Ear candling

Dig them out because You evidently have lost track of the principles or you are ignorant ( which I proclaimed in my post ) of the science behind the reality.

How so? You still haven't explained how fluid mechanics will permit this wax to be moved? I see what you mean about rocket engines now, I assumed you were referring to the fluid mechanics of how they provide propulsion. Of course I should have re-read your paragraph a few times.

It doesn't change the fact you haven't given a description of physics that will lead to wax being removed from the ear wall or lifted. You are right about warm air (convection) lifting light objects, the burning of one of those candles is bound to generate a small air velocity at the base of the tube, and thus a feeling of air moving around.

I think we've been refering to venturi at two different places ... are you trying to describe the mechanism that would allow the material to be deposited inside the candle during the operation of this thing? I wouldn't argue that this could happen in that way, it isn't contentious. What is disputed is whether and how wax can be lifted from the wall of ear by this device, that is where I was saying venturi doesn't really apply unless you can explain how it does. If it (the wax) were particulate or liquid (subject to fluid behaviour) and entrained in a stream of air then getting it out of that air using a ventura would be perfectly plausible.

My textbooks (if I could even find them) would explain to me how to calculate the sufficent air velocities required for carrying/depositing material in tubes of the diameter we are talking about. As fluid mechanics equations are murderously complex and incomprehensible to most people it probably wouldn't prove much. I think analogies work better as we can all visualise them.

But as (I think) you were describing how the wax might get on the inside of the candle and I was questioning how the principle would allow the wax to get into the air flow in the first place I think we have crossed wires.

Well by golly a critique without background , evidence or demonstrable falsehoods of the study in question.......... Ya That skeptical

OK, mea culpa, you've talked me into buying some to prove they don't work. I still don't know where to get them from, but I reckon they're cheap. Can you explain which ones you think work? do I need to get ones with beeswax or paraffin anything? I'd hate to prove my point only to be told I had not gone to the right woo-woo stockist. Is this something that will not work if I use it in a skeptical frame of mind? I normally avoid things that I know cannot work, but I'm curious.
 
And those grain hoppers look interesting, JS . Are you involved in the design of them? As I said, the farms I've seen only had archimedes screws.

Oh, and I'm not related to Arctic Penguin ... I think his was an Adelie or a Gentoo avatar, mine's a Macaroni.
 
Curtc good reads. I must confess that I couldn't prove the residue was ear wax.. maybe I should take a more critical look at the by product./ It LOOKED like earwax and had the consistency, but I guess that would follow, if it was candle residue it IS wax hehe. I did the out of ear tests and couldn't get the same result ..I didn't burn the whole thing , perhaps that was an error. Maybe the heat from the candle mearly melts the larger clumps and just redistributes the wax in the ear. I will test them further the wife brings any more home. In the mean time I guess I'll just have to abide by the consensus, besides as someone else said this is really yucky.
 
TE,

You've complained that Benguin hasn't tried to test this themselves... I say, how accurately did you test this yourself? You did say you tried burning one yourself, but how closely did you reproduce "ear-like" conditions? Other people's tests do seem to produce results that are identical to using them in an ear. It's like a psychic testing: you've done a test and found something. Perhaps it's your experimental design.

In fact it's been tested often enough that they are illegal to sell in Canada. There are no known benefits (aside from the dubious pleasure of sticking a flaming object in your head) and there are definite risks involved. They're not even allowed to be sold as a non-health product.
 
I was going to try and design a test (other than sticking it in my ear). How does this sound?

1. Take a small quantity of butter (because it is hard fat, similar too wax and melts at a lower temperature. At room temperature it should be softer than ear wax.

2. Coat the inside of a thimble with it thickly, leaving a hole similar in diameter to an ear hole. (Might be easier to fill it and drill it!)

3. Weigh the thimble with an accurate scales, and photograph it with a macro lens.

4. Clamp it in position to simulate an ear on a tilted head.

5. "Ear candle" the thing.

Assuming the candling is a success (eg, we see a brown sludge in it, and the thimble stops complaining of hearing loss) We have three tests now;

6. Weigh the thimble to see if their is any change in mass

7. Take another photograph and compare the two.

8. Warm the remains of the candle to 50 degrees C and see if the residue runs away (butter melts at about 32 degrees, beeswax at 64 degrees).

What does anyone reckon?
 
Folly it's not like Psychic testing at all, we have a methodology to check whether it works not some .." well it didn't work because you don't believe" BS. I thought I made it clear that I was standing down and that what I observed was close to my understanding of the advertisement, I saw what was stated and the claim I heard was relatively benign. As I have stated before I had no idea of all the clap trap that was associated with this "device" had I , I would have held it up to greater scrutiny.

edit: Well did a lot more googling and it appearers that the whole thing is hokum, evidently the device used is , "Pay no attention to the man behind the curtain" That the "residue" is probably attributable to the candle itself..I guess the evidence is all anecdotal and the effect if any is feeling on the part of the subject is attributable to action and the warmth of the candle and nothing more.
 
TillEulenspiegel said:
Folly it's not like Psychic testing at all, we have a methodology to check whether it works not some .." well it didn't work because you don't believe" BS. I thought I made it clear that I was standing down and that what I observed was close to my understanding of the advertisement, I saw what was stated and the claim I heard was relatively benign. As I have stated before I had no idea of all the clap trap that was associated with this "device" had I , I would have held it up to greater scrutiny.

My aplogies. I didn't read your last message carefully enough and saw I-know-what-I-saw-but-I'll-let-it-go-for-now, instead of what you actually wrote. My bad.
 
Yes I could see where TE was coming from .... the claim that it can help clear the wax out of your ear is reasonable one, and all I was really talking about.

I'd actually forgotten about all that other woo-woo rubbish about lymph systems and demons and what have you.
 
Benguin said:
I was going to try and design a test (other than sticking it in my ear). How does this sound?

1. Take a small quantity of butter (because it is hard fat, similar too wax and melts at a lower temperature. At room temperature it should be softer than ear wax.

To be more accurate, I suggest you spend some time collecting ear wax (your own, or others' if you aren't squeamish). That way, no one can claim the results were due to the difference between butter and ear wax. :D
 
I guess it was too much to hope no-one would come up with that.

It isn't as if I can present any other defence of substituting butter than 'ick'!
 
This is a definite case of risk (doing candling) outweighing any imagined benefit.

To clean your ears, just swab the entrance of the ear of any wax. Earwax is what cleans the area. If you start sticking things right in, then you wreck the work the wax is doing and open yourself up to infections.

My allergies to cats causes the inside of my ears to itch, all the way to the freaking ear drum. So I have stuck a cotton swab in pretty far. Unless you pierce your eardrum and really ram the thing up, then your hearing and your brain will be okay in spite of your digging.m:D :D

Candling is worse than doing nothing.

From the Cecil article on the straight dope link: As an otolaryngologist with 15 years' experience, I have had more than one occasion on which a victim of ear candling has presented to my office with excruciating symptoms caused by melted wax adhering to the eardrum. This often necessitates minor surgery and puts the patient's hearing at risk. In addition to debunking the efficacy of ear candling, you should mention the inherent danger to hearing. --C. Christopher Smith, MD, FACS, Dover, New Hampshire

You can burn yourself externally (hair, etc.). You can burn the inside of the ear, well the passageway to the internal ear, and you can even lose your hearing. You may even cause an infection to your ear.

The ear is no place to clean out lymph nodes or whatever, and no toxin is going to be drawn out past your eardrum or your inner ear, etc. Heck, what toxins are they referring to anyway? Should one stick a candle in their belly button in order to draw toxins the liver was working on?

Sheesh.

Ridiculous.
 
Go back through the thread and read the butt-candling bit!
 
Actually, one of the large Danich daily newpapers (Politiken) runs a story on ear candling to-day, on the backside, which is traditionally the place for humor. Apparantly the stuff can be bought in Denmark, too :rolleyes:.

Either this is a strange coincidence, or some of the people at Politiken read this BB..... Hellooo, Gorm??

Hans
 
I tried this once. It started a fire in my brain that still hasn't been put out, like those coal fires in china. No, really.
 
Originally posted by scribble
I tried this once. It started a fire in my brain that still hasn't been put out, like those coal fires in china. No, really.
In that case, look out for brain farts. That could really mess up your day :)
 
Benguin, the specific separator on the cover of that book was not one used in an agricultural setting, but one used to move powdered chemical products around in a chemical plant. I'm not involved at all in the design of them, but worked in the office with the designer and the engineer for it. When I was looking for a neat project for 3D modelling, that's what turned up for me to model. :)
 
An x-girlfriend performed this on me..and although releaxing, it was hardly a 'spiritual emema' as claimed my X- and is was so clear the 'wax' in the cut open candles were from the candles, nd not my ear....

My not beleiving in ear candling and that quack science 'Reiki 'is one reason we went splitsville
 
My mother, god bless her, talked her boyfriend into doing this. He punctured his ear drum in the process and spent 2 or 3 years with a loss of hearing and eventually had a surgery to repair it? Don't ask me how or what happened, all I know is he's a saint.
It's only funny because I distinctly recall my mother telling me not to put anything in my ear.
 
For goodness' sake. This is a doddle to prove/disprove. You need 4 things.

1. Person with a decent earwax buildup, preferably one you could grow a crop of spuds in.
2. Ear candles.
3. Tame GP.
4. Thing GP uses to look in people's ears.

Check the ear prior to candling, do the woo thing and then recheck the ear. Simple.

Or you could just buy ear drops. IIRC, some brands use camphor and peanut oil, others use a solution of hydrogen peroxide to dissolve the stubborn wax.

Q-tips/cotton buds shouldn't be poked into the ear canal; I try and use them at an oblique enough angle that it doesn't push the wax in, but picks up enough that I can avoid syringing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom