[Ed.] U.S. Constitutional Amendments and Faith

Nah, my axe and stack aren't nearly as impressive (although I do have a '69 Strat lurking in the music room).
Give me a few weeks to get everything set up... we just bought the house, and I just got the room painted!
Yeah, that would be fairly noticeable! Since I have my own company, our tax situation is a bit more complicated in terms of figuring out a flat percentage.

We're pretty simple, just add our income up, add our total taxes up, and plug them into the tax forms. I know we got hit pretty hard last year, because we were renting, and this year we'll get a cut because we're home owners, but at no point did we pay $30,000 in income tax. People who make that "four months of income to pay our taxes" just seem sort of stupid to me... can they not read their own income tax returns?
 
In my opinion, the amendments that are "valid" are those amendments that were passed according to the procedure for amending the constitution laid out in the constitution itself. If the authors of the constitution hadn't wanted it to be amended they wouldn't have included a procedure for doing so.
 
In my opinion, the amendments that are "valid" are those amendments that were passed according to the procedure for amending the constitution laid out in the constitution itself.
Yeah, well I bet your opinion would be different if you didn't insist on grounding it in logic.
 
As an outsider, I’m confused as to how the ‘intentions’ of those drafting a piece of legislation over two centuries old, or indeed the contents of that legislation, still arouses debate of this sort.

As far as I can see, it’s the equivalent of people in the UK having heated arguments over the Reform Act or the repeal of the Corn Laws – both very important things in the way they shaped our society, neither now considered in anything other than a historical context.

Yet to suggest that the US constitution is anything other than a timeless piece of universally applicable political writing – and certainly to go further and suggest that it probably can’t contribute much to modern political discourse – seems to be heresy in some circles.
 
As an outsider, I’m confused as to how the ‘intentions’ of those drafting a piece of legislation over two centuries old, or indeed the contents of that legislation, still arouses debate of this sort.

As far as I can see, it’s the equivalent of people in the UK having heated arguments over the Reform Act or the repeal of the Corn Laws – both very important things in the way they shaped our society, neither now considered in anything other than a historical context.

Yet to suggest that the US constitution is anything other than a timeless piece of universally applicable political writing – and certainly to go further and suggest that it probably can’t contribute much to modern political discourse – seems to be heresy in some circles.

Not so much heresy, but just factually incorrect. The US Constitution remains the supreme law of the land. There is plenty of debate on whether and how it should be changed to reflect changes in society since 1789, and that's a good thing. And it has been changed - 27 times, each time according to the rules set forth in the Constitution itself. There is no UK equivalent because the UK does not have a single written constitution. But the Constitution is not a "piece of legislation" - it's the founding document of our nation.

Getting to the OP and Warlex's argument... I've heard plenty of arguments about why the 16th amendment is invalid, most of them relating to irregularities in the ratification process. I've never before heard that it should be invalid merely because it is an amendment. The founders, in their wisdom, put Article V in our Constitution for a reason, and for someone to say that a given amendment is invalid because it wasn't in the original Constitution completely ignores the fact that Article V was in the original Constitution. And of course, it forces them to twist and bend in order to defend the 13th amendment, and so on.

You might well argue that the 16th amendment is "bad." You might argue that it never could have been put in the original Constitution. Another person might argue that the 13th or 19th amendment is bad. Another might argue that the 2nd is bad. Obviously, none of them would have gone into the original Constitution (the proof of that is that none of them did). But amendments become part of the Constitution, they become part of the supreme law of the land, and whether you think they are "bad" or not doesn't matter.

Warlex, you should look up some of the historical research that suggests that the 16th amendment was not properly ratified. It's not a winning argument, but it's a heck of a lot better than the argument you're trying to make.
 
Not so much heresy, but just factually incorrect. The US Constitution remains the supreme law of the land...And it has been changed - 27 times, each time according to the rules set forth in the Constitution itself. There is no UK equivalent because the UK does not have a single written constitution. But the Constitution is not a "piece of legislation" - it's the founding document of our nation.

A view which, I'm arguing, is flawed in exactly the way that creates dilemmas like the OPs and seems to make them more difficult to argue against than they should be.

Regardless of what the US constitution was intended to say or actually says, political discourse has reached the point where it's unacceptable, morally and ethically speaking, for a nation not to build an infrastructure for its citizens that is in part funded by means-based contributions from those citizens.

In other, paraphrased words, if income tax did not exist it would be necessary to invent it. What difference would it actually make if the whole thing was discovered to be some sort of spelling error?
 
A view which, I'm arguing, is flawed in exactly the way that creates dilemmas like the OPs and seems to make them more difficult to argue against than they should be.

Regardless of what the US constitution was intended to say or actually says, political discourse has reached the point where it's unacceptable, morally and ethically speaking, for a nation not to build an infrastructure for its citizens that is in part funded by means-based contributions from those citizens.

In other, paraphrased words, if income tax did not exist it would be necessary to invent it. What difference would it actually make if the whole thing was discovered to be some sort of spelling error?

I agree with what you're saying in principle, but the problem with having a written Constitution is that we don't get to do what's "necessary" if it violates the Constitution, unless we amend the Constitution so that it no longer violates it. Or - and this is a little more controversial - unless the Supreme Court interprets the Constitution in such a way that it no longer violates it. Unfortunately, the original Constitution explicitly prohibited an income tax like we have now, so without the 16th amendment, as necessary as those means-based contributions might be (and I agree with you that they are necessary), the government just couldn't do it. The government could, I believe, tax the states, forcing the states to tax their citizens, but a direct tax would have been unconstitutional.

Actually, I think you'd be surprised at the many many things that the US government simply cannot do because of the Constitution. Fortunately, the states have a great deal of power that the US government does not, so between them, things get managed.
 
A curious example from Australia - the federal government is prohibited from making any laws regarding religion.

The states, on the other hand...
 
People who make that "four months of income to pay our taxes" just seem sort of stupid to me... can they not read their own income tax returns?

Generally when I've read that "x months to pay our taxes" it's talking about all the taxes we pay- not just income tax. Even ignoring state taxes (income, sales, etc) and local taxes (property tax, sales tax, gas tax, etc) you pay a lot of taxes to the federal government besides income tax.

For most people the income tax they pay is less than 50% of the total taxes they pay.
 
Unfortunately, the original Constitution explicitly prohibited an income tax like we have now

Could you possible quote the part of the Constitution that actually prohibits it?

If I remember correctly, nothing in the Constitution prohibited an income tax- it only required that "direct Taxes shall be apportioned" to the states. Because of that an income tax was never enacted before the 16th amendment.
 
Generally when I've read that "x months to pay our taxes" it's talking about all the taxes we pay- not just income tax. Even ignoring state taxes (income, sales, etc) and local taxes (property tax, sales tax, gas tax, etc) you pay a lot of taxes to the federal government besides income tax.

For most people the income tax they pay is less than 50% of the total taxes they pay.

So, what those people are basically doing is LYING THROUGH THEIR STINKING TEETH. I knew that.
 
Keep in mind corporations also pay big income taxes on their profits. Although the corporation pays it, keep in mind the effort to generate that money is still distributed across the population of workers as a whole. It's your effort that generates it physically.

In that sense, it's quite reasonable to divide the total tax burden by the number of taxpayers when calculating things like how many days the average person has to work.
 
Keep in mind corporations also pay big income taxes on their profits. Although the corporation pays it, keep in mind the effort to generate that money is still distributed across the population of workers as a whole. It's your effort that generates it physically.

In that sense, it's quite reasonable to divide the total tax burden by the number of taxpayers when calculating things like how many days the average person has to work.

You mean in the sense that it is a lie, designed to give people the false notion that they are somehow saddled with an unfair tax "burden"?
 
A view which, I'm arguing, is flawed in exactly the way that creates dilemmas like the OPs and seems to make them more difficult to argue against than they should be.

Regardless of what the US constitution was intended to say or actually says, political discourse has reached the point where it's unacceptable, morally and ethically speaking, for a nation not to build an infrastructure for its citizens that is in part funded by means-based contributions from those citizens.

I think you misunderstand the issue.

The reason that the intentions of the Founding Fathers' are still relevant is because the words they wrote are still legally binding. With the exception of the handful of amendments (and when you consider the number of times a typical state constitution has been amended, it is truly a handful), the Constitution as originally written is not only still on the books, but still trumps anything written more recently.

So what was the Constitution "as originally written"? What did it mean? Since language changes, it's not enough to simply say "this is what the word means now"; one needs to figure out what the words and intentions were there so that the principles (which are also still binding) can still be carried out.

A simple example. Is the United States Air Force legal? Article I provides Congress with authority "provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States" and specifically "To raise and support Armies" and "To provide and maintain a Navy," but not for an Air Force. Amendment X specifically states that "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution [...]are reserved to the States." A strict reading of the letter of the law suggests therefore that the United States does not have the authority to maintain an Air Force, but the individual states do.

But this is obviously silly. The framers clearly intended national defence, by whatever means, to be a Federal concern. The fact that they didn't anticipate flying machines, satellites, and eventually psychic time-travelling bears with laser beams coming out of their eyes doesn't mean that they thought that Massachusetts should be responsible for supplying the psychic laser-wielding bears to be shipped across the world on Navy transports. The intent controls, not the exact wording.

But similarly, what is an "Army"? Could the Air Force be part of the Army? (Of course; in fact, it was for a long time.) But if that's the case, couldn't we put all government employees in green -- the Air Force, the FBI, the IRS, the Transportation Department -- and then they can do anything they like? Instead of having to justify government actions via the commerce clause, we'll just make everything an Army reg subject to the dictatorial authority of the President.

Again,... no. The founders knew what an "Army" meant and it didn't include the Department of Agriculture. Again, the intent controls.
 
Keep in mind corporations also pay big income taxes on their profits. Although the corporation pays it, keep in mind the effort to generate that money is still distributed across the population of workers as a whole. It's your effort that generates it physically.

In that sense, it's quite reasonable to divide the total tax burden by the number of taxpayers when calculating things like how many days the average person has to work.

Except that the large corporations that pay the bulk of taxes make much of their profit multinationally. The shoes Nike sells in the United States include the labor of a number of workers in lower Elbonistan. If you're going to make that argument, you need to include the Elbonistani workers in the denominator when you calculate how much taxes they pay. After all, the Elbonistani needs to make more shoes to cover the taxes Nike pays in the States.
 
Again, the intent controls.

OK, I understand that the constitution is so important in terms of the process of making US law as things stand. I'd argue that this points up some of the limitations in prioritising a single document as the core principle of your legislature, but then again not having one at all has caused us lot a few problems so I can see both sides.

What I don't understand is why it's so important in general political debate. The OP seems to be imply that proving the invalidity of amendment 16 goes some way towards proving that Income Tax is bad and wrong.

I would, to the contrary, submit that if you do successfully argue that this then that shows one of the many ways in which said constitution as it exists is deficient in terms of shaping a modern state. It just means you would need a properly ratified 28th amendment that made income tax do what it is clearly supposed to do.
 
Could you possible quote the part of the Constitution that actually prohibits it?

If I remember correctly, nothing in the Constitution prohibited an income tax- it only required that "direct Taxes shall be apportioned" to the states. Because of that an income tax was never enacted before the 16th amendment.

Er, you may be right and I may be wrong. I thought it prohibited income taxes, but maybe it just prohibited income taxes like the one we have now...

Good catch.
 
OK, I understand that the constitution is so important in terms of the process of making US law as things stand. I'd argue that this points up some of the limitations in prioritising a single document as the core principle of your legislature, but then again not having one at all has caused us lot a few problems so I can see both sides.

The main reason for a single core document is as a roadblock. The US Constitution was deliberately set up with the ideal of "as small a government as practical, as large a government as necessary" -- with the excesses of 17th century absolutism as a cautionary tale.

The main weakness of the British Constitution is that there is nothing, even in theory, to stop a sufficiently determined despot (read: King) to have his own way, regardless of what the laws say. He can pack the House of Lords with his toadies, dissolve Parliament and rule by decree, and completely abrogate the common law. Not only can he do that, he has; see Stuart, House of -- and for that matter, Hanover, House of.

In the US, it would require cooperation on the part of about 500 people to have the same effect; while that still is a relatively tiny group, it's not within the hands of a single tyrant.

The problem with the tax protestors and such is that this small number is equally deliberate; the founders were as afraid of pure democracy ("mob rule") as of tyranny, so they set up what they hoped would be a meritocratic oligarchy. If the 500 most sensible people in the country agree that something should be done, then the lunkheads on their farms (or in their trailer parks) don't really get a look-see.

On the question of income tax -- the 500 people spoke and said that income tax should be allowed. Later (this question has come up judicially), a different generation of 500 people said that the first 500 people had been acting in accordance with the law. Now, I would certainly believe that if the income tax amendment had been procedurally irregular (or illegally passed), then it shouldn't be part of the Constitution and shouldn't be enforceable; to that extent, I agree with the tax protestors. However, I don't think it was irregular -- and the courts agree with me, not with them.

But that's not a flaw in the Constitution or the political system, any more than running a red light indicates a problem with the car.

The political question is whether or not the government needs to be able to tax incomes. Obviously, if one is happy with the status quo, then it does. There are a lot of people who feel either that the government gets too much money (and should scale back its operations --- do we really need federal oversight of the number of rat hairs permitted in a hot dog? Does the federal government really need to pay for paving roads in West Virginia?), or that the government can more fairly get the same amount of money via other means (such as a VAT or user service fees).

I think that the income tax is one of the fairer methods of spreading out the costs of government, but I don't think the answer is as clear-cut as you would like to make it.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom