[Ed.] U.S. Constitutional Amendments and Faith

Is it? I saw mention of libertarianism earlier, and that's an unfounded and illogical religious belief.

Oooh, buuuurn! :)

In any case, unless some roving gangs of wild mods decide to move this thread, I shall eagerly await warlex's responses to the various issues here.
 
The theory involved is far more complex than simply "bailing the country out," as you put it. More appropriately, you might say that the central bank's duty is to adjust various economic factors to help balance out economic cycles.

Bear in mind that the impact of the central bank's monetary policy extends into various economic areas - it can impact the value of credit, inflate or deflate the currency, and encourage or discourage loans.

But the thing is that the impact of the central bank, if you actually examine the historical evidence, has been largely positive. As UnrepentantSinner pointed out, we've had one major depression since the inception of the Fed. We also had a notable panic in 1987 that the Fed prevented from turning into a major economic disaster.



The central bank is not responsible for deficit spending, the legislative and executive branches of the federal government are.



You're somewhat conflating two very different things. Deficit spending deals with the balance of the budget for each fiscal year, while the national debt deals with our country's debt to various borrowers.

Deficit spending simply means that we spend more in a given period than we take in. Likewise, when we have a budget surplus, it means we've taken in more than we've spent. This is more an issue of accounting than anything else, as the deficit has to do with the government's ledger. If you wish to reduce a deficit, you will have to either increase taxes, cut costs, borrow money, or print more money.

Don't confuse it with the national debt, however, because the budget issue is a short-term issue, handled from year to year. It can snowball if the deficit spending continues, but it's very different from the issue of the national debt.

When it comes to the national debt, you are considering only one side of it if you look simply at the amount of debt, or the rate of growth.

Another metric to consider is the amount of debt as a percentage of national output, which gives an idea of how much of a burden the debt on our country really is.

The debt burden as a percentage peaked during World War II (it actually exceeded our national output during the war), declined until the 1980's, rose again, then started to decline in the mid 1990's. Right now, it's roughly 60% of our national output (similar to the mid-1950's) - I can try to find the specific figure for 2006 or 2007, as the chart I have referenced in the economics text in front of me ends at '03.



That's pretty vague, though. How would the extended debt lead to a massive depression? Why would it be "10 times worse" than the Great Depression? What would cause such a depression to initiate? How does that compare to the fall of Rome?



How? The 16th amendment has nothing to do with banks, or bankers, or banking. It may affect the decisions made by the banks, but it's more about providing the government with a source of money to do the stuff that the people it represents have all come to expect it to do.

You'll need to be a lot more specific when discussing these issues than using a generic phrase like "bankers." What, precisely, do you mean when you use that term? The central bank employees? The owners of the major banks (who, by the way, are stockholders, not just one person)? The bank presidents? The people actually titled "banker" that are salaried employees responsible for managing the bank system?



The thing is, these are two completely separate issues that you seem intent on smashing together. It is perfectly possible to have an income tax with no central bank, or to have a central bank with no taxes. The tax issue is one of providing funding for government services, while the central bank is supposed to deal with monetary stabilization.

I see your comment there about paying the Fed back with all tax revenue. First off, do you have a source to back that comment up?

Secondly, even assuming it's true, it doesn't make a difference. If you want to balance the budget, you still have to take debt servicing into account along with expenses. The end result is that you do need a supply of funding to keep everything running, and without some form of revenue (taxes), it will eventually grind the government to a halt.

I get that you're not a big fan of government programs, but please at least try to understand that you will need to cut a lot of what we currently get from the government in order to remove income taxes. Whether or not this is actually worth it is open to debate.

You also should consider that the States have their own budgets, and can impose their own taxes. Some don't have income tax (TN and NH, for example), and make up that income in other ways. Whether or not such a model can be applied to the bigger scale of the federal government is, again, open to debate.



It certainly is.

Please don't claim that the wars we're currently fighting are simply "for oil." That is immensely simplistic. I agree that the wars are costly, and I think it's high time we started pulling out of Iraq - but that doesn't reduce the situation to something so simple as oil.




You are correct; the role of the central bank is much more complex. I was being pretty general, but the point I was trying to drive home was that back in 1913 the promise was that a panic like 1907 would never happen again if we had a central bank pretty much for the reasons you listed. We gave all the power over to the Fed to regulate our money.

Yes, if you look at the historical record the economy has generally been more stable since the starting of the Federal Reserve. However, this is a very young country. From 1776 to 1913 we were trying a lot of different things. We knew what we didn’t want to do, because the founding fathers saw how oppressive the bank of England was. The US was not a superpower back then as it is today. Since World War 2 the entire world has had to answer to the American dollar. That in itself is a huge economic stabilizer. Before the Fed we didn’t really have a deficit, and our debt to other countries was minuscule compared to what we owe today. You site 1987 as a bailout, but why couldn’t the Fed bail us out in the 30’s? The Fed actually took money out of the system in the 30’s. That just doesn’t make any sense. I think saying that the Fed is the reason for our economic stability is a pretty bold and debatable statement.

Yes, you are right; the central bank is not technically responsible for deficit spending, but it certainly encourages it. Let me clarify what I said about deficit spending being ok as long as the dollar is ok. You are right deficit spending simply means we need to borrow because there isn’t enough money coming in from taxes. In fact the government spends almost 1 million dollars more than it takes in per minute. That is just ridiculous. It is a testament to how out of control our government has become. This kind of borrowing is ok because our economy is so strong and because our military is the most dominant in the world. Our economy generates about 11 trillion dollars every year (GDP). That dwarves the next best country which is not even half that. This is why no one is worried that we borrow so much. However, there is much reason to be worried.

This brings us to fiat currencies. A fiat currency has never worked in the history of the world. Here is a great site to learn about fiat currencies and what a bad idea they are.

http://www.dailyreckoning.com/rpt/fiathistoryWP.html

I won’t restate what is said on that site, but it is basically what I believe is happening and what will be the cause of a huge economic disaster. It will show you how we are on track to falling like Rome did.

As for the income tax and the 16th amendment…Here is a link to the Grace Commission report showing that almost 100% of our income tax goes to interest we owe to the Fed. Not to what we expect are government services.

http://www.freecanadian.net/articles/grace.html


As for our involvement in the Middle East, I am pretty sure we are there for oil. It sounds simplistic because it is simplistic. Corporate interests are huge and the Bush family loves oil. Also as Dave Chappelle put so eloquently: “He tried to kill muh fatha!” Spreading democracy and stabilizing the region is code for give me all the oil and buy Coke.
 
This brings us to fiat currencies. A fiat currency has never worked in the history of the world.

Goodness me, how right you are. That's why there's not ONE major currency today that is not a fiat currency -- which is what reduced the entire world to the barter system.

I won’t restate what is said on that site,

That's good, because it's total gibberish.

And not only that, it comes up with something like six examples, covering the past two thousand years. I can come up with a lot more examples than that of how specie-based currency collapses, starting with the Spanish Empire.
 
Goodness me, how right you are. That's why there's not ONE major currency today that is not a fiat currency -- which is what reduced the entire world to the barter system.



That's good, because it's total gibberish.

And not only that, it comes up with something like six examples, covering the past two thousand years. I can come up with a lot more examples than that of how specie-based currency collapses, starting with the Spanish Empire.

The collapses dont happen over night....
 
This brings us to fiat currencies. A fiat currency has never worked in the history of the world. Here is a great site to learn about fiat currencies and what a bad idea they are.

There is nothing in a fiat currency, per se, that makes it unworkable, just as there is nothing in a backed currency that makes it ideal. By its very nature, money is valuable as a means of exchange. Even a currency backed in gold is valuable because gold is accepted as a medium of exchange.

The backed currency has a built-in physical limitation, but that doesn't protect it from all problems. Hell, it doesn't even necessarily protect it from inflation.

I won’t restate what is said on that site, but it is basically what I believe is happening and what will be the cause of a huge economic disaster. It will show you how we are on track to falling like Rome did.

What is it exactly you believe is happening? That site lists a number of diverse topics, including the supremely disingenuous inclusion of the German hyper-inflation post-WWI.

It also neglects to mention the issues caused by fixed, non-fiat currencies, but that is unsurprising given the position of the author.

Also, they compare the US national debt to Germany's post-WWI (they love that comparison, don't they) debt, which is absolutely insane. The total US national debt is roughly 60% of our national output, which is absolutely nothing on the crushing burden imposed on the war-weary German economy after the first World War.

As for the income tax and the 16th amendment…Here is a link to the Grace Commission report showing that almost 100% of our income tax goes to interest we owe to the Fed. Not to what we expect are government services.

First off, this talks about servicing the national debt, which has nothing to do with paying the Fed. Are you thinking of the Fed's open market operations with securities?

Ultimately, the payments to the national debt are going to the various foreign investors that issued that credit in the first place.

Also, as was brought up in another thread about tax protestors, it is completely untrue that all the tax money goes to interest payments. It is something like 20% of income tax.

This post by Lurker summarizes the current numbers from the budget itself. I held off comment on your Fed debt thing before, because I had to pull the numbers myself, but it appears to be completely untrue.

As for our involvement in the Middle East, I am pretty sure we are there for oil. It sounds simplistic because it is simplistic. Corporate interests are huge and the Bush family loves oil.

But what evidence do you have for this? Has the price of oil even reduced? Has oil production increased dramatically? Have we appropriated Iraqi oil reserves for our own use?
 
The collapses dont happen over night....

Oh sure, it's easy to toss out statements like this. Instead, could you explain the economic theory behind your theory of the collapse? How would a fiat currency result in a collapse? What could be done to avoid this? How would a backed currency prevent it?
 
I agree with Warlexz,

to create an analogy.. say there is a group of people in a room who control a currency machine, which costs them almost nothing to run. they decide between themselves how much currency to make and distribute, for the good of the group.
then one day one of the group says "i think I should be the one who controls the currency machine"
for some unknown reason the group agree with him, and cede him total control of the machine. he can create as much or as little currency as he likes, and there's nothing they can do.
so he goes off into the corner and makes his currency. when some in the group need some currency he supplies it, but says "i'm sorry, but for the currency i'm going to charge you interest"

at this point the whole group has become enslaved to the man in the corner. they are now in debt to him, and if they don't pay the interest he demands he can have them put in prison. if they don't behave the way he wants he can refuse to create enough currency, or he can create too much, in order to create instability. when he refuses to create enough currency he causes poverty and depression, when he creates too much he creates inflation.
In both cases he can exploit the groups vulnerability by buying up their property (which because currency is free for him, is not buying at all, but seizing). Thus, before long, he owns everything in the room.

I know that's a bit of a simplification, and probably has several holes in it, but this is basically how every nation with a Rothschild/Rockefeller Central Bank operates.
It's notable that the so-called "Rogue States" are the only remaining states that don't belong to this private Central Bank system e.g. Cuba, Iran, North Korea (Yugoslavia before the intervention, Iraq before the invasion) it looks like Libya might be changing over to the system soon too.
 
Last edited:
I agree with Warlexz,

I'm not surprised.


to create an analogy..

That is indeed an analogy. An amazingly bad one, since it doesn't really have any observable relationship to reality.


say there is a group of people in a room who control a currency machine, which costs them almost nothing to run. they decide between themselves how much currency to make and distribute, for the good of the group.

Right there, you lose it. The "group of people who control the currency supply" are not doing it for thei good of their own group, but are subject to political control by the rest of the US government; if they decide to compeltely mess up the economy for their own personal benefit, really bad things would happen to them personally.

And there are some rather strict rules in place to make sure that this doesn't occur.



then one day one of the group says "i think I should be the one who controls the currency machine"
for some unknown reason the group agree with him, and cede him total control of the machine. he can create as much or as little currency as he likes, and there's nothing they can do.

This is where you completely part connection with reality in any recognizable form.

Who is this person supposed to be?


I know that's a bit of a simplification, and probably has several holes in it,

No. It doesn't rise to "a bit of a simplification." It's simply wrong from beginning to end. You might as well claim that Dr. Seuss' The Cat In the Hat is "a bit of a simplification" of the United States Tax Code, or that a fried egg is "a bit of a simplification" of The Lord of the Rings.

Movie or book, it doesn't matter. It's simply an incorrect statement.
 
Why would the Grace commission say this though?

"With two-thirds of everyone's personal income taxes wasted or not collected, 100 percent of what is collected is absorbed solely by interest on the Federal debt and by Federal Government contributions to transfer payments. In other words, all individual income tax revenues are gone before one nickel is spent on the services which taxpayers expect from their Government. "

I read through the link you provided for me. The government budget report does show only 20% of income tax goes to interest, but still the question stands, why would the Grace Commission say it doesnt?
 
I'm not surprised.




That is indeed an analogy. An amazingly bad one, since it doesn't really have any observable relationship to reality.




Right there, you lose it. The "group of people who control the currency supply" are not doing it for thei good of their own group, but are subject to political control by the rest of the US government; if they decide to compeltely mess up the economy for their own personal benefit, really bad things would happen to them personally.

And there are some rather strict rules in place to make sure that this doesn't occur.





This is where you completely part connection with reality in any recognizable form.

Who is this person supposed to be?




No. It doesn't rise to "a bit of a simplification." It's simply wrong from beginning to end. You might as well claim that Dr. Seuss' The Cat In the Hat is "a bit of a simplification" of the United States Tax Code, or that a fried egg is "a bit of a simplification" of The Lord of the Rings.

Movie or book, it doesn't matter. It's simply an incorrect statement.

ouch, seems like a touched a bit of a nerve there ;)
as to the person, how about studying the history of the Rothschild family, who along with their subsidiaries, who, according to some economists estimates own around 55% of the world's wealth
such a situation is only possible with a man-in-the-corner scenario.. unless you're suggesting they somehow honestly earned all this through work.
 
The point Im trying to make about fiat currencies is that we over-issue money. It just becomes to easy print money. The dollar has lost 94% of its value since 1913. Its not even worth the paper its printed on. I dont see how this cant be alarming to you.
 
You raise some great points here. You are correct the constitution is a Godless document, but you cant tell me they were not at least somewhat inspired by religious documents such as the Bible.

Everyone,

This is an interesting point. A lot of people will say that the Constitution is godless. Some other people will say that it had Biblical inspiration. Through some good luck, I have been given a job, in which during the coming months, I will have to read through all the notes and all the journals of all the framers of the Constitution. Everyone at the convention. If I can get hold of their notes, I have to read them. The focus of my research has to be on other things, but while I'm reading, I'll be keeping an eye out for any inkling of a religious or non-religious perspective of the framers. If I think of it, I'll report back here. Wish me luck.

warlexz53 said:
I believe in a Lassie Fair style economy.
Beautiful.
 
The point Im trying to make about fiat currencies is that we over-issue money.

Yes. The point I'm trying to make is that you're wrong -- we don't.

That's not, of course, to say that we couldn't. But so far, the United States has generally done a very good of keeping a tight enough rein on the money supply to keep economic growth steady and the standard of living (and all the rest of the good things that the government is supposed to supply) growing.

I'm not even sure what you're supposed to mean by "over-issuing money" -- and I'm equally confident that you don't, either.

Do you think that we should have the same number of dollars in circulation today that we did in 1920? Given that the US population has something like tripled over that period, and that the real growth in productivity has probably been several orders of magnitude, that would be rather silly.

The dollar has lost 94% of its value since 1913.

Why should I even care, let alone "be alarmed"? I'm not even sure what you mean by this -- do you mean that a dollar today buys what six cents would have bought in 1913?

The real measure of economic success is not in "dollars" (although that's convenient), but in "time" and "effort." The US government could decide to completely re-scale its currency with a hundred "dollars" becoming a single "uberdollar" -- or one dollar becoming a thousands "unterdollars" -- without actually changing anyone's standard of living substantially. What really matters is how real wages compare to real prices; working at $20 an hour, it takes me five hours to afford a $100 hotel room. Working at 20 uber-cents an hour, it would still take me five hours to afford a one uber-buck hotel room. No change.

What fiat money has done is made sure that currency is available on an as-needed basis to make sure investment capital is there. Mild inflation is actually good for the economy; it encourages investment and productivity improvements because simply stuffing your matress makes dollars more expensive, which increases the cost of making capital improvements to anything.

The ultimate proof of the pudding, of course, is in the eating. Since 1913, the United States and the (Western) world at large have achieved unprecedented levels of standards of living, improvements that would not have been possible without easy access to investment capital. Fiat money allows the government to keep the costs of investment capital low enough that people can still get needed credit even when local circumstances hurt the local economy.

So the simplest response is -- yes, I understand your point. I also understand that it's wrong. If you tell me that three plus five equals eleven, I don't disagree because I didn't understand you....
 
as to the person, how about studying the history of the Rothschild family, who along with their subsidiaries, who, according to some economists estimates own around 55% of the world's wealth

These "economists" are simply wrong.

And, yes, I've studied the history of the Rothschild family, going back to Meyer. I find it interesting that you consider them to be so utterly scary when a) they made their fortunes during the age of monetarist, specie-based currency, and b) they all but disappeared from the world stage in the two world wars.

Interesting that you think the solution to the "problem "of the Rothschilds is a return to the system that they managed to manipulate with such ease. Is your solution to the problem of a fire to pour gasoline on it?
 
Why would the Grace commission say this though?

"With two-thirds of everyone's personal income taxes wasted or not collected, 100 percent of what is collected is absorbed solely by interest on the Federal debt and by Federal Government contributions to transfer payments. In other words, all individual income tax revenues are gone before one nickel is spent on the services which taxpayers expect from their Government. "

I read through the link you provided for me. The government budget report does show only 20% of income tax goes to interest, but still the question stands, why would the Grace Commission say it doesnt?

It doesn't. It starts by saying "With two-thirds of everyone's personal income taxes wasted or not collected" -- implying that 67% of income tax goes to fraud and waste. It then says that "100 percent of what is collected is absorbed solely by interest on the Federal debt and by Federal Government contributions to transfer payments" -- in other words, that the remaining 33% goes to pay the debt and other obligations. IN this context, "transfer payments" are probably Federal moneys that are redistributed to state and local governments (the opposite of the "unfunded mandates" that are so often the subject of complaints.) For example, the people who pave the stretch of Interstate Highway near your house are probably paid by your state, using money given to them by the Fed to support the Federal Interstate system. The chances are very good that your local school buys Federally subsidized lunches for its poorer students -- the money for those lunches comes from the Fed through the local school district via transfer payments.

Oh, and the single biggest category of transfer payments? Medicare and Medicaid, which are almost exclusively funded via transfer payments to the relevant state governments. Medicaid, in particular, is a joint state/federal program where the Fed simply provides matching funds for state programs in amounts ranging from 50% on up, depending upon the local poverty levels. Since Medicare/Medicaid costs something like a half trillion dollars per year (depending upon which numbers you look at and who you throw into the pile), you can see that this single transfer payment alone is a fairly hefty chunk of change --- that has nothing to do with interest on the national debt.

Basically, the Grace Commission doesn't say what you think it says. I have my own doubts about the accuracy of this particular report -- but I have even graver ones about the accuracy of the interpretation you wish to put on it.
 
Last edited:
These "economists" are simply wrong.

And, yes, I've studied the history of the Rothschild family, going back to Meyer. I find it interesting that you consider them to be so utterly scary when a) they made their fortunes during the age of monetarist, specie-based currency, and b) they all but disappeared from the world stage in the two world wars.

Interesting that you think the solution to the "problem "of the Rothschilds is a return to the system that they managed to manipulate with such ease. Is your solution to the problem of a fire to pour gasoline on it?

oh, well if you say they're wrong they must be.

it comes down to a simple question: Why would the people, through their representatives (the government) hand over a monopoly in producing society's currency to a private company (Central Bank)? And agree to pay interest on that currency? When they could easily print their own, without having to pay interest.

Well the people would only allow something like this to happen through (as is the case) general ignorance of this situation, the real consequences to themselves, and the lack of a sense of the complete injustice of such a system.
Working a third or a quarter of your life, simply to enrich the bankers for nothing in return, is a form of slavery.

Are you proposing an alternative system?
 
it comes down to a simple question: Why would the people, through their representatives (the government) hand over a monopoly in producing society's currency to a private company (Central Bank)? And agree to pay interest on that currency? When they could easily print their own, without having to pay interest.

A simple question deserves an equally simple answer.

They didn't. That scenario you describe has little basis in reality. What you describe never happened, so the people never did that.

Are you proposing an alternative system?

I am indeed. I'm proposing the system that we actually have.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom