Ear candling

We need Kittynh with her Alf doll. He had a lot of ear wax too, but Kitty just cleaned it right out thanks to that candle. You could even see the icky residue.

And unlike Q-tips, I'm sure Alf didn't have to go searching for his brain after accidentally digging it out. *sighs*
 
It's very important that the waxed paper contains BEESWAX because beeswax is natural--ordinary paraffin is not; it was invented by Noah during his Hangover. There was a column about this in The Straight Dope a year or so ago. I think they reported on an analysis of the gunk.
 
I know nothing about the science behind this, but I do know a girl at work suggested I do this to relieve myself of a constant pressure I feel in my ears. She even forced newspapers on me so I could try it. Needless to say the newspapers got tossed in the trash without being burned. It just sounded silly and unreasonable. Glad to hear I was right in my snap judgement.
 
Originally posted by TillEulenspiegel
edit to add:
I have burned the cones vertically with both a blocked opening ( as one would see in a human ear and an open orifice, there was no wax production. Also the remains of wax at the bottom of a cone used in a human ear was red-dark brown not color neutral ( altho some might consider the addition of ash or another compound to be the culprit. I have also used an otoscope and found that wax deposits had either diminished or disappeared. I had this tool because my daughter had otitus and I monitored her condition because the infection can spread to the jaw ( which it already had).
The goop you get inside the candle is probably just the smoke from the burning paper swirling around in your ear and depositing soot on the end of the funnel.

A little experiment just for fun: roll up a square piece of paper into a narrow tube about an inch or two long and less than a quarter of an inch thick, hold it slanted and light the highest tip. You will see thick, white smoke pooring out the lower end. You can even catch this smoke by holding your little burning funnel over a small cup.

Now observe this interesting phenomenon and tell me you're still convinced ear candles are more than make belief quackery (like that electrolysis foot bath) that appear to work because people are led to believe "toxins" are drawn out of the body in the process.
 
Ear wax has a function to protect the ear I think and sticking things into the ear can well cause an irritation that leads to an increased production of wax. The suitable treatment to get rid of wax if it is a problem in the way that the wax will diminish your hearing is to rinse with lukewarm water. You can get a small bladder and fill it with water to do this. If water wont do the trick there are solutions that can help dissolve the wax.
 
Since much of the earwax becomes deposited at the opening to the ear, sticking ANYTHING in the ear, alight or not, will usually force a bigger opening in the wax so that it looks "cleaned out".

Anyway, this subject is just so ICKY!
 
:eek: I just can't believe this topic. I carefully read the title several times and thought: Wtf?? Having read the entire thread (several wtfs later), I can only say: Surely this is something they do in the US, right? Can't wait to use it on Shemp, the next time he raves about how depraved Danes are: "And this comes from the land of ear candling :roll: ?"

Hans
 
I had no idea that this subject had so much bull poop associated with it until I read Lisa's link. The only thing I said was that seemed to work as far as pulling wax out of the ear canal. The rest of this crap is obviously....well crap.
 
OK well you guys are forcing me to defend a process that I have relatively little grasp of .........

May I respectfully suggest it would be easier to do some web searching and find a scientific explanation from a qualified source?

The mechanism that seems to be the dominant factor seems to be the same science that governs jet engines and ventures in everything from grain hoppers to automobile carburetors and rocket engines.

The physics is quite different between these things, carburettors make use of the bernouilli effect to 'atomise' a liquid into a stream of fast moving gas. Wax is not liquified, if it was you'd scald your ear badly.

Rocket engines are not relevant, I think you mean turbines (search for 'whittle' on google). There is an analogy here ... the suction created by the candle at the base is due to the air being drawn through to supply oxygen to the flame. It's a massive oversimplification, but scale that up and we see jet turbines. Trouble is, the air velocity needed to dislodge and actually lift some wax would be very high, even in a confined aperture. Please don't make me dig out my fluid mechanics texts from my uni days! I'd rather soak them in wax and burn them!

Grain hoppers I've seen use an archimedes screw to move the grain about. I'm not suggesting you are wrong, as it is very possible you've seen different ones.

In all of these applications you employ a pressure differential between two zones .

Create and utilise one, yes.

A venturi that accepts a volume of space forces it to compression and accelerates it, relative to the supply side by use of a shaped exit venturi. ( Ever use a can of paint or some other substance and it gets cold? ) I'm fairly sure that the updraft is produced by the temperature differential and the conical shape of the "candle"..

This is mixing two different concepts, convection and venturi. The burning is pulling the air through, if you obstruct a part of that air flow you create a low pressure area. In the demonstrations of the venturi effect one sticks a pitot tube in their supplying a liquid, the low pressure draws the liquid from the tube and entrains into a fluid flow. What you are looking for is turbulence created in the ear hole sufficient to remove particles (of wax) from the sides and have them entrained in the fluid flow and lifted into this tube of the hollow candle.

If I may just use a dreadful analogy! ... imagine a tunnel not much bigger than your car, with the inside coated by wax, you are planning to drive through it fast enough to create enough drag behind your vehicle to tear this wax from the wall and retain it in the turbulence behind the car.

I have used the device under many circumstances and you can see literally how smoke at the bottom of the funnel is sucked up by the candel..............hell what do You think makes fireplaces ( Hearths ? ) work?

I confess I should get some and play with them, and I am deficient in not having done so before critiquing your response. I dunno where to buy them!

Again, hearths work because the fire is drawing air in for combustion, the pressure differential generated by a candle would not lift a fly's wing, let alone pull a lump of sticky wax from a flesh.

This is one area that all have the ability to prove "bulls**t" or bravo, one caveat don't buy .a mop and stick it into yer ear.
Disprove it by theory or by experiment.

You are entirely correct about that. Thank you for a polite description of your understanding.

I see you mentioned your daughter suffers from a TMJ problem, I do to .. though from the sound of it not as serious. She has my sympathy, I don't know what your experiences have been, but I've found there is very little can be done to help with current medical knowledge. That's a hard pill to swallow, don't be tempted to let woo-woos tell you they know more than physicians.

Edited to correct confusing grammar!
 
Benguin, I was going to post something about grain elevators in the Calgary area using high-speed air to move grain around, and about the chemical industry doing the same thing, but after reading your analogy about a car-sized tunnel coated with a thick layer of ear wax, I think I'll take a shower instead.




(As a side note, they use something called a "cyclone separator" to remove the entrained product from the air stream. It looks like this..

013026170X.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg


Cover work modelled and rendered by yours truly. :D
 
JSFolk said:
Cover work modelled and rendered by yours truly. :D
You know, I thought you'd look a bit more... human. Although after being rendered I suppose you might look a bit more cylindrical...

;) :D
 
May I respectfully suggest it would be easier to do some web searching and find a scientific explanation from a qualified source?

You may. but impartial viewpoints are hard to find in this area. All the experts in fluid dynamics and aeronautical engineering were busy yesterday. Goggle a look up and you get pagan, new age crap.

The physics is quite different between these things, carburettors make use of the Bernoulli effect to 'atomize' a liquid into a stream of fast moving gas. Wax is not liquefied, if it was you'd scald your ear badly.

No, the physics in all of the cases I sighted are based on the model of a venturi , which governs rocket motors, carbs , aerosol cans, Et.Al. and the principle is separate from it's effect on the medium. A venturi tube is simply a tube which is narrower in the middle than it is at the ends. When the fluid. passing through the tube reaches the narrow part, it speeds up. According to Bernoulli's principle, it then should exert less pressure.

Rocket engines are not relevant


You couldn't be more wrong. This is the engineering that has supplied the scientific basis for every rocket from Goddard to Shuttle. Check here : http://theduchy.ualr.edu/nasa/cymthesis.pdf


I think you mean turbines (search for 'whittle' on google). There is an analogy here ...Trouble is, the air velocity needed to dislodge and actually lift some wax would be very high, even in a confined aperture.;

No I say what I mean.

Please don't make me dig out my fluid mechanics texts from my uni days! I'd rather soak them in wax and burn them!

Dig them out because You evidently have lost track of the principles or you are ignorant ( which I proclaimed in my post ) of the science behind the reality.

Grain hoppers I've seen use an archimedes screw to move the grain about. I'm not suggesting you are wrong, as it is very possible you've seen different ones.

Uhh No ..Gravity fed hopper loaders use the same design .


This is mixing two different concepts, convection and venturi. The burning is pulling the air through, if you obstruct a part of that air flow you create a low pressure area. In the demonstrations of the venturi effect one sticks a pitot tube in their supplying a liquid, the low pressure draws the liquid from the tube and entrains into a fluid flow. What you are looking for is turbulence created in the ear hole sufficient to remove particles (of wax) from the sides and have them entrained in the fluid flow and lifted into this tube of the hollow candle.

As I stated I do not know the exact mechanism of operation , but the few people I have had who experienced this "extraction" state that they experience a warm feeling in the ear canal.This was followed by an examination of the "candle" and I saw a deposit that I could not experimentally recreate without the same constraints.

I confess I should get some and play with them, and I am deficient in not having done so before critiquing your response. I dunno where to buy them!

Well by golly a critique without background , evidence or demonstrable falsehoods of the study in question.......... Ya That skeptical

Again, hearths work because the fire is drawing air in for combustion, the pressure differential generated by a candle would not lift a fly's wing, let alone pull a lump of sticky wax from a flesh.

No hearths work because warm air rises above colder air., you can float a piece of paper or even a charcoal speck. Notice their 2000BC design ( bread ovens, blacksmiths forges) ? Wide at the bottom narrow at the top rising to an exhaust.. the updraft sucks up combustion byproducts.

You are entirely correct about that. Thank you for a polite description of your understanding.

I see you mentioned your daughter suffers from a TMJ problem, I do to .. though from the sound of it not as serious. She has my sympathy, I don't know what your experiences have been, but I've found there is very little can be done to help with current medical knowledge. That's a hard pill to swallow, don't be tempted to let woo-woos tell you they know more than physicians.

Thank You for Your concern but that was a few years ago ( and not TMJ ) and she is a normal irritating , ungracious teenager.I don't let physicians tell me anything without explanation let alone woo-woos. I find more and more I must educate the physician.

Your not by chance Artic penguin's sock puppet are you?
 
TillEulenspiegel said:

As I stated I do not know the exact mechanism of operation , but the few people I have had who experienced this "extraction" state that they experience a warm feeling in the ear canal.This was followed by an examination of the "candle" and I saw a deposit that I could not experimentally recreate without the same constraints.


How did you determine the deposit was human ear wax?
 
Well, I just Googled "ear candle experiment" and came up with the following:


A Small Study of the Properties of Ear Candles
1. The ear candle, when burned, produced a brown waxy substance that looks like ear wax. However, since the wax appears whether or not the candle is placed in a human ear, we conclude that the source of the wax is the candle and not the ear.
2. It is possible that the candle produced wax but also extracted solid material from the ear the was mixed with the candle wax. However, since the candle remnant of the control candle and the one inserted into a human volunteer weighed exactly the same, we conclude that this did not happen.
3. The human subject reported no feeling of a vacuum which is purported to occur during the burning of the candle. The control candle produced smoke that poured from the bottom of the tapered end, suggesting that positive, not negative pressure was being produced.
4. The subject reported no subjective feelings invoked by the treatment, suggesting that the ear candle was innefective in a controlled environment.

Ear Candling:
I opened that candle as well and found the same amount of wax and powder (supposedly candida) in both candles.

Ear Candling:
They demonstrated that all residue originated from the candle and that no ear wax was removed from the ear.

Ear Candles Not Effective:
So we did a very simple experiment, we lit a candle and held it against a smooth notebook surface instead of an ear. Lo and behold, when we blew out the candle and cut it open it was filled with yellowish "ear wax."

Ear Implants, Ear Candles, and Reptilians:
On this day I saw a very strange object in the piece of candle which was left. It was probably a little over 1/4" long. It was greyish in colour and kind of opaque looking, kind of like a semi-clear plastic. It was oval in shape. It gave me the creeps...

On discussing this with a friend of mine, she reminded me that she had earlier suggested that maybe aliens were putting implants into the ear.

These links were all from the first page of Google results. So who are you with, TE, those on the side of science, or those cowering in a corner hiding from Reptilians?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom