OK, I understand that the constitution is so important in terms of the process of making US law as things stand. I'd argue that this points up some of the limitations in prioritising a single document as the core principle of your legislature, but then again not having one at all has caused us lot a few problems so I can see both sides.
The main reason for a single core document is as a roadblock. The US Constitution was deliberately set up with the ideal of "as small a government as practical, as large a government as necessary" -- with the excesses of 17th century absolutism as a cautionary tale.
The main weakness of the British Constitution is that there is nothing, even in theory, to stop a sufficiently determined despot (read: King) to have his own way, regardless of what the laws say. He can pack the House of Lords with his toadies, dissolve Parliament and rule by decree, and completely abrogate the common law. Not only
can he do that, he
has; see Stuart, House of -- and for that matter, Hanover, House of.
In the US, it would require cooperation on the part of about 500 people to have the same effect; while that still is a relatively tiny group, it's
not within the hands of a single tyrant.
The problem with the tax protestors and such is that this small number is
equally deliberate; the founders were as afraid of pure democracy ("mob rule") as of tyranny, so they set up what they hoped would be a meritocratic oligarchy. If the 500 most sensible people in the country agree that something should be done, then the lunkheads on their farms (or in their trailer parks) don't really get a look-see.
On the question of income tax -- the 500 people spoke and said that income tax should be allowed. Later (this question has come up judicially), a different generation of 500 people said that the first 500 people
had been acting in accordance with the law. Now, I would certainly believe that
if the income tax amendment had been procedurally irregular (or illegally passed), then it shouldn't be part of the Constitution and shouldn't be enforceable; to that extent, I agree with the tax protestors. However, I don't think it was irregular -- and the courts agree with me, not with them.
But that's not a flaw in the Constitution or the political system, any more than running a red light indicates a problem with the car.
The political question is whether or not the government needs to be able to tax incomes. Obviously, if one is happy with the status quo, then it does. There are a lot of people who feel either that the government gets too much money (and should scale back its operations --- do we really need
federal oversight of the number of rat hairs permitted in a hot dog? Does the
federal government really need to pay for paving roads in West Virginia?), or that the government can more fairly get the same amount of money via other means (such as a VAT or user service fees).
I think that the income tax is one of the fairer methods of spreading out the costs of government, but I don't think the answer is as clear-cut as you would like to make it.