Edge dowsing # 2

Edge said:

You guys still don't get it?
I dowse for a spot then as I go I dowse again till I'm sure that I have it all when it's gone,"in My mind", You check it, and it will be, according to me gone.
There are more places to look natural traps,If you think it's there and I say it's not you can check it that way also,three ways of checking acually. There are more traps that are not holding then there are holding.....

I think you're the one who's 'not getting it'. What's stopping you from checking these 'natural traps' yourself as you mine? It would seem foolish for you not to, since you are after all supposed to be looking for gold.


How are we supposed to separate the information you get from mining from the information you get from dowsing?




I did an experiment with a metal detector in side a building and it does the same thing false readings all over the place I used an under water version! Do you know why?

Irrelevant, because you agreed beforehand the test was fair and scored 100% accuracy on the open test. Did you lie when you agreed the test was fair?
 
Edge...

Randi does not set out to prove you are lying...

The tests are designed to prove beyond all reasonable doubt the apllicants claimed skill...

Setting up an unfair playing field...and then winning is only deceiving yourself...

How would you feel if you went to Randi...took the challenge ...and passed..

Your name would be known everywhere..

Plus you would be a million dollars richer...

The way you want to do it...gets you nothing...

Id say wait till you can re-test with Randi...

Try and hone these skills you say you have...

Theres a million dollars at stake...and it doesnt cost you a cent to try...

If Randi lost the million to a Dowsing claim..from that minute on ...i'd believe in it totally and sing its praises...
 
Edge, you have already shown us that your dowsing skills cannot differentiate between gold, aluminum, gold colored ink, manganese, electrical fields, or quartz (and the energy therein). Are there any other things that will give you a false reading? How can you differentiate them in the field if you can't differentiate them in the office?

The quartz one is particularly interesting. What do you suppose is the most common mineral in the crust of the earth? Why it's quartz, of course, which you would know if you had even a beginner's knowledge of geology. All of those rocks you're finding gold in are just lousy with quartz. It is not distributed evenly, so you can't make any "it's just background noise" excuse.

So why will you not accept the easiest method which I proposed?
1) Find an area where you "douse" there is no gold.
2) Repeat the same test you took before.

I truly would like a response to this, explaining why this would or would not be a fair test of your abilities. It would appear to the casual observer that you are afraid to take a fair test because you know, deep down inside, that it doesn't work.
 
Edge said:

Wart If I have x- ray vision then it's not fair, I do not know what's under the ground nor does James or jref or any other minner.
Irrelevant. You couldn't see what what was in the JREF mugs during the test either and you failed miserably to find targets that you claimed you had "100% accuracy" in locating via dowsing. I never said you needed "x-ray vision.

You just need to be able to use your self professed ability to dowse.

You failed once and now all we get from you are excuses and evasions. It's pretty evident that you're afraid to work with Randi and take a proper re-test under conditions agreeable to JREF and yourself.

You claim one minute that the test is fair, then you obfuscate the manner by saying "but not in an office!".

You can't have it both ways. The test was fair or it wasn't.

But of course you agreed to be tested in an office, so it seems pretty silly for you to use it as an excuse after the fact.

You could have easily have told Randi that "electrical waves" from his copier were sabotaging your dowsing skills.

I'm sure he would have gladly taken the test outside or somewhere more amenable to you.

You agreed to the test conditions "100%" and you failed.

As anyone can see right here.
http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
Tricky said,
So why will you not accept the easiest method which I proposed?
1) Find an area where you "dowse" there is no gold.
2) Repeat the same test you took before.

Well yea I said if I go to Lauderdale I would do that, outside in a park. Deep down inside Tricky I know that it works when nothing else does. My other miner friend Carl S. sent those quartz rocks and he said that he could only find them in two places in the county; they are not like other quartz, as far as I know. I’ll have to check that.

Hey De-bunk my favorite loony skeptic.

De-bunk yes we would have to talk, James and I will have to talk, there’s time but it might run out that’s why I’m thinking if he has time and I’m gone he could come up there, but that hasn’t even been talked about yet between us.
It all would depend on if he wanted to make a little more out of it like a vacation.
He does talk to the guy that taught me “Tim P.,” to dowse and that would be a good meeting of minds along with some hunting and fishing and of course some mining, that’s if he’s even interested.
If you go to the field it will shock you if you are not lucky, how long it will take you to hit gold mining with book knowledge. Oh you’ll get a little bit but it will cost you to run that way.

Wart damn you are just obnoxious, You keep twisting my words Look I failed so from my perspective not yours I have to figure out what went wrong that’s the facts, from my perspective It works from yours it doesn’t so then it’s up to me to figure out, not you. They are not excuses but me trying to put some logical explanation to the reasons why indoors it seems difficult.
Again I practiced in two places down here and got worst results and better results than at James office his results were in-between the other results.

I told you about doing it with a metal detector, under water type, and I got some interesting results with that, it tells me that even a machine that’s suppose to find metals such as gold or iron is fooled too.
Simply because of the pig wire and rebar in a concert slab, in one place it will work and another you can’t tell the difference you will get similar results as dowsing for gold inside.
Yes those experiments are relevant to me.

Let me clarify one more thing when I asked about the books they were in line of what was causing the reaction when I asked he said what I needed to know, then I had to look past the wall, the other side, for me that explained that.
Damn easy to understand isn’t it.
Never the less as soon as you put the gold in the end of the stick water is not detected that has to mean something.
Take the gold out and all you will detect is water.
In the field you will find Iron lead gold and a few other things that are hevey enough to get trapped with gold the reason why I used different things for that most possible closeness to what happens in the field. And a couple of new things to give me an advantage.

I didn’t go all that way to not try, I found out something else but you will say it’s an excuse so I won’t tell you but it will be a great advantage to me so it’s a secret in case I go to Lauderdale again. I might but not till I talk to the Jref team dig it I knew that you could!

Flatworm said, I think you're the one who's 'not getting it'. What's stopping you from checking these 'natural traps' yourself as you mine? It would seem foolish for you not to, since you are after all supposed to be looking for gold.
Well yea I dowse those spots as I go but when you look at the ground you can tell if it’s been touched or not if it’s not showing to hold I pass it by. There’s a line of gold or really several that you can follow up the creek and as you go some are holding some are not.
I have gone back to check and it’s always true that it’s not worth digging or dredging.
Especially when you’re hitting ounces every day and if you move off the line that’s producing it’s a waste of time and energy.
You don’t take the whole river or creek out?

I don’t know where in Canada you live but go do some mining and you’ll understand the daunting task of hitting the jackpot.
Of course read the books first I did that, it’s the information you need for common sense and try it it’s fun and the best job I ever had.

It wasn’t a hobby for me it was how I made a living and not to many can say that.
:p
 
Edge said:
Deep down inside Tricky I know that it works when nothing else does.
It doesn't matter a damn bit what you "know".

We have lots of evidence that you can't dowse and absolutely no evidence that you can.

Your failure is here for all to see.

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html

De-bunk yes we would have to talk, James and I will have to talk, there’s time but it might run out that’s why I’m thinking if he has time and I’m gone he could come up there, but that hasn’t even been talked about yet between us.
Hm. Imposing a time limit again? What a convenient way of avoiding a second fair re-test with Randi and JREF's input. We've heard this excuse before.

He does talk to the guy that taught me “Tim P.,” to dowse and that would be a good meeting of minds along with some hunting and fishing and of course some mining, that’s if he’s even interested.
So if your friend "Tim P." is such a fine dowser, why doesn't he prove a point and take Randi's million? Perhaps he's self deluded about his "powers" also?


Wart damn you are just obnoxious,
No, obnoxious is you lying and evading honest questions about your abject failure to prove your abilities under fair test conditions accepted 100% by yourself.

You keep twisting my words
Nope, I presented a list of your lame excuses verbatim.

Look I failed so from my perspective not yours I have to figure out what went wrong that’s the facts, from my perspective It works from yours it doesn’t so then it’s up to me to figure out, not you.
You failed period.
And I can even tell you why.

You have no dowsing powers. They're an illusion, a self delusion on your part.

Wanna shut me up? Set up another fair re-test with Randi. And advance past the preliminary stage.

None of this crap about "self testing" your skills means a thing.


They are not excuses but me trying to put some logical explanation to the reasons why indoors it seems difficult.
Bleh. I printed a huge list of these excuses and you still deny them? It wasn't only "being inside" that you used as an excuse.

It was nonsense like "the gold ink in the encylopedias distracted my stick" or "There's something behind that wall that randi knows about".

These aren't excuses? Then I guess dowsing isn't the only thing you self delude yourself about. pffffffffffffffffft.

Again I practiced in two places down here and got worst results and better results than at James office his results were in-between the other results.
At his place, you got exactly one correct in the actual test. If that's "in between" you must have struck out completely in one of your "self tests"

Yes those experiments are relevant to me.
But completely irrelevant to us.

Pass the challenge, then we'll listen to you.

Let me clarify one more thing when I asked about the books they were in line of what was causing the reaction when I asked he said what I needed to know, then I had to look past the wall, the other side, for me that explained that.
Ahhh, so now you change your story. Now we know it was the evil copy machine that sabotaged you correct? Another lame excuse you can't stop repeating :rolleyes:

I notice that whatever was behind the wall sure didn't stop you from passing your "open test" with 100% accuracy. In fact, take a look at this quote regarding the open test

(4) The performer has the opportunity of deciding for himself — in the "open" tests — whether it's his powers, or just his foreknowledge of the answer, that is actually at work. Mike was convinced of the former.
So you're going to deny this was the case? I'm just dying to hear you say that Randi misquoted or misunderstood you because of how old he is. But wait, we've already heard that excuse haven't we?

Damn easy to understand isn’t it.
Quite easy to understand you'd rather evade and make increasingly lame excuses rather than face defeat a second time in a fair challenge with Randi.

Once again, you claim you knew before the test that it would be "difficult". So why not change the terms of the test when you could? Why did you go through with it if you felt the test wasn't fair? And why won't you give us a simple yes/no answer to this question.

"was the test fair or wasn't it?"

And not trying to have it both ways with junk statements like "Well, it was fair, but also unfair because it was inside."

I didn’t go all that way to not try,
Sure, and Randi would have let you adjust the conditions when you got there if you had requested.

Don't try to blame your failure on cirumstances beyond your control. You weren't a victim. Randi bent over backwards to make a fair test for you and even as late as the actual test, I know he would have made any adjustments you felt were needed as long as it didn't affect the fairness of the test.

I found out something else but you will say it’s an excuse so I won’t tell you
Another convenient lie probably. But since you "won't tell" then I guess it's irrelevant eh?

but it will be a great advantage to me so it’s a secret in case I go to Lauderdale again. I might but not till I talk to the Jref team dig it I knew that you could!
Do you actually believe you're required to go to lauderdale to take the test? Randi has JREF'ers all over the U.S. that can do the prelim re-test on you. All this nonsense about "not having the time" or "not being able to travel to lauderdale" are transparent excuses again.


Tricky asked you a very valid question

So why will you not accept the easiest method which I proposed?
1) Find an area where you "douse" there is no gold.
2) Repeat the same test you took before.

I'd be very curious what you think of his suggestion.
 
Wert has already addressed most of these points, so I'l keep it relatively short.
Edge said:
Tricky said,
So why will you not accept the easiest method which I proposed?
1) Find an area where you "dowse" there is no gold.
2) Repeat the same test you took before.

Well yea I said if I go to Lauderdale I would do that, outside in a park. Deep down inside Tricky I know that it works when nothing else does.
So are you saying then that you accept this methodology? Good that's a first step.

Edge said:
My other miner friend Carl S. sent those quartz rocks and he said that he could only find them in two places in the county; they are not like other quartz, as far as I know. I’ll have to check that.
The "energy" you are describing is piezoelectricity, defined as
pi.e.zo.elec.tric.i.ty
: electricity or electric polarity due to pressure especially in a crystalline substance (as quartz)[/quartz]
It exists in every crystal of quartz. It is the thing that makes quartz watches so accurate. It is nothing paranormal.
Edge said:

If you go to the field it will shock you if you are not lucky, how long it will take you to hit gold mining with book knowledge. Oh you’ll get a little bit but it will cost you to run that way.
I would bet on a metamorphic geologist to beat you every time in the field. I am a sedimentary geologist and I confess I don't know enough about mining to find gold. But I must say that your lack of wealth makes it pretty obvious that it takes you quite a long time to find gold too.

Edge said:
They are not excuses but me trying to put some logical explanation to the reasons why indoors it seems difficult.
They are excuses. Just because you believe them makes them no less excuses. An honorable man would admit that.




Edge said:
Let me clarify one more thing when I asked about the books they were in line of what was causing the reaction when I asked he said what I needed to know, then I had to look past the wall, the other side, for me that explained that.
Damn easy to understand isn’t it.
No, a damned obvious excuse, but I'm quite sure it "explained" it to you because you have no powers of critical thought. Why would the books be in the way if the wall itself was not in the way? Why would it even matter, since they were not "in the way" of the target. What's the range on your dowsing skills, by the way?

Edge said:
I told you about doing it with a metal detector, under water type, and I got some interesting results with that, it tells me that even a machine that’s suppose to find metals such as gold or iron is fooled too.

I tell you what? Why don't you give some third party some of your gold and let them hide it on the beach, then go head-to-head with a person with a metal detector? Winner keeps the gold.




Edge said:
I didn’t go all that way to not try, I found out something else but you will say it’s an excuse so I won’t tell you but it will be a great advantage to me so it’s a secret in case I go to Lauderdale again. I might but not till I talk to the Jref team dig it I knew that you could!
Ah! A secret weapon. Well bring it on, Mike. I'm confident it won't change the results.
Edge said:

It wasn’t a hobby for me it was how I made a living and not to many can say that.
Why did you stop using it as your primary source of income?
 
One day I decided to check under the road which runs north and south through town it parallels the river for about five miles, the river has meandered back and forth from east to west crossing the road and depositing gold along it's path ways for thousands of years, It now flows along the east side of that valley.

The road is kind of in the middle of the valley.
We figured any cracks that go from east to west would be good traps if they lie under the road and that they would be prehistoric traps with lots of gold in them never touched or mined.
Guess what?
There is a lot there, as we traveled down the road Carl and I dowsed together and the attraction was the same for both of us and the sticks would pick up a major load, as we approached then it would stay locked on it and keep pointing and rotating till another load was picked up, the result was a spinning action as we passed at a certain speed.

You had to hold it with out gripping to allow it to do this.
The ends were touching into the palms of the hands, I know with that kind of contact you aren't going to grip and there is no way for any muscle under the skin to work against that kind of leverage try it at home see if you can do it purposely?

Don't forget to put a peice of counter weight in the end, 2 or 3 grams, and try to hold it out parrellel to the ground, ends of the sitck in the palms of your hands.

I will document this experiment on film when I get there.
 
Edge said:
One day I decided to check under the road which runs north and south through town it parallels the river for about five miles, the river has meandered back and forth from east to west crossing the road and depositing gold along it's path ways for thousands of years, It now flows along the east side of that valley.

-----------repeated nonsense snipped.


Don't forget to put a peice of counter weight in the end, 2 or 3 grams, and try to hold it out parrellel to the ground, ends of the sitck in the palms of your hands.

I will document this experiment on film when I get there.
Um, edge.

You already posted this nonsense nearly verbatim in this thread.

Your "self tests" mean less than nothing to us.

Pass the prelim test stage with JREF and we'll listen to you. All this other talk of "well I can document that it works when I'm alone" crap just doesn't wash.


It's a rambling bit that in no way answers for your failure to pass a fair test that you agreed 100% with and helped set up yourself.

Nor does anything in this post address your evasions and lies concerning re-taking the test with JREF.

bleh.

Everyone can see that your lame excuses to Randi and us only point out how self delusional you are....

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
Edge said:
One day I decided to check under the road which runs north and south through town it parallels the river for about five miles, the river has meandered back and forth from east to west crossing the road and depositing gold along it's path ways for thousands of years, It now flows along the east side of that valley.
So you are looking for placer deposits? Before you seemed to be describing looking for lode gold. Do you know the difference?

Edge said:
Guess what?
There is a lot there...
How much? You may use ounces or dollars-worth. Don't worry, since you haven't told us a location, we won't go steal it. BTW. Did you have mineral rights to the places you were looking, or were you stealing it from the people who owned the land?

Edge said:
You had to hold it with out gripping to allow it to do this.
The ends were touching into the palms of the hands, I know with that kind of contact you aren't going to grip and there is no way for any muscle under the skin to work against that kind of leverage try it at home see if you can do it purposely?
Interesting. Earlier you told us how the attraction nearly ripped the rod from your hands. So the effect is different in different places? What causes the difference? How do you know which technique to use?

Edge said:
I will document this experiment on film when I get there.
I look forward to it. Especially the part where you unearth huge amounts of gold.
 

Well yea I dowse those spots as I go but when you look at the ground you can tell if it’s been touched or not if it’s not showing to hold I pass it by. There’s a line of gold or really several that you can follow up the creek and as you go some are holding some are not.
I have gone back to check and it’s always true that it’s not worth digging or dredging.
Especially when you’re hitting ounces every day and if you move off the line that’s producing it’s a waste of time and energy.
You don’t take the whole river or creek out?

This doesn't address how we're supposed to separate the information you gain from dowsing from the information you gain from mining.


Tricky's proposal is a good one. You go over an area and certify that your dowsing finds no gold there. We then repeat the experiment you did at the JREF.
 
To: Edge

Let me try to make this simple as possible.

If you can dowse gold,

Then go dowse some gold!

You would be able to make millions of dollars and not have to worry about Randi, JREF, or anyone else in the Forum.

Good luck!
 
This doesn't address how we're supposed to separate the information you gain from dowsing from the information you gain from mining.

Even in the field there are blank spots many blank spots the test should be done there where gold is dowsed for.

Many ways of checking.

Wart said,"*hearing the sound of crickets*"

No body likes annoying idiots who constantly spam there veiws we know your veiws if you do not what to hear what mine are don't ask.

How skeptics think,
<> Portray science not as an open-ended process of discovery but as a holy war against unruly hordes of quackery- worshipping infidels. Since in war the ends justify the means, you may fudge, stretch or violate the scientific method, or even omit it entirely, in the name of defending the scientific method.

<> Keep your arguments as abstract and theoretical as possible. This will "send the message" that accepted theory overrides any actual evidence that might challenge it--and that therefore no such evidence is worth examining.

<> Reinforce the popular misconception that certain subjects are inherently unscientific. In other words, deliberately confuse the *process* of science with the *content* of science. (Someone may, of course, object that since science is a universal approach to truth-seeking it must be neutral to subject matter; hence, only the investigative *process* can be scientifically responsible or irresponsible. If that happens, dismiss such objections using a method employed successfully by generations of politicians: simply reassure everyone that "there is no contradiction here!")

<> Arrange to have your message echoed by persons of authority. The degree to which you can stretch the truth is directly proportional to the prestige of your mouthpiece.

<> Always refer to unorthodox statements as "claims," which are "touted," and to your own assertions as "facts," which are "stated."

<> Avoid examining the actual evidence. This allows you to say with impunity, "I have seen absolutely no evidence to support such ridiculous claims!" (Note that this technique has withstood the test of time, and dates back at least to the age of Galileo. By simply refusing to look through his telescope, the ecclesiastical authorities bought the Church over three centuries' worth of denial free and clear!)

<> If examining the evidence becomes unavoidable, report back that "there is nothing new here!" If confronted by a watertight body of evidence that has survived the most rigorous tests, simply dismiss it as being "too pat."

<> Equate the necessary skeptical component of science with *all* of science. Emphasize the narrow, stringent, rigorous and critical elements of science to the exclusion of intuition, inspiration, exploration and integration. If anyone objects, accuse them of viewing science in exclusively fuzzy, subjective or metaphysical terms.

<> Insist that the progress of science depends on explaining the unknown in terms of the known. In other words, science equals reductionism. You can apply the reductionist approach in any situation by discarding more and more and more evidence until what little is left can finally be explained entirely in terms of established knowledge.

<> Downplay the fact that free inquiry and legitimate disagreement are a normal part of science.

<> Make yourself available to media producers who seek "balanced reporting" of unorthodox views. However, agree to participate in only those presentations whose time constraints and a-priori bias preclude such luxuries as discussion, debate and cross-examination.

<> At every opportunity reinforce the notion that what is familiar is necessarily rational. The unfamiliar is therefore irrational, and consequently inadmissible as evidence.

<> State categorically that the unconventional may be dismissed as, at best, an honest misinterpretation of the conventional.

<> Characterize your opponents as "uncritical believers." Summarily dismiss the notion that debunkery itself betrays uncritical belief, albeit in the status quo.

<> Maintain that in investigations of unconventional phenomena, a single flaw invalidates the whole. In conventional contexts, however, you may sagely remind the world that, "after all, situations are complex and human beings are imperfect."

<> "Occam's Razor," or the "principle of parsimony," says the correct explanation of a mystery will usually involve the simplest fundamental principles. Insist, therefore, that the most familiar explanation is by definition the simplest! Imply strongly that Occam's Razor is not merely a philosophical rule of thumb but an immutable law.

<> Discourage any study of history that may reveal today's dogma as yesterday's heresy. Likewise, avoid discussing the many historical, philosophical and spiritual parallels between science and democracy.

<> Since the public tends to be unclear about the distinction between evidence and proof, do your best to help maintain this murkiness. If absolute proof is lacking, state categorically that "there is no evidence!"

In the field you will lose.



Crossbow To: Edge

Let me try to make this simple as possible.

If you can dowse gold,

Then go dowse some gold!
Definitly my plans I am going to mine next year in Gods country, my home.
 
Edge said:


...

Definitly my plans I am going to mine next year in Gods country, my home.

Good for You!

By the way, if you gold dowsing power is real, why are you not already rich?

If I could dowse gold, I would not care about JREF, Randi, skeptics, or any of the naysayers. I would just go out, find the gold, cash in, and live the life of Hugh Hefner until the day I die.

Best of luck to you in finding that gold!
 
Edge said:
No body likes annoying idiots who constantly spam there veiws we know your veiws if you do not what to hear what mine are don't ask.
Well, Edge, you constantly spam your views here. Are we unjustified in asking you to prove them? My view is that dowsing does not work and those who believe this have shown it to be true time and time again in controlled tests, as you know from personal experience.

BTW. It is obvious you wrote the last bit because it is full of misspellings and grammatical errors. It is equally obvious that you did not write the next bits because they are as perfectly grammatical as they are perfectly dishonest. Remember, if you quote somebody, you're supposed to give the reference.

Plagerized by Edge
How skeptics think,
<> Portray science not as an open-ended process of discovery but as a holy war against unruly hordes of quackery- worshipping infidels. Since in war the ends justify the means, you may fudge, stretch or violate the scientific method, or even omit it entirely, in the name of defending the scientific method.
A flat out lie. Skeptics ask that claims be proven. You seem to think that science should be "whatever sounds right". And I challenge you to provide one example where skeptics tried to "fudge, stretch or violate" the scientific method. I can give you numerous examples where dowser do.


Plagerized by Edge
<> Keep your arguments as abstract and theoretical as possible. This will "send the message" that accepted theory overrides any actual evidence that might challenge it--and that therefore no such evidence is worth examining.
Another lie. Here are ten cups with gold under one. Find it. You provide that evidence, and we will believe you. Your "stories" of how you have found gold are not evidence as any real scientist knows. All we ask is that you find the hidden gold. How abstract and theoretical is that? Not nearly as abstract and theoretical as claiming interference of electrical fields, aluminum, gold paint and the like. You can't even prove your power exists, yet you give excuses why it doesn't work.


Plagerized by Edge
<> Reinforce the popular misconception that certain subjects are inherently unscientific. In other words, deliberately confuse the *process* of science with the *content* of science. (Someone may, of course, object that since science is a universal approach to truth-seeking it must be neutral to subject matter; hence, only the investigative *process* can be scientifically responsible or irresponsible. If that happens, dismiss such objections using a method employed successfully by generations of politicians: simply reassure everyone that "there is no contradiction here!")
No subject starts out being "inherently unscientific". But if it fails test after test, then it is relegated to the scrap heap. This is how it should be. The rest of this paragraph is just gibberish.


Plagerized by Edge
<> Arrange to have your message echoed by persons of authority. The degree to which you can stretch the truth is directly proportional to the prestige of your mouthpiece.
LOL. That is such a laugh, when pseudoscience likes to get "celeberties" to endorse their useless products. What corresponding member of the scientific community carries such "prestige". I'll bet you can only name one well-know living scientist off the top of your head (Stephen Hawking) and I do not have any examples of where he has pooh-poohed pseudoscience. Do you?


Plagerized by Edge
<> Always refer to unorthodox statements as "claims," which are "touted," and to your own assertions as "facts," which are "stated."
And what else would you call unproven assertions? Facts? Well, you probably would. You have already shown that you will believe anything.

Plagerized by Edge
<> Avoid examining the actual evidence. This allows you to say with impunity, "I have seen absolutely no evidence to support such ridiculous claims!" (Note that this technique has withstood the test of time, and dates back at least to the age of Galileo. By simply refusing to look through his telescope, the ecclesiastical authorities bought the Church over three centuries' worth of denial free and clear!)
Look at yourself, Edge. The ecclesiastical authority is you! You are refusing to look at the evidence, but insist that since it doesn't fit your world view, then it must be wrong. It is people like you that impede the progress of science, not advance it.

Plagerized by Edge
<> If examining the evidence becomes unavoidable, report back that "there is nothing new here!" If confronted by a watertight body of evidence that has survived the most rigorous tests, simply dismiss it as being "too pat."
Whoever wrote this is a bald-faced liar. He is taking everything that pseudoscientists do and trying to imply that skeptics do it. How juvenile. BTW. Where is the "watertight body of evidence" that supports dowsing?

Plagerized by Edge

<> Equate the necessary skeptical component of science with *all* of science. Emphasize the narrow, stringent, rigorous and critical elements of science to the exclusion of intuition, inspiration, exploration and integration. If anyone objects, accuse them of viewing science in exclusively fuzzy, subjective or metaphysical terms.
Got a hot flash for you, genius. The skeptical componant is in fact essential to all science. If you went on intuition, we'd still think the earth was flat. So what this guy is saying is that science should abandon the scientific method and simply accept someones "intuition" or "inspiration".

Plagerized by Edge
<> Insist that the progress of science depends on explaining the unknown in terms of the known. In other words, science equals reductionism. You can apply the reductionist approach in any situation by discarding more and more and more evidence until what little is left can finally be explained entirely in terms of established knowledge.
Duh. The only way to explaing anything is in terms of the known. You can admit that you don't know, meaning you can't explain it, but to try to explain it with an unproven or unprovable fairy tale... well, that's why the Biblical Creation story came about.

Plagerized by Edge
<> Downplay the fact that free inquiry and legitimate disagreement are a normal part of science.
Absolute ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊. Nobody disagrees among themselves more than scientists, and I can give you numerous examples. It is pseudoscientists that tend to accept anything another pseudoscientist says. How many dowsers have you known that you think are fakes?

Plagerized by Edge
<> Make yourself available to media producers who seek "balanced reporting" of unorthodox views. However, agree to participate in only those presentations whose time constraints and a-priori bias preclude such luxuries as discussion, debate and cross-examination.
ROTFL! The media LOVES pseudoscience. Why do you think the X-Files did so well. John Edward? Sylvia Browne. These media hogs get lots of attention, but ask one to appear on a panel where they have to debate their "skills" and you will see them running faster than a jackrabbit with it's tail on fire. Just like Edge is running from a fair test.

Plagerized by Edge
<> At every opportunity reinforce the notion that what is familiar is necessarily rational. The unfamiliar is therefore irrational, and consequently inadmissible as evidence.
Another great lie. Science has proven time and time again that the world is not as we perceive it. Irrational evidence is perfectly admissible provided it is evidence and not anecdotes.

Plagerized by Edge
<> State categorically that the unconventional may be dismissed as, at best, an honest misinterpretation of the conventional.
Absolute balderdash. Skeptics don't dismiss anything unconventional. We test it. Lying paranormalists refuse to be tested. Here's an example. My wife said that if you put a spoon in the neck of an opened bottle of champagne, it will retain it's fizz. I said that didn't sound logical, but I would test. We opened two bottles of identical champagne and put a spoon in on of the bottles. After several hours, we had a friend serve her tastes at random from each bottle and ask her which bottle it came from. She was right 4 times out of ten. (we couldn't do a longer test or I would have had to pour her into bed ;))

Plagerized by Edge
<> Characterize your opponents as "uncritical believers." Summarily dismiss the notion that debunkery itself betrays uncritical belief, albeit in the status quo.
What is it about debunking that you observe is uncritical belief? Please be specific.

Plagerized by Edge
<> Maintain that in investigations of unconventional phenomena, a single flaw invalidates the whole. In conventional contexts, however, you may sagely remind the world that, "after all, situations are complex and human beings are imperfect."
So now you are saying that scientists should not look for flaws in experimental design? Besides, what we really ask is that "unconventional phenomena" experiments be repeatable by independant investigators. Why do you have a problem with this?


Plagerized by Edge
<> "Occam's Razor," or the "principle of parsimony," says the correct explanation of a mystery will usually involve the simplest fundamental principles. Insist, therefore, that the most familiar explanation is by definition the simplest! Imply strongly that Occam's Razor is not merely a philosophical rule of thumb but an immutable law.
Another egregious lie. Scientists use Occam's Razor as a guideline to see what would be the most likely courses to investigate. If that turns up a dead end, then we go to more unlikely scenarios and test those. No scientist says OR is an immutable law. Whoever made this assertion betrays their incredible stupidity about science.


Plagerized by Edge
<> Discourage any study of history that may reveal today's dogma as yesterday's heresy. Likewise, avoid discussing the many historical, philosophical and spiritual parallels between science and democracy.
Science doesn't discourage history or philosophy at all. It is simply not a part of science. Go and make your comparisons and philosophize to your heart's content, but if you make a scientific claim, then these diciplines have no place.


Plagerized by Edge
<> Since the public tends to be unclear about the distinction between evidence and proof, do your best to help maintain this murkiness. If absolute proof is lacking, state categorically that "there is no evidence!"
In it's purest form, science does not even accept the concept of "proof". A theory is either strongly supported by evidence or weakly supported. Only things like mathmatics have real "proof". But if there is no evidence, then that should be noted, right?


Written by Edge (contains misspellings)
Definitly my plans I am going to mine next year in Gods country, my home.

This is something that has always confused me. Since theists claim God made everything, isn't it all God's country. Which parts has he sold off?
And I predict you will be no more wealthy after mining than you are now. Possibly less. If dowsing worked, you'd be rich.
 
copyright violation

Tricky said:
BTW. It is obvious you wrote the last bit because it is full of misspellings and grammatical errors. It is equally obvious that you did not write the next bits because they are as perfectly grammatical as they are perfectly dishonest. Remember, if you quote somebody, you're supposed to give the reference.

Source of Edge's post: http://members.aol.com/ddrasin/zen.html

It's quoted many places on the web, according to a quick google search, so he may have used a different link. Nonetheless, the text is copyrighted by the author, and he explicitly states "May not be reproduced in any form without express permission from the author".

Good catch, Tricky!

Roger
 
:)

Thanks Tricky!

:)

I was wondering who wrote that bit for him since I was sure it was not him due to the lack of spelling and grammer errors.

Originially, I had thought a friend of his had ghost-wrote for him, but it turns out he just copied it from someone else and did not give them credit.

My oh My! What a wanker he is!

He cannot dowse and he cannot give credit where credit is due.
 
Re: copyright violation

roger said:


Source of Edge's post: http://members.aol.com/ddrasin/zen.html

It's quoted many places on the web, according to a quick google search, so he may have used a different link. Nonetheless, the text is copyrighted by the author, and he explicitly states "May not be reproduced in any form without express permission from the author".

Good catch, Tricky!

Roger
So will this post of Edge's now be censored?

btw, that whole article was one huge straw man, with a bit of false analogy thrown in. A lot of the actions quoted are actually those adopted by believers, not skeptics. Eg: "Since the public tends to be unclear about the distinction between evidence and proof, do your best to help maintain this murkiness."

And, for good measure, Occam's Razor is misquoted. Occam's Razor does not say that anything is the correct explanation. It simply says you do not need to invent ad hoc hypotheses to explain something that has already been explained using natural explanations.


(Edited to add quote)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom