as one word can change “the the” whole context you little twerp.

Flatworm we’ll set up some ideas later if they are acceptable to you they might be to Jref.
It will give me ideas on how to present them too.

There are three questions for you warts answer them if you can, Heehee. “the the”
“ take take” the challenge challenge!
 
Originally posted by Edge
Answer the question you little ◊◊◊◊.

Come on we'll go mining in lets say May and you can be next to me in the creek or can you afford to do such a test? And then to fail, as I know you will.
:rolleyes: How many times do you need to be told?

Self tests setup unilaterally by you mean nothing to us. Take a fair re-test with JREF and we'll give you some credibility.

Until then, all these calls to "come mining with me" are worth exactly nothing.

Nowhere did I say he lied. I said false statement. That leaves him plenty of wriggle room.
ah... I see. Now you want to redefine Lie as "false Statement"

Must be convenient to be able to discredit your test result failures by claiming that Randi is guilty of making "false statements".

Randi certainly doesn't need "wriggle room" as the test he set up was very fair and you agreed to it 100%.

Tell us again why your dowsing powers magically vanished after you successfully used them in the open test. :)

Another lie when it’s fair I’ll take it and the money if and when they agree that it’s also fair.
I'm guessing everyone else is noting your use of "weasel words" here to give yourself a potential out to avoid taking a fair retest. You already had that in your first test and failed miserably.
http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html

Why should we think next time will be any different? Gonna pull out that "mysterious" weapon you claim to have that'll take JREF's million?


He's the one to say that not you, if it's fair then we'll do it, if he thinks it's not then we won't, If I think it's not then we won't damn your dumb.
And I'm guessing you'll somehow manage to disagree with Randi and the JREF just enough that you can claim the test isn't fair and therefore avoid taking it.
We have to both agree don't we?
Yep, just like the first time you helped design testing conditions, agreed to them, and then proceeded to fail miserably.


I never said that, that's another lie perpetuated by you.
You really are a dill weed

Mike was to be tested for finding gold, his specialty. The target material he had chosen, and brought along with him, consisted of five quartz stones, nine "Sacajawea" dollar coins, a gold ring, a gold nugget, and a small vial containing water and a few panned flakes. He said he had always been successful in detecting each and all of these seventeen items, when his forked stick was specifically "tuned" to pick up gold — by having a small scrap of gold fastened to its tip

Patiently waiting for you to come back with an excuse that Randi is "old", "forgetful", and makes "false statements", blah blah...

No we are to believe your the one lying about it as one word can change “the the” whole context you little twerp.
Sure, I'm hoping this thread gets even more views so that folks can see the true depth of self delusion on your part. :)

Flatworm we’ll set up some ideas later if they are acceptable to you they might be to Jref.
Afraid of trying to setup a test directly with Randi or the JREF?


Why can't you give us a simply yes/no answer to the following question?
Was the prelim test you took at the JREF with Randi fair?
No excuses please. Yes or no. And if you have to guts to specifically say you felt the test was unfair, then let's see you logically support that conclusion without resorting to unverifiable excuses.

And why not tell us specifically what you find "unfair" about the test that Tricky proposed? Why not simply have you scan an area to be free of gold and "distractions" and simply repeat the test with the mugs there?

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
Crossbow said:
I think I have finally figured out why Edge would want the test to be done in an outdoor enviroment.

First, it would allow him, or an aide, to salt the area well in advance, then Edge could come in find the some, or all, of the planted gold and claim sucess. Further, since it is an undefined area, there would be no way to determine how much gold actually was there, therefore all that he would have to do is find a few pieces to claim sucess.

Edge doesn't even have to find gold. All he has to do is to find any mineral, and call it a "hit".

As for "salting" the area, it's a possibility that would have to be ruled out when such a test is set up. Nobody could know where the test location would be; it would have to be selected at random so that nobody could tamper with the area -- and that includes skeptics.


Second, even if he did not find any gold, he could just claim that it was buried further than could be recovered. Hence, there would be no way to validate his claims.

By the way, one of the things I have noted about dowsers, is that there power only works when they are directly above the target and that they are unable to triangulate the location of the target. I would think that if the power was real, they would be able to do so.

As for my opinion, I think that Edge is at best dishonest, greedy, and self-deluded.

I used to "dowse" with my bare hands...just feel for the "energy". Dig consistently just about anywhere and you'll find something.

Shucks, even here in northeast Ohio there are places a person can pan for gold. Just for kicks, though. Very little ever shows, but it's there.

I know a little trick that was told to me by someone who used to crawl the mountains looking for crystals and such (gold included). Let's just say that any field test should include a restriction that keeps the dowser on low-to-non-vegetated land.
 
Wart says,

Quote from wart.
ah... I see. Now you want to redefine Lie as "false Statement


Again that was about carrying crystals in my pocket not any thing was said about the test, It's what he wrote about that. And then you say,


"Must be convenient to be able to discredit your test result failures by claiming that Randi is guilty of making "false statements"."

Typical skeptics tactics.
What I said was no ones perfect.
Dill weed!
 
Re: Wart says,

Quote from wart.
ah... I see. Now you want to redefine Lie as "false Statement
Again that was about carrying crystals in my pocket not any thing was said about the test, It's what he wrote about that.
Hm, you said specifically that Randi makes "false statements"

Please tell us how that's any different than calling him a liar.

We can all see that you're trying to discredit Randi and his testing of you by claiming he's "old", "Forgetful", and makes "False Statements".

Check the highlighted red text. Are you now saying that everything else Randi said about you in his report about your test was the truth?

He only chose to make "false statements" *lie* about the crystal? :rolleyes:

When you lie about whether or not you feel that your original test was fair, should we classify that as a "false statement" also? :)

Typical skeptics tactics.

Typical Woo woo tactics = Avoiding the actual question whilst blathering on and on about an off topic subject. *crystals*

I'm going to re-post the following since these seem to be questions you seem unwilling or unable to logically answer.


Flatworm we’ll set up some ideas later if they are acceptable to you they might be to Jref.

Afraid of trying to setup a test directly with Randi or the JREF?


Why can't you give us a simply yes/no answer to the following question?

quote:
Was the prelim test you took at the JREF with Randi fair?

No excuses please. Yes or no. And if you have to guts to specifically say you felt the test was unfair, then let's see you logically support that conclusion without resorting to unverifiable excuses.

And why not tell us specifically what you find "unfair" about the test that Tricky proposed? Why not simply have you scan an area to be free of gold and "distractions" and simply repeat the test with the mugs there?

And of course, for those interested, Edge's failure to dowse under test conditions he helped set up and approved of 100% can be found here.

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html

And remember folks, we have lots and lots of evidence that Edge can't dowse *see above link* and absolutely no proof that he can.

Unless you want to take his word on it that is! :rolleyes:
 
spit.gif


I've been following this thread since its inception -- and it has evolved into one of the funniest I can recall.
How much better will it get? :D :D
 
Edge said:
Dans e-mail back to me it took a while to find, for those that think I Plagerize.
Dan's e-mail (I assume)
Sure. The latest version of "Zen...." can be found at
http://members.aol.com/ddrasin/zen.html


But you may also find the following URL very useful -- it provides specific responses to the debunkers.

http://www.survivalscience.org/debunk/ww/toc.shtml


Best wishes, and good luck!

=Dan=
I'm looking over this and I fail to see the part that says "You may reprint this without attribution". It looks to me like he was trying to get you to spread the word about his website, but instead you hid that information and presented it as your own. You did him a disservice (although, after prodding, you have finally revealed the source) and I seriously doubt he would be happy about that.

So, Edge, not only did you call people liars because they correctly pointed out that you used someone else's material without attribution, you have still not shown that you have permission to use that material without attribution. Would you care to apologize, or do you prefer to fire off another salvo of unproven assertions?
 
Edge said:
Dans e-mail back to me it took a while to find, for those that think I Plagerize.

Sure. The latest version of "Zen...." can be found at

-------------woo woo link snipped


But you may also find the following URL very useful -- it provides specific
responses to the debunkers.

-------woo woo link snipped.

=Dan=
Hey Edge.

In case you forgot, the topic of this thread is your inability to prove your dowsing "powers".

Not diatribes about "debunking the debunkers" or charming little religious homilies.

So, Can you answer the following questions or not? I'll repeat them again so people can see your obvious evasions and lies.


Flatworm we’ll set up some ideas later if they are acceptable to you they might be to Jref.



Afraid of trying to setup a test directly with Randi or the JREF?


Hm, you said specifically that Randi makes "false statements"
Please tell us how that's any different than calling him a liar.


Why can't you give us a simply yes/no answer to the following question?

quote:

Was the prelim test you took at the JREF with Randi fair?


No excuses please. Yes or no. And if you have to guts to specifically say you felt the test was unfair, then let's see you logically support that conclusion without resorting to unverifiable excuses.

And why not tell us specifically what you find "unfair" about the test that Tricky proposed? Why not simply have you scan an area to be free of gold and "distractions" and simply repeat the test with the mugs there?

Unless you can answer some of these, mindless cries of "come mine with me and I'll take the million" are seen as transparent attempts to avoid a second and fair re-test with JREF.

And of course, for those interested, Edge's failure to dowse under test conditions he helped set up and approved of 100% can be found here.

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html

And remember folks, we have lots and lots of evidence that Edge can't dowse *see above link* and absolutely no proof that he can.

Unless you want to take his word on it that is! :rolleyes:
 
Good heavens, not that thing again...it's just another tribute to Saint Radin.
 
Flatworm said:


How many times has this been completely thrashed to pieces on this forum? It's a jumble of fallacies, but particularly favours straw man and argument from ignorance.
It's just Edge trying to change the topic.
 
Edge, where are ya buddy?

We miss all your fun name calling and refusal to answer straightforward questions about your self professed dowsing "powers". :)
 
Hello Edge,

I was curious if you have tested yourself in the new location, above merely dowsing the area. Also, could you state five solid ideas or facts that must be true in order for dowsing to be true?
 
No not yet. The last time I went to Lauderdale the ground outside there was promising but I would have to check more to know for sure that it could be retested there.

In the fields were I worked the ground it worked every time and if I made a jump with out dowsing 9 out 0f 10 times I would do poorly.

If you dowse and you try to stop the reaction the willow will arch and keep going any way.

I have been on a big load and the next thing that would happen is the stick twists free from the bark.

Another thing that will happen is it will literally snap the stick at one point in your hand.

There is the test above where I mention it spinning as you travel down the road; this was checked with two dowsers in the car.

I have re-dowsed the spot were I'm dredging to see if I picked up all of the gold before moving on and It has been proven to me one way or the other, That there was more or that the dig was clean.

I can scan the horizon and get a direction and go toward it and dig and find it under foot.
 
Edge said:

If you dowse and you try to stop the reaction the willow will arch and keep going any way.

I have been on a big load and the next thing that would happen is the stick twists free from the bark.

Another thing that will happen is it will literally snap the stick at one point in your hand.

You've mentioned this before. You talked about how it keeps twisting no matter how hard you grasp it, but goes back to normal if you let go.

Doesn't this suggest something to you? You're twisting and breaking the stick with your own hands!
 
Originally posted by Edge
No not yet. The last time I went to Lauderdale the ground outside there was promising but I would have to check more to know for sure that it could be retested there.
Ahh... Now the condition of the ground is a possible excuse. I'm guessing you'll add it to the arsenal of lame excuses you've been using to avoid a fair re-test with Randi and the JREF.

In the fields were I worked the ground it worked every time and if I made a jump with out dowsing 9 out 0f 10 times I would do poorly.
We don't give a damn about your "self tests" where everything seems to magically "Work every time".

As "proof" it's useless. We'll believe you and give you credibility after you pass the prelim test with the JREF.

There is the test above where I mention it spinning as you travel down the road; this was checked with two dowsers in the car.
We also don't accept the anecdotes of other woo-woo dowsers as evidence.

I have re-dowsed the spot were I'm dredging to see if I picked up all of the gold before moving on ....
Hey, March isn't so far away. If you can verify that a certain area is "gold free" then why not take the same exact test you took with Randi on that "gold free" piece of land?


Now, we'd really like some straightforward answers to the following questions.

Was the prelim test you took at the JREF with Randi fair?
No excuses please. Yes or No.

And if you have to guts to specifically say you felt the test was unfair, then let's see you logically support that conclusion without resorting to unverifiable excuses. So far, the only "answer" you've given us to this very important question is nonsense like:

"Yes it was fair, but... (insert lame excuse here)"

or

"Well Randi is old, forgetful and makes false statements'

And why not tell us specifically what you find "unfair" about the test that Tricky proposed?

Why not simply have you scan an area to be free of gold and "distractions" and simply repeat the test with the mugs there?


Why not submit this potential re-test idea to Randi himself?

For that matter, why aren't you in contact with Randi now about setting up for a fair re-test in March?

And please, no more lame excuses about your availability or unwillingness to travel. We see them for the transparent evasions they are...

You've claimed that your dowsing "skills" were at work in the open test with the target in the coffee mugs.

You scored 100% in this test and then moments later, failed miserably in the actual test.

If your powers were working so well one moment, what happened?

Did that "old" "Forgetful" Randi sabotage your test somehow in the short interval from the open to the real test?

Randi asked you if you believed your 100% success was due to your dowsing "Skills". You answered in the affirmative.

Were you lying at that point or simply making "false statements"?

Why are you asking flatworm to set up a re-test rather than Randi and the JREF?

Randi bent over backwards to give you a fair test and said he expects you back to try again. By speaking with Randi, I'm sure you both could come up with a test you can both agree on. You agreed once and I'm sure you could again. Why not use Tricky's suggestion when you discuss your fair re-test with Randi?

Your attempts to make excuses and ask others *tricky* indicates that you have little real intention of seeking a fair re-test with the JREF.

Why do you persist in regaling us with anecdotes about your mining skills and how well your dowsing seems to work when you're conveniently not being tested by the JREF?
As I've stated before. The only proof we'll accept is a fair re-test with JREF. Anything else is seen as a tranparent ploy to somehow wriggle away from the fact that we have real evidence that you can't dowse. Your anecdotes mean less than nothing as far as proving anything goes.




Want to see some really good evidence that Edge's imagined dowsing "skills" don't exist? (except in his imagination perhaps)

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html

Keep in mind that Edge *aka Mike G.* helped set up the test himself and approved of the conditions 100%.

Want some really good evidence that Edge really can dowse?

Um... You'll be waiting a while.

We have plenty of evidence that he can't dowse and absolutely no credible evidence that he can.

Edge also seems to be making every possible excuse to avoid another fair re-test of his dowsing "skills" with JREF in March.... :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom