[Ed.] U.S. Constitutional Amendments and Faith

A simple question deserves an equally simple answer.

They didn't. That scenario you describe has little basis in reality. What you describe never happened, so the people never did that.



I am indeed. I'm proposing the system that we actually have.

So you're saying that the U.S. Government (for example) prints its own money and controls how much comes into circulation, are you?
 
So you're saying that the U.S. Government (for example) prints its own money and controls how much comes into circulation, are you?

Yes, and no.

The Federal Government prints its own money; that's the job of the US Mint. The amount of money printed has little or nothing to do with the amount of money in circulation; most of the money "in circulation" exists only in accountants' ledgers and computer files.

The Federal Government does not "control how much comes into circulation"; the amount of money in circulation is not something that any one entity can control, precisely because anyone who wants to can create more money in circulation simply by guaranteeing or giving a loan. For the most part, people (in the United States) get their loans from formally constituted banks, but there's nothing to keep me from phoning up Moe at Moe's Bar and Grille and telling him that it's okay if Larry drinks on my tab. By doing that, I have put money into circulation (albeit on a small scale).

The Federal Reserve Board is an independent, non-governmental organization that attempts to control credit-granting policies among the major banks to keep the amount of money "in circulation" at a reasonable level. One way that they do this is by setting the interest rates that the major banks charge; by lowering the interest rate, they make more money available for loans, and therefore raise the money supply (raising it, of course, does the opposite).

Another way is simply by re-loaning money. If a bank has $10,000 available (in cash), and lends it out, it almost certainly does not give $5,000 in cash to a hypothetical borrower. Instead, the borrower will simply open an account with this $5,000. This means that the bank now has total assets of $15,000 and can re-loan that $5,000 over and over again. By simply controlling the margin requirments (how often can a single dollar be loaned out, basically), the FRB and the government regulators jointly can act to control the money supply -- this is one area where the US government specifically has the upper hand and keeps the FRB in check.

Another major way that the money supply is controlled is by making Federal money available to the member banks to satisfy their margin requirements. Essentially, the banks can make loans based not only on their own cash reserves, but the government's as well. Although these loans do have interest due, the interest is paid not to the Federal Reserve Board or its member banks, but to the Federal Government itself -- so the bankers are not enriching themselves by making currency available.

This alone destroys your analogy; as you put it, "[the currency man] goes off into the corner and makes his currency. when some in the group need some currency he supplies it, but says "i'm sorry, but for the currency i'm going to charge you interest" at this point the whole group has become enslaved to the man in the corner. they are now in debt to him, and if they don't pay the interest he demands he can have them put in prison." Unfortunately, he does not charge them interest --- the government whom he represents does -- and as a result no one is in debt to him.

But more importantly, none of these policy aspects hinge at all on "fiat money." As I pointed out, the Rothschild's established their banking empire in an age of specie-based money; they can just as easily loan the same 5000 guineas over and over and over again as long as they have enough specie on hand to pay the (few) people who want to actually see the gold. And they did. Similarly, the Rothchilds were able to provide a (specie-backed) loan to the Bank of England when necessary to prevent currency crises, becaue "The Old Lady of Threadneedle Street" was then able to loan out the Rothschilds' money as well as its own.

So, basically, the FRB doesn't do what you think it does -- it doesn't act from the motives you think it has -- it's effect on the economy is not what you think it is,.... and even if you replaced the US FRB and went back on a specie-based currency, it wouldn't make any difference. Again, there's historical examples -- in the UK, banks do issue their own currency; I believe that currently the Bank of England, the Bank of Scotland, and the Royal Bank of Scotland all print money. Barclays does not, nor does the current Rothschild bank (Concordia) -- but they still create money by making loans, and did even when the pound was really based on a pound of silver.
 
For the most part, people (in the United States) get their loans from formally constituted banks, but there's nothing to keep me from phoning up Moe at Moe's Bar and Grille and telling him that it's okay if Larry drinks on my tab. By doing that, I have put money into circulation (albeit on a small scale).


I'm a little lost. Are you saying that you've increased the total money supply or that you've just sent your money out into the economy instead of saving it? If the latter, the loan aspect isn't nearly as important as the spending the money aspect. If the former, I don't think you've increased the total monsy suply unless you're practicing fractional reserve banking which, on a small scale, seems to me to be almost impossible.
 
Yes, and no.

The Federal Government prints its own money; that's the job of the US Mint. The amount of money printed has little or nothing to do with the amount of money in circulation; most of the money "in circulation" exists only in accountants' ledgers and computer files.

thanks for your detailed reply :)
ok. for me, and i think most people, the idea that money (fiat) can just be created out of nothing is very counterintuitive, because we normally ascribe "value" to money.. and if money can just be created by tapping into a computer then where did this extra "value" come from? In the current system this "value" seems to come from indebting somebody. Is indebting people really a wise basis for ascribing "value" in society? Or does it create an inherently exploitative system? (interest slavery)

The Federal Government does not "control how much comes into circulation"; the amount of money in circulation is not something that any one entity can control, precisely because anyone who wants to can create more money in circulation simply by guaranteeing or giving a loan. For the most part, people (in the United States) get their loans from formally constituted banks, but there's nothing to keep me from phoning up Moe at Moe's Bar and Grille and telling him that it's okay if Larry drinks on my tab. By doing that, I have put money into circulation (albeit on a small scale).

Yeah, I see. With this though, despite the fact that you could lend to me, it is still a de facto control of the money supply by those who lend the vast majority of money in society (the private banks)

The Federal Reserve Board is an independent, non-governmental organization
this sounds good, but in fact "private cartel" would be a more accurate description, it being a for-profit private organisation made up of various private banking elements. And from what I heard it is not subject to audit.

that attempts to control credit-granting policies among the major banks to keep the amount of money "in circulation" at a reasonable level.
given that it is a for-profit private organisation, "reasonable level" for who? for the population at large? or would the most reasonable level for the FRB be the one that makes the most profits for its members?

One way that they do this is by setting the interest rates that the major banks charge; by lowering the interest rate, they make more money available for loans, and therefore raise the money supply (raising it, of course, does the opposite).

why should a private for-profit organisation have the right to set the interest rate, thus affecting the whole population? why is this not a job for the government? such a set-up is completely unaccountable

Another way is simply by re-loaning money. If a bank has $10,000 available (in cash), and lends it out, it almost certainly does not give $5,000 in cash to a hypothetical borrower. Instead, the borrower will simply open an account with this $5,000. This means that the bank now has total assets of $15,000 and can re-loan that $5,000 over and over again. By simply controlling the margin requirments (how often can a single dollar be loaned out, basically), the FRB and the government regulators jointly can act to control the money supply -- this is one area where the US government specifically has the upper hand and keeps the FRB in check
.

If the government has the upper hand over the FRB in this area, how does it enforce this? If for example the FRB and the government disagreed over the level of the margin requirements and the government ploughed through with its own policy, would there be anything to prevent the FRB from "punishing" the government by changing interest rates in a way that would damage the population and thus the government? In essence, I'm asking which is the most important and powerful lever? The margin requirement or the interest rate? (Not a rhetorical question, I just don't know the answer)

Another major way that the money supply is controlled is by making Federal money available to the member banks to satisfy their margin requirements. Essentially, the banks can make loans based not only on their own cash reserves, but the government's as well. Although these loans do have interest due, the interest is paid not to the Federal Reserve Board or its member banks, but to the Federal Government itself -- so the bankers are not enriching themselves by making currency available.

In practice in which direction is the net flow of interest? From the banks to the government, or from the government to the banks? Given that I've never heard of banks being in trillions of dollars of debt, but the US government is.. my common sense guess would be that the flow is from the government (the people) to the private banks.

This alone destroys your analogy; as you put it, "[the currency man] goes off into the corner and makes his currency. when some in the group need some currency he supplies it, but says "i'm sorry, but for the currency i'm going to charge you interest" at this point the whole group has become enslaved to the man in the corner. they are now in debt to him, and if they don't pay the interest he demands he can have them put in prison." Unfortunately, he does not charge them interest --- the government whom he represents does -- and as a result no one is in debt to him.
the above question would apply here

But more importantly, none of these policy aspects hinge at all on "fiat money." As I pointed out, the Rothschild's established their banking empire in an age of specie-based money; they can just as easily loan the same 5000 guineas over and over and over again as long as they have enough specie on hand to pay the (few) people who want to actually see the gold. And they did. Similarly, the Rothchilds were able to provide a (specie-backed) loan to the Bank of England when necessary to prevent currency crises, becaue "The Old Lady of Threadneedle Street" was then able to loan out the Rothschilds' money as well as its own.
yes, but even so, if in the modern system, the man-in-the-corner moves in to a nation using a specie-based system, and supplants it with a fiat system (through a strategy like invasion) then the fiat system would apply there too.
Note that I'm not particularly against fiat or for specie. I am arguing for public control of the money production system, rather than private control.. regardless of whether it be fiat or specie. The important thing is WHO has control.

So, basically, the FRB doesn't do what you think it does -- it doesn't act from the motives you think it has -- it's effect on the economy is not what you think it is,.... and even if you replaced the US FRB and went back on a specie-based currency, it wouldn't make any difference. Again, there's historical examples -- in the UK, banks do issue their own currency; I believe that currently the Bank of England, the Bank of Scotland, and the Royal Bank of Scotland all print money. Barclays does not, nor does the current Rothschild bank (Concordia) -- but they still create money by making loans, and did even when the pound was really based on a pound of silver.

I'd be interested to hear what you think FRBs primary motive is.. profit or the public good? :)
 
Last edited:
drkitten said:
For the most part, people (in the United States) get their loans from formally constituted banks, but there's nothing to keep me from phoning up Moe at Moe's Bar and Grille and telling him that it's okay if Larry drinks on my tab. By doing that, I have put money into circulation (albeit on a small scale).

I'm a little lost. Are you saying that you've increased the total money supply or that you've just sent your money out into the economy instead of saving it? If the latter, the loan aspect isn't nearly as important as the spending the money aspect. If the former, I don't think you've increased the total monsy suply unless you're practicing fractional reserve banking which, on a small scale, seems to me to be almost impossible.


I think, thanks to drkitten, Larry now has more spending money (up to the tab limit), and probably a hangover; Moe has more money owed him, thanks to Larry's hangover; and, unless Larry's good for it, drkitten eventually will have to earn some extra money to pay Moe for Larry's hangover, and possibly to get Larry into alcohol rehab.
 
No. It doesn't rise to "a bit of a simplification." It's simply wrong from beginning to end. You might as well claim that Dr. Seuss' The Cat In the Hat is "a bit of a simplification" of the United States Tax Code, or that a fried egg is "a bit of a simplification" of The Lord of the Rings.

Not only an intelligent statement, but also laugh-out-loud funny.
 
it comes down to a simple question: Why would the people, through their representatives (the government) hand over a monopoly in producing society's currency to a private company (Central Bank)? And agree to pay interest on that currency? When they could easily print their own, without having to pay interest.

First off, bear in mind that the rate of interest paid to Fed member banks is fixed at 6% of deposits. That is equivalent to what you or I could get on a standard high-yield savings plan. It is not exactly a high rate of return.

I would imagine that the reason that they don't just print their own money is because the people responsible for controlling the currency have sufficient knowledge of economics to understand the disastrous consequences of such an action. Have you considered that the employees of the Federal Reserve are not part of some conspiracy to rob the people? That they are actually interested in doing their jobs, as described, in order to earn their salaries?

It's easy to talk about inflation eroding real wealth when you only look at the price index, but the economy is much more complex than that. If you look at what your money actually buys, the amount of real purchasing power the average consumer has, and the concept of time vs. money, then the situation today begins to look significantly better than when the price index was lower. Inflation can be a problem, but it tends not to be a big one if kept low enough to allow for natural market corrections in response to it.

Well the people would only allow something like this to happen through (as is the case) general ignorance of this situation, the real consequences to themselves, and the lack of a sense of the complete injustice of such a system.

That is nonsense. As much as you may want to class everyone who thinks differently as ignorant, there are plenty of parties with a firm grasp of economics that are not on the payroll of the Fed or some other part of the US government.

There are real arguments for and against the central banking system we have, and they do not boil down to "everyone who doesn't think it's a scam is ignorant."

Working a third or a quarter of your life, simply to enrich the bankers for nothing in return, is a form of slavery.

You, along with warlex, need to be far more specific when you refer to "the bankers," because it's not particularly clear what group of people you ultimately think is behind this.

Truthfully, the people most accurately called "bankers" are those salaried employees of banks that are responsible for their back-room operations. They are essentially moderately-paid technical professionals.

But I suspect that's not who you're talking about.

So, how is it you're simply enriching these "bankers" for nothing? You don't benefit from the banking system? So you're telling me that you've never received a loan from a bank of any kind? You've never patronized a business that exists only because of a bank loan? You've never made a deposit in a bank?

And surely, you've experienced several bank crashes, depressions, and severe recessions due to an unstable currency, right?

You use a lot of emotionally charged language, but I'm not seeing a lot of facts to back up what you're saying.
 
why should a private for-profit organisation have the right to set the interest rate, thus affecting the whole population? why is this not a job for the government? such a set-up is completely unaccountable

Except they don't set the rates each private bank charges for loans. The Fed sets the rates at which it loans private banks money to bolster their reserves. Such loans are made only in the short term, but if the rate offered by the Fed is lower than the prevailing market rate, it can encourage the banks to borrow from the Fed in order to up their reserves temporarily.

This, in turn, can allow them to make additional loans, which will be backed up by businesses, homes, cars, etc. and thus increase the total money supply (and also promote economic growth).

Private rates are determined by a range of market factors, of which the Fed's discount rate is only one that potentially effects the rate indirectly.

An analogous situation might be to consider the housing market. The availability and pricing of houses depends, in part, on the rates given by banks for home loans. That doesn't mean the banks directly set the price of housing, but it gives them a measure of control through the mechanics of the market. In the same way, consumer demand has an impact on every market, including currency markets.

I'm not sure what major economic player you think doesn't impact the whole population. The market responds to a diverse set of inputs, many of which are ultimately controlled by private interests. If that concerns you, I fear you may be eternally unhappy with the concept of capitalism.
 
I think, thanks to drkitten, Larry now has more spending money (up to the tab limit), and probably a hangover; Moe has more money owed him, thanks to Larry's hangover; and, unless Larry's good for it, drkitten eventually will have to earn some extra money to pay Moe for Larry's hangover, and possibly to get Larry into alcohol rehab.

Yup. Of course, I hope that I had sense enough to make sure that Larry was good for the money. Of course, if Larry's the drinker and Moe is the bartender, that would make me Curly,... so I probably don't have sense enough.

The point is that Larry can spend -- and Moe can accept -- money that neither of them actually has. They're spending my money while it's still in my pocket. If Larry is actually good for the money, then he can spend (and later repay) up to my tab limit many, many, times without reference to me and whether or not I actually am good for the bar tab myself.

Of course, Loss Leader is also correct that the effect of fractional reserve banking multiplies this money creation effect tremendously. I'm not going to be able to run a national economy on the money created by bar tabs. But it also shows that there is no "secret currency machine" that only one person or cartel is allowed to use. Anyone who wants can create as much money as they like. Up until the creation of the FDIC, they often did, and that's one reason that the bank collapses were so bad in the 1930s.

With the FDIC, it's risky (for all parties involved) to start creating money. If Larry isn't good for the money, I'm on the hook (and if I'm doing this via fractional reserve, I may be on the hook for more than I have). If I'm not good for the money, both Moe and Larry are stiffed. The FDIC has provided some guidelines -- if I behave responsibly in creating money, the government -- note, the government, not the FRB -- will cover for me if something goes horribly wrong. Not a perfect solution, but a better one.
 
[If the government has the upper hand over the FRB in this area, how does it enforce this? If for example the FRB and the government disagreed over the level of the margin requirements and the government ploughed through with its own policy, would there be anything to prevent the FRB from "punishing" the government by changing interest rates in a way that would damage the population and thus the government?

If push came to shove, the government could annul the FRB in a stroke of a pen. If necessary, the privately-held banks could be nationalized at the next stroke. If the bankers looked like they were going to do more damage to the economy that the act of nationalization would, then it would be an obvious and more or less irresistable countermeasure. There are a number of smaller countries that have done just that when western-held banks have "gotten too big for their britches."

Given that in your hypothetical, the bankers are acting against the national interest, this particular nationalization act would almost certainly improve the national economy.

In essence, I'm asking which is the most important and powerful lever? The margin requirement or the interest rate? (Not a rhetorical question, I just don't know the answer)

Ultimately, the FRB answers to the Federal Government and not the other way around. It's designed to be an independent organization to prevent minor, day-to-day meddling on matters of mere political import. (You've seen that sort of minor meddling, for example, in the way that Bush appointees have been trying to eliminate the theory of evolution from NASA).


In practice in which direction is the net flow of interest? From the banks to the government, or from the government to the banks? Given that I've never heard of banks being in trillions of dollars of debt, but the US government is.. my common sense guess would be that the flow is from the government (the people) to the private banks.

Your common-sense guess would be wrong. The bankers aren't the ones who hold the national debt (and receive interest on it), any more than stockbrokers are the ones who own the stock market. The national debt is funded through the issuance of debt instruments -- bonds and such -- that are owned by anyone who wants to own a piece of them. It's probably easiest to buy your piece of the debt through a bank, just as it's easiest to buy your milk through a grocer instead of a tire shop.... but the person who ultimately owns the national debt is you.

I'd be interested to hear what you think FRBs primary motive is.. profit or the public good? :)

Um, I don't know where you get the idea that the FRB is a "for-profit" organization.

The actual FRB (the Board of Governors) isn't an organization at all in the legal sense; it's just a decision-making comittee. The individual banks that the FRB controls -- the Federal Reserve Banks -- must, by law, return to the Treasury all excess monies they make over expenses.

Here's the relevant quote from the FRB itself:

Federal Reserve Banks generate their own income, primarily from interest earned on government securities that are acquired in the course of Federal Reserve monetary policy actions. A secondary source of income is derived from the provision of priced services to depository institutions, as required by the Monetary Control Act of 1980. Federal Reserve Banks are not, however, operated for a profit, and each year they return to the U.S. Treasury all earnings in excess of Federal Reserve operating and other expenses.

I would say that pretty much sums it up. They don't operate for their private profit and are not allowed to. This suggests to me that their motive for operating to their own private profit is fairly small....
 
Ok. for me, and i think most people, the idea that money (fiat) can just be created out of nothing is very counterintuitive, because we normally ascribe "value" to money.. and if money can just be created by tapping into a computer then where did this extra "value" come from?

You're simply looking at money (and "value") wrongly. Just because something is counterintuitive doesn't mean that it's wrong.

In particular, the "value" of an object is not inherent in the object (much to the dismay of the Marxists). Ebay proves this on a daily, if not minute-ly, basis. That cheap concert T-shirt that I work out in is worth hundreds of dollars to the right collector. It's worth enough to someone that you could create money just by buying it from me for $20 and re-selling it for $200 and everyone's happy. Where did your $180 come from?

In the current system this "value" seems to come from indebting somebody.

Whom did you indebt by re-selling my T-shirt?

Is indebting people really a wise basis for ascribing "value" in society?

Not exclusively, although personal service does seem to be a common way of putting value on yourself. I make my money teaching people. I'm "indebted" to my students -- I have to show up for class (sober!) or face sanctions. But I don't consider myself exploited. Quite the contrary; I do what I love and I am paid well for the privilege. I'd probably feel much less sanguine about personal indebtedness if I didn't like teaching but had to do it anyway.

But "money" is not something of inherent value; it's simply a medium of exchange. Instead of agreeing to teach for so-many-thousand a year, I could also teach for personal considerations from all of my students. My house needs painting, and I need to re-model my bathroom. Unfortunately, none of my students are professional painters, drywall carpenters, or plumbers. So I need something that I can take from them to the professionals to get my house re-done. That something is simply "money." The carpenter charges so-many-hundred an hour to remodel my bathroom, which I extract from the students and give to him. Eventually he'll probably need something from them, and the circle of life is complete.
 
I get the feeling that a lot of the people in this group like to play devils advocate, which is great. I also feel that a lot of the people in this group repeat what I heard in my high school history classes. I dont want to be a conspiracy theorists, but I dont want to be a blind sheep either. It is so hard to find a balance. I have always believed that aboslute power corrupts absolutely, so I tend to lean toward the conspiracy theorys, but that doesnt mean I abandon common sense and simple logic. Anyway....if there is another attack upon American soil that is bigger than 9/11 before Bush leaves office, I think that will put me over the edge. If there is not, maybe my fears will start subside.
 
I get the feeling that a lot of the people in this group like to play devils advocate, which is great.

Why do you believe that?

I also feel that a lot of the people in this group repeat what I heard in my high school history classes.

Actually, I'm fairly certain that most of the people "in this group" are college educated on at least the undergraduate level, and several also draw from practical experience in relevant fields.

If high school history is the extent of your experience with economics, taxation, political science, or even history (pick your poison, this discussion has included all four), then perhaps you need a more thorough grounding in the prevailing theories and core knowledge of one or more of these disciplines.

I dont want to be a conspiracy theorists, but I dont want to be a blind sheep either. It is so hard to find a balance. I have always believed that aboslute power corrupts absolutely, so I tend to lean toward the conspiracy theorys, but that doesnt mean I abandon common sense and simple logic.

Then don't rely on hokey sayings like "absolute power corrupts absolutely" - they are not the foundation of a sound, logically-reasoned worldview. Ideally, you shouldn't "lean" towards anything, other than perhaps to minimize the number of unfounded assumptions you make when weighing competing theories. Instead, examine the evidence you have available and make your decisions based on that, rather than the desire to not seem like one thing or another.

Anyway....if there is another attack upon American soil that is bigger than 9/11 before Bush leaves office, I think that will put me over the edge. If there is not, maybe my fears will start subside.

What? What does this have to do with the Federal Reserve, our current currency system, or the system of taxation?
 
I also feel that a lot of the people in this group repeat what I heard in my high school history classes.

Sounds like your high school history teachers got it right, then. I'm not sure why you think that just because something was taught in high school, it has to be wrong. Heck, I still use grade school mathematics every time I make change. But it seems to be much more effective than if I were to make up my own addition and subtraction tables -- "Let's see, now : seven minus five should be 'yellow,' I think."
 
Sounds like your high school history teachers got it right, then. I'm not sure why you think that just because something was taught in high school, it has to be wrong. Heck, I still use grade school mathematics every time I make change. But it seems to be much more effective than if I were to make up my own addition and subtraction tables -- "Let's see, now : seven minus five should be 'yellow,' I think."

I thought he was implying that the people here weren't bringing anything else to the table, which is patently ridiculous, but your point is excellent as well.

I still use grade school math too, isn't that crazy?! No kidding, I was studying derivatives and I actually used some math I learned in the fourth grade!

Hell, when I was taking this macro-economics course, I actually used these "letters" I learned to write in kindergarten!

Can you believe it?
 
I thought he was implying that the people here weren't bringing anything else to the table, which is patently ridiculous, but your point is excellent as well.

I still use grade school math too, isn't that crazy?! No kidding, I was studying derivatives and I actually used some math I learned in the fourth grade!

Hell, when I was taking this macro-economics course, I actually used these "letters" I learned to write in kindergarten!

Can you believe it?


pantently ridiculous whoaaa haha, so clever. Im sure you will respond "it wasnt clever it was patently original".

The point I'm tring to make is that there is a lot of questions to be asked both ways. And whoever said that the qoute "absolute power corrupts absolutely" is whatever needs to rethink whatever he said. That is one of the most true statements of all time. We live in a very corrupt world. Conspiracy theories, although freshman, may just be the fresh thinking we are looking for (hahaha). I do believe history repeats itself, and that withouht the proper checks and balances, this world (as you and I know it) is doomed.
 
pantently ridiculous whoaaa haha, so clever. Im sure you will respond "it wasnt clever it was patently original".

The point I'm tring to make is that there is a lot of questions to be asked both ways. And whoever said that the qoute "absolute power corrupts absolutely" is whatever needs to rethink whatever he said. That is one of the most true statements of all time. We live in a very corrupt world. Conspiracy theories, although freshman, may just be the fresh thinking we are looking for (hahaha). I do believe history repeats itself, and that withouht the proper checks and balances, this world (as you and I know it) is doomed.


So, this would imply that god is the most corrupt being possible.
 
A simple example. Is the United States Air Force legal? Article I provides Congress with authority "provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States" and specifically "To raise and support Armies" and "To provide and maintain a Navy," but not for an Air Force. Amendment X specifically states that "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution [...]are reserved to the States." A strict reading of the letter of the law suggests therefore that the United States does not have the authority to maintain an Air Force, but the individual states do.

It may be legal but it would be highly improper, they where not fans of standing armies and the like. Now wondering what they would think of a standing Air Force is an interesting question.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom