Hokulele
Deleterious Slab of Damnation
She wasn't talking to or correcting you.
He meant that tongue in cheek, Joe and I are cool. But thanks slingblade.
She wasn't talking to or correcting you.
The main weakness of the British Constitution is that there is nothing, even in theory, to stop a sufficiently determined despot (read: King) to have his own way, regardless of what the laws say. He can pack the House of Lords with his toadies, dissolve Parliament and rule by decree, and completely abrogate the common law. Not only can he do that, he has; see Stuart, House of -- and for that matter, Hanover, House of.
Now, I would certainly believe that if the income tax amendment had been procedurally irregular (or illegally passed), then it shouldn't be part of the Constitution and shouldn't be enforceable; to that extent, I agree with the tax protestors. However, I don't think it was irregular -- and the courts agree with me, not with them.
I was pretty vague about the sort of tax I meant - I only said that it needs to be means-based (VAT would cover this - the richer you are, the more you buy. I don't know enough about user service fees to comment).I think that the income tax is one of the fairer methods of spreading out the costs of government, but I don't think the answer is as clear-cut as you would like to make it.
There is nothing, in theory or in practice, to stop any head of state having a crack at becoming a tyrant.
And here is the nub of my bewilderment. If I've read this aright, you base your personal political opinions on whether or not they align with the US constitution. Which seems a rather unnatural level of reverence for it.
And here is the nub of my bewilderment. If I've read this aright, you base your personal political opinions on whether or not they align with the US constitution. Which seems a rather unnatural level of reverence for it.
warlex, I'll have a lengthier reponse to your post probably after you go to bed, but if you see this, are you planning on voting for Ron Paul.
I think gets to my point. You are saying that some parts of the constitution (including amendments) are fine, some are not. Some parts of the Bible are fine, some are not. How do you know which ones apply? For example, there are clauses in the constitution that allow for the call-up of troops in the army. Does this not impinge on freedoms? Term limits and age requirements are part and parcel of the description of the role of the presidency. Are these not restrictions? To use a faith as a basis for determination of governmental roles requires that the application be consistent. If you would accept parts of the constitution (and the Bible) as truth, I would assume that there would be a bit more critical thinking involved in determining which other parts hold or not. Sorry to sound harsh, and if you would prefer to wait until tomorrow to respond, that is fine as well.
Like you said, if you want to be president there are restrictions. These rules were debated and went through the ringer. At the end of the day a final rule was set that made sense to the most people.
So you also oppose the 22nd amendment?
These rules were debated and went through the ringer. At the end of the day a final rule was set that made sense to the most people.
As for basic things like freedom of speech and how a man should be free, I dont think there is much debate because those things are innate in all of us.
I never said I opposed the 22nd ammendment. I'm not sure where you are getting that from.
I am a huge Ron Paul supporter. I think thats pretty obvious. He is a TRUE republican, or what is now known as the libertarian party.
I really wish Hal still posted here apart from the periodic JREF or TAM/TAA message because he has a great perspective on how, in the time of the framing, that there was a conflict between those who envisioned a modern, cosmopolitan federal system and those who envisioned a pastoral, parocial anit-federalist system. The federalists won very early in the Republic so I find people like Ron Paul and his supporters to be Ludditish.
Two points in response to your longer post.
Would you agree that this also applies to the 16th amendment? If not, why is this one different than the others.
The problem with this is, it may seem innate in this day and age, but it didn't always. The majority of the people then saw innate rights quite differently, hence the need for amendments emancipating the slaves, allowing women the vote, and restricting the voting age.
All that being said, what does make an income tax different from other tax systems, or other restrictions on personal liberties supported by the constitution, such as age requirements?
Maybe I was misunderstanding your point. What was your point when you were talking about the restrictions and rules about being president?
Would it be possible to PM Hal for his perspective, or do you know of any old threads that can be linked? I'd be interested to read this.
That tells me volumes.
I'm going to defer to drkittens replies since they largely mirror what mine would have been.
We've been finding concepts in the Constitution not explicitly enumerated or espoused with particular verbiage since Marbury v. Madison... and Madison was a Federalist whose side "won" the fight over framing. The genius of the framers wasn't what they wrote into the Constitution, but that they allowed for amendment when it was warrented - such as slavery - and interpretation when the issue was more elastic and didn't require enumeration.
As far as God goes, I'd point to the preamble - WE the People have ordained and established this Constitution, not God. I can't find a direct link, but if you search the 'Net for Biblical references in the Federalist papers... again, the "winning" side, there aren't any. The Constitution is a Godless document, and it should be in a secular society.
Tax protesters bitch about how high our taxes our and I agree in principle. I would love to have all of my paycheck go into my account, but the fact is that we have needs in 2007 that didn't exist in 1787. The SEC, FAA, NTSB, world-wide militar presence, FDA, CIA, etc. etc. There were no hedge funds, airplanes, highways, big pharma, etc. when the Constitution was written. We simply live in a different world than that of Madison, Hamilton and Adams.
I really wish Hal still posted here apart from the periodic JREF or TAM/TAA message because he has a great perspective on how, in the time of the framing, that there was a conflict between those who envisioned a modern, cosmopolitan federal system and those who envisioned a pastoral, parocial anit-federalist system. The federalists won very early in the Republic so I find people like Ron Paul and his supporters to be Ludditish.
A simple survey of American economic history shows how their position is untennable:
- Number of panics/depressions before the Fed: about 1 every 10 years
- Number of panics/depressions after the Fed: 1
I would agree that applies to the 16th ammendment, but you have to look at the time period the 16th ammendment was made law. The industrial revolution was in full swing and a lot more money was being circulated than say 50 years prior. The panic of 1907 made people very weary and bankers promised that a central bank would mend everyones fears. The theory was that if you had a central bank controlling the money supply they could bail the country out if it needed it.
This turned out to be a load of crap, or at least until the late 1930's when the central bank started what we now call deficit spending. That trend has continued since then and right now we are close to 9 trillion dollars in debt.
The theory behind deficit spending is that everything will be ok as long as our economy stays strong and the dollar stays strong compared to other currencies. The dollar is doing horrible and the debt is rising faster than it ever has in history. These two things are a combination for disaster.
I just finished a great book called Empire of Debt that outlines how America has over extended itself and is looking at a depression 10 times worse than the crash of 1929. It would make the fall of Rome look like 2nd grade bully fight.
So it seems the 16th ammendment was protection for the bankers.
Protection for a policy that has gotten way way out of hand. So back in 1913 maybe it seemed like a good idea to implement an income tax and a federal bank. Today however it doesnt look so hot.
There needs to some serious rethinking about how our economy runs. Unfortunately it is much more complicated now than it was in 1913 because everything is connected on a global scale.
So, what those people are basically doing is LYING THROUGH THEIR STINKING TEETH. I knew that.