Ear candling

Talking about cotton buds (Q tips): The reason why I don't like using them is that they make me cough. Provokes some sort of reflex, I suppose. I always found it uncomfortable.
 
Suezoled said:


I'm always a little wary about sticking Q-tips in my ear. I'm deathly afraid I'm accidentally going to dig out my brain and lose it and have to search around on the ground until I find it.
oh my god that is so funny.......errr no.

can anyone prove that q-tips work. i want to see evidence. i want to see credible studies.
 
olaf said:
oh my god that is so funny.......errr no.

can anyone prove that q-tips work. i want to see evidence. i want to see credible studies.

Give me your home address, and I'll send you an evelope full of Q-tips crusted with wax.

Actually, Q-tips don't work, at least, it doesn't work to safely get out built up earwax. I use cotton swabs every day to prevent build-up of ear wax, otherwise, I'd have plugged up ears right now.
 
specious_reasons said:


Give me your home address, and I'll send you an evelope full of Q-tips crusted with wax.


you beat me to it.

I will also send you a number of them from myself and my cat.


Virgil
 
olaf said:
oh my god that is so funny.......errr no.

can anyone prove that q-tips work. i want to see evidence. i want to see credible studies.
Actully, you don't even need to use the Q-tips for them to work. All you have to do is walk into a grocery store, pick up a box of Q-tips, and rap it smartly ten times against a rigid, yet pliable surface. Your ear wax will remember the "essence" of the Q-tips through quantum entanglement, and it will remove itself.

Evidence? My Aunt Fannie had a terrible ear wax problem,. Then she used this method, and her problem instantly went away. The case study was published in the Journal of Psychoenergetic Ludicrousity in the fall of 1972.

OPEN UP YOUR MIND YOU SKEPTICAL IDIOT!!
 
Well the manufacturers print on the side of the boxes here that you shouldn't go sticking them in your ears, though I can't imagine how they'd sell any if people actually read that on the label.

This link here suggests probing around with paperclips, cotton buds etc only aggrevates the production of wax. This is what the manufacturer's say here. Only they are talking about kids, so who knows.

I notice some simpleton has posted on their messageboard in connection with that, that parents should go buy ear candles. They obviously don't moderate it!

I still say the shower (or a bit of water) does me. If I pour a bit of distilled something or other in their every morning instead, can I claim a homeopathic potion works nicely?

Give me your home address, and I'll send you an evelope full of Q-tips crusted with wax.

Are keeping them for some reason, specious?
 
Psiload said:
Actully, you don't even need to use the Q-tips for them to work. All you have to do is walk into a grocery store, pick up a box of Q-tips, and rap it smartly ten times against a rigid, yet pliable surface. Your ear wax will remember the "essence" of the Q-tips through quantum entanglement, and it will remove itself.

Evidence? My Aunt Fannie had a terrible ear wax problem,. Then she used this method, and her problem instantly went away. The case study was published in the Journal of Psychoenergetic Ludicrousity in the fall of 1972.

OPEN UP YOUR MIND YOU SKEPTICAL IDIOT!!

That's exactly what I did!!! I bought the Q-tips, rapped the box smartly (well maybe not smartly, they rattled around in the back of my car) and now my ears are totally free of ear wax! I never even have to get them out of the bathroom cabinet.
 
Benguin said:


Are keeping them for some reason, specious?

Nice play on the nickname...

Well, let's just say that the upstair bathroom garbage doesn't get emptied until it's full. Although, with my house on the market, I probably shouldn't be revealing my housekeeping tendencies. :)

On a more serious note:

We know that you don't need to put the candle into your ear to get the candle to produce the "evidence" that it "works," but that test doesn't actually address the specific claims of the ear candle makers/advocates.

IIRC, the claims are:
- The warm air generated by the candle softens the ear wax.
- The softened wax gets drawn out of the ear, like a candle wick

This claimed mechanism can be tested, outside of an ear. One way I could think of would be to put small amounts of earwax into several glass containers and "candle" them.

I'm thinking 3 tests.
- put an unlit candle in contact with the earwax
- put a lit candle in contact with the earwax
- put a lit candle near, but not in contact with the earwax. I was thinking that a small amount put in the center of the smaller hole, so that the it is not touching, but can be softened by the heat of the candle.

Although, I think this is probably more effort than most people are willing to put forward.

Plus, you'd probably need to have a garbage can full of used cotton swabs to get enough earwax to run tests....
 
A guy here at work just had ear surgery from a candling session. Hot wax dripped into his ear and onto his eardrum, burning it. He's more that finished dabbling with that particular bit of wooism and his family was amazed that it hurt him. Idiots, he may have a permanent hearing loss.
 
Guys OK attack away. I have used this, my wife has and my son has ( he has ear problems -congenital). The principle is sound, you place a funnel shape cone of parchment saturated with beeswax in to the ear light it and the heat ( not too much elevated from body temp on a 1' cone) softens the wax . The partial pressure displacement of the fire consuming the paper draws the wax out of the ear.( not unlike a very partial vacuum). The wax collects on the leading edge of the funnel.

The construction of the material used is paramount to it's function.

I'm not a proponent of this treatment, but I have seen it work and it was disgusting. My old man used to use a little bulb with warm water to flush out his ears, I used H2O2 until the EENT Phys. told me never put peroxide in your ear that I realized it wasn't a good idea.

So if some people make these ear products out of candle wax and paper towels , it doesn't necessarily make the principle unsound, it's not majik. Hell I live on the west coast of Florida and if someone wants to invoke the Randi challenge on this I will gladly travel 200 Mi to demonstrate.

edit to add:
I have burned the cones vertically with both a blocked opening ( as one would see in a human ear and an open orifice, there was no wax production. Also the remains of wax at the bottom of a cone used in a human ear was red-dark brown not color neutral ( altho some might consider the addition of ash or another compound to be the culprit. I have also used an otoscope and found that wax deposits had either diminished or disappeared. I had this tool because my daughter had otitus and I monitored her condition because the infection can spread to the jaw ( which it already had).

Which do you think a medical doctor would reccomend? An office visit @ $75 US for a suction cleaning or a slightly more dangerous $.75 per sheet folk remedy?
 
Which do you think a medical doctor would reccomend? An office visit @ $75 US for a suction cleaning or a slightly more dangerous $.75 per sheet folk remedy?

I know these conspiracy theories work in the US where you pay for it all, here in the UK GPs pay for their referrals from a budget they are responsible for (generally).

No Ear candling here, why waste the £0.75?
 
It's not a conspiracy theory, I don't believe in them by nature. It is an observation that a trained physician would recommend an office visit with the machine that goes "PING" rather the a burning cone of paper stuck in your ear, regardless of it's efficacy
 
TillEulenspiegel wrote:
The principle is sound... The partial pressure displacement of the fire consuming the paper draws the wax out of the ear.( not unlike a very partial vacuum).
What is the sound principle here? Where would a partial vacuum be exactly, and why would that draw out ear wax? I mean, if you tried to do this with ear wax in a hollow tube that was open on both ends, you'd need to blow air through that at a hundred meters per second or so to dislodge it. You're saying that it's sucked out by an imperceiptible (and I think fictitious) airflow? Face it, TE, this is kooky stuff.
 
TillEulenspiegel said:
. The partial pressure displacement of the fire consuming the paper draws the wax out of the ear.( not unlike a very partial vacuum). The wax collects on the leading edge of the funnel.




No it doesn't, the wax is so viscous that to suck it out you would need a high vacuum system so powerful it would pull your ear drum apart. In my line of work I use vacuum systems nearly every day.

also, the gentle warming by the transferred heat is not enough to soften the ear wax until it flows. that would require temperatures ca. 75- 100 C, which would damage your head.

my grandmother goes in to have the wax cleaned out and at the rate medicare reimburses the MD probably breaks even.


Virgil
 
In any case, if you softened it enough with temperature you'd need a massive pressure differential to move it against gravity and avoid scalded ear drums ... simply dipping a burning candle (or straw if you prefer) in a glass of water tells us the pressure doesn't move the liquid up the tube.

Of course you could try tipping your head so the flame is lower than the end of the candle when it's burning ....
 
OK well you guys are forcing me to defend a process that I have relatively little grasp of .........be that as it may, I will attempt to give a scientific basis to explain the action, altho I'm not a proponent of this device or a specialist of the disciplines that would define it's operation , I will attempt a reasonable explanation. Fair?

The mechanism that seems to be the dominant factor seems to be the same science that governs jet engines and ventures in everything from grain hoppers to automobile carburetors and rocket engines. In all of these applications you employ a pressure differential between two zones . A venturi that accepts a volume of space forces it to compression and accelerates it, relative to the supply side by use of a shaped exit venturi. ( Ever use a can of paint or some other substance and it gets cold? ) I'm fairly sure that the updraft is produced by the temperature differential and the conical shape of the "candle"..

I have used the device under many circumstances and you can see literally how smoke at the bottom of the funnel is sucked up by the candel..............hell what do You think makes fireplaces ( Hearths ? ) work?

This is one area that all have the ability to prove "◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊" or bravo, one caveat don't buy .a mop and stick it into yer ear.
Disprove it by theory or by experiment.
 
I've seen TV news reports. They put one candle in someone's ear, light it, and another candle into a glass and light it. They both have the exact same gunk in them. I'm sure if you looked it up, you could find debunking articles somewhere on the net.
 
the vacuum produced by your candle is not powerful enough because the ear wax has too low of a vapor pressure.

any vacuum you could produce is simply not strong enough to pull the wax out. it is just not powerful enough.


Virgil
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom