Ear candling

Benguin

Too Chilled For The Anti-Homeopathy Illuminati
Joined
Apr 23, 2004
Messages
1,897
I know you guys have probably discussed this one to death before, but I couldn't find anything when I searched the forum so forgive me!

A friend of mine was going on about ear-candling the other day ... he was (naturally) most offended at my skepticism. As far as I know they take a waxy piece of paper, curl it unto a funnel and insert one end in the earhole, then light the other end.

After a few seconds they blow out the flame, unfurl the paper and observe with wonderment and awe the brown sludge contained therein.

I told him the brown sludge was the wax from the paper, nicely burned.

Of course he was adamant, but I did feel I shortchanged him as I wasn't sure how to simulate the effect.

Anyone any experience with it? I don't even know where to get an ear candle from.
 
Search the comentries for ideas on how to simulate the effect.
 
Thanks Lothian, I like that. I can see him spending a fortune on candles ... but then maybe he'll learn his lesson, yes, I like it more.

I don't feel I really want to see what Psiload's link is showing. Oh dear, I succumbed to temptation.
 
Or just burn the candle w/o sticking it in the ear. You'll see the same result.
 
Lothian said:
You could suggest to your friend that there are some real and some fake candles out there. The way to tell if you have a real one is to wax your ear twice. Naturally if it works the second candle should be clean.
The other thing I've heard is that if you just "candle" a clean glass, you get exactly the same sludge.

Rolfe.
 
Why the H#LL does crap like this continue. in the US we have Q-tips. they can clean out both ears in 10 seconds. no chance of catching your hair on fire and cost $.001 apiece.


Virgil
 
Yes, well he told me he'd tried just burning one on its own and seen no sludge ... I wondered if you have limit the airflow at the unlit end (with a thimble or something) to simulate an eardrum.

As I don't have access to any to try it on I wanted to check here. I don't supposed they'd be hard to make, though.
 
I wonder about the first person who decided to stick a candle in his/her ear. What kind of drugs was that person on to think about doing that?!?
 
Eeek, great minds think alike!

Two cats ... one flightless bird ... I think I'll go for a swim.

Why the H#LL does crap like this continue. in the US we have Q-tips

Is that what we call a "cotton-bud"? plastic stick with a some cotton wool on each end? Apparently they can cause infections. Sticking your head on one side under the shower is even cheaper though.

I seem to recall (and I'm sure it's in the commentaries) that the ear candling crowd come out with all sorts of woo-woo claims that what they are doing isn't just flushing excess wax out. Even though they aren't even achieving that!
 
Benguin said:




Is that what we call a "cotton-bud"? plastic stick with a some cotton wool on each end? Apparently they can cause infections. Sticking your head on one side under the shower is even cheaper though.

I seem to recall (and I'm sure it's in the commentaries) that the ear candling crowd come out with all sorts of woo-woo claims that what they are doing isn't just flushing excess wax out. Even though they aren't even achieving that!

yes I believe a cotton bud is a Q-tip. I've used them for 20 years (not the same one of course) and I've never had an ear infection.

yes all the impurities, and only the impurities none of the good stuff... and don't forget the international conspiracy of cotton bud makers.

I''ve only embraced skeptism for ca. 1 year and I'm already tired, cranky, and worn out with the same drivel on and on from these people.

This "alternative" anything is just a cult, they believe and nothing is going to change their little minds.

If I were a psychologist I would just like to study these people and compare them with Jim Jones, David Koresh type cultists.



Virgil
 
Benguin said:
Yes, well he told me he'd tried just burning one on its own and seen no sludge ... I wondered if you have limit the airflow at the unlit end (with a thimble or something) to simulate an eardrum.

Yes, that's what you need to do. Otherwise it just burns away and you're left feeling foolish. You could stick your thumb over the end, or bung the end in a glass of water, to show how much nasty wax there is in there.

(the non-burning end, obviously ;) )
 
Cotton buds (Q-tips) are fine, but how do you get the cardboard axle thingy to stay alight once the cotton wool has burned away?? :confused:
P
 
One JREF poster, Kittynh, used a stuffed animal to demonstrate the candling was fake. She followed the directions, just as you would on a person, and I guess the plushie had a lot of accumulated wax and crud in his ear, as there was quite the pile at the end of the cleaning.
 
Peter Jenkins said:
Cotton buds (Q-tips) are fine, but how do you get the cardboard axle thingy to stay alight once the cotton wool has burned away?? :confused:
P




No I was suggesting to use a Q-tip instead of candleing. because I have accedotal evidence that Q tips work I am willing to submit myself to testing on this matter.

Virgil
 
Virgil said:





No I was suggesting to use a Q-tip instead of candleing. because I have accedotal evidence that Q tips work I am willing to submit myself to testing on this matter.

Virgil

I'm always a little wary about sticking Q-tips in my ear. I'm deathly afraid I'm accidentally going to dig out my brain and lose it and have to search around on the ground until I find it.
 
The NPR "radio doctor" Dr. Zorba, got a call a few months ago regarding this practice. He'd never heard of it, and thought that the idea was hilarious.
Kind of reminds me of the old Bob Newhart bit about Sir Walter Raliegh.
"Wait, you take this burning cylinder of tobacco....Let me guess, You stick it in your ear?"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom