[Ed.] U.S. Constitutional Amendments and Faith

The main weakness of the British Constitution is that there is nothing, even in theory, to stop a sufficiently determined despot (read: King) to have his own way, regardless of what the laws say. He can pack the House of Lords with his toadies, dissolve Parliament and rule by decree, and completely abrogate the common law. Not only can he do that, he has; see Stuart, House of -- and for that matter, Hanover, House of.

Packing the House of Lords with toadies won't do your hypothetical despot any good - they haven't been able to do anything except demand a couple of extra readings and a delay since the Parliament Act of 1911. For what happens, even before this, when English Monarchs start getting uppity you might want to read up on the English Civil War and the 'Glorious Revolution'. (see Stuart, House of).

There is nothing, in theory or in practice, to stop any head of state having a crack at becoming a tyrant. In the UK case what you'd get is a constitutional crisis and most likely an abdication, unless there popular opinion sat in the monarch's favour and the army were willing to interpret their remit somewhat rigidly. Governments only work because everyone agrees to let them.


Now, I would certainly believe that if the income tax amendment had been procedurally irregular (or illegally passed), then it shouldn't be part of the Constitution and shouldn't be enforceable; to that extent, I agree with the tax protestors. However, I don't think it was irregular -- and the courts agree with me, not with them.

And here is the nub of my bewilderment. If I've read this aright, you base your personal political opinions on whether or not they align with the US constitution. Which seems a rather unnatural level of reverence for it.


I think that the income tax is one of the fairer methods of spreading out the costs of government, but I don't think the answer is as clear-cut as you would like to make it.
I was pretty vague about the sort of tax I meant - I only said that it needs to be means-based (VAT would cover this - the richer you are, the more you buy. I don't know enough about user service fees to comment).
 
There is nothing, in theory or in practice, to stop any head of state having a crack at becoming a tyrant.

Um,... this is not really true. The United States proved this, for example, in the early 1970s and the Watergate crisis, which was as close as they have come to the Glorious Revolution -- except that no shots were fired. One of the more foresighted features of the US Constitution is to create a number of independent power blocs, none of whom are dependent upon each other. Unlike the UK system, where the Prime Minister is (in theory, and until relatively recently in practice) an appointee of the Crown and dependent upon his pleasure, the Speaker of the House of Representatives is beholden to no one except his constituents. Similarly, at the time the (US) Constitution was drawn up, no one could predict the effects of the Parliament Act of 1911, and the House of Lords was still a potent political force. I fear that you may still undersestimate the power of the Lords -- they're still the court of ultimate appeal for the UK, with the unfettered authority to set binding judicial precedent on a whim.

And here is the nub of my bewilderment. If I've read this aright, you base your personal political opinions on whether or not they align with the US constitution. Which seems a rather unnatural level of reverence for it.

The US Constitution is a remarkably well-written political document. Have you actually read it? It's not long. But more to the point (and even more remarkably), it is a very principled political document; it does a very good job of laying out the principles that form the underpinning of American politics.

The United States is in many ways less pragmatic and more principled than the UK; one of the reasons that Americans seem to want everything laid out in black and white is because they take a much more absolutist view of rights and wrongs. The discussion over the Second Amendment (and gun control) is a good example; there are people on this board who will explain to you how there is something wrong in principle with the government forbidding them the ownership and use of field artillery, on the off chance that they want to go deer hunting and Godzilla shows up. There are others who will insist in principle that allowing a cross to be erected in a public park they've never visited offends them. And there is a third group that will insist that if field artillery is too dangerous to be allowed in private residences, so are realistic-looking water pistols -- because the argument, and the principles behind the argument, are exactly the same.

Yes, they're crazy. So what? At least they don't deep-fry candy bars or insist that just because a window at Oxbridge wasn't fixed in 1530, it should remain paneless forever....

What most Americans support is not the document itself, but the principles behind the document. These are the cherished things like "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness" (which is actually from the Declaration of Independence) or "the four freedoms" (which are actually from a State of the Union speech in the mid-20th century). (I never said that Americans were particularly well-educated, either.)

This is another reason that Americans will often complain about violations of "their Constitutional rights" or "First Amendment rights" even in circumstances where that's a patently ludicrous complaint. "Freedom of speech" is one of the guiding principles and one of the aforementioned "four freedoms," even when it extends beyond the strict legal principles as stated in Amendment I.

Saying something is "unconstitutional" is really shorthand for saying that it violates the principles written into that document. In the case of income tax, one of the fundamental principles is that no one should be deprived of his property unjustly, and so an "illegal" law that forces people to pay taxes is of course unjust. On the other hand, another principle is that the courts and decisions of the courts should be respected.

And one of the most important principles is that you can't be told what to do unless the person doing the telling has specific authorization to do so. (Constitutional scholars refer, for example, to the principle of "enumeration of powers.")

So unless the government has specific authorization to take your money (in the form of an income tax or whatever), it can't do that. A mere pragmatic "need" won't do it; that kind of pragmatic justification has too often been abused (see Bush, House of).

So what you're seeing is not an attachment to the document, but an attachment to the (relatively accessible) principles that underly it. It's not a religious attachment to the document itself, but a belief that the document and founding fathers pretty much got the principles right, and that the principles should not be abandoned for "mere" pragmatism.
 
And here is the nub of my bewilderment. If I've read this aright, you base your personal political opinions on whether or not they align with the US constitution. Which seems a rather unnatural level of reverence for it.

I can't speak for drkitten, but I'll try to speak to this point. What's in the Constitution doesn't affect my opinion of what would be good or bad for the country. But if there is something that I think would be good for the country that is not consistent with the Constitution, the first step is amending the Constitution, not violating or ignoring it.

So, if the 16th amendment were somehow ruled invalid (there is no danger of this happening), the best thing would be to quickly remedy that mistake, rather than to keep enforcing the tax laws as if nothing were wrong. This could involve passing a 28th amendment that does the same thing that the 16th was supposed to. There might be an easier way, though - I think it would still be possible to pass the 16th amendment, even after all these years. The 27th amendment was originally proposed in 1789, and wasn't passed until 1992!

I will also second drkitten's suggestion that you read the US Constitution. It's very very short, and pretty interesting.
 
LOL. 12/4=4?? Derrrr. That just goes to show how damn tired I was last night. I very rarely make mistakes like that, so sorry. As for what people pay on income tax the highest bracket is 35%. You'd have to go to the IRS site to see what the 1040 says, but I know it doesnt go higher than 35. If you make around 20k a year I think its like 15%. The point I was making is that its an average. That 25% number I came up with takes into account all the billionairs and millionairs there are in this country. There are also a lot of right offs you take.
 
warlex, I'll have a lengthier reponse to your post probably after you go to bed, but if you see this, are you planning on voting for Ron Paul.

I am a huge Ron Paul supporter. I think thats pretty obvious. He is a TRUE republican, or what is now known as the libertarian party.
 
I think gets to my point. You are saying that some parts of the constitution (including amendments) are fine, some are not. Some parts of the Bible are fine, some are not. How do you know which ones apply? For example, there are clauses in the constitution that allow for the call-up of troops in the army. Does this not impinge on freedoms? Term limits and age requirements are part and parcel of the description of the role of the presidency. Are these not restrictions? To use a faith as a basis for determination of governmental roles requires that the application be consistent. If you would accept parts of the constitution (and the Bible) as truth, I would assume that there would be a bit more critical thinking involved in determining which other parts hold or not. Sorry to sound harsh, and if you would prefer to wait until tomorrow to respond, that is fine as well.


Knowing which ones apply is a pretty personal decision. I think we all have differeing opinions about things, but most people can agree on the basics, unless you're a dumbass hippie communist. You have a good point about how to decide and what to include and how to base it off faith. But this is where the beauty of democrocy shines. Everyone gets a fair say. Healthy debate is encouraged. Just look at Congress, all they do is argue. If the argument is set up right and done in a manner of friendliness, respect and in an academic setting, much can be learned from one another. People may come up with things you didnt think of. This kind of debate is usually done with the small things though. Like you said, if you want to be president there are restrictions. These rules were debated and went through the ringer. At the end of the day a final rule was set that made sense to the most people. As for basic things like freedom of speech and how a man should be free, I dont think there is much debate because those things are innate in all of us.
 
Like you said, if you want to be president there are restrictions. These rules were debated and went through the ringer. At the end of the day a final rule was set that made sense to the most people.

So you also oppose the 22nd amendment?
 
Two points in response to your longer post.

These rules were debated and went through the ringer. At the end of the day a final rule was set that made sense to the most people.


Would you agree that this also applies to the 16th amendment? If not, why is this one different than the others.

As for basic things like freedom of speech and how a man should be free, I dont think there is much debate because those things are innate in all of us.


The problem with this is, it may seem innate in this day and age, but it didn't always. The majority of the people then saw innate rights quite differently, hence the need for amendments emancipating the slaves, allowing women the vote, and restricting the voting age.

All that being said, what does make an income tax different from other tax systems, or other restrictions on personal liberties supported by the constitution, such as age requirements?
 
I never said I opposed the 22nd ammendment. I'm not sure where you are getting that from.

Maybe I was misunderstanding your point. What was your point when you were talking about the restrictions and rules about being president?
 
I am a huge Ron Paul supporter. I think thats pretty obvious. He is a TRUE republican, or what is now known as the libertarian party.

That tells me volumes.

I'm going to defer to drkittens replies since they largely mirror what mine would have been.

We've been finding concepts in the Constitution not explicitly enumerated or espoused with particular verbiage since Marbury v. Madison... and Madison was a Federalist whose side "won" the fight over framing. The genius of the framers wasn't what they wrote into the Constitution, but that they allowed for amendment when it was warranted - such as slavery - and interpretation when the issue was more elastic and didn't require enumeration.

As far as God goes, I'd point to the preamble - WE the People have ordained and established this Constitution, not God. I can't find a direct link, but if you search the 'Net for Biblical references in the Federalist papers... again, the "winning" side, there aren't any. The Constitution is a Godless document, and it should be in a secular society.

Tax protesters bitch about how high our taxes our and I agree in principle. I would love to have all of my paycheck go into my account, but the fact is that we have needs in 2007 that didn't exist in 1787. The SEC, FAA, NTSB, world-wide military presence, FDA, CIA, etc. etc. There were no hedge funds, airplanes, highways, big pharma, etc. when the Constitution was written. We simply live in a different world than that of Madison, Hamilton and Adams.

I really wish Hal still posted here apart from the periodic JREF or TAM/TAA message because he has a great perspective on how, in the time of the framing, that there was a conflict between those who envisioned a modern, cosmopolitan federal system and those who envisioned a pastoral, parochial anit-federalist system. The federalists won very early in the Republic so I find people like Ron Paul and his supporters to be Ludditeish.

A simple survey of American economic history shows how their position is untennable:
- Number of panics/depressions before the Fed: about 1 every 10 years
- Number of panics/depressions after the Fed: 1
 
Last edited:
I really wish Hal still posted here apart from the periodic JREF or TAM/TAA message because he has a great perspective on how, in the time of the framing, that there was a conflict between those who envisioned a modern, cosmopolitan federal system and those who envisioned a pastoral, parocial anit-federalist system. The federalists won very early in the Republic so I find people like Ron Paul and his supporters to be Ludditish.


Would it be possible to PM Hal for his perspective, or do you know of any old threads that can be linked? I'd be interested to read this.
 
Last edited:
Two points in response to your longer post.




Would you agree that this also applies to the 16th amendment? If not, why is this one different than the others.




The problem with this is, it may seem innate in this day and age, but it didn't always. The majority of the people then saw innate rights quite differently, hence the need for amendments emancipating the slaves, allowing women the vote, and restricting the voting age.

All that being said, what does make an income tax different from other tax systems, or other restrictions on personal liberties supported by the constitution, such as age requirements?


I would agree that applies to the 16th ammendment, but you have to look at the time period the 16th ammendment was made law. The industrial revolution was in full swing and a lot more money was being circulated than say 50 years prior. The panic of 1907 made people very weary and bankers promised that a central bank would mend everyones fears. The theory was that if you had a central bank controlling the money supply they could bail the country out if it needed it. This turned out to be a load of crap, or at least until the late 1930's when the central bank started what we now call deficit spending. That trend has continued since then and right now we are close to 9 trillion dollars in debt. The theory behind deficit spending is that everything will be ok as long as our economy stays strong and the dollar stays strong compared to other currencies. The dollar is doing horrible and the debt is rising faster than it ever has in history. These two things are a combination for disaster. I just finished a great book called Empire of Debt that outlines how America has over extended itself and is looking at a depression 10 times worse than the crash of 1929. It would make the fall of Rome look like 2nd grade bully fight.

So it seems the 16th ammendment was protection for the bankers. Protection for a policy that has gotten way way out of hand. So back in 1913 maybe it seemed like a good idea to implement an income tax and a federal bank. Today however it doesnt look so hot. There needs to some serious rethinking about how our economy runs. Unfortunately it is much more complicated now than it was in 1913 because everything is connected on a global scale.
 
Would it be possible to PM Hal for his perspective, or do you know of any old threads that can be linked? I'd be interested to read this.

You could PM him, but it would probably be faster to e-mail him at his hamiltonlives.com address with a link to this thread. Not to diminish myself, but I only have a BA and made it to Reserve 2LT while he has a PhD and retired an active LTC so he has weight.
 
That tells me volumes.

I'm going to defer to drkittens replies since they largely mirror what mine would have been.

We've been finding concepts in the Constitution not explicitly enumerated or espoused with particular verbiage since Marbury v. Madison... and Madison was a Federalist whose side "won" the fight over framing. The genius of the framers wasn't what they wrote into the Constitution, but that they allowed for amendment when it was warrented - such as slavery - and interpretation when the issue was more elastic and didn't require enumeration.

As far as God goes, I'd point to the preamble - WE the People have ordained and established this Constitution, not God. I can't find a direct link, but if you search the 'Net for Biblical references in the Federalist papers... again, the "winning" side, there aren't any. The Constitution is a Godless document, and it should be in a secular society.

Tax protesters bitch about how high our taxes our and I agree in principle. I would love to have all of my paycheck go into my account, but the fact is that we have needs in 2007 that didn't exist in 1787. The SEC, FAA, NTSB, world-wide militar presence, FDA, CIA, etc. etc. There were no hedge funds, airplanes, highways, big pharma, etc. when the Constitution was written. We simply live in a different world than that of Madison, Hamilton and Adams.

I really wish Hal still posted here apart from the periodic JREF or TAM/TAA message because he has a great perspective on how, in the time of the framing, that there was a conflict between those who envisioned a modern, cosmopolitan federal system and those who envisioned a pastoral, parocial anit-federalist system. The federalists won very early in the Republic so I find people like Ron Paul and his supporters to be Ludditish.

A simple survey of American economic history shows how their position is untennable:
- Number of panics/depressions before the Fed: about 1 every 10 years
- Number of panics/depressions after the Fed: 1

You raise some great points here. You are correct the constitution is a Godless document, but you cant tell me they were not at least somewhat inspired by religious documents such as the Bible. I already made a post about why the founding father's allowed for ammendments to the consitution, so I wont repeat myself.

As far as having so many government agencies some are there for a good reason, some are not. As far as taxes going to pay for these things, every tax but the income tax pays for them. I posted a link to the Grace Commission in the other thread. It shows that almost every dime we give to the government goes to interest on what the government borrows from the fed. Not to roads, education, etc. So the government can pay for everything it needs without an income tax. The government just needs to stop borrowing so much. We are over extending ourselves. These wars we cannot afford are costing us way too much. All for what?? Oil? Give me a break, we can do better than that.

As far as Ron Paul is concerned, he is a diamond in the rough. This country has over extended itself, and its getting out of hand. We cannot go to war illegaly, we dont need so much red tape, we dont need sociolized health care, this big brother crap has to stop. I believe in a Lassie Fair style economy. We are responsible for ourselves. Yes a government is neccessary, but this country has gotten so complacent it just turned into a Frankenstein monster.
 
I would agree that applies to the 16th ammendment, but you have to look at the time period the 16th ammendment was made law. The industrial revolution was in full swing and a lot more money was being circulated than say 50 years prior. The panic of 1907 made people very weary and bankers promised that a central bank would mend everyones fears. The theory was that if you had a central bank controlling the money supply they could bail the country out if it needed it.

The theory involved is far more complex than simply "bailing the country out," as you put it. More appropriately, you might say that the central bank's duty is to adjust various economic factors to help balance out economic cycles.

Bear in mind that the impact of the central bank's monetary policy extends into various economic areas - it can impact the value of credit, inflate or deflate the currency, and encourage or discourage loans.

But the thing is that the impact of the central bank, if you actually examine the historical evidence, has been largely positive. As UnrepentantSinner pointed out, we've had one major depression since the inception of the Fed. We also had a notable panic in 1987 that the Fed prevented from turning into a major economic disaster.

This turned out to be a load of crap, or at least until the late 1930's when the central bank started what we now call deficit spending. That trend has continued since then and right now we are close to 9 trillion dollars in debt.

The central bank is not responsible for deficit spending, the legislative and executive branches of the federal government are.

The theory behind deficit spending is that everything will be ok as long as our economy stays strong and the dollar stays strong compared to other currencies. The dollar is doing horrible and the debt is rising faster than it ever has in history. These two things are a combination for disaster.

You're somewhat conflating two very different things. Deficit spending deals with the balance of the budget for each fiscal year, while the national debt deals with our country's debt to various borrowers.

Deficit spending simply means that we spend more in a given period than we take in. Likewise, when we have a budget surplus, it means we've taken in more than we've spent. This is more an issue of accounting than anything else, as the deficit has to do with the government's ledger. If you wish to reduce a deficit, you will have to either increase taxes, cut costs, borrow money, or print more money.

Don't confuse it with the national debt, however, because the budget issue is a short-term issue, handled from year to year. It can snowball if the deficit spending continues, but it's very different from the issue of the national debt.

When it comes to the national debt, you are considering only one side of it if you look simply at the amount of debt, or the rate of growth.

Another metric to consider is the amount of debt as a percentage of national output, which gives an idea of how much of a burden the debt on our country really is.

The debt burden as a percentage peaked during World War II (it actually exceeded our national output during the war), declined until the 1980's, rose again, then started to decline in the mid 1990's. Right now, it's roughly 60% of our national output (similar to the mid-1950's) - I can try to find the specific figure for 2006 or 2007, as the chart I have referenced in the economics text in front of me ends at '03.

I just finished a great book called Empire of Debt that outlines how America has over extended itself and is looking at a depression 10 times worse than the crash of 1929. It would make the fall of Rome look like 2nd grade bully fight.

That's pretty vague, though. How would the extended debt lead to a massive depression? Why would it be "10 times worse" than the Great Depression? What would cause such a depression to initiate? How does that compare to the fall of Rome?

So it seems the 16th ammendment was protection for the bankers.

How? The 16th amendment has nothing to do with banks, or bankers, or banking. It may affect the decisions made by the banks, but it's more about providing the government with a source of money to do the stuff that the people it represents have all come to expect it to do.

You'll need to be a lot more specific when discussing these issues than using a generic phrase like "bankers." What, precisely, do you mean when you use that term? The central bank employees? The owners of the major banks (who, by the way, are stockholders, not just one person)? The bank presidents? The people actually titled "banker" that are salaried employees responsible for managing the bank system?

Protection for a policy that has gotten way way out of hand. So back in 1913 maybe it seemed like a good idea to implement an income tax and a federal bank. Today however it doesnt look so hot.

The thing is, these are two completely separate issues that you seem intent on smashing together. It is perfectly possible to have an income tax with no central bank, or to have a central bank with no taxes. The tax issue is one of providing funding for government services, while the central bank is supposed to deal with monetary stabilization.

I see your comment there about paying the Fed back with all tax revenue. First off, do you have a source to back that comment up?

Secondly, even assuming it's true, it doesn't make a difference. If you want to balance the budget, you still have to take debt servicing into account along with expenses. The end result is that you do need a supply of funding to keep everything running, and without some form of revenue (taxes), it will eventually grind the government to a halt.

I get that you're not a big fan of government programs, but please at least try to understand that you will need to cut a lot of what we currently get from the government in order to remove income taxes. Whether or not this is actually worth it is open to debate.

You also should consider that the States have their own budgets, and can impose their own taxes. Some don't have income tax (TN and NH, for example), and make up that income in other ways. Whether or not such a model can be applied to the bigger scale of the federal government is, again, open to debate.

There needs to some serious rethinking about how our economy runs. Unfortunately it is much more complicated now than it was in 1913 because everything is connected on a global scale.

It certainly is.

Please don't claim that the wars we're currently fighting are simply "for oil." That is immensely simplistic. I agree that the wars are costly, and I think it's high time we started pulling out of Iraq - but that doesn't reduce the situation to something so simple as oil.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom